4 ms·
How would pseudonyms work? How do I know that Skippy or voter # 123 is eligible to vote in my precinct?
by specialist 12y ago
How would pseudonyms work? How do I know that Skippy or voter # 123 is eligible to vote in my precinct?
- marcosdumay 12y agoYou can control who got a valid pseudonyms, and how many they are. And you can distribute pseudonym validation and make it visible enough that you make sure people don't record them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- specialist 12y agoI don't know enough about your proposal to comment meaningfully. I can speak to my experience as an election integrity activist. A very large fraction of people who care about our elections (in the USA) would respond poorly to your proposal of not using real names when voting. You may be aware of the recurring "voter fraud" kerfuffle that gets trotted out every cycle. Scandal worthy shenanigans such as dogs registered to vote and renown critic Ann Coulter falsifying her voter registration. The only current partial exception to using real names that I'm aware of protecting the identity of vulnerable persons, such as witness protection, victim of domestic violence, and maybe public figures like judges. The idea being to enfranchise those who would be endangered if their identity and location were freely available. So there's separate handling of these person's voter registration and ballot processing. More I can't say, because that's not an aspect that I studied in depth. Also... I learned the hard way that any critic of the current system (e.g. proposing alternatives) will be dismissed out of hand by administrators and policymakers if they don't have complete mastery of the current system. Conspiracy theorist, gadfly, crank, kook, paranoid, etc. And you will be tested. If you develop your idea further, please cc me. Protecting voter privacy is very important to me, and I'd welcome a solution.
- marcosdumay 12y agoI don't have a finished solution. I only think about it sometimes, but got a promising set of ideas. A possible protocol for using pseudonyms could be that people create a random IDs at home, and get them signed under a public setup very like our current setup for voting - several people sign it, and each person signs a limited number of IDs. Those people then give the signatures to the voter, and mark in a control that he got the ID. An ID is valid if it has all the signatures. Ideally we should assure that no data lives the setup after the procedure - but just lighting everything on fire will never feel good enough to be implemented, so I'm out of ideas here. This protocol still has a grave flaw, the electors can prove how they voted. Impossibility of proof is at odds with verification, but I still think there must be a way to make the proof physically hard.