6 ms·
Why I Am Not a Member of the American Psychological Association
- Tloewald 12y agoEducational. But I wonder how many US scientific bodies could be just as easily vivisected. E.g. I'm sure Physics, for example, is full of people with connections to defense, and we know that lots of top Mathematicians have worked for the NSA. It does remind me of a story on NPR (about a book -- http://www.amazon.com/Harvard-Unabomber-Education-American-Terrorist/dp/0393020029 http://www.amazon.com/Harvard-Unabomber-Education-American-T...) detailing how a prominent psychology professor basically tortured a group of students over a period of years, concentrating special intensity for an awkward scholarship student, Theodore Kaczynski.
- jmount 12y agoAnd the prof married one of the involved graduate students. (no: I don't think marrying a graduate students is in general wrong- but marrying one you supervised in an abusive experiment is a bit off).
- pmoriarty 12y ago"I'm sure Physics, for example, is full of people with connections to defense, and we know that lots of top Mathematicians have worked for the NSA." Not to mention the strong historical Silicon Valley links to the "defense", prison, law-enforcement and intelligence industries. One also has to ask what weight should be given to indirect cooperation with and enablement of said industries. If one is not working for a defense contractor, but a supplier of said contractor, or if one even takes money from or in any way benefits from these contractors or contractors of contractors, what's your culpability? Where do you draw the line? I am also reminded of "IBM and the Holocaust",[1] which is deserving of its own HN article. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust
- ealloc 12y agoInteresting, I did not know about this. Here are the NPR story and related Atlantic article by the author of the book: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2000/06/harvard-and-the-making-of-the-unabomber/378239/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2000/06/harvard-... http://download.npr.org/real.npr.na-central/npr/wesat/2000/06/20000617_wesat_12.rm http://download.npr.org/real.npr.na-central/npr/wesat/2000/0...
- api 12y agoThat was a bit of a skeptical thought for me too. In the 20th century the military industrial complex was the only meal ticket in town for a lot of things. In many ways our new VC-finance-disruptive-industrial complex, while evil in some of its own ways, is a moral improvement. while it might spin out dickish ventures like über, as far as I know it has yet to firebomb any villages. I do agree with the author about complicity in torture and am glad a few have stood up to that.
- dredmorbius 12y agoFirst, the history of the practice of psychology, and the ills it's transacted against humanity, is exceptionally telling. The nugget though is buried in the tail of the piece: Craig Chalquist, PhD is a member of Psychologists for Social Responsibility. That is: there is an alternate organization. More on PsySR here: http://psysr.org/ http://psysr.org/ That said, the more the public knows about the list of terribles here, and Edward Bernays in particular, the better. I also very strongly recommend reading the works of Jerry Mander, an economics-trained advertising executive who paired up with Sierra Club organizer (and president) David Brower to create some of the first environmental advertising and outreach campaigns, co-founded Friends of the Earth (backed by ARCO CEO Robert O Anderson, ponder that), and has written a couple of highly worthwhile books, Four Arguments for the Elimination of Television and The Capitalism Papers. http://www.powells.com/biblio/2-9780688082741-13 http://www.powells.com/biblio/2-9780688082741-13 http://www.powells.com/biblio/17-9781619021587-0 http://www.powells.com/biblio/17-9781619021587-0
- SoftwareMaven 12y agoAfter spending the last couple of years really diving deep into nutrition science[1] to save my own health, I've come to believe the almost every three- or four-letter organization has little to do with its stated purpose and much more to do with feeding itself and ensuring its own propagation, no matter how it has to do it (see, for instance, the American Association of Nutritionists and Dietetics' (AAND) relationship with CocaCola and PepsiCo or the American Diabetes Association's (ADA) relationship with AstraZeneca, Eli Lilly, and Janssen Pharmaceuticals)[2]. Regulatory capture, as mentioned in TFA, is a popular method to protect the association. In a previous age, these organizations played an important role in disseminating curated information to its members, with the assumption that it was curated for maximum benefit to those who would ultimately be treated. Today, the Internet has shown that the curation may not be as completely benevolent as we would have hoped as corporate interests subtly and not-so-subtley influence what gets propagated. Unfortunately, it is difficult, if not impossible, to "fix" a heavily entrenched bureaucracy. Instead, I think the best we can hope for it to make them inconsequential. Fortunately, we now have the ability to do this, because we now have the raw information available with just a few clicks. In effect, the wisdom of crowds can overcome the edicts of the anointed[3]. The author of this article is taking a stand, saying that the TLA[4] associated with his field does not represent psychology as he sees it. I think this is a wonderful step, and I would trust him more as a psychologist as a result[5]. As more professionals eschew their self-serving organizations, health care will get better, because those that step away inevitably do so recognizing they have to become the curators of their own knowledge. So when you hear a health care provider is not a member of an organization you would expect them to be, instead of immediately considering it a black mark on their score card, take some time to learn why. You may find they are a better provider for it. 1. Sometimes, it is really hard to use the word nutrition and science together. There is some, but most of it is complete garbage compiled at incredible cost. 2. Sponsorship alone is not a problem, but it's a very dangerous line to walk. Sponsorship that conflicts with the core values of your organization is always a problem. Ask yourself: how strongly would the ADA be pushing for a true cure for diabetes, knowing 1) it would stop having a reason to exist and 2) its major sponsors would take a massive hit in profits? Is it surprising "managing" is the new word for how we treat illnesses? 