2 ms·
"The search site sells the search information to an HFT who buys the domain for $10 (or better, just reserves it for a month without paying anyone), and then of
by kasey_junk 12y ago
"The search site sells the search information to an HFT who buys the domain for $10 (or better, just reserves it for a month without paying anyone), and then offers to sell it to you for $100. Have they have increased market liquidity in much the same manner as the HFT for a similar degree of public benefit?"
In general, I don't like speaking in analogies about HFT as it is a highly technical area that depends on details. That said, this is a particularly bad analogy because unlike equity shares, domain names are not in any way fungible. pets.com is worth way more than akjalfdj89898afdsfyyy834u384734.sexy and there is only 1 pets.com, so if a market participant makes pets.com harder to acquire they are certainly not providing liquidity.
If you really want a stretched analogy, lets assume that McDonalds has contracted with a purchasing company, to secure enough beef to support their SUPER SAD SEPT SALE of cheeseburgers where they will need an extra amount of beef. If that purchasing agent then tells his brother to go out and buy all the beef he can, and they then collude to defraud McDonalds that is probably out of bounds. Conversely, if the purchasing agent finds that the average price of beef on the market is $1 a lb, but he himself has bought some for $.90 a lb, most people would view him selling it to his client for the market rate as fair. If the purchasing agents brother has some $.93 a lb beef and pays the purchasing agent $.02 a lb to sell to McDonals for $.98 we also usually don't have a problem. Further, if the purchasing agent stocks up on Coke because he assumes the sale will drive up the price of sugar water for his other clients, that also doesn't seem out of bounds to most people. Finally, in our super stretched analogy, no one would expect a savvy farmer who notices the purchasing agent buying up all the beef around to not raise his prices.