6 ms·
The Dutch Pension Plan
- mooreds 12y agoHip hip hooray for reality based accounting. The Dutch system may not be perfect, but they are doing as best as can be done within the bounds of financial uncertainty. They definitely get points for choosing pain now vs pain later and aligning incentives more precisely.
- bwb 12y agoSo well thought out :)
- qwerta 12y agoArticle is just b*t. There is zero criticism, zero data, just naive adoration. It is sad to see something like that on NY Times. My friend worked in Netherlands for 6 years. He lost 20% of his salary, he will get ZERO, because he is not local resident.
- bwb 12y agoShould you design a pension system for the people retiring there, or the half of percent of people who are visitors?
- qwerta 12y agoNo, but why to make it compulsory for 'visitors'? He is EU resident. Imagine in US you would be forced to contribute to state pension, but would get your money only if you work for 30 years in single state. Moving from California to Texas == zero pension.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nomercy400 12y agoDutch here. Everybody has to pay if you work. This goes for pensions, this goes for healthcare, this goes for social security. It only works if everybody who works, contributes. I do however find it strange that he's not entitled to a pension he paid for. I guess the EU isn't ready for that yet.
- bulte-rs 12y agoHe is actually entitled to it. You can always arrange for a buy-out (uitkopen); you're still liable for income tax if you contributed pre-tax on your pension.
- danielweber 12y agoDid he not know he was going to work in the Netherlands? I'm open to the idea that the European countries are overtaxing its citizens, but if someone moves there, I say they're getting exactly what was advertised.
- qwerta 12y agoHe was planning to stay long-term, but had to change his job. Just saying this system is not as super as it sounds.
- radicalbyte 12y agoHe should also have paid a very low tax rate - a 30% discount on taxable income, which results in a rate closer to 20% than the 50% I pay. See: http://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-page/official-issues/taxation/30-ruling/what-it-is http://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-page/official-issues/taxation/3...
- davedx 12y agoYou're either earning EUR100k+, or your accountant sucks if you're paying close to 50% :P
- patio11 12y agoPotentially of interest to your friend, depending on their country of citizenship or primary residence over their working career: it is possible that there exists a totalization agreement between that country and the Netherlands which will count his years in the Netherlands system for the purpose of his public pension. A page on the subject, specific to the US, for purpose of illustration: http://www.ssa.gov/international/agreements_overview.html http://www.ssa.gov/international/agreements_overview.html
- smutticus 12y agoIf he had what Dutch people call a pension, it's still his, and he can still collect it. We're not talking about money given out by the Dutch government at retirement. By pension, we're talking about investments made during the lifetime of your employment that the employee owns. If he made contributions to a Dutch pension he still owns it. That's property, and has nothing to do with residency.
- Gmo 12y agoYour friend is not well-informed. If he is a European citizen as you indicate (more exactly, if he is a European resident, as for outside Europe, I have no clue), he will be able to transfer his annuity to his country of residence. As far as I know, he can do it now or he can do it a few years before going into retirement. Source : I'm exactly in the same situation and asked at the services of my current country of residence (France)
- danielweber 12y agoThe Economist looked at pensions systems back in April 2011 and praised the way Netherlands run theirs. It's not just putting lots of money in, it's also keeping a lid on promises: if there is significant inflation, the retirees will have to share the pain.
- jmartinpetersen 12y agoA lot of pension funds in Europe are trying to convert people to market rate products, where the size of the future payouts are entirely dependent on the market. Most usually claim it is because they can give the retirees more, when the funds doesn't have to be so conservative with investments. In some cases, though, it is also similar to what's seen in the US - there might not be enough money in the coffer to honor the guaranteed interests.
- jandrewrogers 12y agoThe challenge for pensions in practice is that they are fundamentally either very expensive or very risky, but almost everyone involved pretends like this tradeoff does not exist. People hate uncertainty but few people can afford to eliminate it to the extent they wish to. People want a pension to be "guaranteed" but they do not want or cannot afford to pay for that guarantee either directly or indirectly. This incentivizes both the sellers and buyers of these pensions to engage in willful denial of the financial fundamentals of pensions; they convince themselves the much cheaper product to be almost as good as the real thing because they can't actually afford the real thing. The layer of indirection between the recipient and the underlying securities makes it that much easier to bury dodgy assumptions. To the extent moving to defined contribution and market products eliminates the popular fiction enabled by pensions, it is an improvement. The actual risk is more transparent to the recipient even if they would prefer to not deal with it.
