8 ms·
India, U.S. Agree to Joint Exploration of Mars
- danielweber 12y agoOn one hand, this could be really encouraging, allowing India to increase its home-grown engineering capacity. On the other hand, "international cooperation" is often the death of many projects, particularly space projects. On the other other hand, it wasn't like NASA was about to do something huge and cooperation with India puts that goal at risk.
- teamonkey 12y ago> On the other hand, "international cooperation" is often the death of many projects, particularly space projects. There are plenty of counter-examples. The ISS is an effort that spans the US, Canada, Japan, Russia and Europe (ESA). Hubble is NASA-ESA.
- mturmon 12y agoOther counter-examples: Planck, SOHO, Cassini/Huygens, Rosetta, ... -- all highly successful.
- danielweber 12y agoWhy is that a counter-example? The ISS is incredibly more expensive, complicated, and accomplishes less science because it's "international."
- ZenoArrow 12y ago"The ISS is incredibly more expensive, complicated, and accomplishes less science because it's "international."" Accomplishes less compared to what? Skylab? Mir? The ISS is designed to host up to 7 crew members. For purposes of comparison, Mir could host 3. What makes you suspect 7 astronauts can do less scientific work than 3?
- danielweber 12y agoSkylab construction cost: 10 billion in modern dollars ISS construction cost: 150 billion ISS science projects keep on getting cancelled for budget reasons. I think spending $150,000,000,000.00 building it has something to do with that.
- teamonkey 12y agoSkylab was cheap(er) because it was launched in one single stage (IIRC it literally was a Saturn V cargo bay). The ISS was designed to be built up over several years, over several launches, with each launch costing much less than Skylab but obviously more overall. It was a design decision that favoured amortizing costs for an age that couldn't afford another Skylab.
- teamonkey 12y agoDo you have any evidence to support that claim? I doubt that a space lab as functional as the ISS could exist without international funding.
- mturmon 12y ago...it wasn't like NASA was about to do something huge and cooperation with India puts that goal at risk... Your nested counterfactuals are a little hard to unpack, but if I understand you correctly, it is somewhat the contrary, at least with NISAR. (Oops, I added another counterfactual.) NASA was about to NOT do something huge and the collaboration enabled it happen. That is, before it became NISAR, the Earth-observing biomass/seismicity SAR mission was called Desdyni (http://decadal.gsfc.nasa.gov/desdyni.html http://decadal.gsfc.nasa.gov/desdyni.html). This mission was referred to as desirable in a 2007 National Academies decadal roadmap (covering the next 10 years), but there were too many other even higher-ranked missions in the pipeline. So it seemed like Desdyni was not going to get on the NASA roadmap any time soon. The Indian contribution seems to have (for the moment) been enough to get it going, because in February NISAR entered "Phase A" which is NASA-speak for "we are starting the mission". There are later decision points depending on how ready the overall concept proves to be.
- JonnieCache 12y ago>Desdyni That is the ugliest project name I've ever seen. It beats any disemvoweled SV startup into a cocked hat. I'm not surprised it almost got cancelled.
- innguest 12y agoWhy could they not have agreed to cooperate before NASA spent $650M on the Maven program which does the exact same thing that ISRO's $74M Mangalyaan does? I demand a refund.
- thearn4 12y agoI would consider technical collaboration in this space (pardon the pun) to generally be a great thing. Missions to Mars have historically been very difficult: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_Mars http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_missions_to_Mars Hopefully, this kind of partnership doesn't get weighed down too heavily by the intricacies of international politics.
- anupshinde 12y agoIF this works, this will surely accelerate the process of sending humans to other planets (may be not Mars)
- privong 12y agoWhy do you say that? The techincal goals of this mission are fairly modest, and do not seem to bush the boundaries of launch technologry or involve technology that would be useful for human survival in space. The agreement and mission are both good things, but I do not see how they will have much of an effect on human spaceflight.
- Naritai 12y agoWhile I'm a big supporter of international co-operation, remember that the US has been striking a number of technical deals with India, as a part of a long-term political investment in bringing up a large democratic power to balance China. I think this has as much to do with that goal as it does with sharing technical information.
- sillysaurus3 12y agoI have a dumb question. What's a large democratic power, and how does it differ from China? I'm not implying China is in any way democratic, but rather inviting someone to further explain what the goal of the US is. Is it likely that this is simply empire expansion rather than an altruistic goal of balancing China? Mainly I'm just wondering what the concerns might be if a large democratic power (and I'd still like to know what exactly that is, and how it differs from other modern powers) isn't brought up in the region. Forgive my ignorance. I probably should have taught myself these things long ago rather than invested all of my time in programming and other pursuits. Also, just to clarify, I am aware of the textbook definition of "democracy," "republic," etc, but it seems like those names are more of a flag for people to fight under than a definition for a state of being in the modern era. So I'm quite curious to understand the issues at play here.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pdx 12y agoSubstitute "large democratic power to balance China" with "large power to balance China", and I think it makes more sense. U.S. foreign policy seems to be to hinder the expansion of other large powers in an attempt to keep them small enough to not be an existential threat at some point in the far future. You send money and aid to whom ever is in a position to hinder those who are growing too powerful, whether the group you are sending that money and aid to is democratic or not. This is not about right and wrong. It's about long term strategy, aimed at preserving the status quo for as long as possible. If you hinder your competitors, that keeps them from becoming even more of a threat to you.
- wilsonfiifi 12y agoI was really hoping India's Mars probe would mean that the public in general would finally have a new independent source of information and data. However this is great news and I'm sure the joint effort will speed up the tough task of uncovering the planet's secrets.
