5 ms·
The problem that Dan Geer pointed out at his NSA talk [1] isn't that they have some surface level vulns, it's that they are mostly all running linux from 5 year
by dmix 12y ago
The problem that Dan Geer pointed out at his NSA talk [1] isn't that they have some surface level vulns, it's that they are mostly all running linux from 5 years ago and rarely get security updates. Home routers are insecure by default. The problem is that even if your home router gets hacked and bricked, you go to BestBuy or Newegg to buy a new router and they are all running the same old broken OS by default - not including the questionable services and awful vendor-created software included (ie Asus cloud management software with 5x CVEs).
So he posed the question: What if all home routers get hacked and wiped in a mass attack against a country? People can't go out and buy new ones since they are just at risk and will probably just get hacked again. This puts a large amount of any countries technical infrastructure at risk.
The router manufacturers really need to step up here. And even technical users could benefit from more options on the market for secure routers, instead of just DIY OpenBSD boxes.
I'm curious if the gov will ever pressure these companies for better security, although they seem to prefer insecure-by-default.
[1] http://geer.tinho.net/geer.nsa.26iii14.txt http://geer.tinho.net/geer.nsa.26iii14.txt
- uptown 12y agoWith their renewed public stance on privacy and security, do Apple AirPorts have any better track-record regarding router security, or do they suffer from the same types of flaws?
- wlesieutre 12y agoWhile I can't speak to many specific vulnerabilities, I do know that Apple issues software updates for their routers. More importantly, they provide their own router management utility (Mac/Windows only), which everyone will have installed when they set up their router. It notifies you of new firmware releases and prompts you to install them. Yes, you could do something similar on an admin panel at 192.168.1.1, but nobody's every going to check it. As much as I loved my WRT54GL and its various 3rd party firmwares, I think Apple's approach is better for general use. Their most recent release was in April 2014, IIRC in response to Heartbleed. http://support.apple.com/kb/DL1708 http://support.apple.com/kb/DL1708
- evan_ 12y agojust to add to what you're saying, they also have an iOS app to control their router, and you can update the firmware from that.
- wlesieutre 12y agoAs an addendum to my own thoughts, this approach is better from Apple, but I don't have much faith in Belkin, Linksys, Netgear, etc. being able to pull it off. Given all of the issues we've seen recently with their router firmware, the router "cloud" features, and the number of different models, I don't think they could do this successfully. Netgear has (at current count) 97 wireless routers for sale on Newegg, including some duplication for refurbs. Whatever the exact number is, it's a lot more than 3.
- wmf 12y agoYes, it's a completely different business model. Retrofitting security into organizations that view software/firmware as disposable is probably so expensive that they will argue that it's impossible.
- lunixbochs 12y agoI'm not aware of any serious vulnerabilities for AirPort routers. They run a pretty clean version of NetBSD with very few services. However, there are some internal Apple services (presumably written in C) running on the router to facilitate configuration, AirPlay, Back to my Mac, Time Machine, and maybe others. The minor things I know offhand: - The old configuration protocol transmits your password (and everything else) in pretty much plain-text, which can be theoretically intercepted by someone connected to your network (and anyone listening when you set it up for the first time). I think the newest configuration protocol uses Secure Remote Password, but I don't know if anyone's audited their implementation. - When new AirPort routers first come online, they broadcast a public open WiFi hotspot to allow wireless setup. This can be accessed by anyone within range. An attacker could make a device (say, a WiFi Pineapple) automatically connect to every AirPort it sees and configure it maliciously. Using only public information, you mostly be able to annoy the owner (maybe intercept some traffic by updating their DNS settings). I won't rule out someone dropping a rootkit on your router during the open configuration period, but the simplest method (a firmware update) at this point will cause the router to reboot so it's at least a bit conspicuous. Also see this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8441500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8441500
- ultramancool 12y agoThere are better options. There are custom firmwares available such as Tomato, OpenWRT, FreeWRT and DDWRT. These all have more dedicated developers issuing regular updates and are generally more secure, current and feature complete than the original firmwares. Many of these are open source and have active communities even. Problem is that these all require some technical knowledge to install. Some are pretty simple though and can be installed once by a semi-technical person then left alone. But that's not enough for mass adoption. What we need is more manufacturers simply to give up on developing router firmware and simply pay the devs on these quality projects to do the work for them. They've proven their dedication and can surely adapt to new hardware with relative ease. Some router manufacturers are already doing this. I know at least Buffalo was for some time.
- plorg 12y agoI have three different routers running DD-WRT (I couldn't manage to find usable packages of the other three firmwares you mention). Of those, one is running kernel 3.2.12, one is running 2.6.34, and one is running 2.4.37. I know for a fact that the one running 3.2.12 (firmware build 2012) is never going to be updated, as newer builds are larger and do not fit in the router's flash. The others are in a similar situation, with their builds not having been updated since 2011 and 2010 respectively. I appreciate what the DD-WRT people are doing, but I would hardly hold them up as the paragon of updated, secure firmwares.
