4 ms·
Your enthusiasm for vote by mail is unwarranted. Who will deliver the ballots once the USPS goes away? The push for e-voting will really heat up then. I encou
by specialist 12y ago
Your enthusiasm for vote by mail is unwarranted.
Who will deliver the ballots once the USPS goes away? The push for e-voting will really heat up then.
I encourage you learn how your local jurisdiction handles mail ballots. It's more or less making sausage. The UAA is 1% (both directions). A large percent are challenged during signature verification. Ballots are electronically scanned (like a fax or OCR) as they arrive and pre-counted (which is illegal). Correcting for voter intent is done by modifying the database, which is difficult to "audit" during recount. I could go on and on.
The correct election administration system is the Australian Ballot (private voting, public counting) issued, cast, and counted at each precinct the night of the election, issuing postal ballots as needed to enfranchise people.
The only meaningful future electronic mediated system must be completely transparent, as in immediately posting ballots online as they are received. Sacrificing voter privacy to ensure election integrity.
I'm against all electronic mediated systems, but it seems inevitable, so I advocate a system which can be verified.
- ddingus 12y agoThe USPS is in the Constitution. And it must be run by the Government. Unless we want to amend to remove it from service, having it deliver votes is a perfectly fine use of an excellent service the public benefits from daily. Actually, Oregon elections can be 100 percent verified. Every single ballot is available for recount activities, which can be done manually, under court and multiple party supervision. Audits are performed and the stats on these and margins of error are well understood. We do use electronic counting, and where those do not match audit records, work is performed until they do. There isn't a fully transparent electronic system, without also personally identifying voters to their votes. I realize you guys do it differently. That's fine. In the US, we do not link voters to votes and we have strong reasons for that. Frankly, I've always maintained e-votes are possible to do in a trustworthy way if we surrender anonymity. I don't see that happening in the US. So long as that is true, we really do need to record voter intent in such a way that it can be used directly for the tally and reviewed under the public eye. Which means e-voting is not trustworthy in the US. VBM is trustworthy, and it delivers very high and consistent turnout rates too. That's another difference. You guys use mandatory voting. We don't. I personally wouldn't mind if we did, but we don't. E-voting really hasn't done us any good on turnout as the machines, placement, performance, record keeping and a host of other factors make it a bigger mess than ballots currently are. VBM sidesteps nearly all of those problems nicely. Every year, another district or another state picks it up because it works.
- marcosdumay 12y ago> The only meaningful future electronic mediated system must be completely transparent ... Sacrificing voter privacy to ensure election integrity. It's possible to get a quite good amount of privacy by the use of pseudonyms. You won't get a system with verifiable guarantees of both confidentiality and accuracy, as that's impossible, but there's no reason we can not make it as good as paper ballots.
- specialist 12y agoHow would pseudonyms work? How do I know that Skippy or voter # 123 is eligible to vote in my precinct?
- marcosdumay 12y agoYou can control who got a valid pseudonyms, and how many they are. And you can distribute pseudonym validation and make it visible enough that you make sure people don't record them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- specialist 12y agoI don't know enough about your proposal to comment meaningfully. I can speak to my experience as an election integrity activist. A very large fraction of people who care about our elections (in the USA) would respond poorly to your proposal of not using real names when voting. You may be aware of the recurring "voter fraud" kerfuffle that gets trotted out every cycle. Scandal worthy shenanigans such as dogs registered to vote and renown critic Ann Coulter falsifying her voter registration. The only current partial exception to using real names that I'm aware of protecting the identity of vulnerable persons, such as witness protection, victim of domestic violence, and maybe public figures like judges. The idea being to enfranchise those who would be endangered if their identity and location were freely available. So there's separate handling of these person's voter registration and ballot processing. More I can't say, because that's not an aspect that I studied in depth. Also... I learned the hard way that any critic of the current system (e.g. proposing alternatives) will be dismissed out of hand by administrators and policymakers if they don't have complete mastery of the current system. Conspiracy theorist, gadfly, crank, kook, paranoid, etc. And you will be tested. If you develop your idea further, please cc me. Protecting voter privacy is very important to me, and I'd welcome a solution.