6 ms·
I want to love Amtrak. Trains are such a fabulous way to travel. But I've just gotta vent at how embarrassing and seemingly inept the train system is in my coun
by kibwen 12y ago
I want to love Amtrak. Trains are such a fabulous way to travel. But I've just gotta vent at how embarrassing and seemingly inept the train system is in my country.
This very morning I went to pick up a friend who was riding Chicago to Pittsburgh. The train was due to arrive at 5:00 AM, giving me plenty of time to get her home and get myself to work by 8:00. But knowing how these things tend to unfold, I was savvy: I told my boss that I might not be in until 9:30 or so, giving myself enough headroom to breathe even if the train was an unthinkable three hours late.
I was naive. The train was five hours late.
Meanwhile, I have friends who work for companies who write the software that control train scheduling throughout the country. After what they've seen, they refuse to ride on trains, and from the stories they've told I don't blame them.
It's easy to attempt to excuse this state of affairs. Our rail infrastructure is some of the oldest in the world. The country is huge and sparsely populated. The system was designed for hauling freight, not passengers. But none of that keeps me from reading pieces like the recent HN article on Japan's bullet train (http://www.theguardian.com/cities/2014/sep/30/-sp-shinkansen-bullet-train-tokyo-rail-japan-50-years http://www.theguardian.com/cities/2014/sep/30/-sp-shinkansen...) and longing for something so punctual and efficient.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- orborde 12y ago> Meanwhile, I have friends who work for companies who write the software that control train scheduling throughout the country. After what they've seen, they refuse to ride on trains, and from the stories they've told I don't blame them. Can you tell us more about this?
- kibwen 12y agoThe stories are mostly the mundane sort of terrible, rather than of the outlandish and entertaining variety. You know, impossibly buggy software plagued by decades of half-rewrites and no documentation or tests, the sort of stuff that's typical for most big companies except that this particular big company is responsible for shepherding untold quantities of earth-scorching chemicals via an infrastructure so archaic that they often have no idea where the trains actually are unless the conductors call in personally and read out the signs of the towns they're passing through. Hair-raising close calls. Problems that we have the technology to affordably solve, but are merely too apathetic to. I'm enough of a non-expert that if I attempted to relay anything more specific then I'm afraid that I'd just be talking out of my ass. I should note that my friends do not work for Amtrak specifically, or even necessarily have anything to do with Amtrak. However, I can tell you that there are definitely major companies involved, if you're looking for a particularly Fight-Clubby response.
- clebio 12y agoInteresting (terrifying) synopsis. I might have to borrow that last bit, too: "he was a bit too fight-clubby for me".
- wcummings 12y agoI take the train between NYC, Boston and Providence very frequently (dozens to hundreds of times a year), and to DC occasionally (MBTA between Providence and Boston, usually). When I worked in NYC, I could leave Providence on an early train and know I'd make it to Midtown in time for work. Boston and NYC (and DC) both have good public transit, so I can hop on a bus or a train on either end to get around the city. The northeast corridor has decent trains, at least compared to the rest of the country from what I can gather. tl;dr I live in the Northeast without owning a car and it's OK Our shitty rail infrastructure might have to do with the interests of the automotive industry [1] [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspi...
- pasbesoin 12y agoI've reached the conclusion that the East Coast... "commuter" corridors are simply a different matter, although from what I read they have problems, too. I live at a cross country termination point, and I have had friends and family travel here by Amtrak. They are always, invariably, many hours late. For their return trips, the departing trains generally leave from this originating station on time. They simply have no chance to make it down the tracks in a fashion that comes anywhere close to maintaining their schedule. As offensive as anything, is the simple unreality of the schedules and their continued persistence of said schedules, year after year. If they were more truthful, at least the unsuspecting one-time or occasional traveller could plan accordingly.
- wcummings 12y agoI doubt a lot of people commute daily between NYC and BOS, but you're right, its worlds apart from "cross country" travel. The Northeast also has a high concentration of large cities
- cjslep 12y ago> I've reached the conclusion that the East Coast... "commuter" corridors are simply a different matter I reached the same conclusion and have had similar experiences to your friends and family. 5 years ago I took the Charlotte-Raleigh train a handful of times over the period of a year or two. Only once was it on time when arriving at my destination, and only once did it depart from my departing station late (by an hour). The worst I experienced was about a 5 hour delay in-transit, putting the time at 2AM instead of 9PM. I quickly dropped the train as a reliable mode of transportation.
- Spooky23 12y agoJust ask the Amtrak people and they will give to a realistic expectation. The issue for east-west trains is that the track usually owned by CSX or another freight railway, and the thousands of tanker cars heading for Albany, NY for transfer to barges to New Jersey oil refineries have priority over everything except the trains that bring in produce from the West Coast. I frequently ride Northeast corridor trains Amtrak owns 95% of those tracks. The trains to NYC usually run +/- 10 minutes of schedule, depending on the number of people embarking at midpoint stations. Of all of the transportation providers that I deal with, Amtrak is the lowest hassle and best experience. Consistent pricing, no security theatre, comfortable cars and friendly staff most of the time.
- ycombobreaker 12y agoCSX freight also causes delays between Chicago and New Orleans. When I was delayed, the conductor claimed that CSX was in violation of either state law (IL) or the rail-sharing contract they have. I forget which.
- saalweachter 12y agoI've heard a conductor on the Lakeshore line out of Chicago vent similarly. It was something like, the contracts with CSX specify a dollar amount based on the on-time percentage Amtrak achieves, which Amtrak thought would guarantee priority, but it turns out that CSX would rather leave money on the table than give Amtrak the least bit of priority. I honestly suspect CSX actively hates Amtrak at some level of management. You've got these passenger trains running fixed schedules 3-5 times a week and you can't run them on time? I can't believe that is an accident.
- CalRobert 12y agoWhen Amtrak owns the tracks, it's a far better experience. I had similar (horrible) experiences riding the coast starlight between San Luis Obispo and Sacramento, but when I stuck to the commuter lines between Sacramento and the bay area, or LA and San Diego, it was always pleasant.
- ams6110 12y agoIf Amtrak was not government-funded it would have gone out of business decades ago, and appropriately so. Intercity passenger rail no longer works in the USA. The automobile and air transport infrastructure works so much better for most people. It's time to give it up. Edit: I'm not saying that commuter and regional rail can't work, it clearly does in the right circumstances.