9 ms·
The Curse of Increasing Marginal Work Utility, or Why I Work So Much
- marvin 12y agoThis is only true if you don't value the "compulsory" part of the job: Teaching, writing grant proposals, supervising Masters-level students, supervising Ph.D students where you do not publish as first author, etc. The system is set up so that researchers don't primarily research, which is a big problem and places absurd incentives to do an unhealthy amount of work. On the contrary, I find that in most jobs I do, there is decreasing marginal utility of my work, since I have a finite amount of energy and the quality of my work goes down as I cross the 40-hour mark. People seem to have individual differences in where this cut-off point is, but I have yet to meet someone who claims it is not there. So for me, given that I value all my work, the concept of increasing marginal utility of work is strange. It would perhaps be different in another field than plain vanilla software development consulting, would be interesting to have a discussion around this.
- roye 12y agoI was also thinking along these lines as I read, and there have been plenty of articles posted on HN on the diminishing returns of working too long. Basically it boils down to people getting tired, and especially in creative pursuits, it helping to get away from your project and let your mind wander sometimes. What I expected the author might say is that with many accumulated hours you become more efficient such that over time your output per hour grows, but his view seems quite different.
- _delirium 12y agoI think it's pretty common in tech jobs as well. A frequent setup is that you have a longer-term project that's really interesting but not deadline-pressing, so you can only work on it when you've gotten other immediate things out of the way first. There are attempts to try to explicitly make schedule space for the interesting long-term work (like Google's 20% time), but it still often ends up that you have to get a bunch of other less-interesting stuff off your plate each day or week, before you can get to the best stuff.
- wastedhours 12y agoYeah, I've got an interesting website reflow project that's on my todo list and will make a big difference, but it's not a priority I can block time out for, and the daily stream of tasks that need to be done "now" means I rarely get to it, but simply adding more hours to my work day wont actually produce the desired/best work.
- tonyedgecombe 12y agoYou might be surprised with what you can get away with not doing from your stream of daily tasks that need to be done.
- wastedhours 12y agoI'm pushing that to its logical extreme already ;)
- mooreds 12y agoThis is the whole 'urgent vs important' work problem (ironic that I'm posting on HN, which is neither). Covey's time management grid describes the problem: http://www.usgs.gov/humancapital/documents/TimeManagementGrid.pdf http://www.usgs.gov/humancapital/documents/TimeManagementGri... (pdf)
- vec 12y agoNot to mention that quite a few small companies don't have the ability to hire a dedicated sysadmin, IT staff, and/or customer support rep. These tasks falls to the engineers. Doing these tasks is almost certainly a suboptimal use of any single product engineer's job, but if they don't get done by someone the business won't be a business for long.
- nazgulnarsil 12y agoRecognizing the increasing marginal utility of work is exactly what allows you to live your life well. IF you take advantage of it correctly. Imagine you are stuck in a room with 10 screaming people. You could expend a bunch of effort and get one of the people to stop screaming, but this hardly seems worth the effort. There will still be 9 people screaming, and now you will be too exhausted to work on your own projects. Instead you devote a little effort to learning how to deal with the screaming while you get your work done. THIS IS A MISTAKE. It is a mistake because getting that person to stop screaming is a permanent improvement upon your situation. Getting the first person to stop screaming has very little utility, but the next one is easier AND makes an even bigger difference. The next one even more so, etc. By the time you get down to only 2 or 3 screaming people you are amazed at all the new things you can hear. You can almost hear yourself think! When you work on things that give yourself more capability you are making permanent stackable improvements. By the time I had fixed the loudest screaming voices of nutrition, sleep, exercise, and constructively reacting to stress, I couldn't even recognize the person I used to be.
- tomohawk 12y agoAbsolutely! Other screaming voices: learning which meetings you can skip (and how frequently), learning which emails you can ignore, learning what can be dropped without too much consequence, learning which 'emergency' requests can be deferred (as they will probably be overcome by events anyway), effectively delegating instead of micromanaging. Basically, learn to stop sweating the small stuff.
- jamesaguilar 12y agoOne of my favorites: when "mandatory" actually is, and when it isn't.
- dclusin 12y agoDon't forget about its evil twin, three different people with equivalent rank coming to you with three different things and having all of them say this the highest priority issue you should be working on.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoThere is academic work studying this. The superlinear return on time invested does occur in a variety of fields, and pay tends to follow the productivity gains. Here is a paper which cites a lot of the literature (note: primary topic of the article is flamewar inducing): http://www.aeaweb.org/aea/2014conference/program/retrieve.php?pdfid=1103 http://www.aeaweb.org/aea/2014conference/program/retrieve.ph...
