6 ms·
Every time that this argument is made, I can't help but wonder if the mere existence of a sustainable off-world colony would cause humans on Earth to give even
by kibwen 12y ago
Every time that this argument is made, I can't help but wonder if the mere existence of a sustainable off-world colony would cause humans on Earth to give even less of a damn about maintaining a habitable planet. A sort of moral hazard (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_hazard) on an interplanetary scale. Which is to ask, could colonizing other worlds actually accelerate the destruction of human civilization, rather than ensure it?
As an alternative to possibly engendering environmental apathy, imagine a scenario akin to the Cold War, except that one of the superpowers has a million citizens on Mars, and the other doesn't. Does MAD still apply, or does the interplanetary superpower suddenly becoming all the more willing to watch the world burn?
- scj 12y ago>As an alternative to possibly engendering environmental apathy, imagine a scenario akin to the Cold War, except that one of the superpowers has a million citizens on Mars, and the other doesn't. Does MAD still apply, or does the interplanetary superpower suddenly becoming all the more willing to watch the world burn? Or do you just get a third superpower less invested in the fate of home planet?
- freehunter 12y agoI have no doubt that given enough time and enough people born on Mars, the population of Mars will become more and more uninterested in the politics of Earth. We've seen it happen so often in colonization around the planet, there's no doubt that if a Mars colony is successful that we will see the same thing. No one born on Mars is going to have any reason to care about what happens on Earth any more than the people of one continent care about the day-to-day life of people on another continent.
- celticninja 12y agohowever the people on mars would have been supported significantly more by people from earth, both in getting to Mars and maintaining a colony before it became self sufficient. So it would take a generation or two after full sustainability for this sort of mindset to come into play in the younger generations, perhaps 4th and 5th generation martians.
- kibwen 12y agoI think it's true that Martians will feel a great cultural separation from Earthlings (note to self: think of a better demonym), but I don't think it's true that colonies have historically become disinterested in the politics of their founding countries (be sure to consider only colonies that establish new populations shipped in from a host country rather than subjugating natives, since AFAIK Mars has no natives to subjugate). > No one born on Mars is going to have any reason to care > about what happens on Earth any more than the people of > one continent care about the day-to-day life of people on > another continent. But humans on Earth care about what happens on other continents incessantly. Today in the news: attacks on ISIS, Hong Kong protests, and the ebola outbreak. I care about all of these things, and as a taxpayer my money is influencing all of these things, though I cannot say that I was born in Iraq, China, or Senegal.
- freehunter 12y agoYou follow big news events happening elsewhere, but that is far different from caring about the day-to-day life of people. Mars would have a CNN equivalent to broadcast what is happening on Earth as well. But how much of the international news focuses on the impact back home? We're worried about ISIS because we might have to send troops to fight or risk them somehow endangering us directly (attacks in other countries, long range missiles, etc). We're worried about the ebola outbreak because there is potential to spread to our own nation. We're interested in the Hong Kong protests because of the impact that China has on the international economy. Watch CNN or Fox or Sky or whatever and listen to how often they will say "And what is the impact to [insert your country]?" or "How long until we're facing this threat in [country]?" What on Earth (literally) could threaten the Martians once they've become self-sustaining? The only time they would care about what happens on Earth from anything more than a pure curiosity standpoint is when they are dependent on Earth for survival. After that point, until we develop ships fast enough that we can get to Mars as fast as we can get across the Atlantic and trade once again becomes an issue, who cares what happens to Earth? Mars is just fine.
- notahacker 12y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but I don't believe the existence of distant relatives in Oceania (rather a lot of them if you include the fellow English-speaking capitalists in Australia and New Zealand) was ever seriously advanced as an argument in favour of MUAD wouldn't necessarily be a bad end to the Cold War from a US point of view.
- jerf 12y agoAre you personally currently environmentally apathetic because you know China is shoving as much burned coal into the air as they can? Are you personally currently environmentally apathetic because you know somewhere there are some unspoiled mountain lakes that are still hardly touched by the hand of man? Are you personally unconcerned about the possibility of your home being nuked because thank goodness Alaska will probably survive? You hypothesize a very bizarrely precise self-interest that very suddenly gives way to complete wild suicidal abandon at a very precise point. I'm not at all convinced what you've ordered up here can exist.
