5 ms·
Hmm seems like he made the classical mistake of thinking that an x86-64 server is somehow special and more worthwhile than just buying a bare-bones PC. I've ma
by Someone1234 12y ago
Hmm seems like he made the classical mistake of thinking that an x86-64 server is somehow special and more worthwhile than just buying a bare-bones PC.
I've managed Dell servers before (real ones) and aside from a bunch of stuff to make managing them in mass easier (like DRAC), there isn't very much value in trying to retrofit one for home use.
VT-x or 24 GB of RAM support isn't exactly a hard requirement in 2014. Plus the Xeon E5410 is a 2007 chip (7 years old!) and gets it butt kicked by even a low end i3 from 2012 [0].
Plus modern systems consume less electrical power which makes running them cheaper and a PC is certainly quieter than any rack mounted server (which are designed for maximum cooling, noise be damned).
Additionally if he had purchased off-the-shelf parts he would likely have a warranty for 12 months (or more). With the eBay purchased Dell machine he not only doesn't get any warranty but ALSO Dell themselves don't even support it(!) so no firmware updates.
So while this was a fun read, it just reminds me of my more nieve days when I thought doing stuff like this was a good idea. Go over to any SysAdmin forum (e.g. spiceworks community) and they'll tell you the same thing.
[0]http://cpuboss.com/cpus/Intel-Xeon-E5410-vs-Intel-Core-i3-3220 http://cpuboss.com/cpus/Intel-Xeon-E5410-vs-Intel-Core-i3-32...
edit: Originally linked to an 2012 i5 comparison ($180 CPU). Altered it to an 2012 i3 comparison ($100 CPU) which still out-performance the 7 year old Xeon. The $100 price tag seems a lot more comparable than a near $200 CPU. Plus the i3 supports 32 GB of RAM and VT-x (the OP's requirements).
- bluedino 12y agoA lightly used i5/i7 with a bunch of RAM and an SSD would be a much, much better host. I rescued a Dell workstation with an i7-950 from disposal, and added 2 disks and some RAM (9GB). Still not as quick as a 2500k in a lot of stuff but great for anything I can throw at it (decent size MySQL DB, lots of Rails apps, and quite a bit of web traffic). I could bump it up to 24GB but that's still $250 worth of RAM, new.
- theonewolf 12y agoYeah, the RAM alone is a costly thing actually. I was lucky to find it so cheap :-)
- evandena 12y agoECC is nice, especially coupled with ZFS.
- drzaiusapelord 12y agoSysadmin here. Agreed. 1 or 2U servers for home use is fairly ridiculous. In fact, its kinda ridiculous for some business use now. We're probably only a few years away from a mainstream and popular form-factor that's a fraction of the size, with tiny SSDs instead of giant spinning drives and power-sipping x86 or ARM chips. Imagine something the size of a stack of 4 or 5 ipads replacing the typical 19" racked server. For small and perhaps even medium business, this could be a good fit. The 19" rack really is something from a past era. Soon people will look at it the same way I look at old mainframes and minicomputers. As far as the article goes, $300 is impressive, but the costs of wasted electricity will eat up the savings eventually compared to just dropping some cash on a new Synology NAS, and you get a warranty.
- Roritharr 12y agoThere is a Hamburg based startup called Protonet which are targeting smaller agencys with basically the formfactor you describe. They offer a drop-in solution that acts as your wifi ap, provides everything from "local cloud" data storage to offering a complete groupware solution ontop of it. Thats why they are so expensive, but their potential customerbase is huge and they've got the product design in a good position. (Not affiliated with protonet anyhow, just like the stuff they do.) https://protonet.info/en/product/comparison/ https://protonet.info/en/product/comparison/
- theonewolf 12y agoAgree with you and the OP, for me I always work with these servers (or am supposed to with my cloud research), and wanted to toy around with one on my own. The noise of the CS24-SC actually isn't so bad (as others report). The power is 400W, less pulled when the whole system is idled. So not horrible. We do not run 24/7, this isn't being used as a traditional server. We turn it on to manipulate large VM images (my case), or to run an algorithm that needs a lot of RAM and cores (her case). So it runs at most 8-10 hours, 2-4 times a week.
- existencebox 12y agoSysadmin as well, proudly running a 4U supermicro box as my home fileserver. If I can find a tower that can hot swappably fit that many drives, I'd look twice, but there are some other small advantages. Redundant power is nice in some situations, as is ECC if you really care about that sort of thing. Finally, given the sheer amount of processor overhead a dual socket gives you, it was easy for me to also utilize the machine as a VM server. As other posts have pointed out, an out of box IPMI system is additionally hard to turn down; these are all capabilities that I simply have not found together in commodity products. My point I guess, is that I think there's still situations that merit rolling your own "Server box", even at home. (Not to disagree with anything you said, but to provide my own outlook)
- theonewolf 12y agoI don't think it's special at all. I work with these things in my cloud research and thought it'd be cute to play around with one at home. Partly because of the challenge at getting an old clunker back into a working state. And partly because I like dogfooding and really knowing what it takes to run an entire stack---including the hardware underneath me. Those are my real reasons. This was for fun :-)
- joezydeco 12y agonoise be damned Holy crap you're not kidding. I (briefly) had a 1U server in an upstairs home office for a project, it got banished to the basement within an hour because of the jet-turbine noise coming off of it. I could still hear it in the basement.
