7 ms·
W.H.O. Forecast for Ebola Worsens as Mortality Rate Rises
- simplemath 12y agoI'm trying to remain calm about this, but its growing increasingly difficult. We're not far off pandemic territory. 10k new cases per week? Very very alarming.
- jerhinesmith 12y agoI'm really interested to see if the r-naught is sustainable in developed countries. This paper (http://www.eurosurveillance.org/ViewArticle.aspx?ArticleId=20894 http://www.eurosurveillance.org/ViewArticle.aspx?ArticleId=2...) projects it as between 1.0 and 2.0 -- the nurse in Dallas makes it at least 1 for the first US case, but it could be a few more weeks to know if she was the only one.
- simplemath 12y ago>Our statistical analysis of the reproduction number of EVD in West Africa has demonstrated that the continuous growth of cases from June to August 2014 signalled a major epidemic, which is in line with estimates of the Rt above 1.0. Moreover, the timing of Rt reaching levels above one is in line with a concomitant surge in cases in Sierra Leone and Liberia. In a worst-case hypothetical scenario, should the outbreak continue with recent trends, the case burden could gain an additional 77,181 to 277,124 cases by the end of 2014. Not good. R~2 is a deeply scary figure. R1.7 is better but still wildly explosive. 1.4 puts us in run of the mill "ballooning epidemic" territory. The best case estimates of R-naught for Africa don't have a whole lot of "best" about them. Clearly the dataset outside Africa isn't large enough to support meaningful analysis yet. I hope it stays that way, and Africa can get its arms around this thing before it kills millions.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoFor others who wondered about the R-naught reference - how many people one infected person will then onwards infect. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_reproduction_number Measles is 12-18, Ebola 1-2. Before that makes you feel comforted, 1918 flu had r0 of 2-3. Great.
- hga 12y agoProblem is, the data from West Africa is so bad in quality it could easily be 3 (e.g. I believe that's in line with the CDC's worst case estimate for January). Which to echo simplemath is deeply scary.
- azakai 12y ago> the nurse in Dallas makes it at least 1 for the first US case, but it could be a few more weeks to know if she was the only one. Since it's a single case though, this is far from statistically significant. We don't know what R0 will be in the US.
- MichaelGG 12y agoMalaria kills over half a million people a year, out of over 200M cases. Why is ebola so much more alarming?
- adventured 12y agoA few reasons. 1) Because malaria is 'over there' and ebola is threatening to come 'over here.' 2) Ebola has been hyper sensationalized, and is not as well understood as malaria. 3) Ebola has a very high mortality rate, with an almost coin-flip chance of surviving it. 4) The world has been dealing with malaria for a very long time. Ebola is new on the block. It seems any new virus tends to make waves these days, from SARS to West Nile.
- sigmar 12y agoYou pretty much answered your own question- .5M deaths out of 200M. Ebola kills 50-90%
- pdabbadabba 12y agoI think the answer can be summarized: "human-to-human" transmission. Malaria, to be sure, has been a much more significant public health problem historically, but with ebola you have the possibility of human-to-human transmission and, thus, geometric growth. You also have the possibility that it will spread elsewhere in the world. And we're not just talking about the western world here either (though that surely drives more than its fair share of the panic). Imagine, for instance, ebola in Mumbai or Mexico City.
- hyperpape 12y agoUncertainty is really the kicker. Ebola may turn out to be substantially less significant than malaria. But we can't rule out it being a good deal worse.
- fiatmoney 12y agoMalaria is mosquito-borne; effectively a condition of geography. One moves to a non-malaria zone and is no longer susceptible; or one can invest in some mosquito netting and dramatically cut their risk. Caring for the infected or burying the dead does not increase the risk. Ebola is person-to-person and by all accounts highly infectious, particularly targeting caregivers. It's a recipe for a much more severe social breakdown. It's also clear the number of malaria cases is bounded, at a level that is in some sense "livable". It is not clear at what level Ebola will top out at; it may not be compatible with maintaining a functioning society in particularly hard-hit areas.
- nostromo 12y agoI'm worried about the coming flu season. Many people will have the early symptoms shared by both flu and ebola (a fever and a headache). The medical establishment will need to find needles in the haystack. Don't skip the flu shot this (or any) year, folks.
- jMyles 12y agoI've never gotten the flu shot, and hadn't planned to this year. I'm in great health; my immune system seems to be functioning extremely well. I never get sick. However, I am concerned about the needle-haystack phenomenon with ebola. Can you link me to a reasonable, digestible abstract about the real pros-and-cons of flu shot?
- jfoutz 12y agoIs your immune system unusually effective, or do you simply have a lower exposure because people you come in contact with get their vaccines?
