6 ms·
Obama mandates FCC to support Network Neutrality
- mgrouchy 17y agoI'm really glad that the American government has taken some leadership in this. Hopefully other governments will follow suit and make similar mandates/suggestions to their regulatory bodies.
- phatboyslim 17y agoI despise arguing politics, religion, or money matters. That being said, I have no hesitation telling people this is the chief reason I voted for Obama in the most recent election.
- simonsarris 17y agoWhy is it you despise arguing politics? I know its a difficult topic to broach with civility, but I think that the United States would be a little better if more people openly discussed politics and policy, instead of just militantly sticking to their views (or their parent's views, and so on)
- phatboyslim 17y agoLet's just say my parents are staunch Republicans and it hasn't been easy at family dinners when politics is the subject of discussion.
- jsz0 17y agoAmericans need to learn the art of agreeing to disagree. It's a shame it always goes back to EVIL vs. GOOD in most political debates. This is exactly why partisans try to promote childish political discourse because the idea of a bunch of people with different opinions figuring out a reasonable compromise makes them obsolete.
- binarycheese 17y agoSame here. Can you imagine if we had waited around for Comcast or At&T to come out with a viable search engine? The US will be behind in technology and inovation. But now after seeing Google take the lead, they want to control the internet.
- JCThoughtscream 17y agoYou know, this might be the first time in a few years that I've appreciated an FCC policy.
- DenisM 17y agoSo you didn't like number portability very much then? Or shared access to DSL lines?
- antipaganda 17y agoNumber portability! Bastards.
- kgrin 17y agoTechnically it's not Obama, but an Obama appointee who's doing the mandating (and wrote the linked blog post): Julius Genachowski (FCC Chairman). Obviously the proverbial buck stops with Obama, and it's fair for him to be credited, but it's important to recognize the distinction.
- sachinag 17y agoJulius wouldn't have the job if Obama wasn't certain this was the outcome.
- jrwoodruff 17y agoAny speculations on if/how this affects wireless providers, particularly in regards to the recent iPhone/Google Voice/ATT hullabaloo? If you read the full speeech (http://www.openinternet.gov/read-speech.html http://www.openinternet.gov/read-speech.html) it's clear that this policy states that consumers should pick the winners and losers, not providers, and networks must allow 'non-harmful' devices to connect to the network...
- jhancock 17y agoBest news in a long time!! At first glance it would seem this policy effects ATT more than Apple. The devil is in the details. It will be very interesting to see how this pans out.
- wmf 17y agoNote that they aren't talking about regulating non-ISPs like Apple. Apple won't sell iPhones to T-Mobile? Nothing to do with net neutrality. Apple rejects (er, not accepts) Google Voice? Ditto. When it comes to 3G, this part worries me a little: "there may be benefits to innovation and investment of broadband providers offering managed services in limited circumstances. ... I believe such services can supplement -- but must not supplant -- free and open Internet access..." I can see it now: Crippled 3G? $50/month. Neutral 3G? $200/month (because "that's what it costs us to provide it").
- jrwoodruff 17y agoI noticed that too. I'm also interested in what the definition of 'non-harmful' devices is. This seems like a possible loop hole to argue for restricted devices, as in "allowing live streaming video from 3G devices will harm the network." I'm not positive, but I'd be willing to bet this is how cable providers are allowed to disable some functionality of set-top boxes...? Overall I think it's a very good thing, but it will be interesting to see how it plays out as case law defines these guidelines.
- wmf 17y agoI think the device issue can be solved with a little trickery as well. AT&T could allow you to use any unlocked GSM phone on their network but just not advertise it so that virtually no one takes advantage of it. As for cable STBs, they don't even connect to the Internet and thus are exempt from net neutrality. And if you don't like your crippled Cisco/Moto cable box you can always buy a Moxi... for $800... that will be obsolete in a year.
- sachinag 17y agoI love the example of "one provider blocking access to political content" - that was Verizon Wireless blocking text messages from Naral PCA. That moronic decision, more than anything, is why the wireless carriers are subject to NN. <nelson voice>Ha ha.</nelson voice>
- DenisM 17y agoLink for the curious http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/27/us/27verizon.html http://www.nytimes.com/2007/09/27/us/27verizon.html
- nfriedly 17y agoand if that link gives you an annoying login screen, try the coral cache http://www10.nytimes.com.nyud.net:8080/2007/09/27/us/27verizon.html?_r=5 http://www10.nytimes.com.nyud.net:8080/2007/09/27/us/27veriz...
