7 ms·
UW fusion reactor concept could be cheaper than coal
- pyrocat 12y agoNeat! I wonder what the next steps for commercial use would be, since the patent is filed through the UW's Center for Commercialization and funded by the US Department of Energy. Could BP or whoever come in and say "we're interested" and throw money at them to build a full scale reactor (in a few years)?
- johlindenbaum 12y agoI think "a few years" is optimistic. I would assume a lot of the community is holding its breath to see how ITER fares once it's switched on in 8-12 years. Nobody knows for certain if it's possible to generate a plasma on earth that can heat itself, and then produce excess energy. And by that time the anti-fusion lobby will have poisoned the mind of the average power user to believe that fusion = fission.
- Filligree 12y agoThere's an anti-fusion lobby?
- johlindenbaum 12y agoGreenpeace and others. http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/ITERprojectFrance/ http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/IT...
- Semiapies 12y agoJust the people who've been hearing "fusion is right around the corner!" for the last 40 years.
- rfrey 12y agoIt was editorial license by johlindenbaum to call it an "anti-fusion" lobby, but we can all agree that there's a pro-fossil-fuel lobby.
- johlindenbaum 12y agoGreenpeace is very outspoken against fusion, as they believe it carries the same dangers as fission. http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/ITERprojectFrance/ http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/IT...
- jotm 12y agoWait, there's an antifusion lobby? Who are they? But yeah, people will still think negative when hearing about "nuclear". Maybe we should change that to "Atomic" to make the distinction and give it a less negative connotation :-).
- johlindenbaum 12y agoGreenpeace and others. http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/ITERprojectFrance/ http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/press/releases/IT...
- pjlegato 12y agoExxon, BP, Shell, Chevron...
- chc 12y agoI can't find any examples of any of them lobbying against fusion (which is unsurprising, since lobbying against something that is currently impossible is not a good use of funds).
- VLM 12y agoThose are mostly oil financiers providing capital to contractors who do the work, and project management. They won't care. Too much oil is used for transport and petrochemical (aka plastic) industry. Some of the peculiar niche uses for petrochems are much less price sensitive than bunker A boiler oil, so they would make more money overall in the long run if people used oil more wisely, which sounds weird but is an economic truth. You care a lot about the price of gas in your car, but you probably don't really care about the cost of plastic in your legos, so if it went up by 10x it would still be a rounding error at the checkout line although in the long run they'd make more money. The coal companies, on the other hand, are likely concerned.
- jotm 12y agoIf anything, they'd be the first to invest in working fusion technology. They already invest billions in alternative energy research - to secure their own domination in the future, but still...
- karmicthreat 12y agoFrom what I understand its mostly a materials problem because the plasma just erodes everything.
- jerf 12y agoI doubt it. There isn't much ITER can do that will surprise anybody. Even if it works perfectly, it still won't produce economical fusion. People already know that if you want practical fusion you've got a huge opportunity to bypass ITER.
- mdturnerphys 12y agoUW student and patentee here. That's what the UW C4C is for—to license UW-developed technology to interested parties. They front the money for filing the patent and then recover the cost when the patent is licensed to an outside party (or by the inventors, if they want to commercialize their work on their own).
- crusso 12y agoWhat's the rationale for patenting work funded by taxpayers? The research was funded by the U.S. Department of Energy.
- mdturnerphys 12y agoThis is definitely something I've wondered about before. Links to some decent references are below. Basically, the idea seems to be that giving patent rights to grant recipients gives them an incentive to develop and commercialize ideas that will benefit the public. Taking a concept from the lab to the marketplace is often a non-trivial affair, and patent rights are a way to drive that process. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayh%E2%80%93Dole_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayh%E2%80%93Dole_Act [2] http://www.mofo.com/resources/news/2002/10/the-governments-patent-policy-the-bayhdole-act-a__ http://www.mofo.com/resources/news/2002/10/the-governments-p...
- serf 12y agobut doesn't this act also stymie concurrent tech developments from competitors in their respective fields? Is a monetary incentive for the grant recipient really a greater moving force for the market within a specific industry than capitalistic competition amongst the existing forces in that industry?
