3 ms·
I don't really get it. YouTube is under no obligation to host his content for free, and that's probably spelled out in excruciating detail in the Terms of Servi
by pavlov 12y ago
I don't really get it. YouTube is under no obligation to host his content for free, and that's probably spelled out in excruciating detail in the Terms of Service.
If he thinks it's fair use, why doesn't he just put the video file on his own server?
- Dylan16807 12y agoYoutube pretends to be an unbiased platform for hosting any videos (outside of certain categories like porn). But many of their processes have very unfair bias in them. Youtube is allowed to be unfair, but it's reasonable to complain about it.
- pavlov 12y agoThey're a corporation, so naturally they're biased towards their customers, shareholders and business partners. The important point is that the original poster doesn't fall into any of those categories. If he wants his file to be hosted by someone who cares, a Google subsidiary probably isn't that.
- Dylan16807 12y agoThis isn't about having a hard-working host for free. It's about basic decency: having a system that doesn't intentionally roadblock people without justification. If Google doesn't want to host videos for free, fine. But it needs to be honest about the service it's providing, no matter who the customer is. (I say intentionally because content ID is known to be horribly flawed, and they very deliberately have made appeals unworkable. If they would require DMCA notices instead then appealing would be easy.)
- darkarmani 12y ago> I don't really get it...If he thinks it's fair use, why doesn't he just put the video file on his own server? No, you don't get it. Not once did he ever suggest that youtube is under an obligation to host his content. He is criticizing their implementation of the DMCA. Youtube is dependent on uploaders and viewers -- if they piss those people off, what value does youtube have?
- maxerickson 12y agoYou're complaining about what someone else is complaining about but still surprised that they bothered?