5 ms·
Drones are less practical than existing tools for most everything you just listed. For peeping in windows, a drone is extremely impractical. A telescope will y
by baddox 12y ago
Drones are less practical than existing tools for most everything you just listed.
For peeping in windows, a drone is extremely impractical. A telescope will yield much better results. The only thing a drone can better do is look down at your roof, or over your fence if your fence is higher than nearby buildings.
For assassination, traditional tools are clearly more practical in nearly every case. A hunting rifle at a few hundred meters is going to be a heck of a lot cheaper, more reliable, easier to use, and more difficult to trace than some drone with a mounted weapon.
I don't really know how arsonists generally do their thing, but I can't imagine that dropping something flammable is more practical than just driving by and throwing it.
I'm sure there are very specific cases where sophisticated drone usage could be useful for committing these crimes, but I don't think it's a major concern, and not even one of the biggest concerns of drones.
- lwhi 12y agoI think the biggest 'benefit' to having a drone perform these tasks is the fact a robot is carrying out the task. For example, instructing a drone to assassinate is potentially closer to hiring a hitman, than murdering someone firsthand with a shotgun. Closer in the sense that the puportrator feels a sense of detachment.
- hamstergene 12y agoYou seem to be only considering the moment of crime and disregarding what happens before and after it. A tool that almost completely removes risk of getting caught and need for alibi will surely be seen as more practical by all except mad and ridiculously dumb people, regardless of how less effective it is.
- baddox 12y agoI considered the likelihood of getting caught as well. I mentioned that explicitly in the rifle example. It's fairly obvious for the telescope example. For arson, again, I don't know much about how arson tends to be committed, but it seems that a drone is not inherently harder to track than a car, bicycle, or person on foot, given the range, speed, reliability, and conspicuousness of those modes of transportation.
- hamstergene 12y agoHow would you trace back a drone that shoots a bullet then wipes its data and dies?
- ansible 12y agoThe MAC addresses for the wireless interfaces are likely trackable to an individual purchase.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoOften they can be wiped as well.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoWhat? ifconfig or My Network Places in Windows. Adapter cards had to have their mac address programmed once; it can be done again. Its firmware.
- ansible 12y agoIn some cases yes, but that requires additional expertise.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoNot much. The OS has a utility to do it.
- e12e 12y agoPerhaps. But a wlan card taken from a discarded/stolen/recyled/used corporate machine, then transported half-around the globe and sold for cash, isn't necessarily easy to trace back to a perpetrator.
- tormeh 12y agoA drone with a gun is unrealistic, I think. The stability of a light, air-borne vehicle is just not good enough. A drone with fragmentation grenades, on the other hand, could work well and pretty much erase all evidence.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoA drone leaves all that bomb trace leaves and more - its construction, hair skin and dna traces of the builder, even its radio control details. So its not perfect; its more like leaving the rifle at the scene. And the idea that shooting a gun brings down some hailstorm of official response is myth. Fire a gun in most places and ... nothing will happen. Folks will rush to the scene of any murder, but will only find the sniper's location after hours or days of investigation. It won't be like the NCIS show where the investigator glances around and says 'must have come from that rooftop; its the only secure sniper post in a half-mile!' You can shoot from nearly anywhere with line-of-sight, from the partly-open door of a parked delivery van, without much risk of discovery.
- jjwiseman 12y ago"Shotgun-Toting New Jersey Man Shoots Down Man's Drone", charged with criminal mischief and weapons charges: http://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/weird/Drone-Shot-Down-Lower-Township-277605811.html http://www.nbcphiladelphia.com/news/weird/Drone-Shot-Down-Lo...
- personZ 12y agoAs hamstergene mentioned, drones are the before and after risk abatement. A hunting rifle at a few hundred meters is going to be a heck of a lot cheaper, more reliable, easier to use, and more difficult to trace than some drone with a mounted weapon. Aside from the difficulty of a few hundred meter shot in urban settings, shooting a weapon from a location announces where you are, exactly when you are there. Aside from the immediate and overwhelming response likely, the human traces would be enormous and unavailable. A drone, in contrast, comes from some unknown place off in some unknown direction, can with ease get anywhere near the target (on a nearby roof for instance), and then when the task is complete it can go low and fast and get back to a drop-off. For arson and peeping, the same premise holds -- a drone can go to exactly where is needed, do what is necessary, and get away with, currently, essentially zero risk of capture. Will we eventually have drone registrations and tracking systems, comprehensive urban radio tracking and announcement, police overrides, etc? Yeah, probably, which was what I was getting at -- events will inevitably happen, and regulations will adjust.
- baddox 12y agoThese types of assassinations don't seem to happen very often, so there probably isn't much actual data. But I would expect that a single shot of a rifle is quite difficult to pinpoint, especially in an urban setting. There are audio gunfire locators that some cities have, but even then, the assassin can be long gone by the time anyone could respond. Just drive a car into a nearby parking garage, do the thing, and leave. For a drone operation, the setup and "mission" time is almost certainly much longer. I don't think we're anywhere near fully autonomous missions that could assassinate with any appreciable reliability, so you're going to need to fly line of sight (very impractical because of the range) or FPV (still impractical because of the required skill, equipment and mission time). Could a professional band of assassins pull off an assassination with a drone? Certainly. Would it be far easier to just use a rifle? I'd say absolutely.
- jagawhowho 12y agoThe us military finds drones more practical for bombing.
- arh68 12y ago> A hunting rifle at a few hundred meters is going to be a heck of a lot cheaper, more reliable, easier to use, and more difficult to trace than some drone with a mounted weapon. Perhaps, but you've still got to pay the guy holding the rifle. A drone could self-terminate. Most parts can be 3D-printed & assembled in a clean tent, untraceable. The most expensive part is possibly the infrared camera ($1~2k).
- krasin 12y agoThere's Seek Thermal Camera that has a decent resolution (200x156) and a low price ($200): http://obtain.thermal.com/category-s/1818.htm http://obtain.thermal.com/category-s/1818.htm
- uptown 12y ago"For peeping in windows, a drone is extremely impractical. A telescope will yield much better results." I'm not sure I agree with this at all. Drones allow you to access viewpoints that are otherwise impossible using telescopes at a fraction of the overall cost. Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLB66lge6oA&list=UUZfBMqj1pN_jbtgn46qkIIA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kLB66lge6oA&list=UUZfBMqj1pN... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PKG8q94D98 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2PKG8q94D98
- e12e 12y ago> For peeping in windows, a drone is extremely impractical. Well, say I set up a drone for remote control over the internet, then rent it out to people that are located half around the globe. I act as a cut out, and whomever is spying will (may[1]) be hard to track. [1] If I'm getting paid, there's the issue of anonymous transactions, and as for control, latency might be too high to use Tor -- but the main point is that drones already facilitate something new, if not revolutionary new.