- kibwen 12y agoI'm really not sure what any of these are intended to show. Can you clarify?
- jerf 12y agoI'm taking the attitudes you suppose might exist in the future and translating into your current context, with the intent of showing that once you consider them concretely they don't make much sense. The United States isn't going to go "Oh, it's OK if everyone on Earth gets nuked, at least our Mars colonies will still be there." anymore than you're going to be unconcerned about whereever you live getting nuked because some other chunk of your country will probably survive. Self-interest isn't going anywhere.
- Taek 12y agoI think he's saying that we're already succeptible to moral hazard in the same way that we would be if we colonized mars. People in America don't have much skin in the game when it comes to protecting the environment in India or China. Except, we still do care if their water is toxic and if the air conditions are poor. The same sort of empathy will apply to people on other planets as well. Even though a heavily polluted other planet doesn't directly affect us in the same way that a heavily polluted Earth affects us, we are currently pretty well isolated from the extreme conditions in Shanghai and yet we still care what happens there. Furthermore, because of the large costs of shipping between planets, most of the things causing pollution on one planet is probably benefitting almost exclusively the residents of that planet. Moral hazard is an interesting concern but I don't think that it's going to end up being a severe problem.
- danielweber 12y agoAn off-world population is extremely vulnerable to attack from space. And even with a million people, Mars would be a long way from resupplying or repopulating a major country composed of hundreds of millions of people.
- mendort 12y agoI suspect that once we see how hard it is to build a self-sustaining extra terrestrial colony, we'll come to appreciate what we have even more.
- kibwen 12y agoSo far, this is the best argument against my cynicism. I certainly hope you're correct!
- danatkinson 12y agoWhy do you think it'll be hard? I'm not saying it's going to be easy, but what difficult challenges to survival do you specifically think they'll struggle to overcome?
- seanflyon 12y agoJust imagine how screwed up thing would have to get on earth for it earth to be on par with mars. The air is unbreathable, there are no living plants (or anything else) outside, the sun is dim, water is scarce, energy is scarce, and it is very very cold.
- MisterBastahrd 12y ago"Let's spend trillions and throw it into space" The technical issue is not the matter. It's the sheer amount of resources for which the overwhelming majority of the human race will never see a benefit from in their lifetimes.
- seren 12y agoIn the short to mid term, living on Mars or an asteroid will be much harsher that on Earth. It is colder, there are plenty of space radiation. You'll have to put a suit to go outside. You are not going to frolic in a shallow creek on Mars soon. Creating new habitable space will be expensive it will be like living in a submarine or an Antarctic base during winter. Forget about having large space for entertainment like a football stadium or a theater. I think that after a few months of that regimen people will start to appreciate more life on good old Earth.
- oskarth 12y agoImagine an island with two tribes, except that one of the tribes has a boat, and the other doesn't. Do both tribes want to preserve the coconut trees on the island, or is one tribe willing to take all of the coconuts with them on their boat? Sure. And that would suck. But that's not an argument against boats. Take the bigger perspective. The universe is bigger than you can ever imagine, on any scale.
- kibwen 12y agoI wasn't intending it as an argument against boats, but your scenario becomes quite bleak when you add in the fact that there exist less than a dozen islands in the world, and only one of them is known to actually support coconut trees by dint of not being perpetually on fire. "The universe is bigger than you can ever imagine" indeed, and I'm not advocating against space exploration. But humans as a species will never venture beyond the solar system; self-replicating robots designed to withstand 200,000 years of space travel might.
- dubcanada 12y agoAccording to Futurama, you are correct.
- Shivetya 12y agoI thin the Red Mars trilogy might be closer, corps and countries fighting over who can go and who is paid not to go The selection process would be pretty draconian at the start and for quite some time. Can you imagine the protests over genetic and medical screening that would preclude a great many from ever being considered?
- seanflyon 12y agoI don't think enough people are going to go to give the average person any real chance of getting there. Even if we send a million people that is still 0.014% of the population. I think it's more likely that we send far fewer people and let the population grow for mars-born children. Transportation to mars is incredibly expensive. Even with reusable rockets refueling on mars (and that would be quite the accomplishment) it would still be incredible expensive to send 1,000,000 people.