3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzPnnDDCIjo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KzPnnDDCIjo 4. "Three letter acronym" 5. Stepping away is not the only option. There is, for example, a strong group (Dietitians for Professional Integrity) working to change the AAND internally. I hope they succeed. http://integritydietitians.org/ http://integritydietitians.org/
- tokenadult 12y agoAs other comments have mentioned, if you criticize an organization by choosing bad actors who are members of that organization to criticize the whole organization, few organizations come out looking good. On my part, I'd like to hear more discussion of the Association for Psychological Science (APS),[1] an organization formed as a conscious effort to introduce more sound science into the practice of psychology. The articled submitted here is from 2013 (excerpted from a 2013 publication, but posted on a website with a 2010 copyright notice). He tries to sum up the history of a large organization more than a century old with a few anecdotes. I wonder how the author, whose website[2] has links to some more recent writings, prioritizes his critique of the American Psychological Association now. (And by the way, what do you fellow participants here on Hacker News think of the author's website, from which the kind submission here was linked?) [1] http://www.psychologicalscience.org/ http://www.psychologicalscience.org/ [2] http://www.chalquist.com/ http://www.chalquist.com/
- pmoriarty 12y ago"if you criticize an organization by choosing bad actors who are members of that organization to criticize the whole organization, few organizations come out looking good" To be fair, the article's author did not simply choose a few random rank-and-file members of the APA. By my count, he provided as evidence the words and deeds six APA Presidents: John Watson D. O. Hebb Martin Seligman Joseph Matarazzo Patrick DeLeon Ronald Levant
- lutusp 12y ago> As other comments have mentioned, if you criticize an organization by choosing bad actors who are members of that organization to criticize the whole organization, few organizations come out looking good. Yes, that's certainly true. But there's one important difference between the APA and scientific organizations -- scientific organizations can be shamed into following the evidence. In psychology, if there's no theory to suit your fancy, you can invent one and gain a following, and your theory doesn't have to pass a reality test or forge a consensus -- indeed, psychology is overflowing with theories in open conflict. Here's an example: those who have very narrow personal focus and/or a lack of interest in relationships, might be described as having (a) Asperger Syndrome, or (b) Grit. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grit_(personality_trait) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grit_(personality_trait) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asperger_syndrome http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asperger_syndrome For those who claim the described symptoms prove Asperger's, there has been much recent controversial activity asserting that it's a condition on the Autism spectrum. For those who claim the symptoms prove a person possesses Grit, there are now movements to empower and offer therapy to intensify this trait. But there's no effort to compare these views either to each other or to reality. The described symptoms might represent a treatable mental illness, as the Asperger's advocates assert -- no one knows. They might represent a natural gift, one possessed by many successful people, and might even represent a positive evolutionary adaptation to a changing environment. No one can persuasively argue that view either, for lack of solid evidence, for lack of anything resembling science. Bill Gates probably possesses Grit, and certainly has an Asperger's diagnosis -- assigned by someone who never interviewed him. Albert Einstein, the same. Thomas Jefferson. Many others -- all members of both these opposing schools of thought. In physics, Lee Smolin can criticize string theory (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trouble_with_Physics http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Trouble_with_Physics) for (in effect) not really being a theory on the ground that it's untestable, and his views are widely read by people who don't see this as a challenge to physics -- quite the opposite. In psychology, critics have a much more difficult time because nothing is either demonstrably true or false. This is why two sequential chairs of the NIMH (Steve Hyman and Thomas Insel) have criticized their own profession's disregard for science, only to be (so far) shouted down by vested interests within the field. The defense offered by the field's defenders can be concisely summarized -- no one really knows how science is defined, therefore one cannot persuasively describe something as unscientific. Shockingly, this is a view widely held among mental health workers. But this isn't a tenable view among physicists and other workers in scientific fields, who find that science's definition is very clear.