6 ms·
I reject the idea that one should have to pay to license technology developed by a (taxpayer funded) federal agency. If tax dollars funded it, it belongs to al
by mindcrime 12y ago
I reject the idea that one should have to pay to license technology developed by a (taxpayer funded) federal agency. If tax dollars funded it, it belongs to all of us anyway.
I believe I'm going to write my Congressional reps later today and suggest pushing for the elimination of licensing fees for tech from NSA, NASA, DOD, etc. I'm sure it won't go anywhere, but what can ya do?
- jngreenlee 12y agoAgreed, it's interesting that they do this. I don't have time to dig in, but I wonder if the $$ goes back to NSA R&D budgets, or to the US's general fund.
- ganeumann 12y agoDisagree. While the taxpayers funded it, the taxpayers also get the benefit from others paying for it. Charging for the tech gives them information about what others find valuable, so is an important signal as to where they should spend their research time.
- atmosx 12y agoMaybe it's just me, but I fail to see reason in your reasoning. There are other ways to find out the what is important, ways that are less prone to errors, ESPECIALLY for research...
- garric 12y agoIt's not just you, though it sounds like his reasoning is based around the ideological context of conflating "democratic choice" with "choice in a market". The role of price is a principal guarantor of democracy, after all. /sardonic
- ganeumann 12y agoThe part about "democratic choice" should be handled by our "democratically elected leaders." But I don't think I really understand your point at all. What does selling the IP v. giving it away have to do with democratic choice? My point was that selling the IP instead of giving it away is revenue neutral to society (and, in fact, a positive to the taxpayers who are not buying the IP) and so selling it does not decrease welfare and may well improve it if it provides some data to the agency on what the users of their research value. This is entirely unlike what happens with NSF-funded research which is given away to journals who charge a fortune to read it. In this latter case (unless you think that peer-review is incredibly valuable, which no one besides the publishers seem to believe) the overall effect is welfare reducing.
- dkural 12y agoHe's saying putting a price on it helps gauge market demand as expressed by willingness to pay, a signal that people find it valuable. What's so unreasonable about that? He didn't say it is a way to find what's important, he said it is an important signal to find what people value enough to spend their money on.
- benologist 12y agoWhy does this matter to the NSA? They're not a for-profit company and their needs are surely different to for-profit companies so why would they optimize anything on sales?
- irollboozers 12y agoUnfortunately, there just aren't many good metrics for future potential scientific value. It's not like you can just give NSA / DARPA / NIH one impact factor, as weird as that sounds.
- cowsandmilk 12y ago> he said it is an important signal to find what people value enough to spend their money on. No, he didn't, he said: > is an important signal as to where they should spend their research time anyone who has looked at basic research knows that immediate commercialization potential is a horrible guide for where to spend time. As a quick example, would you pay for someone to research the immune systems of sharks and camels? No technology transfer office can sell a description of how the immune systems work. It seems ridiculous. But after years were spent researching these topics, describing them in detail in the publicly available literature, companies have taken features of these systems and built products based on them. The goal of government-funded research is not to run a business, directing research into immediate commercialization, it is to do basic science that would not be funded by companies because it does not appear prima facie to have commercial application.
- dkural 12y agoActually, he is saying "what others find valuable is an important signal for research", and I don't see anything obviously wrong with taking into consideration what others find commercially valuable - because NSA is not a "fundamental sciences" research organization. I agree that NSF should pursue what scientists find interesting/important and disregard commercial concerns. NIH will often come ahead doing that as well. On the other hand, let's look at NSA - They develop technologies for spying on people. They write software & do a bunch of other applied work detailed in that PDF. I don't think they should run a business either, but NSAs primary aim is not science. If they go the extra mile beyond publishing a paper and want to license their code / tech to companies for a fee, I don't see why that's a problem. Often some exclusive access or license can spur further investment. I do think open access to all can & often also spurs innovation - but not always. Pharma for instance depends on a government-granted monopoly on the manufacture of a small molecule in the form of a patent, to ensure it can recoup its costs of R&D and indirectly bribing prescribing doctors & paying for ads.
- higherpurpose 12y agoThe government is not a business. It shouldn't act as a business. There's FAR more value from researching a technology with taxpayer money and then allowing everyone to use the results of that technology, rather than a few select companies (to which they have to give the stamp of approval, meaning there can also be selection bias)
- _eqet 12y agoWhy not just use track the number of downloads or pull requests for this metric?
- higherpurpose 12y agoI especially find ridiculous the fact that the government itself can "patent" a technology - in its own country.
- tomohawk 12y agoIf the government were to release the tech into the public domain, then they would be charged for the use of the technology. This has happened in the past when contractors charged the government for a system that was based on government developed technology that the government failed to patent. If they patent it, they can recoup some revenue, but they can also ensure that any products based on it can be used for free or much more cheaply by the government.
- zachrose 12y ago> If the government were to release the tech into the public domain, then they would be charged for the use of the technology. Can you explain this part? I don't understand why anyone would have to pay for public domain technology.
- fit2rule 12y agoIndeed, the entire mechanism should be available to the general public for use, or in other words - entirely radical thinking - why don't we defeat the NSA by demanding it open-source itself, 100%? After all, it might make all the difference in the world if maximum intelligence was suddenly and irrevocably available to every single living human on the planet .. its actually within our grasp, as a species, to share such a moment. Gimme root, NSA.
- happyscrappy 12y agoGiving your enemies all your tech is not wise. Thankfully hipster dufuses have no real power.
- fit2rule 12y agoToo bad the makers of enemies seem to think they're the only ones who can be trusted with power.
- happyscrappy 12y agoThen move to Russia and fight the evil West.
- krapp 12y agoShow me a powerful nation without enemies.
- fit2rule 12y agoMaybe we wouldn't have so many enemies if we didn't keep so many secrets.
- jazzyk 12y agoSo you (just like the US government/NSA) think that the people of this country are the enemy.
- 12y ago
- lr 12y agoThen you need to write to the state universities (and even private universities) in your state, as well, as they do the same thing with both state-funded and federally-funded research. It has been going on for decades.
- dmix 12y agoIsn't this why Aaron Swartz risked so much attempting to steal the data, because alternative options of liberating the data were almost entirely futile?
- bryondowd 12y agoIf they give it away for free, that benefits a relatively few people who can make use of it. If they sell it, they can put that revenue back into their program in place of (or in addition to) more taxpayer money. This lets them do more with less taxpayer money going forward, so it sounds like a win for the average Joe taxpayer. (In theory.)
- jonknee 12y ago> If they give it away for free, that benefits a relatively few people who can make use of it. If there are relatively few people who benefit the sales will also be meaningless. You'll also have a bunch of losses for things that didn't sell well, liability for when something goes wrong, etc etc. The government isn't a business, it should not try to be one.
- bryondowd 12y agoWell yeah, but there's a difference between "Let's list all this stuff we've already done for our own purposes and see if we can recoup a little cash" and acting like a business. As long as they aren't putting too much effort into sales, it probably works out to an easy net positive.
- quahada 12y agoThe main motivation of this sort of technology transfer program isn't the license revenue itself. That's insignificant when compared to their operating budget. The point of this program is to provide evidence that the research has commercial applications. With this evidence, they are able to go to Congress and show their research helps the economy, which is used as part of the justification of their research budget.