4 ms·
Lest this thread become an echo-chamber of cheerleading for new FCC regulations, I should point out: - each such new rule on broadband providers brings closer
by gojomo 17y ago
Lest this thread become an echo-chamber of cheerleading for new FCC regulations, I should point out:
- each such new rule on broadband providers brings closer the day the FCC adds content-censorship rules to internet communications, as the FCC already applies to broadcast TV, and as other nations -- even those we don't think of as especially prone to censorship, like Australia -- have started to apply to the internet
- this closes off potential business models for upstart bandwidth and content providers. Oh, incumbents will be sure to have their preferred models interpreted as being in compliance. Disney's ESPN360 will still be able to negotiate ISP-by-ISP video access [1]; Google will still be able to pay ISPs to install its edge caches so Google's traffic is the fastest on the internet [2]. But if an upstart wanted to offer "free" broadband subsidized by sponsoring sites -- for example, a service offering 6Mbps to paying sponsor websites, 128Kbps to everyone else -- that'd be unfair discrimination, until sufficient lobbying/donations occur to get a favorable FCC ruling.
The only good thing I see in the rules is Genachowski's second rule, "broadband providers must be transparent about their network management practices." Transparency can help consumer activism and competitive choice control abuses better than any agency rulemaking.
[1] http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/06/cable-isps-see-net-neutrality-foul-in-espn-online-video-charges/ http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/06/cable-isps-see-net-ne...
[2] http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2008/12/net-neutrality-and-benefits-of-caching.html http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2008/12/net-neutralit...
- roc 17y agoWhy would network neutrality and transparency laws bring us closer to censorship laws? If you're arguing that increasing the scope of the FCC's authority leaves it open to future abuse by people we may not agree with, I think it's pretty clear that keeping the FCC out of it wasn't working either. Sad as it is, I believe I have more say in how the FCC operates than I do in AT&T and Comcast. Particularly given the realities of local telecom monopolies in the US. And the entire point of the ruling is to emphatically state that subverting standards and protocols is not a business opportunity. Ad-supported broadband that relies on manipulating the IP stream is a danger, not a victim.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoI believe I have more say in how the FCC operates than I do in AT&T and Comcast. Perhaps that's the problem. Other people, who may have very different values than you, also have say in how the FCC operates. Since we've long ago crossed a line limiting the federal government to enumerated powers, and that protecting our physical safety is now at least as important as protecting our freedoms, it's easy to imagine a regime where some majority elects to silence some minority of [porn readers | gay supporters | militia supporters | whatever unpopular minority].
- jorgeortiz85 17y agoAs someone in a thread below points out, unaccountable commercial carriers were already restricting speech on their networks: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/27/us/27verizon.html?_r=1 http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/27/us/27verizon.html?_r=1
- lupin_sansei 17y agoYou can always change carriers that restrict what you want to do though. When the government restricts something you can't change to something else.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoIn what way are the commercial carriers "unaccountable"? I can always vote with my pocketbook, as the saying goes. But when it's the FCC ensuring that one-size-fits-all, I can't do that. And in the past, when the FCC has issued regulations or fines that you disagree with, how have you made them account for their actions? What, exactly, is the process for a citizen to exert influence over specific regulatory policy? Granted that, as a parent post argued, you can exert some influence in general by way of your legislators, but how can you ever say "that was the straw that broke the camel's back, I want out."? In the case of the commercial carriers, though, restricted speech may in some specific situations be a good thing. While I disagree with it myself, should people with specific sets of values be allowed to purchase a net connection that's pre-filtered for ideas the find offensive (say, hate speech, or gay content)? That's their right, isn't it? Today in the television arena, we argue because what's broadcast goes out to everyone, and some people don't want some shows to be seen. With broadcast, they don't have the option of blocking it from their own home, so the get the FCC to block it from everyone's home. If ISPs are allowed to filter, then those ISPs can do the filtering for those with "delicate sensibilities" can have the bland world they want, and the rest of us can revel in free speech unhindered.
- billybob 17y ago<blockquote>But if an upstart wanted to offer "free" broadband subsidized by sponsoring sites -- for example, a service offering 6Mbps to paying sponsor websites, 128Kbps to everyone else -- that'd be unfair discrimination, until sufficient lobbying/donations occur to get a favorable FCC ruling.</blockquote> <p>Maybe we are missing out on that. But we're preventing Comcast from throttling the bandwidth on Youtube because they'd rather you buy the cable package. And given how few ISPs there are in this country, and how many businesses they're in, that's a pretty big danger already.</p> <blockquote>each such new rule on broadband providers brings closer the day the FCC adds content-censorship rules to internet communications</blockquote> <p>Does it really? It sounds more like the FCC is saying to the ISPs "what people do with their internet connections is none of your business." With the exception of the bit about copyright enforcement, of course. Which is a pretty big exception.</p>
- jedediah 17y agoAnd given how few ISPs there are in this country, and how many businesses they're in, that's a pretty big danger already. The solution to this should not be to limit those companies that do exist, but to foster the establishment of competitors. (Edit: markup)
- trunnell 17y agothis closes off potential business models for upstart bandwidth and content providers. That is a good thing. We want innovation on top of the network platform, and getting there is easier when we make the network a commodity.
- jrockway 17y agoCensoring the Internet is not technically possible, so I am not too worried. China tried, but it didn't do a very good job. Do you really think the FCC will do better if it decides it wants to?
- jonny_noog 17y ago... and as other nations -- even those we don't think of as especially prone to censorship, like Australia -- have started to apply to the internet You make it sound like blanket Internet censorship has already begun in Australia. This is not the case. Firstly you have to understand that the "clean feed" idea that the Australian Government has been bandying about since they were elected has more to do with political manoeuvring than any desperate desire for censorship. Certain key conservative independents are enamoured with the idea and the government generally needs their support to pass controversial legislation. The "clean feed" is wildly unpopular with Australian industry and the public. Many grass roots organisations have quickly taken up the fight against it and some of Australia's largest ISPs have even spoken out publicly[1]. The government said that industry was misinformed or some such crap, but the damage had been done. Last reports spoke of a trial going ahead involving some Australian ISPs, using a small test sized blacklist. This blacklist was subsequently leaked and just hammered further nails into the coffin of the "clean feed" when it was discovered that the blacklist contained many sites of types that were not meant to be censored[2]. The government back-peddled, saying the blacklist was not the "official" list or some such crap, but the damage had been done. There has not been a peep out of the government about this censorship business for months now since the leaking of the blacklist. I think and hope they've decided that the idea is far too controversial to pursue. If they do ever get back onto it, you can bet that they will encounter even more resistance than before. The only thing that has ensured the "clean feed" is not permanently dead are the hysterical "won't somebody please think of the children!" cries coming from those who have no understanding of the technology involved and desperately wish to impose their own social standards on the rest of us. Those with vested interests choose to exploit these sentiments and only those who have not bothered to inform themselves of the real issues find them compelling. So please don't offhandedly cite the boogy man of blanket Internet censorship in Australia to strengthen your argument. It's far from a forgone conclusion and if I had to bet, I'd say it won't come to pass. [1] http://www.zdnet.com.au/insight/communications/soa/ISP-level-content-filtering-won-t-work/0,139023754,339292158,00.htm http://www.zdnet.com.au/insight/communications/soa/ISP-level... [2] http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2009/03/19/1237054961100.html http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2009/03/19/1237054961100.html