5 ms·
Satya Nadella Email to Employees: RE: Grace Hopper Conference
- aceperry 12y agoI guess that means he recognized that he put his foot in his mouth.
- x0x0 12y agoIt's in Satya's interest for employees not to demand raises. Goes for men too. I bet he tells employees not to share salaries either. All it does is breed discontent when you find out how much more your peers make. Instead, you should work super hard and hope the salary fairy will recognize your contributions! Everyone in a company should go interview every year or two and figure out how much $ you're worth. If you're underpaid, you'll be in a great position to either get a raise or hop jobs. Of course assholes like Mark Suster will tell you not to hop jobs -- you might get paid what you're worth! Instead, you should stay at startups, be underpaid, and bust your ass. Especially if Mark invested. Don't listen.
- pm 12y agoWhen has Mark Suster said that?
- akkartik 12y agoI think he means http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2010/04/22/never-hire-job-hoppers-never-they-make-terrible-employees http://www.bothsidesofthetable.com/2010/04/22/never-hire-job....
- csallen 12y agoUgh, the post you linked is baffling. "You’re in it more for yourself than your company." Obviously! It's called rational self-interest. It's the company's responsibility to treat their employees well enough that it's in their best interest to work there. If you've spent a lifetime honing your skills, why would you want to work for someone who doesn't understand this or doesn't care?
- pm 12y agoI like much of Mark Suster's writing, but I agree with you on this point wholeheartedly. Not all companies are built the same. There are lots of unhappy people pissing their life way doing shit they don't like - I don't intend on being one of them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- x0x0 12y agoNope, it's your job to close the sale. I just indicate I'm open to being sold.
- acjohnson55 12y agoIt's also in his interest not to appear to be an aloof non-ally of women in tech.
- SeoxyS 12y agoI think it's impressive, and somewhat refreshing to see someone so plainly admit "Sorry, I fucked up, I was wrong. I know better now." I was expecting more bullshitty-tasting PR-written damage control.
- CHY872 12y agoIn fairness, this technique is very normal, just perhaps not in recent years. http://www.check-six.com/Crash_Sites/Shiga-SFBay.htm http://www.check-six.com/Crash_Sites/Shiga-SFBay.htm
- yid 12y agoI think that's the point. Apologizing sincerely seems to be a forgotten art.
- CHY872 12y agobut he didn't. he said he answered the question wrong, not that the answer was wrong. You could argue about semantics, but it's clear at a very superficial level to everyone that he answered the question wrong - wrong forum, wrong wording - but that says nothing about how correct the answer is. Like for a personal parallel, it would probably be wrong to announce to a friend that you thought they were ugly, no matter how correct you were. The sincere apology would have been to announce that his answer was incorrect - otherwise he is just trying to pacify the mob, if that makes sense. Perhaps I'm being a little pedantic, but this email has clearly been proofread by a number of people, and the key statement is definitely not as clear-cut as this HN thread seems to be deciding (it's a very clear-cut non-statement). Edit: Criticism definitely fair, I jumped to conclusions.
- alasdair_ 12y agoIn the UK, people would typically say "I answered the question wrong" and consider it synonymous with "The answer I gave was wrong". Many Indians (that I know personally at least) seem to copy UK speech patterns more than US ones. I think you are reading more into this than is really there.
- timothya 12y agoVideo of the interview: http://new.livestream.com/accounts/10060267/events/3447060 http://new.livestream.com/accounts/10060267/events/3447060 The question about women asking for raises happens around 01:34:04.
- yen223 12y agoAs a person who can't currently view videos where I am, what was the controversial statement that Satya made?
- manachar 12y agoIn short: Satya indicated that women shouldn't ask for raises and let it all work out in the long term. A mashable article on the topic: http://mashable.com/2014/10/09/microsoft-ceo-women-karma-raises http://mashable.com/2014/10/09/microsoft-ceo-women-karma-rai...
