9 ms·
Honestly what it really boils down to is resources and money ("resource" can also be described as "money" therefore really money and money). Up until very rece
by Someone1234 12y ago
Honestly what it really boils down to is resources and money ("resource" can also be described as "money" therefore really money and money).
Up until very recently there were simply not enough hazmat suits, not enough burn-able bedding, not enough people (who wants to work with Ebola?), not enough disinfectant, and heck even clean water in SOME areas.
Then you have to consider how damn hot it is there, so a $5 hazmat suit may not cut it (this article covers that). Now you're dealing with suits costing tens of times more than that for basic AC, just to allow the people in them to work longer shifts.
You also have a lot of local population pushback. The hazmat suits scare people, and all locals see is Ebola patients go into treatment and die. There is a lot of suspicion that Westerners are getting people sick to kill them, so they hide away family members until they get infectious.
What can be done? Money, and resources. It isn't a magic bullet but if you train a metric ton of local people and give them everything they could possibly need it would at least slow the spread if not reverse it entirely...
PS - This article is exactly WHY I am not legitimately concerned about a wide-spread infection in the Western world. We are simply too rich, we have or can acquire the resources, and even your average Joe Smith on the street can Google how to protect themselves from Ebola exposure.
- gohrt 12y agoWe also need to stop intentionally delivering fake medical care http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-cia-fake-vaccination-campaign-endangers-us-all/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-cia-fake-vacci... and then wait decades to earn trust back.
- chernevik 12y agoThat episode probably (hopefully?) hasn't much to do with the Ebola thing. Apparently it has been a huge problem for the polio eradication effort in Pakistan. A very, very serious error by the CIA.
- ghshephard 12y agoIt may turn that those actions by the CIA result in more deaths than occurred as a result of 9/11. Absolutely no excuse or justification for using the cover of medical treatment for their para-military reconnaissance in that situation, particularly as it turns out it was never needed anyways.
- tokenadult 12y agoThere was Islamist opposition to polio eradication campaigns before anyone in the West was sure that Osama Bin Laden was in Pakistan. (That's why it surprised me that vaccination campaigns were used as a ruse for verifying his whereabouts, but apparently Bin Laden's personal crazy ideas didn't include opposition to vaccination.) It's not entirely a coincidence that even before anyone heard about Bin Laden, the last few places on earth with endemic polio were all places with militant Islamist movements. Personally, I would rather have my children live long healthy lives, no matter whose idea it was to invent vaccines or to use a vaccination campaign as a pretext to find an international fugitive, but logic doesn't always appeal to people who are already making excuses for being illogical.
- sliverstorm 12y agoparticularly as it turns out it was never needed anyways. Let's avoid armchair quarterbacking.
- ghshephard 12y agoI was more commenting on zero dark thirty, in which the attempt to get genetic material by the doctor was prevented, and played no role in the actual decision to storm the compound. You are correct in that the reality may have been somewhat different than the movie.
- tokenadult 12y agoYour comment is quite irrelevant to the topic of this thread, which is efforts to prevent deaths from ebola, a disease for which there is currently no vaccine.
- pilsetnieks 12y agoIt's not about vaccines, it's about doctors' access to patients.
- ObviousScience 12y agoIt's not like the US intentionally infected a bunch of people in a foreign country with a disease because they were curious about it, then waited 65 years to apologize for their crimes.[1] And certainly the US government would never lie about treating people for a disease in a government program, and then just watch them die instead of actually helping them.[2] Snark aside, have you ever considered that maybe there's a reason people don't trust the US government to act ethically or in their interests? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guatemala_syphilis_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guatemala_syphilis_experiment [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuskegee_syphilis_experiment http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuskegee_syphilis_experiment
- adventured 12y agoYou're referring to things that happened 60 or 70 years ago as a reference basis for trust, for a government who has as its President a man born 53 years ago. There's a long list of warranted criticism to throw at the US Government, but I don't see how your examples are valid criticism of today's government. The US Government of 1950 no longer exists. Yet you're referring to it as though it does. I guess Angela Merkel is not to be trusted because of what happened 70 years ago? Or Shinzo Abe?
- Rapzid 12y agoYou always here about this stuff 60-70 years afterwards unless it was leaked. This is because the people involved are long buried and everyone alive can deny involvement...