- swatkat 12y agoOfficial press release: http://www.nasa.gov/press/2014/september/us-india-to-collaborate-on-mars-exploration-earth-observing-mission/ http://www.nasa.gov/press/2014/september/us-india-to-collabo... And, NISAR Earth observation mission looks very exciting as well: http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=32478.msg1237077#msg1237077 http://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=32478.msg12...
- mturmon 12y agoNISAR is a very interesting mission from a technological point of view. It will have two radars, at least one of which gives 10m resolution, and they will be obtaining global coverage. The data rate is huge, larger than any Earth remote sensing mission to date (many TB/day). Earth scientists are already having problems dealing with contemporary data volumes, and NISAR really raises the stakes.
- peeters 12y agoThis is exciting but makes me nervous. India is re-imagining "space travel on a budget", but if all of a sudden they have to play by NASA's rules and standards, their ability to innovate at low cost might be hampered. Hopefully whatever form of cooperation they come up with lets India continue to operate mostly independently.
- shas3 12y agoYou are implicitly assuming somehow they don't currently 'play by NASA rules (and NASA-level) standards.' Any evidence that this is so?
- Karunamon 12y agoAren't NASA-level standards historically slow and inefficient? I was of the impression that private parties streamlining that process and coming up with a cheaper program is what led to NASA (or congress by proxy, whatever) abandoning manned spaceflight to the private sector. In other words, maybe India is taking a leaf from SpaceX's book rather than NASA's
- hackuser 12y ago> Aren't NASA-level standards historically slow and inefficient? I've seen nothing that tells me that this reputation is anything more than 1) the bureaucracy inherent to any large organization, 2) requirements of very complex, cutting edge engineering and science, 3) requirements of engineering systems that must work perfectly the first time (unlike Facebook, NASA can't 'move fast and break things'), and perhaps most of all 4) the public's habit of attributing characteristics to 'the old established thing' (NASA) and to the 'new shiny thing' (SpaceX, etc.) Name every place in the solar system where NASA missions currently are located. Outside the solar system? Where they have gone historically? Their achievements are staggering; history-making events are routine; they are by far the greatest explorers in the history of humanity. Certainly they aren't perfect and every organization can improve, but they do pretty well. > I was of the impression that private parties streamlining that process and coming up with a cheaper program is what led to NASA (or congress by proxy, whatever) abandoning manned spaceflight to the private sector. Manned spaceflight hasn't been delegated to the private sector, only flying to Earth orbit (or only low-Earth orbit?). NASA has been doing it for 50 years; the technology is mature enough that private companies can do it and NASA can invest its resources in bigger challenges, including a manned mission to Mars (in the long term).
- melling 12y agoI wrote this on the WSJ comments several hours ago but it's worth repeating here. I believe that it would be valuable if the US invested more basic research money in India. We might be able to greatly increase our research output in the basic sciences. Start small then increase the budget as research in India matures.
- suprgeek 12y agoExciting news but is it an unqualified positive for both? Sometimes Constraints are what drives breakthrough innovations. India's ability to Manage Significant space exploration programmes on a Shoe string budget is driven in part by the need to innovate on a "ShoeString" budget. What we as a race desperately need is low cost access to Space - which perhaps may not become such a priority if NASA is allowed to influence ISRO. On the other hand maybe ISRO will influence NASA & wewill get the best of both - super low cost missions with super advanced payloads :)
- cjensen 12y agoNASA had a "go cheap" program to try crazy stuff on a shoestring that just might work. There were good results like Pathfinder ($150M) which tried the crazy idea of landing using an airbag. The problem is that the Powers That Be were not understanding about the failures inherent in trying crazy ideas out. So we went back to expensive spacecraft which were less likely to fail.
- Ankaios 12y agoNASA has opportunities like the Small Explorers (SMEX, http://explorers.larc.nasa.gov/APSMEX/ http://explorers.larc.nasa.gov/APSMEX/), Discovery (http://discovery.nasa.gov/p_mission.cfml http://discovery.nasa.gov/p_mission.cfml), and New Frontiers (http://discoverynewfrontiers.nasa.gov/program/index.cfml http://discoverynewfrontiers.nasa.gov/program/index.cfml) into which you can propose to conduct missions of different size/cost classes. If you have low-cost mission concepts for achieving important scientific objectives, please propose them.
- nether 12y agothe desification of the US continues: dean of harvard ceo of microsoft ceo of pepsico ny ag 1/3 of mckinsey
- krylon 12y agoI've been hoping for a while for more international cooperation on space exploration. Going to space is not cheap, and if several countries pool their resources, under ideal circumstances the result should be more science for everyone. But politics has kind of prevented that. For governments, space exploration seems to be more about showing off than about advancing science. I hope that in the future, different countries cooperating on missions will become the norm rather than the exception. I know I'm being somewhat optimistic, but this article shows I am not being completely naive. Nice.
- chelch 12y agoI'm pretty sure there is a significant amount of cooperation when it comes to space exploration. Space missions often carry instruments from different countries. For example, the lunar probe that discovered water on the moon, Chandrayaan-1, carried instruments from different countries. Curiosity carried instruments from other countries too, if I'm not mistaken. It's just that you don't read much about this in the newspapers, because newspapers would rather make it look like there's a space race going on.
- ps4fanboy 12y agoThis is great news, I am surprised the EU doesnt have a more uniformed vocal space program.
- BrianLee24 12y agoLets just hope both of them can finally find some Martians
- WWKong 12y agoJust a friendly reminder that India follows metric system.
- tn13 12y agoIndia and US also agreed to fight terror while US continued to fund terror in Pakistan. Very likely US is going to put sanctions on Indian space research as soon as India declares its ASAT capabilities.
- tauslu 12y agoAs usual, action speaks louder than words. This co-operation would probably not take place if India's mission did not take place or very few would listen their Indian counter parts if such agreement were signed without the mission.