7 ms·
Detroit fears of losing carmaking to Silicon Valley
- armenarmen 12y agoWhile other cities and regions may poach auto manufacturing jobs and plants from Detroit, the idea that any significant amount of manufacturing will be done in the SV is unlikely, based on real estate prices alone. Not to say that a large part of research and innovation cannot be done here rather than in Detroit.
- Zigurd 12y agoIf the Silicon Valley mindset wins, cars will be made by contract manufacturers, not by vertically integrated manufacturers. As others have pointed out, there is a lot of expertise in Detroit. That expertise will have to go obsolete. Self-driving "cars" could mark their obsolesce. A self-driving "car" is going to be nothing like current cars, and 100 new business models will bloom alongside their new forms.
- sliverstorm 12y agoWhy would it necessarily be contracted? All the big players in SV are currently hell-bent on vertical integration. SV is not immune to it.
- jonmrodriguez 12y agoIn the past 20-30 years, automotive engineers have invented a lot of ways to make cars much safer (e.g. crumple zones). It sounds like you're saying the designers of self-driving cars will throw all of that expertise out the window -- I assure you that they will not.
- rstupek 12y agoNothing like current cars. Except they'll have wheels, suspensions, door, bodies, propulsion systems, etc. Don't believe that a self driving car changes much beyond who is driving the car
- Zigurd 12y agoSo do buses. Busses differ from cars by all these components being significantly different. Self-driving cars will be at least as different. > Don't believe that a self driving car changes much beyond who is driving the car Except everything. Current cars have one occupant a high percentage of the time. That occupant drives the car. Change that and every design parameter changes.
- potatolicious 12y ago> "Current cars have one occupant a high percentage of the time. That occupant drives the car. Change that and every design parameter changes." I doubt this. The American car (distinct from cars in general) is not only a utilitarian tool but a cultural artifact. For huge portions of the country it is the manifestation of freedom - especially now that we've demolished all of our urban areas in favor of freeways and strip malls. Look at American culture and you'll see that personal car ownership is intrinsically associated with freedom, coming-of-age, and a huge host of cultural values that Americans take very seriously. If you think making driverless cars is going to suddenly tilt us away from single-occupant SUVs and into little self-driving pods (Minority Report style), IMO you're sorely mistaken. At best we're going to get SUVs without a steering wheel. Cars will not get substantially smaller without regulatory intervention, people will continue to own personal automobiles, and they will still have more seats than are needed 99% of the time. Driverless cars will be great, but I think you're severely overestimating their impact on car design/ownership/usage patterns. I know it's popular to imagine a society where people stopped owning cars, where cars are always right-sized for the situation, where cars show up on demand and parking lots made obsolete, etc etc, but that's a 1950s Popular Mechanics style of sci-fi pipe dream.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> I know it's popular to imagine a society where people stopped owning cars, where cars are always right-sized for the situation, where cars show up on demand and parking lots made obsolete, etc etc, but that's a 1950s Popular Mechanics style of sci-fi pipe dream. It does seem kind of plausible. Right now you need a car for everything. To get to work, to buy groceries or anything else from a store, to get to any kind of recreation, etc. Now suppose there exists an autonomous electric taxi that you can hail from your phone and use to get from one end of the city to another for around $1. You no longer need a car for anything but getting to work. Rush hour is the peak demand so the price of a ride during rush hour would be prohibitive for commuting. But the same reason the car operators can't justify buying more cars just for rush hour is the same reason commuters won't want to do it. Once commuting is the only reason you own a car you start looking for housing and employment near functioning mass transit. Which is going to bring people back into the cities. And once you do that and people give up owning a car the rest of it follows.
- greglindahl 12y agoAn amusing prediction, given that Tesla and SpaceX are both vertically-integrated manufacturers.
- simulate 12y agoTo wit, Tesla selected Nevada as the site for its first $5 billion battery factory. Alternative sites included Sacramento. http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-tesla-nevada-gigafactory-20140903-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-tesla-nevada-... It's certainly not necessary to have R&D and manufacturing in the same location.
