7 ms·
The Free Internet Project
- sarciszewski 12y agoI look forward to the day the entire map is green. (Even if it never happens, it's something to work towards.)
- alphydan 12y agofor us colorblind, Russia, Turkey, Iran, Pakistan & Company aready are very very close to it. :)
- sarciszewski 12y agoHah. Sorry to hear that.
- lucb1e 12y agoNever knew that the Netherlands and Brazil are the only countries in the world that have net neutrality as a law. Like with legal euthanasia, drugs, gay marriage, etc., as a Dutchman I'm amazed at how non-liberal much of the world is.
- ehPReth 12y agoChile as well: http://thefreeinternetproject.org/countries/chile http://thefreeinternetproject.org/countries/chile
- lucb1e 12y agoOh! Thin and light; missed that one. Thanks!
- teekert 12y ago"Personal data protected"? So it is protected while our government stores it for 6 to 12 months?
- oscargrouch 12y agoAs far as i know its not the government that keeps the data itself, is the ISP's and service providers.. its a minimum period of archiving, for them to respect, so if a law enforcement signed by a judge ask them to reveal some logs for instance, they should have it, if its in the date range they have defined, or else they would also be accountable. I think this is quite good
- zorbo 12y agoThere's a voluntary program in the Netherlands that financially compensates ISPs for uploading logs to a central database where law enforcement is free to query it without, in practice, judicial oversight. Laws are great, but they're easily circumvented. Especially in the Netherlands. That's why this "Free Internet" project is reasonably useless. Its view is too narrow, focusing only on official laws and not on actual practices. For instance, after the whole Project-X incident[1], law enforcement has been looking into being able to remove social media posts on a whim, without judicial oversight. Such underwater erosion of rights is common in the Netherlands. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_X_Haren http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_X_Haren
- lucb1e 12y ago> its a minimum period of archiving And a maximum. Privacy laws also dictate that data should not be retained longer than needed for the purpose for which you're storing it. If you store data for statistics, a few days would be the max because you can count hits and anonymize data almost immediately. If you store data for the government and the government only needs it for 6 months, then after 6 months you have no right to store it anymore. And ISPs really stick to this.
- icebraining 12y agoAs a Portuguese, I have never felt the need for net neutrality laws. I have four ISPs competing to provide me service, and as far as I know they're all "neutral", including with regard to bittorrent traffic and such. I also raise you full decriminalization of all drug consumption :) though I'd still like to see legalization at least of a few softer drugs.
- byandyphillips 12y agoSorry if this is off topic, but I wonder how many people typically donate when they see a "donate" button on a website. I imagine it's very small if any at all. Am I wrong?
- kaoD 12y agoI don't have a donate button, but I made some Bitcoin addresses specifically for donations and spread them around forum signatures, link in my GitHub page, etc. One random day I was syncing my blockchain and noticed a ~$10 donation. Made me really happy :) Unfortunately I'm not even sure what triggered it, but I probably helped someone on an internet forum and he wanted to give back. Thanks, random stranger! So, to sum it up, according to my experience the total amount of donations on the internet is >= $10.
- xnull 12y agoThis is interesting. Allow me to provide some counterpoints to the bullet points listed for a few (major) countries. China: * The Great Firewall of China blocks people's access to many websites, e.g., Facebook, Google. * Government engages in extensive censorship especially related to political organizing or protests. * Foreign social media apps are banned. Users must use real names on social media. The Great Firewall and the blocking of media apps does also function as a Firewall. It is not merely a censorship technology. The United States and allies are known to target media in other countries to stir dissent. Radio Free Europe, "Voice of Iraq" (cough American), the Lincoln Group infiltrations and partnerships, etc. The Snowden leaks and the history of (especially) Google but also other US businesses in China (and export exceptions limiting the purchase of infrastructure technologies) tell a tale of the US trying to export compromised services to China. China does not want its citizens' informations in America's XKeyScore nor it's citizens Google, Microsoft, Apple, Facebook, etc data in America's PRISM. (There's a reason all of those programs get permission through the FISA "Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act" Court). Just this past year the CIA (under USAID) pretended to be a grassroots movement on Twitter served 'news' critical of the Cuban regime that nearly caused a Cuban uprising. The DoD's MINERVA project specifically looks to understand the cultural components of stability of various countries and mechanisms to encourage or disrupt that stability. Among a great number of social studies you will find DoD research on how to seed information inside of specific Asian countries, including China, for the targeted introduction of instability. I will leave speculations of possible connections to the Hong Kong protests to the reader. http://minerva.dtic.mil/funded.html http://minerva.dtic.mil/funded.html It's a global issue right now. This year Egypt sentenced Al Jazeera journalists that they believed were partnered with geopolitical interests of other states. As of this year Putin is now requiring bloggers to register if they have a certain number of readers, so that his administration can curtail international influence. America, too, faces challenges. A number of journalists have called out that the state has been extremely aggressive to dissenting opinions, even to go so far as labeling current policy on the issue "War on Journalism". American officials have exported a number of journalists with Middle Eastern descent and journalists like Ayman Mohyeldin have been pulled from Gaza and other conflicts when reporting has erred on the side of other state interests. And of course there's the article "I Liked Everything I Saw on Facebook for Two Days", which is definitely worth a read. The TL;DR is that below the thin surface of social information bubbles enormous amounts of radicalizing geopolitical and domestic political ads and campaigns. http://www.wired.com/2014/08/i-liked-everything-i-saw-on-facebook-for-two-days-heres-what-it-did-to-me/ http://www.wired.com/2014/08/i-liked-everything-i-saw-on-fac...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- curiousfab 12y agoI hope that it's just a honest mistake that they made a part of Latvia belong to Russia (probably thinking it is Kaliningrad). Such details are important and getting them wrong can make some people very angry. Edit: At least the Crimea still belongs to Ukraine on their map :-)
- jaredmcdonald 12y agoNorth Korea is colored red with no explanatory text... is that just to say "come on, it's North Korea?"
