8 ms·
When the Guy Making Your Sandwich Has a Noncompete Clause
- drivingmenuts 12y agoTheir food is disappointing and now their business practices are, too? I'm really wishing the NYT had tried to get a comment from Jimmy John's corporate before publication. I'd love to hear their justification for that.
- JTon 12y agoProbably something like protecting their operational advantages i.e. standardized processes found at the retail front line that give them a competitive advantage
- nhangen 12y agoI'm guessing they don't want to spend time training people only to have them leave for another shop. I wonder if there is a limit on this clause?
- jessaustin 12y agoMaybe I'm a clueless jackass, but I've made sandwiches before, and I've seen sandwiches made in sandwich shops before, and I can't imagine this "training" taking longer than a shift. The training that isn't directly related to sandwiches, e.g. how to stock the cooler and where the dumpster is located, is likely to vary from shop to shop. Most hiring shop managers are going to look more closely at how long one has held jobs than whether those jobs were with a competing sandwich chain.
- nhangen 12y agoI'm thinking more about the type of training that teaches someone to be a responsible worker, productive, show up on time, etc.
- jrokisky 12y agoI worked at a Jimmy Johns for a few months. They make the sandwiches in a very specific way to optimize for speed. The average time between order and handoff to a customer was about a minute during busy times.
- owenmarshall 12y agoIs that "very specific" method of assembly so complex or so secretive that it couldn't be deduced by anyone camped out at a table near the register? Somehow I doubt it.
- AnimalMuppet 12y ago"Our SuperSekrit(TM) ingredients and procedures make our sandwiches so much better than our competitors, and we have to protect that." Turn the problem into a chance for free positive PR, no matter how much you have to twist things to do so. That's what I'd expect, anyway.
- mratzloff 12y agoHere's all I really need to know about the company: http://www.smilepolitely.com/splog/jimmy_john_is_a_big_man._with_the_photos_to_prove_it/ http://www.smilepolitely.com/splog/jimmy_john_is_a_big_man._... I used to eat there pretty regularly until I saw those photos. I haven't ate there since.
- jackmaney 12y ago0_0 Fuck...I've eaten there fairly regularly myself. No longer.
- krigi 12y agoI've been under non-competes before. I've just ignored them. Most of them are unenforceable and in cases like Jimmy John's are just another form of harassment.
- aroch 12y agoHell, many places will release you from a non-complete if it gets you to fuck off faster after being let go. Non-competes aren't really about punishing after you leave, they are there to "encourage" you to stay.
- johnward 12y agoI'm not at a high enough level that I think an employer would actually try to enforce a non-compete but the fact that I signed something that says they could still scares me.
- pnathan 12y agoI had a 6-month non-compete-ish agreement at a taco shop in 2007. I couldn't take the taco recipes to another taco shop within the nearest `n` miles. Kinda lulzy at the time...
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoThis got a little too typically NYT generic and preachy at the end -- I was expecting either an altar call or somebody to pass a collection plate -- but the specific case about non-competes deserves some attention. For all the things California is doing to drive out businesses, one great thing about the state is that non-competes have very little weight. (In fact, this was what led Google and Apple to screw over the tech industry for many years, but I digress). The measures are very rarely enforced even in states that do support them. What with a new load of state legislators coming into office over the next few months, fixing non-competes in those other states is an easy win that could increase the state's competitiveness.
- VLM 12y ago"The measures are very rarely enforced" Don't get into an agreement you're not willing to enforce... lets be realistic, the victims are judgment proof, if they lose, the company might be able to repo their hat or apron, that's about it. Most likely result is if you quit and tell your boss you're going to a competitor of any sort in the food service industry, you won't get your last pay check. It'll cost too much to get it, so corporate wide its free money for the company across the large set of all employees.
- ceejayoz 12y agoAttempting to withhold a paycheck for hours worked will get the Feds involved, for free, very quickly.
- x0x0 12y ago1 - not so quickly as all that; 2 - particularly if you don't know how to work the system, where to file a complaint, or how to get help; 3 - still a problem if you don't have the money to wait for that paycheck to show up for months or years
- danielweber 12y agoIt won't be "months or years." If you worked hours, the state will tell the company to pay you for that, now. Even if they are bankrupt.