- msandford 12y agoOn the surface I agree with you, but it's really dumb to keep design & production separated by any distance. Tesla can site battery production away from the car plant because for them batteries aren't the car. They're a part of the car but having a battery plant isn't a core competency. Musk is building one because that's the fastest way to bring prices down. Not because they have to have it in order to continue churning out the Model S. http://qz.com/32575/ge-a-pioneer-of-outsourcing-is-bringing-american-manufacturing-back-to-life/ http://qz.com/32575/ge-a-pioneer-of-outsourcing-is-bringing-...
- bdcravens 12y agoAll of Google's data centers aren't in Mountain View. Wherever said manufacturing takes place, I'm pretty sure it'll be in a location where union labor is nonexistent. (Consider that a large number of Toyota's trucks are produced in San Antonio)
- tw04 12y agoI'd rather they lose it to Silicon Valley than Shanghai or Tokyo.
- eru 12y agoWhat's wrong with the people in those places?
- dropit_sphere 12y agoNothing. Why don't you give them your salary? It would go farther there than wherever you live. Or, to be less snide: Kin selection, but with memetics rather than genetics. To be more simple: cultures whose behavior patterns perpetuate the survival of their members, survive themselves.
- glenra 12y agoI'll see your "kin selection" and raise you "comparative advantage". :-) Economic theory says we're better off letting other countries do the stuff they're better than us at doing. If Shanghai makes better cars, it helps both them and us "perpetuate survival" if we just go ahead and buy their cars and spend our effort (and our savings!) doing something else. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparative_advantage
- dropit_sphere 12y agoThis is a fair point, but I feel like whenever it's brought up, it's focused on to the exclusion of all else. (I'm not saying that's what you're doing. Frankly, this is a backlash against my misspent youth). Efficient markets mention nothing of capital, and the tendency for it to self-perpetuate. I can trade my oranges for your turnips and we both benefit, but what happens when you eat my oranges and I sell your turnips for a pear orchard? You could argue that rational actors would tend toward investment rather than consumption, and I'd point to a negative/extremely low U.S. savings rate. Humans behave like rational actors, but we aren't. Or perhaps we are, but our utility functions are incomputable, or have conflicting interests with different weights at different times of the day, etc. So, revering markets for their sensitivity, speed, and efficiency, I am nonetheless suspicious of them. Markets didn't take us to the moon, but I'm glad we went. Markets allow the smart to get wealthy, and the stupid to get poor. We should remember the latter as we celebrate the former.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoYes. It's that "Polaroid in 1998" moment for them.
- jostmey 12y agoDetroit already lost carmaking - manufacturing was outsourced outside the city long ago. Now all that is left are a bunch of offices. So yeah, they are at risk, especially so because they have failed to innovate from their offices.
- hackuser 12y ago> Detroit already lost carmaking - manufacturing was outsourced outside the city long ago. Now all that is left are a bunch of offices. So yeah, they are at risk, especially so because they have failed to innovate from their offices. Detroit may not be as dominant as it once was, but it is the center of the American car industry. There are many manufacturing plants for cars as well as for components, as well as major R&D facilities, etc. Also, there are the world headquarters of GM, Ford, Chrysler (now a Fiat division, but I think still hq'd in Detroit), major suppliers (which are Fortune 500 companies themselves, I believe), as well as the US headquarters of some foreign manufacturers.
- Htsthbjig 12y agoWow, it is "scary stuff"! They had the opportunity to help Tesla(or be Tesla), and they made everything on their power to destroy it, remember the GM first electric car. Now it is scary because it survived and it is the future, not them. This people is frightened by the future so they try to delay it as much as they can. They are worried about themselves, rent seekers trying not to lose what they have instead of caring about their customers. In business you have to care(genuinely)for your customers or you are dead. Like dinosaurs.
- D_Alex 12y agoThis part: >Now we have Silicon Valley challenging Detroit's leadership in the auto industry's most promising growth areas — autonomous cars, connected vehicles, eco-friendly powertrains made me snigger. "Detroit's leadership" - and this applies to many of the overseas subsidiaries of Detroit's companies also - has been mainly in rent-seeking behaviour for years. Since 1970's the only trend they have kept up with is the move to SUVs, missing just about everything else: downsized engines, turbocharging, diesel, reliability engineering, interior design and of course the electric car. I had a little glimpse through my job at the inside workings of one of the "Big Three" US carmakers. I got the impression that far too few people working there actually, you know, liked cars. The employees were generic dispassionate corporate managers, engineers, accountants etc. They really needed an injection of car enthusiasts.