- ChrisAntaki 12y ago> what was the controversial statement that Satya made "It's not really about asking for the raise, but knowing, and having faith that the system will actually give you the right raises, as you go along. And that, I think, might be one of the additional super powers, that quite frankly, women who don't ask for a raise have. Because that's good karma, it'll come back! Because somebody's going to know, 'That's the kind of person, that I want trust.'" He's assigning good karma to a lack of assertiveness in women.
- Confusion 12y agoNo, he's assigning good karma to everyone that places trust in colleagues, managers and 'the system'. Which may seem naive and even incomprehensible, but that does not preclude that he actually believes it and that his belief system is something that is as worthy as any of ours.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago
- suprgeek 12y agoRefreshing to see Satya clearly state "I answered that question completely wrong." No weasel words there...as opposed to so many other non-apology apologies.
- general_failure 12y agoI see signs of a great CEO here. Owning up for mistakes is not easy!
- BadassFractal 12y agoNot really. When you say something that stupid, you have no option but to backtrack. Imagine if he answered one of the questions with the assertion that "black people must die". Do you think we would have had much of an option there?
- quesera 12y agoThe question remains: did he merely misspeak, or is he actually that disconnected from what it's like to have a job? It's good to see a clear and quick retraction, but jeez -- did the words really reflect a thought he had in his head?
- BadassFractal 12y agoExactly. "I answered that question wrong" to me read like "I should have been more politically correct with my wording", it doesn't change the fact that in his head he actually thinks employees should shut up and work hard hoping that good things will happen to them.
- x0x0 12y agoAnd ignores that -- if you believe minimsft, and there's little reason not too -- microsoft is an extremely political company.
- x0x0 12y agoDefinition of gaffe -- saying what you really think.
- nandemo 12y agoI'm surprised that people are surprised. I'm male and I've heard variations of "you shouldn't ask for a raise/bigger salary" many times from my managers or hiring managers (when looking for a job). For example: "you shouldn't be focusing on money, just do great work and the financial rewards will come [someday]". Or "we are looking for people who have passion for $whatever_our_company_does, not people who are primarily interested in higher compensation".
- danielweber 12y agoYeah, I've heard that, too. Fuck those guys. I remember Steven Yegge said "every time someone has tried to make me happy with money they've succeeded, usually on the first try."
- Mizza 12y agoHey guys, I didn't mean it from a _male_ perspective, I meant it from a _management_ perspective! It's okay that way! Yes, it's nice that he's admitting he said the wrong thing (thanks to the Twitstorm), but let's not forgive him so quickly for showing us how management really thinks.
- ntkachov 12y ago>Maria asked me what advice I would offer women who are not comfortable asking for pay raises >If you think you deserve a raise, you should just ask. Great Advice. A+. His original answer probably answered the question better. The answer he gave for the question he was asked was very appropriate. The "Do it anyways" response that was given by Maria doesn't answer the question, it avoids the topic all together and doesn't help the person for whom its an actual problem.
- brandonmenc 12y agoI'm not saying that merely asking for raises will close the wage gap, but since when did "if you're uncomfortable doing something you should be comfortable doing, you need to force yourself to start doing it" become bad advice?
- gohrt 12y agoMaria gave some useful advice: she said to role-play a negotiation. Satya said, "you are getting paid enough, don't worry about it", which isn't true for most women and isn't true for most men either. (But may be more true for some men, men who already figured out how to ask for a raise.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- javert 12y agoThis comment is a perfect example of "given them an inch and they'll take a mile."
- piyush_soni 12y agoIn any case, how does that show misogyny? Even if we assume he really thinks that way, what's the evidence that he doesn't think like that for men?
- kylec 12y agoI know the question was posed at a conference about women in technology, but I think a good answer to the question of how to ask for a raise goes beyond narrowing the pay gap between women and men. There are plenty of men, myself included, that also feel like we're not getting what we're worth and what our colleagues are getting, but don't have the knowledge how or courage to confront our manager and ask for a raise. Perhaps women are more predominately or more severely affected by this issue, but there's more to it than the men/women pay gap. I liked Maria Klawe's answer a lot more, it provides some really useful advice beyond "if you think you're being payed less than your male peers, ask for a raise".
