9 ms·
How feminism helped me solve one of file systems’ oldest conundrums
- aftbit 12y agoIt seems to me that the author is conflating feminism with her helpful community of mailing lists, and further with good engineering practice. I don't see anything particularly feminist about reporting bugs upstream.
- muglug 12y agoShe's saying that the creation of a "safe space" for women to discuss linux development without fear of dismissal was key to her being able to solve the atime issue.
- andrewchambers 12y agoBut why limit it to a safe space for women, why not a safe space for anyone who doesn't want to be insulted? It seems sexist to me to assume men can't be in a non abusive community.
- HarryHirsch 12y agoThe point is that this is a polemic piece, it's Valerie Aurora after all. The opposite of polemics would be apologetics. Valerie is implying that feminism is equivalent to civility, civility in the Latin sense of being mindful of the rights and responsibilities to human society. That's where she loses me. And what's with this dehumanizing technique of not naming those she disagrees with? You see this often.
- hashbanged 12y agoThey name names, it becomes a radical feminist attack piece. People would ask, why did she attack so and so? They are so nice and do so many things for the community. What's with begging the question by saying "it's Valerlie Aurora after all"? It doesn't do anything for someone reading your comment who doesn't know what to think of her.
- sliverstorm 12y agoI'm not a gender studies major, but to me it seems safe to say feminism is rampant with sexism. Not necessarily in the hateful way, but in the way that affirmative action is fundamentally racist. So, while I may not always agree, it is never a surprise.
- daeken 12y ago"Feminism is the radical notion that women are people." - Rebecca West There's nothing sexist about feminism; it's simply wanting equality for women -- that does not mean that women and men are the same (as is often claimed), but that they are treated the same. Comparing feminism to affirmative action is incredibly misleading.
- ObviousScience 12y agoPretending that the definition you gave is actually what drives all the "feminism" movement isn't being honest: it's certainly true for most people, but there is (and always has been) a not-small branch of feminism that is staunchly sexist.
- hypatiadotca 12y agoKinda like Hacker News. CHECKMATE.
- Jach 12y agoRebecca West does not speak for all feminists. She wasn't even alive for the mess of the third wave we're still in. I'm just replying to say your comment on a first reading comes across as naive in the subject of feminism. But it can also be seen as disingenuous, for it's a classic propaganda technique to hide behind a reasonable claim made by a proponent of X_1 to further along some goal of X_2, all while using the undifferentiated label X. (See https://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/orwell46.htm https://www.mtholyoke.edu/acad/intrel/orwell46.htm on 'democracy'.) I also can't ignore that, left unqualified, an uncharitable reader may interpret your claim for men and women to be treated the same as a claim to be treated the same in all contexts, which is obviously a stupid idea, because men and women aren't the same. I'm not trying to argue with you, I'm just trying to encourage you to be less sloppy if you're going to reply to comments like sliverstorm's with intent to change minds. At best, your reply is just an argument over a definition (http://lesswrong.com/lw/np/disputing_definitions/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/np/disputing_definitions/), let's all try to do better.
- pessimizer 12y agoThe more we work to make every space safe for women, the less need women will have for a safe space. edit: There are enough exclusively male places for me to be feminist in, if I feel there's some sort of shortage of places to express myself.
- hashbanged 12y agoIt's a pretty accepted fact that men interrupt women and women do better when they have women authority managers or teachers. It's why there are women's colleges.
- TTPrograms 12y ago> But I was part of a culture – a feminist culture – in which I respected people like my friend and programmers that attempted to use fully defined, useful features of UNIX in order to implement features efficiently. That is one hell of a stretch of the definition of feminism. This article seems like some weird interweaving of two unrelated stories about sexism in tech and relative atime. The stories independently seem reasonable, but this weird fusion does not really make sense to me other than as a promotional advantage.
- fizwhiz 12y agoOP seems to have conflated taking a "human-centered" approach with a "feminist" approach. This constant reinforcement in the article about taking the "human" point of view leads me to believe that OP's perception of non-feminists is that they're in the camp of people more likely to take a "non-human-centered" approach. How bizarre.
