18 ms·
It's almost like the executives at the studios and distributors who own the rights to these films don't realize that, if I can't easily, quickly and convenientl
by mindcrime 12y ago
It's almost like the executives at the studios and distributors who own the rights to these films don't realize that, if I can't easily, quickly and conveniently buy access to their film legally, I will just bittorrent the damn thing. And personally I don't even feel guilty about it. It's 2014, join the 21st century or suffer the consequences.
I don't mind paying for content, and - in fact - I largely prefer to do so, so there will be more new content coming. But I am not going to bend over backwards to accommodate these laggards and dinosaurs refusal to pay attention to the world we live in.
- zobzu 12y agoCan't agree more.
- colinbartlett 12y agoReally nothing infuriates me more than when CanIStream.it tells me that the movie I want to watch is unavailable to stream for purchase or subscription on any service. I pay for Netflix, Prime, Hulu, and will gladly rent just about any film for $4.99 yet more than once per week I find films that I would need to go to a store and purchase just to see.
- click170 12y agoIt would be neat if we could easily wrap these various streaming services up in one UI so that you simply search for a movie and it streams it from Netflix or hulu if possible and bittorrent if not. Its unfortunate that in today's world this would get you sued out of existence.
- wanderingstan 12y agoThat's a rather interesting startup/service idea. On setup you tell it what services you have accounts on, and then when you search it will tell you the options (with links to signup on new services), and always with a "BitTorrent at your own risk" fallback.
- colinbartlett 12y agoCanIStream.it is 90% of the way there to your idea.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- eightofdiamonds 12y agoRoku does this. They have a universal search and any channel on the device that the movie or show is available on will come up with the pricing.
- 8_hours_ago 12y agoThis is something that a company such as Microsoft or Apple should implement. It would be a killer app for either the X Box or the Apple TV.
- marwatk 12y agoTivo currently does this (albeit without a bit torrent option) for upcoming live TV, Comcast on-demand, Hulu Plus, Amazon Instant Video and Netflix. There may be more now, but those are the ones I use. You search for a title and it will tell you where it's available and you can watch it from any of them directly from the Tivo UI.
- bduerst 12y agoIt would be impossible to access content as Netflix, Hulu, etc. would most certainly block your service. For them it's also about controlling the overall experience, not just regurgitating the content they serve (e.g. users spotting gaps in coverage).
- wooger 12y agoThis already happened with Google TV and various online video services. The original plan was to offer a service exaclty like this.
- colinbartlett 12y agoOn the contrary, Netflix recently shut down their API and CanIStreamIt was one of only 8 services they allowed continued access. I think they understand the value of it. http://developer.netflix.com/blog http://developer.netflix.com/blog
- bduerst 12y agoIf enough customers are using those 8 services, then they're not going to shut it down with the API when they block everyone else. It's a common deprecation strategy for APIs, and only proves Netflix is tightening control over their user experience.
- jfb 12y ago"Really nothing infuriates me more than when CanIStream.it tells me that the movie I want to watch is unavailable to stream for purchase or subscription on any service." It's probably in window for in-flight service only. Ha ha only serious.
- fineline 12y agoHere's something that infuriates me more. I go to canistream.it to find that a movie is available for rental on iTunes for $2.99. I then open iTunes to find that here in Australia they will charge me $4.99 Australian, which is $4.42 USD. I'd rather rent legally, but it infuriates me to see this global discriminatory price gouging.