- sqrt17 12y agoI didn't read the paper in its entirety, but is the argument something like competition introduces a superlinear factor in the time/pay equation superlinear factors on average hurt women more than men since the latter are more likely to be on the upper end of workload (assuming a linear correlation of time/pay, you'd already get from a 77% "wage gap" to a pay gap of around 92%, which would tighten further or disappear if we account for "winner-takes-it-all" distribution of pay) I find it relatively easy to believe that today's working environment leads to an incentive structure similar to all-pay auctions, where the employer reaps huge benefits due to everyone's fiction of attainable winning, and which hurt a majority of people, but women more visibly than men.
- danielweber 12y agoLaw firms are a prime example of that. When the client calls at the end of a 60-hour work week, he wants to talk to the guy who is primary on the case. Even if he's burned out a bit, the answer he gets from him is still better than the answer any other person in the law firm could give him
- qwerta 12y agoAuthor basically has a hobby (research), which costs him lot of time. It is like a manager who can not code because of his job. There are two ways: * step down from administrator/teaching role and become full time researcher with all implications (lower salary, less prestige) * give others full supports to do "your research", give them credit, your ideas and so on. Sitting on too many chairs is just bad.
- _delirium 12y agoIf it was just a question of salary/prestige, I think taking a lower-salary job with more research time would be appealing to many people. But many pure-research jobs also have little employment stability, or just don't exist. The ones that do exist are often "soft money" jobs like postdoc and research scientist, which are tied to grants, typically with a contract length of 1-3 years. It's possible to chain such jobs together, but stressful and uncertain, and may require moving frequently (which can be tricky if you have a partner, and especially if you have school-age kids). There are stable research positions, but they tend to actually be high-prestige and hard to get, like faculty member or permanent fellow at a research institute (Institute for Advanced Study and the like). In some fields you may also be able to find research positions in industry, or at a national laboratory, and those options are pretty popular, where they exist. A really well-funded lab that can string together enough grants to insulate the research scientists from the money flow and provide them de facto permanent jobs can also be such a place, e.g. the heyday of the MIT AI Lab, which had many non-faculty researchers. Also a popular option when it exists, but fairly rare in CS (more common in areas like medicine).
- qwerta 12y agoI know situation fairly well, my wife works in marine research. Organization with 150 people has 10 HR persons. There are no money to fund research, everything went into fancy office. McDonalds stuff are paid better than lab assistants... My point is that people at such position can best serve science, if they funnel some money into actual research. There are many researchers, but qualified administrators who actually cares, are very rare.
- 12y ago
- aangjie 12y ago> But as I was good at research I got promoted to a position where I had to spend most of my time doing something else Peter principle??
- VLM 12y agoI would ascribe it to a different form of bad management. Lets say you have 10 first class applications graduated for every first class level job. There are immense value judgments to be made, but from a lazy manager perspective its much less psychically painful to just reward the guy who works the longest hours or has the worst stockholm syndrome (as this guy clearly has, because someone's getting a reward for his excessive work and it isn't him...) Things are always going to get weird when the supply is too large compared to the demand. If the average PHD creates 4 new PHDs in his lifetime, then all four are in deep trouble unless three extra jobs are created for them to sit in. What, you say the number of jobs is shrinking? Whoops. Life's going to suck for all four.
- aangjie 12y agoAh.. that's a better explanation. Thanks for that.
- michaelochurch 12y agoThis issue is one of the reasons the Iron Triangle (MacLeod-Gervais-Rao organizational model) is so interesting to me. See also: http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2014/09/28/can-agile-break-the-iron-triangle-can-open-allocation/ http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2014/09/28/can-agile-bre... . I spent a lot of time investigating this in a number of different organizations. What I found is that most people who think they're overworked and have "no time" are spending a lot of time working on the wrong things. They've volunteered for mediocre projects and created too many recurring commitments for themselves. Recurring commitments make it harder to fire you, but they don't do much for your career, because doing the same job 20 times doesn't deliver much more benefit than doing it once. If you work at a company where everyone works 9 to 8, you also have to work 9 to 8. The good news is that you can still probably get most of your work done in 2 hours, freeing up 9 to network internally and look for better projects, or read books/papers to study up on the skills your next job will require. If you never volunteer (except for a career-advancing project) and avoid recurring commitments, this means you have a lot of time to "learn on the clock". (Don't be dumb and write side-project code at your day job; you can do your exploration/research at your day job to make the side-project work more efficient at home, but it has to be done on your own time and machinery.) This is how most of the programmers who are reinventing themselves as "data scientists" are doing it. Doing more grunt work, here meaning work that you don't learn or gain anything from, is a pointless game (for the Clueless). You get tired