- celticninja 12y agoperhaps the inverse is true, we send a load of people and a spend a huge amount of resources to be able to make an inhospitable planet, hospitable, through the means of huge domes etc. Perhaps then we will realise how fortunate we are to have a planet where this is not required and that may cause us to increase our efforts to save earth. I would agree however that finding a hospitable planet that did not require 'terraforming' would be the death knell for the earth. Mainly because the rich/powerful would see their exit and would happily use all of earths remaining resources to get themselves there even if it was at the cost of most of the rest of the population of earth and earth itself.
- mironathetin 12y ago'I would agree however that finding a hospitable planet that did not require 'terraforming' ' Doesn't look like this is available in the solar system. Even the jovian moons MAY be habitable, but living there would certainly not be a pleasure. Planets around other stars are currently a little hard to reach. Science certainly need more (earth- ) time to get there.
- ErikRogneby 12y agoOr on the flip-side once people see how crappy life on Mars is, they will realized that we need to take better care of the paradise we have been living in?
- nightski 12y agoYou act like it is our choice whether the earth remains habitable or not. That remains to be seen (rather unlikely in my opinion). Sure we can affect it but I think in the end it really isn't up to us.
- callahad 12y ago> I can't help but wonder if the mere existence of a sustainable off-world colony would cause humans on Earth to give even less of a damn about maintaining a habitable planet. [...] does the interplanetary superpower suddenly becoming all the more willing to watch the world burn? If you're interested in fiction along those lines, Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars Trilogy (Red Mars, Blue Mars, Green Mars) seems right up your alley. I'm about half way through the first book, and it's starting to delve into whether or not the distant, Earth-based powers that financed initial settlement have any ability to actually influence or control the resulting Martian population. Environmental concerns are also pretty explicitly considered. Definitely a fun read.
- judgardner 12y agoAgreed, these books are interesting and cover the geopolitical aspects of a mars colony attempting to break away from the control a dying earth government.
- Istof 12y agomost of the biggest users of earth's resources already don't care (think companies that prioritize profit over everything else), so why would you think that it would be worst?
- crimsonalucard 12y agoMorality has nothing do with environmental apathy. Survival takes precedence over morality and convenience, that much is obvious. People will violate morals in the name of survival. The question of saving the environment is not a moral question but one of survival. The irony about it all is, if saving the environment is about survival why do people still don't care? Ask yourself, "If I care about the environment, if I care about my survival, why do I pollute it by driving a car to work every morning?" The answer is deceptively obvious. I direct you to an insightful article by Garrett Hardin describing a phenomenon known as the tragedy of the commons: http://www.sciencemag.org/content/162/3859/1243.full http://www.sciencemag.org/content/162/3859/1243.full
- MichaelAO 12y agoConsider the following a thought experiment and not some ideology worth attacking. This type of discussion always reminds me of a story Terence Mckenna told (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLikdK8LjmE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fLikdK8LjmE). To paraphrase, a vine refused to grow onto a branch of a tree in his backyard. One day, while contemplating this unfortunate affair, he witnessed the branch fall off the tree. He realized that the vine 'sensed' the instability. He then thought that the complex ecosystem of Earth might have a similar mechanism and that it might be aware that the Sun will explode at some point in the future, destroying all life. In anticipation for this inevitability, the human race (or another advanced species) was called forth to extend life/consciousness beyond the confides of our eventual death trap. So why tell this story? What if the destruction of ones home planet is part of the evolutionary process of advanced consciousness? The same way that a fetus must purge itself from the womb or risk death by toxicity. In weird paradoxical way, those that pollute planet Earth might be playing their role as designed. It's worth noting that I'm 100% for ecologically sound technological advancement and a society that doesn't destroy the environment. But part of me thinks everything is going according to plan, when viewed from a large enough perspective.
- lmm 12y agoEarth is not intelligent. Species can and will drive themselves to extinction via evolution. The destruction of Earth may be the only way to make humanity successful in the long term - that was the view given in some of Asimov's stories. Or it may just be a way to kill ourselves. The ecosystem as a whole is not an optimized complex system like a vine; it has not been subject to evolutionary pressure. There is no plan; the outcome will be down entirely to luck and our own decisions.