- hackuser 12y ago> I got the impression that far too few people working there actually, you know, liked cars. These aren't startups. Are most IBM or HP employees so passionate about information technology?
- BrainInAJar 12y ago> Now it is scary because it survived and it is the future, not them. The future is civic design around people rather than cars, and that's a threat to Tesla and GM alike
- 12y ago
- hawkice 12y ago> "The future of the car is in Silicon Valley," a vice president of the San Francisco-based Bay Area Council Economic Institute boldly predicted I think I'll go ahead and challenge the boldness of making that prediction when that's your job title. He might end up being wrong, but even if, for instance, California law prohibits all automobiles or pictures of automobiles within 100 miles of SF for any use, no one would really blame him (and I think it's almost certain he won't be _that_ wrong).
- zenocon 12y agothis article is dumb, but what do you expect from usa today? i work and live in the detroit area, and have lived here most of my life (also lived in silicon valley, fwiw). there's no doubt there's some great innovation being done on the west coast, and these local guys could use a kick in the pants - a literal kick in the pants (i mean i would love to kick some of them...i worked for some of these pricks). but it takes a good deal more than some infotainment radios, and interesting r&d project to displace a major sector of the economy. it's much harder than you think. as the article already points out -- manufacturing is long gone. competition is good -- viva competition.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoPeople have been pitching electric cars in Detroit for a long time. The Big Three aborted every opportunity.
- veccalc 12y agoI wonder whether it's really about electric cars, or about how innovative Tesla has been in the overall car experience (the high tech dash, etc.). Ford and Chevy have electric cars, but they're nothing like Teslas.
- Jupe 12y agoHuh? Ever hear of the Chevy Volt?
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoYes. It was introduced in 2010, also the popular EV1 from the 1990's.
- chaostheory 12y agoI guess they forgot about Tennessee. It's really anywhere that's better than Detroit. I vaguely remember reading that $3000 of the cost or producing a car in Detroit went to the union (pensions I believe) due to agreements made in the 60's to keep salaries down. That's a huge competitive disadvantage.
- hackuser 12y ago> I vaguely remember reading that $3000 of the cost or producing a car in Detroit went to the union (pensions I believe) due to agreements made in the 60's to keep salaries down. That's a huge competitive disadvantage. It's a point that is often made, but a few considerations: 1) How much do labor costs impact overall profitability? 2) There may be advantages to paying workers well in salary and benefits. 3) You weren't addressing this aspect, but certainly there are advantages to the workers, who I have no reason to be less sympathetic with than management, and in some ways to society.
- chaostheory 12y ago> 1) How much do labor costs impact overall profitability? Well in this case a lot. Competitors were able to produce better quality cars at the same price point, since they didn't have approximately $3000 in extra overhead. > 2) There may be advantages to paying workers well in salary and benefits. There are advantages and there are good examples for this, but it depends on the industry, the culture, the location as well and a lot of other factors. > 3) You weren't addressing this aspect, but certainly there are advantages to the workers, who I have no reason to be less sympathetic with than management, and in some ways to society. Then why did Detroit fail?
- hackuser 12y ago>> 1) How much do labor costs impact overall profitability? > Well in this case a lot. Competitors were able to produce better quality cars at the same price point, since they didn't have approximately $3000 in extra overhead. Many factors determine quality and costs. Nothing you say indicates that labor was a decisive or major factor. For example, people assume much manufacturing is in China due to labor costs, but many businesses will tell you it's because of manufacturing capabilities and resources, and labor costs are a minor factor. >> 3) You weren't addressing this aspect, but certainly there are advantages to the workers, who I have no reason to be less sympathetic with than management, and in some ways to society. > Then why did Detroit fail? I don't know what exactly you mean by 'fail', or if you mean the city or the car industry. As far as the city 'failing', structural racism played a big role as did the related flight of the tax base to the suburbs, which are doing well. A race to the bottom for workers' welfare didn't help, as factories moved to non-union locations. For the industry, from what I know bad management was a major contributor, as well as poor engineering. I think labor was too.