- tjradcliffe 12y agoBut the additional cost goes to flipping the closed captioning upside-down :-) In fairness, I feel your pain. The situation in Canada is similar with all digital content, to the extent that I keep my Kindle linked to my amazon.com account because about half the books I read aren't available on amazon.ca. I've even on occasion twiddled things so I appear to be living in France so I can buy content from amazon.fr. Which is insane: I could fly to France, buy the physical book there, read it there, and come back. Or I could bring it back and pay a trivial duty/GST on it. But make it digital and suddenly it's magically impossible to sell it to me? And the Daily Show etc frequently have next-day availability in the US but show up weeks or months later in Canada. Frustrating. There is a fundamental disconnect between what we have come to expect of the 'Net (worldwide seamless connectivity) and what corporations and governments are increasingly dedicated to delivering (nationalist walled gardens.) Personally, I'm betting on the 'Net to win this particular fight, although if governments and corporations behaved with economic rationality the technological solution to cross-border accessibility--including duties--would be pretty trivial. Anyone who has worked in internationalization will tell you that simply implementing a few well-defined zone-specific additional charges is trivial compared to the wacky linguistic nonsense that has to be dealt with.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- maximumoverload 12y agoUmm, did you... did you actually read the article?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- res0nat0r 12y agoGoing to Amazon.com and purchasing a DVD is really that back breaking?
- Spooky23 12y agoIf you're into niche stuff, yes. One DVD of a early 1980s cartoon movie I was looking for sells for $75 on Amazon. The cheap titles are usually horrific quality-- almost worse than old VCR tapes.
- mindcrime 12y agoSpeaking for myself? Sometimes, yeah. I'm kinda impulsive at times. When it's 2:00am and I'm just struck by the urge to watch some random movie; if it's on Amazon Prime Video or Netflix, or if I happen to own the DVD, great. If not, I don't feel like driving somewhere to buy a DVD or waiting for Amazon to ship it to me. So yeah, I'm probably just going to torrent it.
- chc 12y agoIt's pretty inconvenient and financially unreasonable, yes.
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoAnd then what? You watch it once and keep it forever? Is there an online way to sell used DVDs?
- cbd1984 12y ago> Is there an online way to sell used DVDs? Honest question, since by implication Amazon is not an answer: eBay?
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoMaybe, maybe Craigslist. There are a few brick and mortar used DVD stores. Not many.
- DodgyEggplant 12y agoAlso consider international, same thing. Even streaming is not available in many countries. Even if you want to pay - you can't, while the pirated files are one click away.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y ago> It's almost like the executives at the studios and distributors who own the rights to these films don't realize that, if I can't easily, quickly and conveniently buy access to their film legally, I will just bittorrent the damn thing. They realize that, they just assume that most potential viewers don't know how to bittorrent (and they are very likely right about that).
- anigbrowl 12y agoIt's almost like film consumers don't realize there are transaction and frictional costs to the licensing and distribution of a film, even for streaming, and many films are not popular enough to earn back those costs in the foreseeable future. I don't think people realize how expensive it is to manufacture a film. I don't mean in terms of hiring big-name actors or in terms of striking prints and pressing DVDs, although those can be very expensive indeed. But even if you stay digital all the way it can be very expensive. Look at this distribution contract, in particular the list of deliverables on pps 19-20: http://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/migrated/2011_build/entertainment_sports/distribution_agreement_form.authcheckdam.pdf http://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/migrated/2011_bui... Every time you have a rights transfer (eg to a new licensee) there's a agreement and a bunch of deliverables along those lines, which have to be negotiated and QCed. It's not a matter of just taking what people have an uploading it to (say) Netflix's servers; if there's something wrong with the digital copy or it isn't conformant to (ever changing) standards, then dissatisfied viewers are going to blame Netflix. The absolute bare minimum to get a piece of content through a distribution pipeline is about $5000. People will put up with bad torrents of something because, well, it's free. But if they've paid for something (even though a subscription service) and it doesn't play back properly, that becomes a PR problem.
- mindcrime 12y agoAnd if the studios are OK with that arrangement, then more power to them. I'm just tired of them whining and moaning about piracy while desperately trying to cling to an outdated distribution model.
- lemonberry 12y agoThis would tug at my heartstrings if there wasn't so much fuzzy math in Hollywood keeping actors and workers from getting paid appropriately. I shed as many tears for the record companies that gleefully screwed musicians out of their royalties for years.