- penprog 12y agoDid he really rise to being CEO of Microsoft by believing the bs he said? If he did, he has to be one of the most fortunate people on the planet. Male or not.
- raghavsethi 12y agoIf I may put a bit of a cultural spin on this, his comment sort of reflects the culture in India, where a vast majority of people do not feel comfortable simply asking for a raise. Most people (men and women) essentially follow the strategy that Nadella suggested, to work harder and believe that you will be rewarded for it eventually. I'm not in any way suggesting that this is an effective strategy (especially for women), but it might explain his comment somewhat. Great apology, though.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- benjaminButton 12y agoSettle down, no need to sensationalize. That's not what even the OPs comment meant. Also, no, not everyone in India treats women like "chattel" (heck most of them worship them) and I'm pretty sure, neither does Satya.
- neilellis 12y agoI am not commenting on Satya in this reply, just the idea that either a) all women are treated like chattel in India or b) no women are treated like chattel in India. Neither of which of course is true. Women's lack of equality in India, compared to the UK, are in general I'm afraid pretty appalling, when I was younger I nearly moved to India for a while. But my wife who is of Indian descent was extremely reluctant because of they way they are treated in India compared to the UK. The rights of women are minimal compared to men. That's just the reality. On the other hand they are allowed out of the house unescorted, so as always it's a sliding scale. Don't get me wrong India is home to some of the loveliest, kindest and gentlest people I have ever met. On average I'm pretty certain I'm a much less decent human being than the average Indian. It is a country which has many great qualities we can learn from over here, just not respect and equality for women. And that omission, like the caste system, is very saddening. But hey I have a huge log in my eye :-) People worship their cars, personally I wouldn't equate desire with respect.
- wildpeaks 12y agoThe 502 error "Invalid response" that the server returns right now is ironically spot on.
- FlyingLawnmower 12y agoFull text below for those who have difficulty accessing the site: All – Today I was interviewed on stage by Maria Klawe at the Grace Hopper Conference – I encourage you to watch the video. It was great to spend time with so many women passionate about technology. I was honored to be a part of it and I left the conference energized and inspired. Toward the end of the interview, Maria asked me what advice I would offer women who are not comfortable asking for pay raises. I answered that question completely wrong. Without a doubt I wholeheartedly support programs at Microsoft and in the industry that bring more women into technology and close the pay gap. I believe men and women should get equal pay for equal work. And when it comes to career advice on getting a raise when you think it’s deserved, Maria’s advice was the right advice. If you think you deserve a raise, you should just ask. I said I was looking forward to the Grace Hopper Conference to learn, and I certainly learned a valuable lesson. I look forward to speaking with you at our monthly Q&A next week and am happy to answer any question you have. Satya
- ChrisAntaki 12y agoFor context, here was Satya's first answer: > "It's not really about asking for the raise, but knowing, and having faith that the system will actually give you the right raises, as you go along. And that, I think, might be one of the additional super powers, that quite frankly, women who don't ask for a raise have. Because that's good karma, it'll come back! Because somebody's going to know, 'That's the kind of person, that I want trust.'" I hope every woman at Microsoft asks for a raise tomorrow.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cilantro1994 12y agoSathya's first answer is probably based on his innate belief in teachings of Bhagavad Gita. Many Indians believe that. In short, what karma yoga means is that "One acts without being attached to the fruits of one's deeds" It backfired. But lot of people believe in it. Personally it keeps me calm and do my work. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karma_yoga http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karma_yoga Background: The Bhagavad Gita gives a summary of the karma yoga process.The Gita itself is a chapter from the epic known as Mahabharata, wherein a dialogue takes place between the prince Arjuna, and his friend and chariot driver, Lord Krishna, on the brink of a great dynastic war. Their conversation is prompted by Arjuna as he is engulfed by sorrow and misgivings regarding the oncoming battle in which he has friends and relatives on both sides. In reply, Krishna then elucidates upon a number of philosophical yoga systems and practices (including karma yoga) by/through which he should indeed continue with the fight on righteous principles.