- richmarr 12y agoIt's not conflation, she used approaches developed in another context. Jumping from feminist to human-centred doesn't seem like a bizarre stretch to me at all. Both (from the perspective of the status quo) involve letting go of "I know best" and attempting to empathise with others, understand their problems, and often try to drive change.
- dwild 12y agoAm I the only one that feel like this article is a whole "I know best" than non-feminist group?
- richmarr 12y agoNo, I don't think you are the only one. My personal take is that the OP meant no such thing. I think she's just saying that women bring different approaches, and those different approaches can be useful.
- tonysuper 12y agoI don't really see how this is feminism. I do think that supporting women in tech is a noble goal, but "considering user needs in the design of a system" never struck me as a uniquely feminist concept.
- derefr 12y agoI guess I could parse the attitude of developers who don't "consider the user's needs in the design of a system" as patriarchy... but in the gender-neutral "parents telling children what's good for them" sense of the term, not the gender-politics one.
- sliverstorm 12y agoErr... I don't think there is such thing as a gender-neutral patriarchy. A patriarchy is not "a power system" or "a system of authority". It is a system in which males are in power.
- halostatue 12y agoSupporting women in tech is not a “noble goal”; it’s a baseline for civilised behaviour. And while “considering user needs in the design of a system” isn’t necessarily feminist, it is something that is more likely to come up within a space that starts from respect rather than disrespect. (Blaming users, male or female, is inherently anti-feminist.)
- andrewchambers 12y agoActually, it sounds like an issue completely unrelated to gender at all.
- LyndsySimon 12y agoMuch of feminism - particular the branch that is vocal within the tech community - is not gender-specific. It's a social (and in many cases, political) worldview.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- simoncion 12y ago> As recently as 2013, a leading file systems developer was still arguing that file systems didn’t have to save file data reliably by mocking users for playing computer games. Tso neither mocks users for playing games, nor argues that filesystems should not be required to be reliable. He says: "[Lortie, that filesystem operation that you said was guaranteed to be safe actually isn't safe. You mis-read the docs. It's racy, and here are the two races that you could lose. Losing both could lose your data. Here's an analogy to illustrate the races: ] The failure scenario would probably be something like the user who plays tux racer all the time, and uses crappy proprietary drivers that crash the system every single time an OpenGL application exits. If they think that's normal, and are willing to live with the crap proprietary drivers, and they are also the sort of people who carefully position all of their windows to be precisely just so, and if the !@#!?! desktop libraries are still bogusly rewriting the entire contents of every single registry file, regardless of whether the application changed anything --- then eventually, said user will whine about how the hours she spent obsessively setting up their window layout got lost after Tux Racer creashed (sic) their system again." Notice the carefully constructed persona used in the illustration: * Tolerates terrible, crashy, OpenGL drivers. * Makes use of the OpenGL drivers by playing a video game. * Spends a lot of time meticulously positioning application windows. * Uses a WM that stores application window position in a single file that gets updated all the damn time for no reason at all. * Whines when the enormous amount of work put into positioning windows gets wasted when the poorly-designed software they're using crashes and takes some of their data with it.
- vaurora 12y agoIt was safe to rename() a file and expect the data it contained after crash to either be (1) the data before the rename(), (2) the data after the rename(). What changing the ext4 default logging mode to "data=writeback" did is add two more options, (3) nothing (0 bytes), and (4) whatever random garbage it found on disk, potentially including a copy of /etc/shadow. No-one misread the docs, the behavior changed. But hey, if you're angling to be hired by a YC-funded storage startup, this is certainly a post.
- simoncion 12y ago
- lotsofmangos 12y agoYou can't just bag all reasonable behaviour and call it feminism. Feminism might be a broad church due to there being many historical revisions of it, but if you make it so wide as to just basically mean people being nice, then it loses all meaning. Also, if you make the argument that a feminist environment was in some way necessary rather than merely conducive to the development of this particular solution, then were the experiences gained in a hyper-masculine and highly misogynistic organization based on the needs of state violence required for Grace Hopper to invent compilers, given that she was a Rear Admiral in the US Navy? edit - I fully support the creation of comfortable safe spaces and organisations that bring more people into programming as society in general seems far too accepting of abusive bigots, so these places and organisations serve a good and useful purpose. I also think that the creation of spaces like this will in time help raise the quality of software by having a wider range of perspectives looking at the problems, so it isn't just a good idea because it is being nice. I just think that the author here is putting an undue amount of weight on feminism as a major cause of this particular solution to the atime problem. I can't see anything about it as a solution that couldn't have been worked out by, say for instance, a hermit who hates everyone.
