5 ms·
Malaria kills over half a million people a year, out of over 200M cases. Why is ebola so much more alarming?
by MichaelGG 12y ago
Malaria kills over half a million people a year, out of over 200M cases. Why is ebola so much more alarming?
- adventured 12y agoA few reasons. 1) Because malaria is 'over there' and ebola is threatening to come 'over here.' 2) Ebola has been hyper sensationalized, and is not as well understood as malaria. 3) Ebola has a very high mortality rate, with an almost coin-flip chance of surviving it. 4) The world has been dealing with malaria for a very long time. Ebola is new on the block. It seems any new virus tends to make waves these days, from SARS to West Nile.
- sigmar 12y agoYou pretty much answered your own question- .5M deaths out of 200M. Ebola kills 50-90%
- pdabbadabba 12y agoI think the answer can be summarized: "human-to-human" transmission. Malaria, to be sure, has been a much more significant public health problem historically, but with ebola you have the possibility of human-to-human transmission and, thus, geometric growth. You also have the possibility that it will spread elsewhere in the world. And we're not just talking about the western world here either (though that surely drives more than its fair share of the panic). Imagine, for instance, ebola in Mumbai or Mexico City.
- hyperpape 12y agoUncertainty is really the kicker. Ebola may turn out to be substantially less significant than malaria. But we can't rule out it being a good deal worse.
- fiatmoney 12y agoMalaria is mosquito-borne; effectively a condition of geography. One moves to a non-malaria zone and is no longer susceptible; or one can invest in some mosquito netting and dramatically cut their risk. Caring for the infected or burying the dead does not increase the risk. Ebola is person-to-person and by all accounts highly infectious, particularly targeting caregivers. It's a recipe for a much more severe social breakdown. It's also clear the number of malaria cases is bounded, at a level that is in some sense "livable". It is not clear at what level Ebola will top out at; it may not be compatible with maintaining a functioning society in particularly hard-hit areas.
- pmorici 12y agoYou can easily protect against Malaria with various drugs.