- atomical 12y agoMy take is that he doesn't want to encourage anyone to initiate or challenge a raise. That's a pretty normal response from someone in a leadership position.
- kqland 12y agoAsking for raise because you are woman ? How is that not gender discrimination against men ? Guess, US does not follow its own law. There are literally hundereds of thousands of women coming here from India, China and working hand-in-hand with men. IN many many cases I can show you women earn more than men. Problem is that liberal femi-nazi propaganda is flawed. You can't just take average of salary for women and compare it with men. There are depth and breadth of job categories and averaging out salaries does not work. Read "Flaw of Averages" from Sam Savage of Stanford to better understand the game. If you are really competent enough go change the jobs , work for startups, work for top 10. Who is stopping you ? Now , don't complain that companies don't hire you because you are a woman. I feel that US is gradually following path of Scandinavian countries where women ultimately want to overpower men rather than seeking equality. Many feminazi movements are for free social welfare. What about men who also quietly accept job and underpaid for years and years. Just look at many smart engineers still working ass-off after 10 yrs and getting 100k. Learn to look and live outside silicon valley. One last point I want to bring is that if you create business hostile environment not only talent will run away but also companies will start to migrate. America has fought war after war for 20 years and I respect those who have lost lives , served the country. When you create/join any movement don't think short term or instant gratification rather think long term social+political+economical impact for you and your children. I feel bad that America is on downward spiral and unless some magic happens or you get another MLK ; its very hard to stop the demise.
- izzypark 12y agoAs a female in tech, this is disheartening because it discourages men to advocate or talk openly for gender equality. How awful is it that we just shamed him publicly so instantly? I hope men aren't discouraged by this. Guy needs a bear hug.
- jcheng 12y agoThe takeaway I got from this article is that some women in tech find the very idea of male allies condescending: http://readwrite.com/2014/10/09/technology-sexism-male-allies-grace-hopper-celebration http://readwrite.com/2014/10/09/technology-sexism-male-allie... What do you think?
- izzypark 12y agojcheng - The problem of gender equality cannot be solved by women alone if that's what the author is insinuating. Of course men can't truly empathize, they aren't women. It's about awareness. Most senior board positions in the corporate world are held by men - they don't think it's a problem at all and the thought doesn't cross their mind. Not all of them need to "get it right" right away but getting them to talk is a good next step. My school recently did a student body survey on this topic: 34% of my male colleagues think American companies have policies in place to help men & women succeed vs 17%(!) women. http://whartonjournal.com/2014/09/29/wharton-women-in-business-wwib-survey/ http://whartonjournal.com/2014/09/29/wharton-women-in-busine...
- CmonDev 12y ago"Most senior board positions in the corporate world are held by men" Why focus on gender? I think every board should have first-generation immigrants, people of different faiths, different races and genders and most importantly no more than 50% should come from rich backgrounds and prestigious universities.
- QuantumChaos 12y agoI agree, it seemed like he was driving at the idea that we shouldn't dismiss the way women were acting as wrong, but instead try to see the advantages of their approach. Even though he didn't say it like this, I imagine his thought process was that being overly aggressive in negotiations creates ill-will and hurts you in the long run. Maybe there are men out there who constantly ask for raises and would be better off if they didn't. >I hope men aren't discouraged by this. 90% of men are simply trying to avoid the entire issue as much as possible, because stuff like this happens all the time.
- alecdbrooks 12y agoI suspect he gave his standard advice about raises without considering the circumstances or that it wouldn't work equally well for men and women. That's not an excuse, but a reminder that sexism doesn't have to be deliberate to be sexism. On the positive side, he did apologize without the typical spin or qualification.