- jMyles 12y agoI surmise that I just have a good immune system (I'm not sure if it's "unusually" good). I don't go around asking all my friends and colleagues if they've gotten a flu shot, but I don't think they do? edit: Jeez, downvotes? Did I say something wrong? I'm not trying to troll, just answering the question.
- dghughes 12y agoIt's called being an asymptomatic carrier look up Typhoid Mary. You may be infecting elderly and babies but are unaffected, as others have said a flu shot isn't so much about protecting you it's about people around you. My 70 year-old dad has IPF his lungs are shot and if he catches the flu he's as good as dead. It's frustrating the ambivalence or apathy or just outright paranoia is so prevalent these days. At my workplace out of 400 people one year only 3 people got a flu shot; myself and two others. The majority are 20-somethings and others who don't get the concept of a vaccines. I feel like saying "We don't care about just you we care about everyone!" but it's not a very good catch phrase.
- danieltillett 12y agoNot stopping this outbreak with all the resources we have is running a massive natural experiment in how well adapted Ebola can become for efficient human-to-human transmission. As a zoonotic virus Ebola in its wild state is very unlikely to be optimised for human-to-human transmission. Every new case is increasing the chance that a new strain will arise that will be efficiently transmitted between people. I am not too keen to see how well adapted Ebola can become to humans.
- simplemath 12y agoThere's already limited evidence that some transmission is occurring via atomized saliva/mucous. A truly airbone variant could cause a "get in your bunker and ride it out" kind of event.
- freyrs3 12y agoMight as well start worrying about an airborne mutation of HIV while we're at it. Wouldn't start heading for the bunker just yet.
- danieltillett 12y agoYes Ebola can be transmitted that way, but it is an unlikely route. The way Ebola is constructed it is very unlikely to become airborne [1], but it could increase in natural reproductive efficiency (R0). We really have no idea of the R0 for Ebola right now as we don’t have the people on the ground recording what is happening in the community. Ebola does not have to become airborne for it to be a problem. Polio is not airborne and it has a very high R0 (5 − 7). The difference is polio is adapted for human-to-human transmission while Ebola is very unlikely to be. I don’t want to find out how well adapted Ebola can become. [1] Something that I have noticed about the discussion here is many people are unclear about what it mean for a virus to be “airborne” (this is not surprising since most people are not virologists). What airborne mean is that the virus is adapted to spreading via small mucosal droplets. The classic virus for this is rhinovirus (the most common cold virus). Rhinovirus infects the mucosal cells of the upper respiratory tract, it causes you to produce lots of mucus, it makes you sneeze a lot releasing this mucus in small droplets into the air, the virus is hardy enough to survive in the small mucosal droplets, and it doesn’t make you that ill so you still go to work where you can spread it around your co-workers. Doing all the things required the evolution of many interlocking adaptations in the Rhinovirus genome. Ebola's infection mechanism is nothing like Rhinovirus. While in theory it is possible that Ebola could acquire all the adaptions required to be spread efficiently by small mucosal droplets, it is really unlikely as there are so many changes required. This is why most experts think it is unlikely that Ebola will become “airborne”.
- danieltillett 12y agoIf anyone is interested I have put up a post on my personal blog about Ebola and what needs to be done [1]. [1] http://www.tillett.info/2014/10/08/ebola-what-needs-to-be-done-right-now/ http://www.tillett.info/2014/10/08/ebola-what-needs-to-be-do...
- Chromozon 12y agoWhat scares me the most is the mortality rate. The numbers right now put it at 50%. Catch Ebola. Flip a coin and guess heads or tails. If you guess incorrectly, you die. It will be interesting to see this number once it (inevitably) spreads to "developed" nations with much higher standards of health care.
- danieltillett 12y agoIf Ebola does become able to spread in western countries (right now it can’t), then unless you are one of the first few hundred to get it then there will be little difference between the first world and third world since all our hospitals would soon collapse.