- frandroid 12y agoThe reason it seems to you that broadly defined reasonable behaviour gets all thrown in the feminism bag is because feminism just asks people to act reasonably with women; it does encompass a broad set of reasonable behaviour. As the quote goes, "Feminism is the radical notion that women are people." Yet this is so hard to achieve.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoThe idea that women are people is not confined to feminism. You could of course argue that all outlooks that regard women as people are de-facto feminist, however this would still not make them feminism. A good example would be ancient Sparta. Their society definitely regarded women as people, however Spartan society is not feminism.
- 12y ago
- penrod 12y ago"Unfortunately, as a result of my work, several more Linux storage developers came out publicly in favor of harassment and assault." I really would like links to these public statements. I'm not a fan of shaming, but if people are advocating violence, some finger-pointing would be entirely appropriate.
- vaurora 12y agoWill you volunteer to filter my social media and email for rape threats, and compensate me for the lifetime earnings loss that is the result of naming someone who controls whether my code gets merged or whether I get invited to the top Linux invite-only summits? I've learned not to name names unless I'm ready to face the consequences of speaking out to protect other people.
- nickthemagicman 12y agoThe problem with women's groups in technology is that there are very few women in tech to join the groups. And I highly doubt that male chauvinism/sexism/harassment is the reason women aren't going into tech careers. http://espnfivethirtyeight.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/chalabi-datalab-flightattendants-2.png http://espnfivethirtyeight.files.wordpress.com/2014/10/chala...
- mixologic 12y agoHow would you explain that there used to be more women than men as programmers? (http://gender.stanford.edu/news/2011/researcher-reveals-how-%E2%80%9Ccomputer-geeks%E2%80%9D-replaced-%E2%80%9Ccomputergirls%E2%80%9D http://gender.stanford.edu/news/2011/researcher-reveals-how-...) What do you think changed?
- Estragon 12y ago> I highly doubt that male chauvinism/sexism/harassment is the > reason women aren't going into tech careers. > How would you explain that there used to be more women than men > as programmers? The women who went into "programming" back then for the most part played a role somewhat similar to the role a compiler does for modern programmers, and so the fact that it seemed like an attractive role to some women of that era has very little bearing on its appeal now. At that time "programming" meant the relatively unskilled job of translating someone's detailed pseudocode onto punch cards or worse. The need for such unskilled labor diminished as the abstractions and automation improved. Ensmenger speaks for himself about his research on this in the following article: Goldstine and von Neumann spelled out a six-step programming process: (1) conceptualize the problem mathematically and physically, (2) select a numerical algorithm, (3) do a numerical analysis to determine the precision requirements and evaluate potential problems with approximation errors, (4) determine scale factors so that the mathematical expressions stay within the fixed range of the computer throughout the computation, (5) do the dynamic analysis to understand how the machine will execute jumps and substitutions during the course of a computation, and (6) do the static coding. The first five of these tasks were to be done by the "planner," who was typically the scientific user and overwhelmingly was frequently male; the sixth task was to be carried out by coders. Coding was regarded as a "static" process by Goldstine and von Neumann -- one that involved writing out the steps of a computation in a form that could be read by the machine, such as punching cards, or in the case of the ENIAC, plugging in cables and setting up switches. Thus, there was a division of labor envisioned that gave the highest-skilled work to the high-status male scientists and the lowest-skilled work to the low-status female coders. As the ENIAC managers and coders soon realized, however, controlling the operation of an automatic computer was nothing like the process of hand computation, and the Moore School women were therefore responsible for defining the first state-of-the-art methods of programming practice. http://womensenews.org/story/books/120323/women-were-first-computer-programmers?page=0,1 http://womensenews.org/story/books/120323/women-were-first-c... This one story -- about a small group of women chosen for their exceptional capability as human "computers" who previously calculated by hand numerical tables like the ones the ENIAC was designed to calculate -- has been spun into a narrative suggesting that women dominated early software development. Nothing could be further from the truth, and I don't think Engsmenger sees it that way. He says elsewhere that "Although many of the earliest programmers were women, by the beginning of the 1960s programming was generally considered a male profession. Certainly the elite ranks of ‘‘systems men’’ [i.e., those responsible for what we would today consider software design] were, quite literally, men." http://homes.soic.indiana.edu/nensmeng/files/ensmenger2003.pdf http://homes.soic.indiana.edu/nensmeng/files/ensmenger2003.p... Of course, all of this shows that male chauvinism (and very very very probably harassment too) has always been a huge problem for women who wanted to participate in this field, but the idea that "there used to be more women than men as programmers" just isn't true, at least as we understand the word "programmer" today, and the evidence it's based on has no bearing on why women aren't entering tech fields today.