7 ms·
Ex-Employees Say Home Depot Left Data Vulnerable
- rbc 12y agoIt does sound like a Home Depot's management may have failed to practice due care in protecting their customers credit card data. That will be perceived as a failure of corporate governance and expose the company to charges of negligence. I'm surprised they let it go on this long. It seems like there will be a material effect on the companies operations now...
- wfjackson 12y agoHere's an article with more details. http://www.dailytech.com/Appalling+Negligence+DecadeOld+Windows+XPe+Holes+Led+to+Home+Depot+Hack/article36517.htm http://www.dailytech.com/Appalling+Negligence+DecadeOld+Wind... Looks like they were still using Windows XP embedded instead of moving to Windows 7 embedded.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- withinrafael 12y agoHeads up: Windows XP != Windows XP Embedded. Extended support for XPE has not ended yet. http://support.microsoft.com/lifecycle/search/default.aspx?alpha=Windows+XP+embedded&Filter=FilterNO http://support.microsoft.com/lifecycle/search/default.aspx?a...
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoOne thing I haven't seen the popular media take Home Depot to task on is: Why didn't they review their security after the Target breach? The Target thing was announced in December last year. Home Depot had between then and April-May to do a full review and see if they too were vulnerable. Not only did they fail to do that, but they failed to find this issue for 5 additional months(!). I liken it to being a miner, watching the canary die, and then continue to work. Then you're shocked shocked that there was poisonous gas in the mine when you "found out" hours later. I just looked up "Gross negligence" (per corporate law) and this seems to wholly fit. This is almost textbook Gross negligence but yet not a single prosecutor in the US has gone after Home Depot, why is that? In fact it seems like Home Depot will walk away from this almost cost-free, no fines, no prosecution, no significant costs (the "free monitoring" is stupidly inexpensive, plus nobody actually utilises it), and only minor negative PR. Maybe states should just fine companies 10c for every Credit or Debit Card number lost. That's a 5.6 mil fine for Home Depot, maybe then they'd take it more seriously.
- ghshephard 12y agore: "One thing I haven't seen the popular media take Home Depot to task on is: Why didn't they review their security after the Target breach?" From the article: "After the Target theft, Home Depot’s chief executive, Frank Blake, assembled a team to determine how to protect the company’s network from a similar attack, said one person briefed on the project. In January, Home Depot brought experts in from Voltage Security, a data security company in California, these people said. By April, the company started introducing in some of its stores enhanced encryption that scrambled payment information the moment a card was swiped."
- pbhjpbhj 12y ago10¢? $20 would be more like it paid to the government who would then, on request provide $15 as compensation to pay for the postage and time arranging your new payment card. Even then it's just a token of the costs that they've caused to be incurred. So, $1 billion fine, do you think they'd do it again? Executives from other companies holding that many card details might actually think it was worth paying a few $100k to get their own systems in order then. IMO if a company can still afford to pay profits to shareholders after making these sorts of errors then you're not hurting them enough.
- wdr1 12y ago> One thing I haven't seen the popular media take Home Depot to task on is: Why didn't they review their security after the Target breach? ? It's right there in the article: "After the Target theft, Home Depot’s chief executive, Frank Blake, assembled a team to determine how to protect the company’s network from a similar attack, said one person briefed on the project. In January, Home Depot brought experts in from Voltage Security, a data security company in California, these people said. By April, the company started introducing in some of its stores enhanced encryption that scrambled payment information the moment a card was swiped. "But criminals were already deep in Home Depot’s systems. By the time the company learned on Sept. 2 from banks and law enforcement that it had been breached, hackers had been stealing millions of customers’ card information, unnoticed for months. The rollout of the company’s new encryption was not completed until last week."
- JPKab 12y ago
- georgeoliver 12y agoSo what's the chance one number out of the 50+ million will be used fraudulently? 1%? 10%?
- ams6110 12y agoI've already received notice from Discover that they are sending me a new card. They didn't mention Home Depot but did say that my current card had the potential to be used fraudulently. If the card companies can issue new cards quickly enough they can contain the damage. 50 million is a lot though.
- johnny5 12y agoWhat I don't understand about these massive breaches is that once a pattern has been established all the cards get flagged... right? Which greatly increases the likelihood of subsequent transactions being flagged on the spot, which makes the risk of being caught much greater. Wouldn't the hackers and their clients be better served by much smaller batches of credit cards that aren't clearly from the same breach?