- mikeyouse 12y ago> What scares me the most is the mortality rate. The numbers right now put it at 50%. Unfortunately, it's actually worse than that. The initial predictions about this outbreak were a 50% mortality rate, later estimations put the rate at closer to 70%. To continue your metaphor; You flip two coins and try to guess heads or tails. If you're wrong on either coin, you die. [1] - http://www.aljazeera.com/news/africa/2014/10/ebola-outbreak-killing-70-percent-victims-20141014132345720164.html http://www.aljazeera.com/news/africa/2014/10/ebola-outbreak-...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ausjke 12y agowhy is USA still allowing people from those countries fly in? the body temperature measure at airport is 99% useless. When will Duncun's family pay back all those medical expenses here since he lied to the airport before he boarded? Not to mention he put other innocent people in ciritical danger at Dallas.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoI'm sorry, did Duncan's FAMILY lie on the form? While we're at it, did Duncan? It's fairly widely reported that he did not know that the woman he helped had ebola. Apparently her family had been in denial, and told people she was experiencing complications from the pregnancy. >Duncan did not know he'd been exposed to Ebola by the pregnant woman, says his brother-in-law, John Lewis. >"The family said that the girl did not die from Ebola; they continued to say it until they went and buried this girl," says Lewis. http://www.npr.org/blogs/goatsandsoda/2014/10/09/354645983/fond-memories-of-ebola-victim-eric-duncan-anger-over-his-death http://www.npr.org/blogs/goatsandsoda/2014/10/09/354645983/f... And in any case: how about you spend a little more time trying to feel compassion for people like you who just lost a husband/father/son and a little less trying to figure out who should get the bill.
- Crito 12y ago> "It's fairly widely reported that he did not know that the woman he helped had ebola. Apparently her family had been in denial, and told people she was experiencing complications from the pregnancy." She apparently died several hours later. If that is true, then while he was interacting with her she was extremely symptomatic. We're talking bleeding out of everywhere. Ebola is not a subtle disease, and she was not merely exhibiting flu-like symptoms at that point. Furthermore, the hospital turned her away because their ebola ward was full. While it is possible that he was an idiot who believed the claims that it was simply pregnancy complications, we're deep into "sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice" territory. And frankly, it is more charitable to Duncan to assume that he lied. Better a liar than an idiot of that magnitude. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Eric_Duncan#Timeline_of_contraction_and_initial_symptoms http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Eric_Duncan#Timeline_of_... > "On September 15, 2014, the family of Ebola virus disease patient Marthalene Williams were unable to summon an ambulance to transfer Williams to the hospital. Their tenant, Duncan, helped to transfer Williams by taxi to an Ebola treatment ward in Monrovia, Liberia. Duncan rode in the taxi to the treatment ward with Williams, her father, and her brother. The family was turned away due to lack of space and Duncan helped carry Williams from the taxi back into her home, where she died shortly afterwards.[11]"
- atiffany 12y agoDonation link: http://www.doctorswithoutborders.org/our-work/medical-issues/ebola http://www.doctorswithoutborders.org/our-work/medical-issues...
- jMyles 12y agoI've been following this organization for a few years now. Its blogs and 'field news' have informed me about places in the world I didn't realize even exist - places with unique cultures that are threatened by lack of medical care and all the ways in which war and capricious borders create shortages in supply of medical care. I've given what I can - please do the same everyone!
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- oska 12y agoThere is a good recent article in The Guardian where three western nurses describe their experience in caring for people with the virus. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/oct/13/ebola-nurses-describe-life-death-on-frontline-liberia-sierra-leone http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/oct/13/ebola-nurses-de...
- cc439 12y agoThis seemed misguided: "I have heard media reports calling for people such as me who have been treating Ebola patients to be quarantined for 21 or even 42 days. These ideas are not based on the medical facts. People only need to be quarantined if they are showing symptoms and if you do not have a fever, there is no risk of you transmitting Ebola to someone.: What happens once you start showing symptoms? They're likely to have touched a large number of surfaces and interacted with a large number of people by the time they realize their worsening condition is the onset of Ebola. By the time I know I'm sick, I'm pretty sick. I'm damn good at trudging on until the point of no return and I'm sure healthcare workers would do the same since Ebola is contagious well before it's debilitating.
- bokonist 12y ago"These ideas are not based on the medical facts. People only need to be quarantined if they are showing symptoms and if you do not have a fever, there is no risk of you transmitting Ebola to someone." Also, that above fact is wrong. "Yet the largest study of the current outbreak found that in nearly 13% of "confirmed and probable" cases in Liberia, Sierra Leone, Guinea and elsewhere, those infected did not have fevers." http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-1012-ebola-fever-20141012-story.html#page=1 http://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-1012-ebola-fever-2014101... Even letting one-in-ten get through undetected is too high. Especially since any strains of the virus that are harder to detect are exactly the strains that most the most threat and must be kept out.
- ericwhyne 12y agoThere are a lot of great perspectives and threads in this discussion. If you're interested and want to develop them further, a few of us have stood up ebola-wiki.com to share data sources and information. It's a place to build on these ideas, cite your sources, and refine them. I'd welcome feedback. Also, if you are a mediawiki admin please contact me. We could use more help and advice as this scales.
- Oculus 12y agoDr. Paul Farmer discusses Ebola: http://youtu.be/lb11QbP3tOg http://youtu.be/lb11QbP3tOg After listening to the talk, I'm not as worried as this article makes me. I certainly trust the source in the video better.