- mdturnerphys 12y agoSome academics do work on specific problems with a known commercial application, and sometimes this research is funded by commercial entities. The primary goal of most academics isn't to produce commercial products, but in the course of research useful things can pop up. Giving patent rights to grant awardees gives them the ability and incentive to commercialize offshoots of their research. Here's an example (I'm not a biomedical guy, so please excuse the errors): Dr. Brown researches some disease. He's not particularly trying to come up with a treatment for it, just trying to understand it better. He's in academia, so he needs to publish papers to get tenure and receive grant funding. The NIH funds his research because it's somewhat promising and because he will do a good job educating students. Suppose his group happens to discover a chemical compound that seems to be effective in treating this disease. What happens next depends on whether the university can patent this discovery. Before the treatment can be prescribed by doctors it needs to receive FDA approval, which requires expensive clinical trials. Without patent protection, no one (neither the university or outside companies) is willing to fund the trials because they won't have exclusive rights to sell the treatment once it's approved. Dr. Brown could work on the trials himself, but that would mean neglecting his other responsibilities. No one has a sufficient financial incentive to make the next step, so the treatment never makes it to the market.
- jobu 12y agoAfter so many years of hype around fusion it's hard to take press releases seriously. This bit at least offers some hope: "The researchers have successfully tested the prototype’s ability to sustain a plasma efficiently, and as they further develop and expand the size of the device they can ramp up to higher-temperature plasma and get significant fusion power output." Unfortunately they don't mention how long the plasma was sustained.
- api 12y agoHype is a double edged sword. Without it, nobody pays any attention and you can't raise money. With it, everyone ends up disappointed and you can't raise money. :)
- jdnier 12y agoYeah, that seems to imply they've already achieved a sustained fusion reaction. Seems like that would be big news on it's own.
- jdnier 12y agoThe dynomak paper abstract (http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0920379614002518 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0920379614...) makes it all sound conceptual/simulated.
- brwnll 12y agoThis article concludes with "The research was funded by the U.S. Department of Energy.", does this impacts the availability of the research to other researchers? Even with the University of Washington in my backyard, I hope the advancements in such an important field are shared as widely as possible. On the fusion topic, energy.gov reports 63 active US Fusion Program Participants, and over 100 total (including gov't, private companies, international with US pressence)[1]. But last year the Boston Globe reported that MIT was shutting down, "The shutdown will leave only two fusion experiments in the United States, one at Princeton University and the other at General Atomics, a company in San Diego", due to a cutoff of federal funding.[2] Anyone have any insight on the actual current state of fusion energy R&D in the U.S.? [1] http://science.energy.gov/fes/research/fusion-institutions http://science.energy.gov/fes/research/fusion-institutions [2] http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/05/19/fusion-energy-research-mit-shut-down-people-lose-their-jobs/x8CDMwik26faDd9FmwlrTO/story.html http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2013/05/19/fusion-energy-re...
- m0th87 12y agoHow this works depends on the department that's funding the research. With NSF/NIH grants, it's at the desecration of researchers on whether they want to apply IP rights. Other departments (mostly DoD) do contracts for research and own the IP afterward, but I'd bet DoE is in the former camp.
- jff 12y agoThe specific contract with the DoE may have defined ownership and distribution of the results, but in general it should be possible for the creators to get IP ownership from the DoE if for example they want to create a company around the technology.
- mng2 12y agoThe DOE actually provides research funding for most 'hard' sciences. Particle physics and supercomputing are primarily funded by DOE, for example. Unless it's classified, the research is open.