- pwr22 12y agoOutput from OpenWRT, on 4MB router Linux gw 3.3.8 #1 Sat Mar 23 16:49:30 UTC 2013 mips GNU/Linux
- pwelch 12y agoI have this exact same problem. I used to run an Asus Router with DD-WRT and it was awesome. However, the firmware version I needed never got updated again for whatever reason. Along with the barrier to contribute back to the DD-WRT project I moved on. Are any other Firmware versions out there more actively maintained?
- gear54rus 12y ago> home routers get hacked and wiped in a mass attack against a country Who would want to do that, I wonder. I mean, it's not a one-click process, on that scale, diversity will be an important factor (FW and HW versions, manufacturers, OpenWRT and stuff). It seems to me that this would require a lot of effort and the result will be questionable. What will be achieved by this? I think if someone cares about security, they've already flashed DD-WRT by now and those who don't... well, router (in)security will not stop their systems from being overtaken.
- watty 12y agoSome people just want to watch the world burn. But you're right, it'd be an extremely difficult task on that kind of scale. It's like saying someone could just brick every PC in existing using some magical Windows 0-days.
- thisGuysAccount 12y agoyeah, they'd need something like a botnet spread out over multiple branches of the internet, to prevent backbone-level shutoffs of the attack, and a metasploit-like framework that could extend the attack vehicle as the number of known vulnerabilities grow leading up to the attack. ... I'm pretty sure the infrastructure exists for organized crime to do this, just going by what I've read in the news.
- ezrathesleepy 12y agoI would not be surprised if the various cyber-warfare teams for government players have contingency plans in place for doing exactly what you describe. Except they might have more strategic plans in mind than merely bricking the owned devices. I wonder if there might already be sleeper code in place for this purpose? Botnet zombies seems to be the most obvious use-case, though. Or create your own TOR-type network to obscure the origin of criminal activity. With sufficient density of vulnerable devices, you could setup your own mesh network to send your nefarious packets through someone else's Internet gateway miles away.
- 12y ago
- makmanalp 12y agoWhat we need is a worm that uses the most common vulns to reflash these routers with a recent version of openwrt. Yeah, right ... :)
- danielweber 12y agoAnd even technical users could benefit from more options on the market for secure routers, instead of just DIY OpenBSD boxes. This is a pretty active market already. It's called "Unified Threat Management" by the analyst firms. Keep your support up-to-date and they (ought to) take care of keeping the latest firmware on the device for you. Here are a bunch: http://mosaicsecurity.com/categories/68-unified-threat-management http://mosaicsecurity.com/categories/68-unified-threat-manag... NB: I used to work for one of those companies.
- peterwwillis 12y agoFirst of all, a Linux box from 10 years ago is no less or more secure than Linux box from 2 days ago. I'm positive I could put a Linux 2.2 box on the Internet today and it'd never get hacked. Second, your hypothetical mass attack would be easy to fix. Reinstall Windows on your malwared-up desktop, buy a new router, plug them both in, and update the router using approved vendor sites. There's no WAN hacks and the client machine wouldn't have any malware on it, so it could update safely. The router manufacturers just need to disable all remote administration features and require a USB or CAT5 "admin port" to access setup functionality. Honestly, a bare-bones firewall with no features other than DHCP and NAT is all 99% of people use anyway.
- sebcat 12y ago> So he posed the question: What if all home routers get hacked and wiped in a mass attack against a country? People can't go out and buy new ones since they are just at risk and will probably just get hacked again. This puts a large amount of any countries technical infrastructure at risk. That's just plain old FUD, nothing new under the sun! I realize this is not a very constructive comment, but the fact of the matter is that some people in the information security business likes these types of extravagant displays of "this is the end of the world as we know it!" Not many SOHO-routers have capabilities exposed to the outside world. I mean, yes, it would be nice if the world was a safer place, but it's all about risk management, and risk is a factor of probability and cost, and the probability level here is very low.
- mschuster91 12y ago> That's just plain old FUD, nothing new under the sun! LOL. AVM, biggest german manufacturer of soho routers (Fritzbox) suffered from a RCE vulnerability; hackers pwned the boxes and made highly expensive premium calls.
- meowface 12y agoThere's no doubt that some particularly bad routers out there are vulnerable to RCE by default (usually because they have remote management enabled by default and have an authentication bypass issue or some other dumb flaw on the login page), but it's definitely FUD to speculate that someone can wipe "all the routers on the Internet". Most routers are incredibly insecure, but a good portion of those vulnerabilities can only be triggered if you share a LAN with the router or have and can widely deploy a XSS/CSRF exploit.
- sebcat 12y agoLaugh all you want, what you are saying does not invalidate my point. How big was the Fritzbox market share?