- radmuzom 12y agoWell, Netherlands has a better minimum wage compared to the US even after adjusting for PPP. [1] Private insurance companies are regulated by the government and MUST offer a core universal package including the cost of all prescription medicines. They must do this at a fixed price for all. [2] Taking into account these two facts, the article makes sense and provides good reasons why the system works. Looks like progressive policies with healthy government regulation always works better than the free market. [1] http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/09/how-americas-minimum-wage-em-really-em-stacks-up-globally/279258/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/09/how-amer... [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_the_Netherlands http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_the_Netherlands
- neonhomer 12y ago> Looks like progressive policies with healthy government regulation always works better than the free market. Can you elaborate? Since the US is far from a free market when it comes to healthcare I'm not sure how you are making that comparison...
- radmuzom 12y agoI am doubtful whether the free market exists anywhere in the world (please correct me if I am wrong). My theory is that whenever it tends to exist, a few corrupt players (government or private) will tend to game the system and take all the riches for themselves and the market will not be free any more. That is because the Econ 101 which free market theorists tend to talk about does not take into account human psychology which is far more important. The alternative is a shared sense of social well-being(not socialism or communism) with healthy government intervention, rather than individualism which Americans seem to be fond of. I would accept a lower GDP where people are happy (subjective) over the American way of life any day.
- adventured 12y agoThen why do free market systems produce by far the greatest standard of living as compared to any other system? To the degree that countries use the free market, they're prosperous, it's that simple. If you were right, Hong Kong would have been impossible. People like to reference Scandinavia. Well, Swedes in the US possess a higher standard of living than Swedes living in Sweden do. And Sweden's modern boom the last two decades was produced by a shift toward the free market, rather than away from it. Previously it was mired in a long-term stagnation brought on by heavy welfare state policies. The free market version of the Untied States produced the first, and by far the largest, true middle class in world history. There isn't even a close second. Prior to the the US abandoning the free market system 40 years ago, it was basically at the top of the pile in nearly every metric, from education to savings to growth to upward mobility to standard of living; along with an amazing college system that was affordable, and an affordable healthcare system that was the best in the world. If the welfare state worked, it wouldn't be collapsing rapidly all around the planet. The debt piled up faking prosperity under the welfare state system has begun to come due, and all those gains that were pulled forward to pretend the system worked, are eroding.
- smutticus 12y agoWhat a puff piece. I am the proud owner of both a Dutch pension and an American 401k. I much prefer the American 401k. If only because I don't have to pay 15% front loaded commissions everytime money gets put into a fund. I had to claw and fight with my Dutch pension company to even understand how much of my contribution they were taking on their front loaded mutual funds. And the sad part was that most of my Dutch colleagues didn't even understand why I was so upset about it. Another thing that sucks about the Dutch pension system is that once I hit 65 I'm forced to buy an annuity with it. Most likely my pension company will trick most people into buying an annuity directly from them, but I do have the option of shopping around. Work for multiple companies, get multiple pensions and multiple annuities. There are options for rolling over one pension into another. But nothing as straight forward as a TIRA, and nothing where you can choose what funds are actually held. I was told by an independent Dutch pension expert that my Dutch pension is standard, so my case isn't an outlier.
- nodata 12y ago15% upfront forever, or 2% fund total per year like in the UK?
- wsc981 12y agoAs a Dutch freelancer, I will avoid collective pension funds like the plague. I'm quite certain that once I reach the age of my retirement (70?), there will be very little money, if any, left in the collective funds. The biggest issue with the Dutch pension system is that one doesn't safe for himself / herself, but instead pays for the current elderly people. With more and more elderly people and less and less workers, eventually this system won't be sustainable anymore. Dutch people should watch this informative movie: http://www.dumpert.nl/mediabase/6576741/e81f2c3e/beste_pensioenstelsel_ter_wereld_uitgelegd.html http://www.dumpert.nl/mediabase/6576741/e81f2c3e/beste_pensi...
- unknownBits 12y agoPensions are (your)savings, done by some large profitmaking organizations. Now all the money is in there they are starting to steal it(of course), with the excuse that the economy is in heavy weather. It is normal nowadays to see them scraping off 10% a year. Those billions are just magically disappearing. And all those hardworking people can say bye bye to their savings. It's more a proof that you can never trust a large profitmaking organization taking care of your money.
- MaysonL 12y agoFor a more detailed description (from the viewpoint of the pension fund association, so possibly somewhat overly favorable) see: http://www.pensioenfederatie.nl/Document/Publicaties/English%20publications/Nederlandse_pensioensysteem_Engelstalige_versie.pdf http://www.pensioenfederatie.nl/Document/Publicaties/English...