13 ms·
S.F., L.A. threaten Uber, Lyft, Sidecar with legal action
- refurb 12y agoIt will be interesting to see how this all plays out. Uber has gotten big enough (and has enough cash) to put up a pretty good fight in court. At the same time, city attorney's have a lot of stuff on their plates. Obviously someone thought this was worth spending on time (aka the higher ups want it to happen).
- walterbell 12y agoIt rarely results in meaningful regulation of the business, yet provides endless free publicity and brand building.
- colechristensen 12y agoI am all for reasonable regulation my Uber and it's kind and severe punishment for straying outside that regulation. The thing is that unlike my own fine city of Minneapolis, many other metropolitan areas seem incapable or unwilling to respond reasonably to try to work with these companies to come to a mutually agreeable set of regulations. The city governments are incompetent to do their jobs instead they throw around legal threats and the companies openly flaunt the law. Neither seem to be doing what's right.
- cwiz 12y agoI'm thinking more & more about decentralised p2p bitcoin based uber which cannot be ever shut down or controlled. Now it's becoming apparent that it's what world will soon need.
- sneak 12y agoIf it can't be shut down, there's nothing stopping violent muggers or kidnappers from participating as drivers. If there's a feedback system, there's nothing stopping Sybil attacks from gaming it and forging reviews en masse. You have to trust someone's opinion, somewhere.
- baddox 12y agoOf course there would still need to be either reputation systems or arbitration systems. The reason restaurants usually don't plainly defraud you isn't the threat of litigation, because litigation would cost much more than the value of the transaction. It's because they rely on reputation and repeat business. Decentralized or massively federated reputation and arbitration networks are possible. Clever people would need to figure out a way to set things up, but it's certainly not a technological impossibility.
- bigdubs 12y agoThe bit about Uber saying it screened drivers thoroughly, and then the DA (or the office) finding examples where that was clearly not true is interesting and (IMHO) not unreasonable. The weights and measures complaint I am curious about and wonder if it's to do with surge pricing. For the record I'm against surge pricing as I feel it amounts to usury in the Aquinian sense.
- Meekro 12y agoI wonder how many people in ordinary taxis got assaulted during the same time period. The DA's "failed background check" example reminds me of how one Model S caught on fire, and everyone freaked out and forgot that regular cars do that all the time, too.
- richcsmith 12y agoBeyond the scope. The DA didn't say he wanted them to offer more thorough background checks or threaten to shut them down if they didn't. Likewise, afaik, he's also not going after taxi companies saying drivers aren't allowed to drive if they have records, because it's not illegal. That said, I think it's completely reasonable for the city to ask these companies to stop lying to consumers to make us feel safer for the sake of their revenue. I'm totally for innovation and everything that comes with it though. I want these companies to succeed (well, maybe not Uber) but them behaving in this way is going to make it more difficult from a legal perspective for the startups of tomorrow. Anyway, does anyone know if there's any type of 'Startup Legal Counsel' where companies that are innovating faster than the the law is able to evolve can be advised on the laws they may be breaking or help them lobby to get relevant laws updated faster before it has to get to this point? Or should they just know better?
- jonknee 12y agoYea and it wasn't really failed. Uber says they weed out people with dangerous driving records and the DA didn't mention the driver had one. The cited "Felony drug dealing" sounds really scary, but it was for selling weed five years ago. After this specific case Uber volunteered to make its background checks more rigorous. http://www.sfgate.com/default/article/Uber-driver-charged-with-punching-S-F-passenger-5526413.php http://www.sfgate.com/default/article/Uber-driver-charged-wi... Seems like a DA being a DA and it will go away once his power tantrum runs its course.
- pbreit 12y agoUber, et al are not going away so the governments need to figure out the proper amount of oversight and stop this ridiculous volley of shutdown threats.
- bsder 12y agoUm, not at all. Given the absolute raft of laws that Uber/Lyft/et al. violate most of the DA's are being more respectful than I would have expected, actually. SF could force these services to shut down tomorrow and they would be on very safe legal grounds.
- aianus 12y agoI'd imagine the rich and powerful citizens of SF are regular users of Uber et al. Doesn't seem like the wisest political move to shut it down.