- gojomo 12y agoIt's sad how every outlet is putting in its headline some form of: "Satya Nadella to Women: Don't Ask for a Raise". But "don't ask for a raise" weren't his words. His actual words were subtly different, and more along the lines that it can be OK not to ask for a raise – you shouldn't have to ask for a raise – when a compensation system is working right. It was sort of a "don't feel too bad" reassurance to women who are not comfortable pushing for raises. The main problem with his answer was that it was sufficiently unclear as to allow for the "don't ask for raises" misinterpretation... and lots of people rush to the worst, rather than best, interpretations. Who can report subtleties when there's revenue-goosing rage-hits to attract?
- Bud 12y agoI think you are doing a good thing by pointing out his exact words. You are right that subtle differences matter. However, Nadella was still incredibly tone-deaf here...and this wasn't the first time. He's been doing this over and over. And in this case, the compensation system is NOT working right, and he certainly knows that, and the question was clearly asked in that context...the context of what we should do about a failed system which is unequal and unfair.
- kqland 12y agoPay is based on background + experience + knowledge and how much company see as valuable resource. There are literally hundreds of thousands of women from India and China earning $100k salary in California itself. If you average out salary across depth and breadth of jobs and complain women don't earn enough I pity you. Look out for "Flaw of averages" from Dr. Sam Savage of Stanford. If you are competent what is literally stopping from changing company ? or Start your own business ? Complaining that you get paid less because you are women is nothing but non-sense. Show me recent graduate girls ( women ) earning less than recent grad boys. In US you don't just look at salaries. You look at total compensation which includes PTO, 401k, holidays etc etc. Each company is different so some companies might be paying low on salary but high on PTO. So all I am saying is you can't just average out and claim that you are getting paid less. By the way how this is not gender discrimination ? Guess US does not follow its own law. There are thousands of men also who get paid less , go years without increase what about them ? Why no movement for them ? US is following path of Scandinavian countries and it is very sad that it is in downward spiral.
- chrismealy 12y agoCome on people, have a little class consciousness. Don't expect upper management to give you good career advice.
- drawkbox 12y agoExactly, he is thinking as CEO here and the last thing they want is everyone asking for a raise every 6-12 months. He was also led into it a bit when asked about why women haven't asked for a raise that are successful. I think he should have said when I think the best time to ask for a raise is, just after a major delivery or few. After proving substantive worth via projects/ship is the best time to ask for an uptick. It is more about the timing than anything. I think he was trying to say it this way but failed.
- chrismealy 12y agoCome on people, have a little class consciousness. Don't expect upper management to give you good career advice.
- BobMarz 12y agoIf only the press and twitter got as worked up about the multi year wage fixing lawsuit that may or may not go to trial rather than these little gaffes and gotcha moments
- ps4fanboy 12y agoLike asking a bank the best way to avoid paying interest.
- CmonDev 12y agoThis is so sad. Why not say this: "I believe all intelligent beings should get equal pay for equal work." This includes races, genders, being offshore/onshore, being a shareholder or an employee etc.
- xerophyte12932 12y agoOn the topic of getting a raise, i wholeheartedly agree with this blog post: https://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20140908150126-76592-get-a-raise-in-2015-ask-this-one-question https://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20140908150126-7... TL;DR: The best way to ask for a raise, is to ask your manager/superior "What do I need to do to get a raise?" Asking what you need to do to receive a raise does the following: - Maturely suggests that you want one without putting your supervisor on the spot - Communicates that you are willing to do what is needed to receive one - Generates clear goals for you to work towards - Exposes areas where your boss thinks you need to improve - Foreshadows whether you should be looking for a new job
- jschlemm 12y agoI was there and it was interesting to see the crowd react to his comment. The dynamic shifted shortly after he made the comment, then the crowd cheered when he was presented with the correct response. I just think the backlash is crazy and there are certainly a group of people that are focused on making noise and not progress
- hakcermani 12y agoIf he has never asked for a raise in all his career, such a thought process would not be out of place. Granted saying this in a women specific forum will not go well, but his later tweet, that we need to close the gap is precisely what needs to be done. Regarding employees in general having to ask for raises, i cannot say much, as in my job career of over 30 years, never had to ask for one. I thought I was fairly compensated - maybe i was too happy in my job :-( but life has not been bad.