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoHow misogyny helped me beat the market I had a problem - figure out how to make money off the stock market. Luckily I was part of a culture - a privileged mysoginist racist evil culture - which recognizes that there is an objective reality that can be approximated by concrete models and empirical corrections. So I did some bayesian stats and came up with a moneymaking stat arb strategy. That's about as reasonable an argument as the one contained in the OP. It occasionally brushes against reality (e.g. feminist critiques of analytic philosophy and objectivity [1]) but really just attributes intellectual success to an unrelated ideology. That said, I'm upvoting this in the hopes that someone can steelman her argument, which could be interesting. The aforementioned steelman should hopefully also reject my argument. [1] http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/femapproach-analytic/#FemCriAna http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/femapproach-analytic/#FemC... http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/feminism-epistemology/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/feminism-epistemology/
- arjie 12y agoSteel man. Interesting: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Steel_man http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Steel_man . Sort of an idea in the vein of (but stronger than) the Principle of Charity.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoYes, the steelman is a stronger variation of the typical principle of charity. It goes beyond interpreting your opponent's argument as strongly as possible, all the way to actually fixing your opponent's argument. It's a great technique, one that I'm not as good at as I'd like to be. On the one hand, arguments supporting feminism that I see tend to be vacuous and borderline dishonest (case in point: this article). But there are sufficiently many smart and honest people who buy into the general theory that it's hard for me to completely reject it. That's why I'm so curious in threads like these, and why I'd love to see a steelman. Some good steelmen would allow me to draw a reasonable conclusion about the theory itself, rather than merely it's vocal proponents. I could then safely either accept or reject it.
- jessaustin 12y ago
- vaurora 12y agoOP here. To all the people flustered that I'm calling "listening politely" and "respecting people" feminist acts, I'll point out that, at the time, the only place you could reasonably expect that behavior in the Linux community was... a feminist collective, LinuxChix. To this day, women in $COMPUTER_THING groups tend to be overrun by men searching for a civil place to have a technical conversation. It happened with the #debian-women IRC channel too. Just today, another man told me how volunteering for Women Who Code taught him to be more welcoming to newcomers in his own open source project. And have you seen the stickers on Guido Van Rossum's laptop? So, yeah, it's possible to have these values without identifying as feminist, but in open source software today, explicitly feminist communities are usually the only ones that put these values into practice.
- ObviousScience 12y agoYour comment suggests a strong confounding factor: feminist communities are likely to be both smaller and more focused on user conduct than technical communities at large. Without controlling for these factors, attaching the behaviors you do to "feminism" is nothing but saying "good things are done by those who agree with me, and bad things are done by those /others/". Your argument does nothing to explain why you think this happens, and simply admits you're appropriating them without knowing why the correlation exists in communities. Classic propaganda. Ed: I'm glad I've been downvoted and apologized for because I raised a methodological issue with trying to ascribe behaviors to a community, instead of actually showing me where she discussed why she doesn't think it's either of the (relatively well known) effects I asked about. I couldn't find anywhere she addressed this topic, but I'm entirely open to being corrected. Here's the wikipedia article on the fallacy I'm claiming is being committed here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_causation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_does_not_imply_caus... Ed 2: My latin is terrible these days, lol
- hashbanged 12y ago> feminist communities are likely to be both smaller and more focused on user conduct than technical communities at large Is Python small? I'm sure there were other small linux communities (the term seems almost redundant) who were much less welcoming to women. I don't know what to say to convince you that open source communities are traditionally hyper male and sexist. It's not so hard to imagine that you might get more contributions from women in an explicitly women friendly space within a larger women unfriendly (to say the least) community. Here's some reading, I encourage you to read it if you think I'm wrong. http://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/4291/3381 http://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/4291/33...