- snowwrestler 12y ago"It happened before I was born" is a pretty good denial of involvement.
- lutorm 12y agoWhether it's rational to not trust either the US or German government because of what happened in the past, the actual situation is that such actions are not easily forgotten. There are plenty of people who still carry suspicions against Germany for what happened 70 years ago.
- danieltillett 12y ago>This article is exactly WHY I am not legitimately concerned about a wide-spread infection in the Western world. Leaving aside the moral argument of preventing huge numbers of innocent people from dying Ebola if we can, there are two reason we in the west should be concerned: 1. There is a serious risk that Ebola will mutate to become more infectious. It is very unlikely to become airborne (this is about as likely as pigs becoming airborne), but it could relatively easily mutate to slow down its kill speed. At the moment Ebola kills so quickly that there is little time for a patient to spread it to other people. Ebola is under huge selection pressure to slow down the disease progression in humans. We could see a strain arise that takes a month to kill you where you are asymptotically infectious for a couple of weeks. Model this sort of virus and things look far less rosy for us in the west. The more people we let Ebola infect the more likely that such a strain will arise. 2. Once the number of cases get very large (25,000 a day by Jan 2015 according to the CDC) this is going to start disrupting international trade as countries close their borders. We already saw the sort of recession that can result from disruptions to trade when this happened in the GFC and the Asian crisis in the 90s. With interest rates at or near zero in most countries there is not much that can be done to buffer us economically.
- AlexDanger 12y agoYou can bet Madagascar will be the first to close their borders.
- asdffdsajkl 12y agoFor those that didn't get the reference - this is a reference to the web game pandemic in which the objective is to design a virus/bacteria/parasite to infect the entire world - Madagascar is the hardest country to infect in this game because it only has one port in the game.
- phkahler 12y ago>> There is a serious risk that Ebola will mutate to become more infectious. Not likely. Survival of the fittest for a virus usually means allowing the host to live longer - in other words LESS lethal. It is not likely to become airborne, and if it did it would not be ebola any more. The symptoms of most diseases are not an accident, they are tied to the means of transmission: Colds make you cough and sneeze. Flu makes you cough, sneeze, barf and sweat. Rabies makes you crazy and want to bite. STDs some think may make people horny. Ebola makes you barf, shit, bleed, sweat. The one scary thing is I once read that a single gene make Ebola hemoragic, and if that were to transfer to a flu, that would be very deadly. But it would also be less virulent due to that same deadliness and so would be selected against as our response to related flu vidii would wipe it out. None of that is helpful short term, but this notion of the virus getting more horrible than it already is, I don't think so.
- DustinCalim 12y agoI do agree that we(humans from other countries) should all just dump resources on the people there - but I think the legitimate concern here is that while we squabble about resources and their cost, the virus spreads and mutates - and if it makes the jump to airborne, I think it will make the average Joe Smith pretty vulnerable.
- sliverstorm 12y agoIt's a prisoner's dilemma sort of thing. The best outcome for ME is if YOU dump lots of money into it, so I sit around on my hands hoping you take action, while YOU do the same waiting for ME to take action. As a result, we arrive at the worse outcome- nobody does anything.
- danieltillett 12y agoThis is the philosophical explanation for government taxation. In this particular case I think we can say that it is now beyond voluntary funded NGOs to solve.
- robomartin 12y ago> This article is exactly WHY I am not legitimately concerned about a wide-spread infection in the Western world. I guess you have never been in a disaster in the western world. Well, I have. More than once. And I have seen what people can devolve into. I'll probably get voted down mercilessly for saying this: The truth of the matter is that "civilization" is thin-skinned. It doesn't take that much for people to revert to cave-men behavior. The worst thing we can do, by far, is to adopt a smug "won't happen here" attitude in the "civilized", "educated" and "sophisticated" west. The minute we don't attack this as the existential threat it is, we are simply setting ourselves up for a catastrophe of unimaginable proportions.
- cturner 12y agoIt's not just resources, it's also about trust. The government/foreign operations had basically shut down Ebola earlier in the epidemic. But there was an atmosphere of conspiracy theories associating the operation with the outbreak of the disease. Ebola cases went underground. The foreigners had started to pack up and go home when it reemerged.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]