- bsder 12y agoUh, yeah, sure, rich and powerful people need to "share" a rideservice. Riiiiiiight. That's why even the slightly upper class stores all deem it important enough to have valets ... their clientele is all taking Uber/Lyft/etc. ... suuuuure, you keep on believing that The rich and powerful make money off of people dumb enough to believe in the concept of the "sharing" economy enough to be their peons.
- pbreit 12y agoDoes it really make sense for there to be a "raft of laws" concerning driving people around for money? What is the purpose of such laws?
- bsder 12y agoUm, to make sure that the guy whose cab you are getting into actually has things like ... say ... brakes?
- clarkm 12y agoIt's interesting to contrast this article with the update that was just emailed out to the Uber Oklahoma list: "Today, we are thrilled to announce that the Tulsa City Council and Mayor Bartlett have paved the way for a permanent home for uberX in Tulsa by signing the recently passed rideshare ordinance." http://us1.campaign-archive1.com/?u=8d2fd6968b2b5c64d0d22dba2&id=7ab4f30f99 http://us1.campaign-archive1.com/?u=8d2fd6968b2b5c64d0d22dba... Edit Here's a copy of the ordinance: http://councildocs.tulsacouncil.org/SuperContainer/RawData//671AOKJV882014103244/14-678-1a.pdf?a=1 http://councildocs.tulsacouncil.org/SuperContainer/RawData//...
- toasted 12y agoIt is only a matter of time before these outfits are replaced by decentralised, actual peer-to-peer networks, either running off blockchain technology or similar decentralised databases, with no house take and the only option for government being charges against individual operators. There is no network lockin effect when drivers can easily install a competing app and drive for no commission to anyone else.
- smaili 12y agoI disagree. People were saying the same thing about Facebook and Diaspora but that never actually happened.
- sneak 12y agoThat's because diaspora sucked. The distributed social network is coming.
- jMyles 12y agoWow, this is the impatience of our age. How long do you give a network distribution methodology before you declare it a failure?
- toasted 12y agoFacebook has a strong network effect in that everyone is on it and few regular people are interested in signing up for multiple social networks. OTOH, rideshare drivers are incentivised to have as many (useful) rideshare apps on their phones as possible to maximise their ride volume, and customers are then incentivised to order their rides from the rideshare app with the lowest commission, and eventually a race to the bottom will result.
- frewsxcv 12y agoI think more people are willing to switch away from Uber/Lyft than from Facebook since (from what I understand about the service) there's nothing really personal about them except for user ratings. If a new competitor opened up tomorrow that promised to be decentralized with fewer fees, I'd bet on it succeeding. Facebook has many more purposes like communication, media hosting, and event planning (with a very strong network effect). People aren't going to give up on that platform very easily.
- tunesmith 12y agoI hadn't really thought about it before but it strikes me as kind of odd that a taxi/limo/uber with one passenger would be allowed to use the car pool lane... given that the driver wouldn't otherwise be going there.
- eridius 12y agoI think the reason is that the incentive of the carpool lane is to get fewer cars off the road, not to literally reward the act of carrying more than one person in a vehicle. To that end, taxis can use carpool because someone using a taxi is someone not driving a personal vehicle (and parking it at their destination, and driving back home later). If taxis are good enough, people won't buy cars, and fewer owned cars generally means fewer cars on the road.
- baddox 12y agoIs "transit lane" the same thing as a carpool lane?
- mikeryan 12y agoNo, in SF and other urban areas transit lanes are exclusively for taxis and buses.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ChuckMcM 12y agoWhy is that odd? The "goal" was to incentivize multiple people per car. Not unlike say, babysitters transporting their charges from school to daycare. Some places put the limit at '3' to avoid just those situations (but it also freezes out couples going on a date) and at least one jurisdiction was quoted as allowing only vehicles at their 'full passenger capacity' what ever that is (which seems a bit extreme to me)
- ilaksh 12y agoYes the laws are outdated, but it almost seems like they are just ignoring all of them. And of course the government feels pressure to stay relevant. But legal threats and other government systems can't keep up with a fast-changing digital economy. I think that we need some kind of effectively integrated system of regulation that can somehow represent the public good in a way that interfaces more directly with things like mobile apps and the blockchain, etc. I also think we need to move away from a single-point-of-failure, all-powerful centralized government into something more egalitarian and decentralized. Maybe even polycentric. Exactly how you do all of those things is an incredibly challenging set of problems.