- Retr0spectrum 12y agoYou can read about it here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_in_North_Korea http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_in_North_Korea
- jaredmcdonald 12y agoThanks. Led me to this... wonder if they've implemented ES6 yet? :P > Red Star OS features a modified Mozilla Firefox browser titled Naenara used for browsing the Naenara web portal on the North Korean intranet network known as Kwangmyong. [1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Star_OS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Star_OS
- bliker 12y agoI am quite sure whole EU has a net-neutrality law. http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-26865869 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-26865869
- icebraining 12y agoNope, it still has to be voted by the Council.
- nojvek 12y agoNot sure why India is red. I mean its a pretty crazy country to be in, but no one censors your shit like China.
- adwf 12y agoWasn't India one of the countries that demanded intercept capabilities from Skype and Blackberry? ie. Break your product or you can't do business. That's pretty hostile as far as internet freedom goes.
- enlightenedfool 12y agoTell me, what's the difference between government acting without a court order and one acting with a secret court order based on questionable laws. the result is the same. Also, when I know that there's government surveillance and weak privacy, I am less willing to speak free, which is effectively no free speech.
- lukasm 12y agoThere is a lot freedom in Poland, only because our retarded government has figure out yet how powerful internet is.
- happyscrappy 12y agoPoland and others that suffered under Communism know first hand how bad it can be and value their new life, Hong Kong is going in the other direction unfortunately.
- logicchains 12y agoHong Kong doesn't really have a choice in the matter; it can't exactly just decide "hey, I don't want to be ruled by mainland China any more" and become independent, China would never allow that.
- undefined0 12y agoPoland actually hosts a lot of the popular file related websites because it's "untouchable" being located in Poland for such websites. Zippyshare, Filestube, Torrentz.eu, etc. Maybe Poland doesn't clamp down on such sites for economic reasons, and the reason the USA isn't forcing Poland to takedown the websites is because they need Poland since they're strategically needed to combat Russia. Just my theory.
- spindritf 12y agoWhy does "left to market" seem to imply "less protected"? I have much more trust in my connection with five competing ISPs than I would have with five regulators. I also find communication with the customer retention department smoother and more productive than trying to figure out which complaint form I need to fill.
- krapp 12y agoPerhaps because markets are meant to optimize for profit, and not necessarily freedom?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- spindritf 12y agoAnd government officials optimize for freedom? Has this been your experience?
- krapp 12y agoNot always, obviously. But I think it's important to at least differentiate between the purpose of law and the purpose of business. Assuming the best case for the former but the worst case for the latter doesn't make a lot of sense. Laws at the very least could act to limit the ability of corporations to limit access and mine user privacy - but businesses in the best case are still going to attempt to do what makes money, which will almost never mean the less lucrative option of allowing their customers greater freedom and more privacy. I think the general thesis here is that internet freedom is more secure in an environment where it is considered a right and not a term of service.
- oscargrouch 12y ago
- coolgeek 12y ago"The Free Internet Project is a nonprofit whose mission is to provide the public with information about the latest legal and technological efforts to protect Internet freedoms around the world" What am I missing here? What are these guys doing that EFF, EPIC or other organizations isn't already doing?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gexcolo 12y agoThe United Kingdom is colored Yellow, yet there is Internet censorship in the UK: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_censorship_in_the_Uni... The description mentions the ISP-controlled, opt-in "filtering" plans, but not the state-mandated no-opt-out censorship of an indeterminate number of websites (the lists are not public)
- shawabawa3 12y agoThe state mandated no-opt-out censorship appears to still be the choice of the ISP. At home, using virginmedia I can't access the pirate bay. At work (unknown ISP), I can
- undefined0 12y agoIn the UK, they have censored filestube, took down filecrop and others. Why I mention this instead of TPB? Well, filestube, at the time of the censorship, didn't encourage copyright infringement, it litterly was just a search engine for file host links. The excuse they gave for censoring it was that they couldn't keep up with the takedown notices. Imagine if they applied that logic to Google.
- biomechanica 12y agoI'm pretty sure Canada removed it's Hate Speech law. http://news.nationalpost.com/2013/06/27/hate-speech-no-longer-part-of-canadas-human-rights-act/ http://news.nationalpost.com/2013/06/27/hate-speech-no-longe...
- pinpoll 12y agogreenyoda, what do you require to assign a colour to Austria? I could maybe help you out here doing some research according to your criteria. One of the last major "freedom initiatives" in Austria was our government's decision to abolish the data retention law on Juli 1st to comply with EU law - a small victory for data protection activists.
- tom_scrace 12y agoDo they say anywhere what exactly it means for a country to have 'net neutrality', 'safe harbours' etc?