- elektronjunge 12y ago
- tokenadult 12y ago"University of Washington engineers hope to change that. They have designed a concept for a fusion reactor that, when scaled up to the size of a large electrical power plant, would rival costs for a new coal-fired plant with similar electrical output. . . . . "Right now, the UW’s concept is about one-tenth the size and power output of a final product, which is still years away. The researchers have successfully tested the prototype’s ability to sustain a plasma efficiently, and as they further develop and expand the size of the device they can ramp up to higher-temperature plasma and get significant fusion power output." Well, good luck to them. But this is a press release about a "concept," and it has not been tested out as a source of electrical power (as contrasted with being a test-bed for plasma containment) at all yet, at any scale. Solving the plasma containment problem for a fusion reactor is something I have been waiting for more than forty years. If it was easy, it would have already happened. Maybe the new concept will help solve that problem, but maybe not. At the very least, we still have NO IDEA what the economics of running a power plant will be at scale when using this concept. Many, many submissions to HN are based at bottom on press releases, and press releases are well known for spinning preliminary research findings beyond all recognition. This has been commented on in the PhD comic "The Science News Cycle,"[1] which only exaggerates the process a very little. More serious commentary in the edited group blog post "Related by coincidence only? University and medical journal press releases versus journal articles"[2] points to the same danger of taking press releases (and news aggregator website articles based solely on press releases) too seriously. Press releases are usually misleading. Not all press releases spin their statements as badly as one very bad example a skeptical blogger commented on,[3] but all of them should be compared to independent sources for a second opinion. Whether in medical research or in reports about new breakthroughs in energy production, press releases often run ahead of the facts. The most sure and certain finding of any preliminary study will be that more research is needed. All too often, preliminary findings don't lead to further useful discoveries in science, because the preliminary findings are flawed. The obligatory link for any discussion of a report on a research result like the one kindly submitted here is the article "Warning Signs in Experimental Design and Interpretation"[4] by Peter Norvig, director of research at Google, on how to interpret scientific research. Check each news story you read for how many of the important issues in interpreting research are NOT discussed in the story.
- 12y ago
- cowardlydragon 12y agoMeanwhile, Thorium could be done now...
- anigbrowl 12y agoWhat's stopping it, though? There are new nuclear plants being constructed in Georgia and there's ~$1 trillion budgeted for renewal of the US nuclear arsenal over the next 30 years (see http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/22/us/us-ramping-up-major-renewal-in-nuclear-arms.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/22/us/us-ramping-up-major-ren...). This is about as favorable an environment for Thorium reactors as can be imagined, certainly compared to the last few decades. While I think the technology is promising, if it's such a done deal where's the private capital seeking a building permit?
- discardorama 12y agoIf I had a penny for every time I see how some so-called breakthrough technology "could be X", I'd be very rich. And the bigger the impact after the "could be", the lesser the chance that it'll ever happen.
- mikeash 12y agoFission was supposed to be "too cheap to meter." This seems to be getting way ahead of itself. Seems like they should look to hit important milestones like producing more energy from the reaction than is required to sustain it, before they start worrying about producing electricity for pennies per kilowatt-hour. Walk before you run, and all that.
- tedks 12y agoIf we had stayed with fission instead of bailing after relative non-incidents (Chernobyl and Three-Mile Island), wouldn't it have drastically increased the power supply to almost that point? The casualties, even the most indirectly computed casualties, from nuclear accidents are far, far less than the casualties from coal. It's going to get even worse once the sea levels really rise. A single fission plant used to supply about a third of my energy; if they had proliferated to the extent people thought they would have, it energy would have, in fact, been a lot cheaper. Democratic ignorance and regulation killed that dream, though. At least we still have "clean coal."
- Retric 12y agoChina which cares little about what people think and has huge air quality problems. Yet it is still building a lot of coal plants instead of nuclear. Which might suggest there not the ideal solution you think they might be. France was actually the most reliant on Fission of any country and even they are stalling far back from there peak despite having few actual problems of any kind.
- slavik81 12y agoThere are 72 nuclear reactors being built around the world right now. 29 of them are in China. They're building more reactors than the next four builders combined. That is, more than Russia, India, Korea and the United States put together. [1] The Chinese government has stated that they want to decrease their reliance on coal by building more natural gas, nuclear and solar power capacity. [2] Aside from a few regions, I don't think they've stopped building coal plants entirely, but the Chinese government pretty clearly likes nuclear power. [1] http://www.iaea.org/PRIS/WorldStatistics/UnderConstructionReactorsByCountry.aspx http://www.iaea.org/PRIS/WorldStatistics/UnderConstructionRe... [2] http://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2013/09/12/the-war-on-coal-goes-global-china-bans-new-plants-as-obama-epa-plans-killer-regs/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2013/09/12/the...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]