- emocakes 12y agoshutup bitch, make me a sandwich
- dang 12y agoThis comment was killed by user flags.
- ps4fanboy 12y agoAs a man I have found the linux community extremely toxic, RTFM etc, over time this has gotten better, but I would hardly call it sexism.
- agrover 12y agoIt's not about sexism, it's about decreasing "geek machismo" that has existed in the community, and how this helps more people be comfortable putting themselves out there and having a technical discussion (where there is always a nonzero chance one is wrong) in public. fwiw the Kernelnewbies list and irc is another good place to start for civil kernel discussion. I would suggest that common to both it and Linuxchix is the belief that no matter what the questioner or respondents' level of expertise, the only possible response to a question is a positive, helpful one.
- fizwhiz 12y agoThis entire article could communicated everything it intended by focusing on the motivations behind creating intermediate "safe spaces" to have an open judgement-free discourse. Instead, it was pitched as a pro-feminist piece coming across as Feminism = InclusiveProgress. I'm in agreement with ObviousScience when he says that it came across as a propaganda piece. Also, I would rephrase the "geek machismo" to "geek hardassery" since machismo seems to outline masculine pride. I do, however, agree that people tend to be hardasses with the whole RTFD/RTFM angle and that's something we could collectively improve upon.
- ps4fanboy 12y agoI think this is a biproduct of what open source is. People contributing their spare time for little to no financial gain, and when new people expect them to hold their hands they take offense and lash out. I think it could be a slippery slope to expect people to act a certain way when contributing to the common good (open source and the like) because really there is no obligation to use the work these people produce. Conversely this sort of behavior when dealing with vendors where money changes hands is almost non existent. And I suspect this is because there is a economic incentive in place for people to act civil to each other. Complaining about this dynamic wont change it only changes to the economic model will change peoples behavior.
- bjourne 12y agoOf the three options noatime, relatime and atime, I think relatime is the worst. Why? Because it is the most complex. Ordered by complexity, noatime is the easiest and relatime the hardest. Updating a timestamp based on an algorithm is much harder than never doing it or always doing it. Complexity is bad, complexity even if it solves user problems is bad. The bash shellshock bug is a consequence of complexity. If I where Linux dictator, file access time would be deprecated starting from today. POSIX be damned, but they can also do the right thing and deprecate atime in their standard. Mutt would suffer but I'm pretty sure I could write a patch for it to make it independent of files atimes. It saddens me that it seemingly "cant be done" because of legacy. Linux is full of Unix cruft in every corner (dotfiles anyone?) it needs to be cleaned up.
- tomp 12y agoAlthough you're right about it being relatively the most complex, it's absolutely a very simple algorithm. noatime: if false: update() atime: if true: update() relatime: if a > b: update() Doesn't seem very complex to me.
- bjourne 12y agoI believe the original check was if mtime was greater than or equal to atime. The current Linux implementation isn't that simple though, see: http://lwn.net/Articles/244829/ http://lwn.net/Articles/244829/. If you allow some extra complexity, it's easy to then allow some more, and then some more..
- zimpenfish 12y agoI'd like to see that patch because it sounds pretty damned tricky to me unless you're proposing to read the entire file in each time you want to check if it's been updated.
- kangaroo5383 12y agoGreat read, thank you for posting that! There's an interesting shift towards empathy in programming that I think will make better software. The empathy to ask - what is the easiest for the user, what are the expected actions and expected results from the user's point of view, etc. This same approach can be used in actual software design as well - treat each components / class / API as a person with motivations and goals, figuring out what's the least amount of info this person needs, best way to get to their goal etc. I've found that way of thinking yields cleaner design overall, and is easier to communicate to others. This method of approaching problems should be encouraged, heck, if not demanded, from all!