6 ms·
> This is a very interesting perspective; did you ever travel to rural parts of China? China isn't what would normally be considered a western society; I assum
by rsynnott 12y ago
> This is a very interesting perspective; did you ever travel to rural parts of China?
China isn't what would normally be considered a western society; I assume they were talking about the developed world.
Much of the developed world does have substantially better social safety nets that the US, and lower rates of income inequality, though probably not due to the distribution of ownership of farmland.
- zo1 12y ago"Much of the developed world does have substantially better social safety nets that the US, and lower rates of income inequality" Can you point me to your sources on this, I'm quite curious?
- dragontamer 12y agoThe better social safety nets are damn obvious. Much of Europe (including UK) has free education up to College-level, truly universal healthcare (State-Sponsored for all citizens). As for income inequality, the statistics are pretty telling. http://money.cnn.com/2011/11/08/news/economy/global_income_inequality/ http://money.cnn.com/2011/11/08/news/economy/global_income_i... But it is the goal of liberalism to have strong social safety nets and equalize pay to all. The US has a different culture with different values... tending towards the "conservative" and with great trust in market forces. "Obamacare" is seen as Socialism and half the population seems to hate it. But Obamacare only establishes rules for the free market to operate under... standardizing health care plans across insurance companies. There is no state-sponsored health care from the law, and yet people are still worried about socialism. Obamacare is closer to Credit Card reform, in that it forced all credit card companies in the US to standardize upon the "Annual Percentage Rate" / APR so that everyone can comparison shop across credit cards. With Obamacare, all insurance companies have to offer similar plans (bronze, silver, gold, platinum), and they must cover certain provisions (contraceptives make the controversy here). So now when you see a "Bronze" plan from say... Aetna Health Insurance, you know it is similar to "Bronze" plans from Kaiser Permanente. As far as the "Socialism" goes... US has had Medicare / Medicaid for nearly 80 years now. The "socialist" part of our health care system has existed for a very long time, but no Republican seems to want to attack it. But inside the US, any new laws upon the market is seen as a "Market Distortion" and is criticized as "Socialism". Because most American's don't even know the meaning of that word. The absurdity in the "Net Neutrality" argument is more proof of the free market sheeple ignoring important issues and placing their trust in the free market instead.
- gretful 12y agoObamacare is closer to car-insurance, with the caveat that even if you don't want a car you still have to buy the insurance. THAT is what has most of the nay-sayers agitated. Medicare/Medicaid are, like the student loan programs with college tuition, at least partially responsible for driving up the costs of healthcare in the US. We've backed ourselves into a very difficult corner, and getting out of it isn't going to be easy, and it won't be popular.
- dragontamer 12y agoObamacare is closer to car-insurance, with the caveat that even if you don't want a car you still have to buy the insurance. THAT is what has most of the nay-sayers agitated. I must be listening to different nay-sayers than you. http://www.foxnews.com/on-air/oreilly/2014/07/24/bill-oreilly-obamacare-and-socialism http://www.foxnews.com/on-air/oreilly/2014/07/24/bill-oreill... Bill O'Reilly, who is frankly a good conservative voice, clearly thinks that "Obamacare is Socialism"... that it is about income redistribution. Which tells us a few things: Bill O'Reilly hasn't read Obamacare, and he also doesn't understand what "Socialism" means. Otherwise, he'd be attacking Medicaid. And Bill O'Reilly is actually an overall intelligent guy. I do enjoy listening to him a lot of the time. His opinion and views are generally very reflective of conservatives. So when Bill O'Reilly gets it wrong, it reflects poorly upon conservatives as a whole. ------------- Without getting into the Obamacare debate, you have to admit that a fairly large portion of the conservative crowd doesn't even understand what "Socialism" is. That's what I'm trying to say. Obamacare is a massive example. The individual mandate has absolutely nothing to do with socialism or income redistribution, but is instead a provision to eradicate "pre-existing conditions" clauses in insurance companies. Socialism is... like the US Postal Office. The Government ownership of a service that the Free Market could take over. (ie: FedEx / UPS)
- gretful 12y agoNothing? So the fact that young (presumably healthy) people HAVE to buy insurance to make ACA a success means nothing. It's pretty clear that the mandate IS Socialism.
- dragontamer 12y agoMuch of the developed world Hardly relevant when we're comparing the USA to China however.
- rsynnott 12y agoThe original comment said that the US has big poverty problems compared to other western countries, not compared to China.