5 ms·
Instead of spending all this money on private buses why not spend it on getting the local public transportation into better shape and give something back to the
by sschueller 12y ago
Instead of spending all this money on private buses why not spend it on getting the local public transportation into better shape and give something back to the community?
Am I the only one who find it quite sick that these large firms use private buses when they could be getting together to fix/improve what is broken?
- SeoxyS 12y agoActually, I see it as the complete opposite. Oftentimes, the public systems are so broken that sinking money into it is a lost cause. The entrepreneurial solution, taking matter into your own hands and building a better solution, is a much better alternative.
- sschueller 12y agoWhy not "disrupt" by starting a private "public" transport.
- SeoxyS 12y agoThat would be awesome! But, it's not really Facebook (or Google or Apple)'s business or area of expertise. That said, there are a few startups working on it.
- Daishiman 12y agoBecause on the long run it doesn't work. The city of Lima, Peru, has a system of informal buses which go through the city in different routes, and charge an extremely low price. On the surface, it works well, but it suffers a tremendous problem of lack of coordination which leads to huge systemic inefficiencies. The government of Lima is fighting back by improving the public transport infrastructure, but it's a project that will take decades.
- Houshalter 12y agoBut the system works, you're just saying it doesn't work as well as it ideally could if everything was coordinated.
- Daishiman 12y agoI'm saying it is objectively worse than the cities which have coordinated, centralized and effective public transportation systems and the overall cost in lack of regulation, pollution, noise, and other factors is much greater than the alternatives.
- function_seven 12y ago"Sick" is a strong word. They're not charities. It would be nice of them to contribute money beyond their taxes to improve the public transit infrastructure, but they are in no way obligated to do so. The cities, counties, and state should already be improving the infrastructure with the revenue they have.
- sschueller 12y agoThese companies don't pay taxes only the employees do. So giving back in by improving infrastructure would be beneficial to all. I don't think there is a law that forbids privately owned public transportation. They may need to be licences and follow certain laws but that should not stop someone from "disrupting" a broken system.
- frankchn 12y agoThese companies definitely pay property taxes for their buildings to the city/county.
- RangerScience 12y agoYou're reading more into the situation than is available. Do you know why the south bay has historically bad public transit, and particularly bad transit connections to the rest of the bay? Let me put it this way: There were (are?) overpasses that were designed to be too low for city buses to pass underneath them. Improving public transit requires the cooperation of multiple entities. Hiring private buses does not. We do not know, one way or another, if cooperation was attempted.
- x0x0 12y agoWhat? We do, of course, know that cooperation was attempted -- and San Mateo screwed us all. They're why bart doesn't come to palo alto. See eg the original map [1]. Half or more of the problem with all bay area public transport is that lots of the peninsula actively likes not having working public transit. I live in Belmont and I'm an active voter. Mayoral / council campaigns here don't outright say "no public transit ever" but if you read between the lines its there. Lots of people move to the peninsula to have their house in the suburbs (turning nimby the second the deed changes names), and public transit or dense housing is not desired. Of course, bitching about 101 or 280 doesn't stop just because they actively subvert the only way to fix our transportation fiasco. I do have a solution, though: it's time to give up on the bay area. I figure I can start a company in Tahoe and draw amazing engineers. Live in Tahoe and get 20 snow-days a year doesn't sell every engineer, but it definitely sells a handful of great ones. That's the idea, anyhow... [1] http://www.sonic.net/~mly/www.geolith.com/bart/figure1.html http://www.sonic.net/~mly/www.geolith.com/bart/figure1.html
- badusername 12y agoYou underestimate the amount of capital needed to even make a small dent in public transportation. I'm sure facebook's spend is not even a miniscule amount of what any public transportation project would take. It's quite amazing that these companies provide commuter buses, and that's probably the best way every private company can help the community. Each one of those buses probably takes hundreds of cars off the road, easing traffic and reducing pollution. I don't understand why the media is obsessed with viewing private buses as a symbol of privilege, and not as a practical solution to bay area's commute problem.
- sschueller 12y agoHow much more capital is really needed to operate these busses at a fixed schedule with specific stops and allow anyone to use them for a fee? Uber for public transport if you will.
- hoka 12y agoIt's not that simple. There are gigantic forces involved: government officials at several levels, unions, etc.
- sschueller 12y agoIf anyone can do it, it would be these companies which have more capital than god. :)
- TeMPOraL 12y agoAnd here we circle back to the original argument - them doing private buses is more cost effective way to give back to the society than wasting boatloads of money on trying to integrate with public transport infrastructure.
- DINKDINK 12y agoDisclosure: I don't work in the tech sector. I agree with you that I doubt that the budgets of tech company's transit benefits probably wouldn't make a significant impact in the effectiveness of public transit (or even get the same amount of bang for the buck). A problem with many of the initial transit offset arguments was that they didn't take into account that given the presence of the buses how many people chose to live in communities farther way from their work, when absent the buses, they would have moved closer. This and other externalities. Regarding "the media is obsessed with viewing private buses as a symbol of privilege" is because it is a symbol of privilege -- Unless you want to make the argument that it's a symbol of disadvantage. Someone who has a personal driver is more privileged than someone taking a private bus than someone taking a private car than someone taking a public bus than some poor chap who has to bike or walk everywhere. The reason why the media and much of the non-tech public has disdain for the buses is that it creates two cities. One set of people has access to travel means A and B and the second set just has access to B. The last time that sort of forced social sorting was prevalent in the United States was in the 1960's when there were White and Colored water fountains. These are the connotations the general public thinks about consciously or subconsciously.
- BorisMelnik 12y agoLast I heard in the news, one of the main reasons these busses exist is because FB employees don't want to / don't feel safe bussing it to work with the normal 9 to 5ers. And honestly I don't see why they shouldn't have a private bus. FB employees worked their asses off their whole life in school and learning to code etc.
- pm90 12y agoYou don't really need to justify their position. FB is a private company employing private buses for its employees. By doing so it is taking cars off the road. Full Stop.
- nemothekid 12y agoFBers don't bus to work because there isn't a bus that runs from San Francisco/Oakland to Menlo Park. What a completely strange and "us vs. them" rumor to spread.