- bsbechtel 12y agoThe article has a pretty obvious slant in one direction. A lot of times small businesses will require this of their entry level workers not because they are afraid of their workers going to a competitor, but don't want their employees to go and start a competing business, which in the small business world is a very real risk. It costs much less to start a small business, and in the local market many of these small businesses operate in, a new competitor can take away a big chunk of an already small pie. If that competitor did so by stealing your business practices, then congrats, you are putting yourself out of business. I'm not necessarily saying this is wrong or right, but it's the other side of the story the NYT didn't discuss. Ironically, I worked for JJ in college, and never once did this ever concern me. This may be my personal bias, but I think the NYT is trying to make mountains out of molehills here. There are much bigger contributing factors to low wages for fast food restaurant workers, such as illegal immigrants depressing wages, limited ability for workers to organize, and perverse tax incentives that prevent profits from working their way down the economic ladder. As a side note, JJ pays better than a vast majority of fast food restaurant chains. Their in-shop workers are paid above minimum wage (average around $8.50), and it's fairly easy to move into a delivery driver position where you can earn $25/hr on Fridays and Saturday nights.
- lotsofmangos 12y ago"The article has a pretty obvious slant in one direction." I noticed there's a signpost pointing down that way as well. There's some writing on it saying 'Sanity'. You may want to stroll that way a little.
- DanBC 12y ago42 minutes and your direct personal attack - which also contains stigmatising language about mental health - is not grey. :-/
- owenmarshall 12y agoI'll step up to defend lotsofmangos: that's a particularly uncharitable reading of the comment. I took it to mean "your opinion is ludicrous; a person getting paid $8.50 an hour to flip burgers or assemble sandwiches lacks the access to capital required to start a restaurant". That's absolutely correct, and not at all a direct personal attack. (though I'd agree that the choice of "sanity" is unfortunate)
- lotsofmangos 12y agoWelcome to the Corporate Logocracy. Please enjoy your stay and note that by entering you agree to submit to mediation in the case of a dispute.
- brianbreslin 12y agoIts amazing how fast Jimmy John's has been expanding too. They seem to be popping up all over florida now.
- nissimk 12y agoNon compete clauses do not make sense for employees that are not highly compensated. They are a violation of the 13th amendment and frequently unenforceable. This doesn't stop people from trying to use them as a tool to increase employee retention especially in the face of poor work conditions and bad management. If an employer insists on one, you should ask for compensation. Make sure they agree to pay you some amount greater than your equivalent total compensation with benefits for the entire duration of the non-compete period.
- notacoward 12y agoOne of the problems with being poor is that you might not be able to afford lawyers to contest a suit over a non-compete. Therefore, we can't rely on post hoc legal remedies. Companies need to be proactively prevented, via regulation, from trying to pull this kind of stuff.
- eggoa 12y agoAs VLM notes elswhere in this thread, being poor also means you're usually "judgment proof" (i.e. too poor to be worth suing).
- notacoward 12y agoThe company might not recover costs by suing, but that won't necessarily stop them from doing it to make an example of someone.
- DanBC 12y ago> there are other cases where low-paid or entry-level workers have had an employer try to restrict their employability elsewhere. The Times article tells of a camp counselor and a hair stylist who faced such restrictions. Being poor does not seem to have helped those people.
- x0x0 12y agoBut it's often the next employer that is intimidated into not hiring you. So the poor person gets fucked.
- johnward 12y agoI'm hoping that companies pushing non-competes to workers at this level causes some discussion around non-competes at national level. Hopefully, as a country, we will treat non-competes more like CA does.
- jakozaur 12y agoTwo models that make sense: - California, non-competes are not enforceable - Poland, you can make non-compete for the time you pay full salary (e.g. if company wants you to restrict employment for 3 months after leaving it, you will get your salary during that period)
- johnward 12y agoMy understanding of the CA model was that they are unenforceable except for when an employee has a controlling interest in the company. For example you could enforce a non-compete on a co-owner who tried to create a competing service. At least that's the way I interpreted it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- johnward 12y agoI'm not in CA but there does appear to be cases where they can be enforced per http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-compete_clause#Exceptions_-_valid_non-compete_agreements_in_California http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-compete_clause#Exceptions_-... "Non-compete agreements are automatically void as a matter of law in California, except for a small set of specific situations expressly authorized by statute. They were outlawed by the original California Civil Code in 1872." "here are limited situations where a reasonable non-compete agreement may be valid in California. (1)Where the owner of a business is selling the entire business, or is selling the goodwill in the business, the seller may be bound by a non-compete clause. (2)When there is a dissolution or disassociation of a partnership. (3)Where there is a dissolution of a limited liability company." So #1 says "you cannot sell your business with the intention of competing in the same space after the sale". Which seems reasonable.
- couradical 12y agoRealistically, these are all the same thing in different manners - dissolving a business, and starting another immediately competing in the same space, which seems shockingly sensible to me.
- wmf 12y agoI wonder if this is related to companies' refusal to hire full-time employees. If you only hire an employee for 20 hours per week, obviously they're going to need two other minimum-wage jobs... which may be at your competitors. I heard a story (which may or may not be true) about a guy who worked part time at Home Depot and part time Lowe's.
- vampirechicken 12y agoCould also be used prevent your competition form poaching your workers for the buck an hour more that you're not willing to pay.