faster, you're more likely to lose social polish and fail politically. The first people fired or PIP'd in a "low performer initiative" (which is a dishonest layoff) are usually overperformers who worked too hard, got themselves emotionally overinvolved, and lost the political game. It's only in a deep cut (10 to 20%) that the company runs out of politically-failed "pain in the ass" employees and start removing the long-term underperformers who've been hiding for years. Of course, there is work (growth-oriented work, in particular) where the returns are exponential and, for that kind of work, you shouldn't stop because it's 5:00pm. If one programmer is growing at 4% per year and the other one works three times as hard and grows at 12% per year, the difference over 20 years is that the former will be just 2.2 times more productive, and the latter will be 9.6 times more productive. (In capability, if not salary, I've seen programmers grow at 30 percent per year.) That may not matter for salarymen, but it's a big deal if you ever want to go off and start your own thing. The 4%-growth engineer is barely able to justify a senior-level salary; the 12%-growth engineer is a sought-after "10x" engineer. So what's the answer? If the work is strategically valuable and growth-oriented, do as much of it as you physically can do well. This doesn't mean neglecting your social life or relationships or fitness, because those are important too. It does mean that you shouldn't stop just because it's 5:00 and you're three episodes behind on the Walking Dead. (I'd say that the average person can handle about 65 hours per week; beyond that, it starts to get unsustainable for most.) For the scut work that's not going to help your career or teach you anything, that just gets shuffled around because no one wants to do it, do as little as possible. The politically optimal point, when assigned bad work, seems to be the 35th percentile in quality. Below the 25th percentile, you risk the appearance of having intentionally blown off the grunt work (which is different from just not being well-suited to it, because the former will be taken against you and the latter will be tacitly accepted) but above the 50th, you're in danger of doing it too well and getting assigned more of it. The importance is knowing the difference. You need to do just enough of the "dues paying" work to fit in, and avoid recurring commitments as much as you can get away with, but put as much of your work time as possible into the compounding-interest growth-oriented work, and as little into the dead-end grunt work. In Iron Triangle terms, this is why strategy wins out over dedication.
- Anderkent 12y agoI don't understand this. If he has the freedom to choose what he works on, and if it's conceivable that he could coast on 40 hours doing 'just his job', what forces him to spend the 40-60th hours on advertising research etc rather than doing his own? It seems like he should be able to just do his 40 hour job then do as much personal research as he likes after hours.
- analog31 12y agoIt seems like work because it's done at work. An aspect of an academic job is that once you've done your 40 hours, you are free to use your employer's facilities, which include physical infrastructure but also library access, and the "branding" of the university to promote yourself. This is what provides that extra utility. A line cook at McDonald's, if faced with what to do after putting in 40 hours, could at most make more burgers. Many white collar workers are restricted by things like confidentiality and conflict of interest rules. Many of us get our super utility out of hours 41-60 by having a side business at home.
- mooreds 12y agoMarginal utility to whom? The author? His university? Society? It seems to me in almost every case (except possibly the first) that everyone would be better served hiring someone to take care of the incidental work that consumes the first 60 hours (or as much as possible) and letting the professor work on his research. The fact that this isn't so points to a couple of possibilities. 1. Only the professor gets much utility out of his research--the organization which employs him would prefer him to spend his time on managing phd students and teaching. 2. Universities are organized to optimize for organizational utility and not for each professor's maximal utility. Incidentally, this story reminds me of many developers who are promoted to be managers and then are removed from what they loved about their profession in the first place. Similar to the author, such managers often have side projects at home to keep coding. Unfortunately, the professor doesn't have the option of 'dropping out' of management like the developer-turned-manager does.
- judk 12y agoOr, research, teaching, and management are ALL important and interconnected, and have increasing marginal utility.
- michas 12y agoMy main conclusion after reading the article is: "Man, you really should change a job". Problem here is that his job is divided into two different sets of duties: "boring" stuff like teaching students and "fun" stuff, aka "research". Employer tends to stress importance of boring stuff, forcing employee to spend most of usual 40 hours a week on that, because he knows, that employee would do "fun" stuff anyway, acting of his free will. It is just obvious Jedi mind-trick intended to make employees work more, without using whip.
- sgentle 12y agoLet's say you have a queue processor called Q. It takes in jobs described by tuples of (hours, utility) like (8,1), (2,4), (5,15). Using the above example, you make an interesting observation: if your queue processor processes only two items, it has an efficiency of (1+4)/(8+2) = 0.5 utilities per hour. If you process three items, it shoots up to (1+4+15)/(8+2+5) = 1.33 utilities per hour. Remarkable! It would seem that the more items on the queue you process, the more efficient this queue processor becomes. Perhaps you have just discovered the Law of Increasing Marginal Queue Processing Utility. Or perhaps the queue is being processed in the wrong order.
