3 ms·
Confession: I watched with interest until he added the reset button. At this point, he silently starts making classic textual changes. A non-obvious but quite b
by javajosh 12y ago
Confession: I watched with interest until he added the reset button. At this point, he silently starts making classic textual changes. A non-obvious but quite bad thing is that it required simultaneous multiple edits in disparate parts of the file - each of which required expert knowledge of the libraries, the language, and the file itself. This is why visual programming environments suck - because in the end, you still have to know exactly what to do, and you have to do it simultaneously, without feedback. These kinds of things will continue to fail until you can add a reset button incrementally and visually.
- vegggdor 12y agoInstead of text editing, sliders and knobs to manipulate values work well. Music lends itself well to graphic interfaces, because of it's sequential nature, you don't usually work with text or conditionals. Especially for the _feedback_ anything visual works a treat though. With expert systems you work blind half the time, because of the size, that you can't get all into scope. So you simplify and make abstractions, but it's complicated to map multidimensional decision space onto 2d. Therefore a good visual programming environment would have to be a complicated system, that, well, you'd have to learn to navigate and memorize. Don't know what you mean, how to _incrementally_ add or reset a button, like Undo/Redo?
- arloft 12y agoFirst reply, be gentle. I think the problem you're describing is one that results when an expert tries to teach / design something to beginners and they forget how to present the information in an approachable manner. Sure, with code it _seems_ like "duh of course you need to _know_ the libraries to use a visual editor!" but that goes against the basic concept of having a visual styled IDE. I'm a UX / visual design guy very interested in learning to program, have been for several years. But it's just not approachable beyond stuff like CodeAcademy, as it quickly becomes a labyrinth of documentation, cryptic instructions, and unclear ways to approach building a worthwhile program. I digress, as that's not my point. Point is, many visual editors, even Quartz Composer, fail on the same area; they aren't approachable beyond tinkering with the switches and buttons. UX isn't even a passing thought on these tools. I would love to participate in building one of these tools and learning X language in the process. Until a visual designer is involved, these tools will continue being relegated to tiny niches unless a visionary developer comes along (-and actually completes the thing, as was mentioned above about the LightTable Chris guy). I'm not saying design is _the_ answer, but all the best tools have been co-created with a visual/ mechanical/ industrial/ designer of some kind.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoMy wife is a visual designer (on feature phones, weirdly enough), she isn't very helpful with my own programming experiments [1] :) Actually, we need a visual designer who is also versed in programmer experience (rather than end-user experience) design, and I haven't found anybody like that yet. A UX designer is not some magical person who can magically do design in any domain; even HCI researchers are not a panacea [2]. Also, designs, even by seasoned designers well versed in the domain they are working in, are never perfect, there are always trade offs to be made. Nothing is ever finished, we only get closer to our goals that are infinitely away. [1] http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/liveprogramming/typography.aspx http://research.microsoft.com/en-us/projects/liveprogramming... [2] http://faculty.washington.edu/ajko/talks/CHI2006Barista.pdf http://faculty.washington.edu/ajko/talks/CHI2006Barista.pdf
- mkremins 12y agoThis is spot on. In programming communities, design is frequently dismissed as an "implementation detail" or part of "making it look good" (i.e. marketing). This is a distinct and recurring cultural blind spot – more conceptually interesting programming tools than I can count have been torpedoed by a lack of attention to visual/UI/UX/HCI design. Design is absolutely critical when it comes to helping people understand complex systems. Well-designed tools work with the human brain to mitigate cognitive load, allowing the user to focus on making stuff happen rather than on juggling handfuls of information. Few programming tools, experimental or mainstream, fit this description; even fewer have anything like it in mind. Successful efforts to make programming less opaque and more accessible will necessarily involve massive leaps forward in design. I'm glad to see design beginning to make some inroads into programming culture, but we've got a long way to go yet considering how frequently the Unix CLI is still held up as the state of the art.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoYou do know there is a whole field called programming language design right? Not everyone in the PL field is doing theory or chasing better performance, some of us actually focus on design (and I'm not the only one, and design has been studied and practiced since at least the 70s). Visual design is where we are especially weak, but we have our PX down (like UX, but User becomes Programmer).
- swartkrans 12y agoRight, this is just regular code, drawn in boxes. This is not visual programming.