- anigbrowl 12y agoWell, as one of those workers, you are not doing a goddamn thing for my economic freedom when you pirate a movie. Are you gonna send me any portion of what you saved if you download something I worked on via Bittorrent instead of paying for it? Because if you're not, that argument is total fucking BS.
- philsnow 12y agomp3sparks "solved" exactly this problem by making content available at a low cost. I wonder [0] if there is a modern company in russia or china offering streaming of video content without actually negotiating licenses with the relevant parties. [0] just for the sake of speculation; I have a backlog of thousands of hours of stuff I'd like to watch on netflix, but prioritize doing other things
- avn2109 12y agoYou're missing the key fact in the piracy debate, which is that _the market value of a recorded film/music/whatever is ~zero._ It follows from the laws of supply and demand. As a thought experiment, imagine this this: tomorrow, I invent a machine that can make unlimited free copies of soybeans, and distribute those beans instantly to almost any point on the globe, also for free. And also, for the sake of argument, imagine that nearly everyone on earth has access to my soybean copier. In this case we could fairly say that the supply of soybeans is ~infinite, and you only need to read the first page of the Econ textbook to learn that the price must necessarily fall to zero, no matter what. It's a mathematical certainty for any finite demand. You can pass whatever laws you want, but so long as they're practically unenforceable, you won't change the boots-on-the-ground spot prices in the market, which will hover very close to zero. (If you doubt me, ask the Argentine currency bureau if legislating prices works well.) Obviously the price will never be exactly zero, because my machine still needs electricity to run, and the market will perhaps price in a little law-enforcement risk. But in general these costs are probably going to be negligible. And of course this has nothing to do with soybeans---the same thing will happen for corn and light sweet Saudi Crude #2 and intelligence reports about the location of Assad's WMD or any commodity you'd care to name. And digitally copyable goods are the very definition of a commodity, for while not all soybeans come off the vine created equal, a torrented .avi is a provably interchangeable item with the original. Thanks checksums. (If a film ain't on the Pirate Bay, then obviously supply != infinity, so my argument doesn't apply). This sucks for the business models of the entertainment stakeholders, but capitalism doesn't care that you disagree with the market about the price of your product. Those stakeholders took profits for a long time, playing (approximately) by the rules of the game, and now they're pissed that those same rules have invalidated their business. Well, tough luck, MPAA. The market's invisible hand is slapping you and you'll have to adapt.
- anigbrowl 12y agoThose stakeholders took profits for a long time, playing (approximately) by the rules of the game, and now they're pissed that those same rules have invalidated their business. Right, because the entertainment industry consists solely of monolithic studios that have been around since the beginning...not. Do you not realize how absurd this argument is? Imagine that you had this idea for a film and you desperately wanted to make it. Well, nobody wanted to take the risk and so you learn to produce a film. It's a feature, so if you managed to get it completed and sold within 5 years of deciding you want to make movies you are doing extremely well. So you push your Little Film That Could out into the world, but since your first feature probably doesn't have any big stars or or amazing production value it gets a minimal theatrical release and you hope to recoup your costs on DVD, foreign, and streaming sales. Not really to make any money - simply breaking even on your first film and returning the investors' input is the benchmark for industry success. Then someone comes along and tells you that the market value of your film is zero, and if you make any attempt to protect your IP you're a troglodyte who has failed to adapt, and you should feel bad about all those decades you spent fleecing the public. That's like saying startups should give their product away for free because IBM, Microsoft, and other industry incombents have often exploited consumers in the past.
- ASneakyFox 12y agoThe way I see it is if it takes me longer than 30 seconds to search-buy-start download of your media... Then your business failed. Music and video games have this figured out. Movies need to catch up.
- LBarret 12y agoAs Gabe Newell (Valve/Steam CEO) put it : "Piracy is almost always a service problem and not a pricing problem." This guy built the 21st version of a Studio. it's not perfect (the model has its own problems) but at least it is in phase with the current world.