- judk 12y agoHigh-value items are often dependent on low-value* things * low value on their own. Breathing/sleeping/eating/commuting/booting-up is a very low value activity, but it is a prereq for all high-value activities
- mynegation 12y agoOr perhaps we attach a third field to the tuple and call it a "priority" and require that everything with higher priority is done before anything with low priority. Let's call it (I am probably inventing the term here) "priority queue". Author actually writes about it. There are plenty of tasks that may be of low value to him but are absolutely essential for external reasons.
- ivan_ah 12y agoFor certain types of academic work (e.g., writing a book) the mental cost of initially loading all the relevant material into working memory takes a very long time, so once I've paid this upfront cost, I tend to keep working as much as physically possible to amortize the upfront costs. If I stop working at 5pm like salaried ppl (or say 8pm like startup ppl), then the next day I'll have to spend another 2--3 hours to get back to the same mental state. I rather continue push on and ship something tonight (with some damaging health effects) than pay the upfront costs again tomorrow.
- Moru 12y agoAnd burn out at 40 realizing that you can't keep a train of thought more than 2 minutes.
- ivan_ah 12y agoYou don't even need to get to 40---I have mini burnouts all the time! I keep saying to myself this is the last epic push, and then I'll take it easy and work in a civilized way from this point forward. Now's the time...
- dantheman 12y agoOr just structure your time differently, work really hard for 2 days. Take a day off, work a half day the next and work a normal day. There are gains from working in long shifts, but if it's done everyday they completely disappear and turn negative.
- hawkice 12y agoFirst thought: this person has described a clear way in which his job is (truly, seemingly unfixably) broken. Second thought: this seems like a business opportunity. Why are there such high-ritual organizations employing these people? Third thought: Why are university professors allowed to do research at all if this isn't profitable? You'd expect if it makes them money they'd actually help, that's not happening, so it must not, but why have them spend so much time on it anyway? I keep hearing about publish or perish... what on earth is going on?
- xaa 12y agoThis author has an unusual view on what constitutes his job. In my area, bioinformatics and life sciences, it is taken for granted that a professor or PI (principal investigator) will be performing very few or no experiments personally. Becoming a PI is a devil's bargain: you get more resources and personnel to tackle the questions that interest you, but in exchange, you largely give up the ability to directly do research yourself. The research gets done, but the actual code is written or experiments performed by grad students and postdocs. The PI has two main tasks: 1) getting grants, and 2) deciding on the goals and methods of the research. Many PIs would argue that having a PI do experiments personally is actually a suboptimal use of time, like having Steven Spielberg meddle in minutiae of costume or set design instead of managing the big picture.
- jeffdavis 12y ago"These are all tasks that I must do - not doing them would mean that I am simply not doing my job... The utility of that sixtieth work hour is so much higher than the tenth or twentieth because I can use it do my own research." I don't think he makes a very good case here. The twentieth hour of work could mean the difference between doing his job and failing at it. The sixtieth could make him more prestigious. There is a good case to be made for increasing marginal work utility, but it's much easier to make in terms of basic numbers in an ordinary market economy: working more hours often leads to a higher average hourly rate. For instance, if you are a consultant, and you spend extra time writing books, you may become a recognized expert and be able to demand much higher rates. That makes it sound like overwork is logical. But this calculation targets only money, and money has a decreasing marginal utility. And many other aspects of life also have a decreasing marginal utility, which is why people lead varied lives. So, this problem has more to do with tunnel vision about your goals than with a fundamental curse of life. Keep at least a few goals in mind most of the time, and that will prevent you from falling into this trap. My list would be something like (not necessarily in this order): health, family, friends, financial security, achievement, helping others, and making improvements for future generations. Usually I'm falling behind in a couple of these areas at any given time, and that helps me see what I need to do to change.
- rverghes 12y agoThe problem here is that the first 40 hours of work--which the author believes has low utility--are the hours which generate the money to pay for the author's job. The author places higher utility on the next 20 hours, but those hours don't generate money, but prestige and scientific advancement. The situation is similar to an artist who cannot (yet) make money off her "artistic" work. Instead she has to do commercial work to support her "artistic" ambitions. Utility seems to have several dimensions. It's easy to say that the first 40 hours of commercial work have low utility, but without those first hours, you would not able to survive to do the rest of the work that you are more interested in. At the end of the day, you have to pay your bills. The work that pays your bills is not automatically lower utility than the work that you do for fun/prestige/skill/art/etc.
- thesteamboat 12y agoExcept that's likely not the case here. For many professors, their salary is effectively paid by grants they bring to the university, which depend solely on their research. People who are paid to be teaching with no expectation of research do not generally have tenure track positions.
- asgard1024 12y agoMy company (rather big american software house) doesn't encourage me to work very hard. The harder I work, the more of my coworkers will be let go, but the software will still suck the same. The customers will pay the same. The competition adopts a similar strategy.