32 ms·
I agree with you that this mentality is likely how we gotten into the mess, but I think the way out is less clear. Thanks to the whole piracy dilemma, there was
by xg15 12y ago
I agree with you that this mentality is likely how we gotten into the mess, but I think the way out is less clear. Thanks to the whole piracy dilemma, there was motivation your three strategies and develop the technology and services that they require. But now the technologies are there and aren't going away anymore, even if everyone would suddenly start paying again for everything.
Take Adobe for example: They moved from selling Photoshop as a software to a subscription-based model where they are effectively selling the same thing as a service. They didn't just use the cloud technology to secure their old business model, they actually made it even more restrictive.
Similarly, when you buy a phone, you don't get to choose between a cheap, locked down phone and an expensive free phone - you're paying the full price and still get the locked down phone.
So I believe, it is necessary that we get an alternative to the "free" culture, but it isn't enough. As things are today, it makes the most economic sense to abandon the "free" culture and still keeping your users in serfdom. Something else has to happen to shift balance, but I have no idea what that could be.
- api 12y agoAgreed. Making things even harder is how deeply entrenched the piracy-is-good mentality still is. Try arguing against it over at Reddit or on any thread about Popcorn Time or Kim.Com (what a douche) and see how far you get. You'll get attacked pretty viciously and downvoted into lower Hades, even at Hacker News. If you don't pay, you don't matter. Free means serfdom. This is one of those things that absolutely nobody gets, IMHO, and I see no sign of more people getting it for a while. It's gonna have to get a lot worse before it gets better.
- quadrangle 12y agoFree can also be Free/Libre/Open. You don't pay for Wikipedia and you're not a serf as a reader / user, you're not the product.
- api 12y agoThat only works for a subset of things, namely those things that can be effectively crowdsourced at small increments. I'd also argue that Wikipedia is heavily indirectly subsidized by academia and government. Large coherent software products and great works of art are by definition the products of individuals or small teams focusing intensely for long periods of time. That is inherently expensive. Only the independently wealthy or the otherwise subsidized can afford to focus for thousands upon thousands of hours and then give the product away... not unless they have another idea for revenue like freemium, SaaS, etc. (... and those don't work for music, movies, books, etc.) ... and "otherwise subsidized" takes us back to some of the pathologies I mention... propaganda, advertising, etc. driving art and surveillance/manipulation based business models driving software. Do we really want a future where only trust fund kids and propagandists create art? Do we really want a future where software is created exclusively to monetize its users? The Wikipedia model can only work for everything in a true post-scarcity society where the marginal cost of everything is zero and everyone can live with no real "income." Until someone finds a way to draw unlimited energy from the quantum vacuum, we are stuck with some form of economy where everything I said applies. Another way of thinking about the pirate economy is as a deflationary spiral in which monetary velocity collapses and all kinds of pathologies emerge from that. Deflationary spirals are actually really great for uber-capitalists that already own lots of rentier assets, but they're bad for workers, entrepreneurs, and other non-rentiers. Sound familiar?
- quadrangle 12y agoWikipedia happens to be supported by a huge quantity of individual supporters around the world, both in writing and in funding the servers and development. They actively avoid reaching out to wealthy philanthropists and governments and get all their support from the general global community. Wikipedia indeed requires a smaller dedicated team to keep the system running. But they are not subsidized in any pathological way. They are funded by large quantity of small donations. There's nothing wrong with that. We don't need to reach a true post-scarcity world in order to better allocate the scarce resources we have. It's completely feasible to provide a basic income or other basic resources just like we do with clean water. We can have mechanisms to charge for use beyond the basic level. And we can have the community fund people to make the resources we want. The "pirate economy" you talk about is the "freerider economy" (pirate is a stupid term here). Freeriding is a REAL problem. We can't live on a freeriding economy. But we can still have Free/Libre/Open resources if we can get people to fund them without compelling them through artificial restrictions. Wikipedia works because the scale is SO large that they get adequate support despite freeriding. There's also lots of ways to discourage freeriding / encourage donation better than we do now. The first step is to get everyone to STOP wasting their limited funds on proprietary products so that they actually can afford to better support Free/Libre/Open ones.
- whizzkid 12y ago"alternative to the "free" culture" ( for both software and hardware) - Reasonable price tags on products. - Companies standing behind their products instead of letting it being bought by 3 biggies. (this is hard) - Learning how to make beautiful and useful user experiences from Google, Apple. You need to be passionate about what you are doing. If your people do not buy it, then you can not sell it to others. There are already some companies doing these and getting pretty good results. I keep my faith in them. As long as we do not improve ourselves, we are kind of helping these big companies to rule the environment i am guessing.
- _delirium 12y agoI think piracy is one motivation, but I suspect it'd be going in this direction even without it: a yearly recurring revenue stream is just more attractive than selling software. Companies in many industries prefer the "license/rent you something" model to the "sell you something" model, and it's mostly a question of whether culture/economics/technology/competition/law makes that practical. In the enterprise space it's long been standard: IBM won't sell you a mainframe outright, but rather rents you computing services. In the consumer space it's traditionally been harder, because it wasn't obvious why someone should pay you a subscription fee for a CD-ROM; though some companies did try to sell subscriptions to yearly updates. With a software delivery model more like a classic mainframe+terminal, it's easier to pitch the software-rental approach to consumers, so unsurprisingly they're doing so.