- kirubakaran 17y ago"... and make sure that the garage, the basement, and the dorm room remain places where inventors can not only dream, but bring their ideas to life." Fuck yeah!!!
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- profgubler 17y agoNot an Obama fan, but this is a great move. Good one Mr. President.
- jhancock 17y agoHere is an interesting narrative on how the FCC used to operate: http://books.google.com/books?id=GOvTxS-txFMC&pg=PA214&lpg=PA214&dq=Colin+Powell+AOL+Time+Warner+stock&source=bl&ots=AZyC70Rkhv&sig=jgea3aBUCkxIA51N8_F5eim-abo&hl=en&ei=Adm3SpXUBuGPtgfprsDGDg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=5#v=onepage&q=Colin%20Powell%20AOL%20Time%20Warner%20stock&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=GOvTxS-txFMC&pg=PA214&#...
- gojomo 17y agoLest this thread become an echo-chamber of cheerleading for new FCC regulations, I should point out: - each such new rule on broadband providers brings closer the day the FCC adds content-censorship rules to internet communications, as the FCC already applies to broadcast TV, and as other nations -- even those we don't think of as especially prone to censorship, like Australia -- have started to apply to the internet - this closes off potential business models for upstart bandwidth and content providers. Oh, incumbents will be sure to have their preferred models interpreted as being in compliance. Disney's ESPN360 will still be able to negotiate ISP-by-ISP video access [1]; Google will still be able to pay ISPs to install its edge caches so Google's traffic is the fastest on the internet [2]. But if an upstart wanted to offer "free" broadband subsidized by sponsoring sites -- for example, a service offering 6Mbps to paying sponsor websites, 128Kbps to everyone else -- that'd be unfair discrimination, until sufficient lobbying/donations occur to get a favorable FCC ruling. The only good thing I see in the rules is Genachowski's second rule, "broadband providers must be transparent about their network management practices." Transparency can help consumer activism and competitive choice control abuses better than any agency rulemaking. [1] http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/06/cable-isps-see-net-neutrality-foul-in-espn-online-video-charges/ http://www.wired.com/epicenter/2009/06/cable-isps-see-net-ne... [2] http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2008/12/net-neutrality-and-benefits-of-caching.html http://googlepublicpolicy.blogspot.com/2008/12/net-neutralit...
- roc 17y agoWhy would network neutrality and transparency laws bring us closer to censorship laws? If you're arguing that increasing the scope of the FCC's authority leaves it open to future abuse by people we may not agree with, I think it's pretty clear that keeping the FCC out of it wasn't working either. Sad as it is, I believe I have more say in how the FCC operates than I do in AT&T and Comcast. Particularly given the realities of local telecom monopolies in the US. And the entire point of the ruling is to emphatically state that subverting standards and protocols is not a business opportunity. Ad-supported broadband that relies on manipulating the IP stream is a danger, not a victim.
- CWuestefeld 17y ago
- pmorici 17y ago"preventing Comcast from throttling the bandwidth on Youtube because they'd rather you buy the cable package." YouTube isn't a TV replacement, Hulu is. I've read that in the future Hulu might go to a model requiring you to have a cable subscription to have access to Hulu. The logic was that cable providers pay large fees to carry various channels and those fees was what was financing productions of tv. Content owns don't want to jeopardize those fees.
- jsz0 17y agoAs someone who works for an ISP I fully support the President on this. I don't feel like it's a major problem today but looking ahead to the future it seems plausible that there will be consolidation of Internet content just like so many other industries experience after a few decades of maturity. If we were to reach a point were a few powerful companies were controlling the vast majority of online content/services wouldn't it basically be a mirror of the mass media today? Fixing the problem now is the right thing to do.
- jsz0 17y agoAs someone who works for an ISP I fully support the President on this. I don't feel like it's a major problem today but looking ahead to the future it seems plausible that there will be consolidation of Internet content just like so many other industries experience after a few decades of maturity. If we were to reach a point were a few powerful companies were controlling the vast majority of online content/services wouldn't it basically be a mirror of the mass media today? Fixing the problem now is the right thing to do.
- skwiddor 17y agoThat's "President Obama".