- discardorama 12y agoAll that is fine and dandy, but the RAM. These days RAM is so much more expensive! 4GB DDR3 is around $8-$10/GB. So his 24GB memory alone would cost around $200 at least.
- theonewolf 12y agoPrecisely, you get it. This RAM was _insanely_ cheap :-)
- sciurus 12y agoSure, it's cheaper than buying new RAM, but it's also * 5+ years old * has a peak transfer rate that's only 40% of contemporary PC3-12800
- theonewolf 12y agoAnd the whole point of the article is cheapness. As in, some people buy old clunker cars and fix them up as a hobby and also sometimes for cheapness. Sure, they pollute more, get less MPG, etc. etc. But they can be dirt cheap, and fun to restore if you like that kind of thing.
- rsync 12y ago"Plus the Xeon E5410 is a 2007 chip (7 years old!) and gets it butt kicked by even a low end i3 from 2012" Yes, but in an age of ZFS, can a non-xeon support ECC RAM ? I think a rackmount home server is a good choice if you already have other rackmount equipment in place, such as switches and routers. If that server is the only rackmount device you're going to get, then I think it's probably unnecessary.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Sanddancer 12y agoThe i3s support ECC. The i5s and i7s don't because that's where intel branches their consumer from their server models.
- throwaway41597 12y agoActually, it seems some (not all) laptop CPUs from the i3 up to the i7 do support ECC, while the desktop versions don't. Search for ECC in the pages below. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Core_i3_microprocessors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Core_i3_micropro... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Core_i7_microprocessors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Core_i7_micropro...
- walshemj 12y agoDepends if you want compute heavy HPC/Big data the dual xenon's with 128GB memory and 30-40 TB of DASD are the way to go. And a lot of the consumer boards cant handle that many of the Tesla cards they run out of PCI lanes
- ChuckMcM 12y agoNot really a "mistake" they are different. A machine destined for a data center will have an IPMI subsystem in it, that is the thing you can run the machine remotely from, reflash the bios and reboot if you want. A data center machine will probably have ECC RAM which a barebones PC won't unless you are picky and find the one sku that ASUS and Gigabyte make that both have ECC capable chipsets and support in the BIOS. And lastly a datacenter machine will be more comfortable running headless than a barebones PC so there won't be any thing popping up on the VGA screen and saying "press any key to continue." Lastly a machine expecting to be in a rack in a data center probably has some insane fan noise when the fans spin up :-).
- Tiksi 12y ago>a datacenter machine will be more comfortable running headless than a barebones PC so there won't be any thing popping up on the VGA screen and saying "press any key to continue." Foreign configuration(s) found on adapter. Press any key to continue or 'C' to load the configuration utility, or 'F' to import foreign configuration(s) and continue. All of the disks from your previous configuration are gone. If this is an unexpected message, then please power off your system and check your cables to ensure all disks are present. Press any key to continue, or 'C' to load the configuration utility. Entering the configuration utility in this state will result in drive configuration changes. Press 'Y' to continue loading the configuration utility or please power off your system and check your cables to ensure all disks are present and reboot. But generally speaking, that's more or less true (except for the temperamental LSI based controllers)
- Theodores 12y agoIMHO a bare-bones PC is a bit over the top for a home setup. Broken laptop is the way to go if you want to get the power requirements and noise down. Really it comes down to whether the broken laptop will do what you need it to and the price is very competitive compared to even the most basic (and slow) VPS. You can also pop in an SSD and the broken-laptop server sings along. I should define broken - this is where a keyboard or screen has died yet the actual gubbins work as Intel intended. What you don't want is where the CPU has fried the thermal paste and gone hot for an extended time. That won't run good even if 'fixed'. A broken-laptop-server will also contain battery backup. The power supply is definitely hot-swappable if you happen to have another power adapter for it. Really there should be some USB-stick version of a common version of Linux that is completely optimised for power management with the intended use being a redundant laptop turned into a home server. It could have wake on lan magic packet in use too, effectively making it a device that only uses power if you actually use the device. This would be a complete contrast to the normal over-engineered server arrangement.
- vacri 12y agoBroken laptops are certainly overlooked as an option, but you also have to be aware of your use-case. RAID is generally not available, and if you want to crunch lots of data as in the article, CPU and RAM aren't usually much to write home about. Horses for courses.
- theonewolf 12y agoWe are using this server sporadically, essentially wake-on-lan. Especially with the BMC console, we can remotely power it on, off, reset, etc.