- meowface 12y agoYou're right, but they do it in a sneaky way to try and avoid that. The Russian/Ukrainian rings that hit Target and Home Depot (and various other companies) gathered the cards in secret over many months, while not actually using or selling any of them. Then once they feel like they've gathered enough cards to compensate them for their time, or if they feel like they'll lose access or get caught in the near future, they dump them in bulk batches. Generally these breaches, and the company that was breached, get discovered after the very first dump batch. The banks who issue the credit cards can often figure out what store was breached if they're given a random sample of 1000 or so credit cards; they just correlate the cardholder locations with the stores in the area, and see what store has the most overlap. Often bank security personnel are some of the first to buy the credit card dumps. In fact, this is how Home Depot and Target both found out they were even breached at all: the banks ran their analytics on the dumps and informed them. After the first batch is released, the subsequent batches are usually less likely to work, but sometimes the banks will just issue notices saying "you recently shopped at Home Depot, please check your account statement" instead of blanket disabling all the cards. In those cases, staggering the dumps in batches increases the overall fraud gain. You can learn more about these kinds of tactics on Brian Krebs' blog: http://krebsonsecurity.com/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/
- rdl 12y agoProbably the most strategic way to use 50mm credit cards would be to use them destructively, rather than just for direct gain. (All of this is illegal as well as immoral, but just presented so people can develop countermeasures) Know that using the credit cards will cause the accounts to get frozen, which will cause decreased purchasing; it will also scare people away from those stores, and possibly from purchasing in general. A nation state could do this for disruption directly; Russia could filter the 50mm cards to find cards belonging to US people (or just assume home depot = usa), and intentionally cause transactions requiring replacement. Do this on the last week before xmas, or black friday, or some other strategic time. A criminal organization could use the breach to manipulate the stock market -- either directly (shares in the breached company tank, although this doesn't happen to a very large extent), or by blocking cards used at one merchant in particular, raise the sales of a competitor indirectly. There's also straight extortion -- we'll sell these back to you and go away IFF you pay us.
- Pxtl 12y agoSo how did the malware get onto these machines in the first place? Why is a POS system running unexpected binaries?
- Spooky23 12y agoLike most companies, client support is a real shitshow, with the most junior employees and fewest resources.
- xnull2guest 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victim_blaming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victim_blaming Seriously. Defending cyber infrastructure is hard. Incredibly hard. If you only play defense you lose. Always. 100% of the time. Nuclear facilities and critical infrastructure get hacked when they aren't even connected to the broader internet. Our software stacks are built insecure from the ground up. And what's the threat model you want to Home Depot to protect you against? Hackers coming in directly from the internet? Hackers coming in from a contractor (like Target)? Hackers breaching their corporate datacenters? Attackers that gain access to the production line? Attackers that return goods after they've been infected? Attackers that phish for access to employees or with PDF malware as job applications? Leaving infected CDs, harddrives, and USB sticks near the company HQ of the business they buy their point of sales device from? Creating rouge access points or using femto cells to gain access to company devices? Hacking into home devices of employees? Attackers planting backdoors into the hardware at the manufacturing level? Attackers guessing weak passwords that employees configured? From these attacks applied to vendors and partners? From attackers that compromise tools used by employees hosted on C|NET and others (like sysinternals)? There's a million ways in. Point of sales devices are just one way adversaries could collect this data. Security researchers have been crying that the internet has no clothes for decades. The internet is a wild west without vigilantes. It's been designed weak from the start. Adversarial-tolerant design costs far, far more than fault-tolerant design does. Wall Street was hacked. The Department of Defense is routinely hacked. The _NSA_ has been hacked. This isn't Home Depot's fault. Everyone gets hacked. Everyone.
- bobzimuta 12y agoPlease don't bring social justice theory into a factual discussion of a company's missteps and negligence that resulted in a serious breach of its systems.
- xnull2guest 12y agoBecause it's not relevant? I argue it is. There's no way Home Depot could have prevented this. If they took every step suggested by every article and every comment in this 'factual discussion' they would have been owned another way. And it would have received a tirade of similar articles and similar comments about what it should have done to protect its data another way. Hindsight and backwards engineering security suggestions is easy. But it isn't productive to the overall posture of cyber security. I guess it depends on what scope of the discussion you find interesting. The root or the symptom.
- Istof 12y agoSince you can't prove a negative; Any proof that Home Depot benefited from this?
- jessaustin 12y ago...more than a dozen systems handling customer information were not assessed and were off limits to much of the security staff. This sort of decision is made at an executive level. There must have been multiple reports that included a record of the decision. PCI is a joke.
- lgleason 12y agoWe have two issues here which are both bad. One, big corporates that don't take the appropriate steps because of incompetence, corporate inertia and a lack of consequences. People who say something are not taken seriously and the good ones leave. The other, has to do with startups, who are dealing with sensitive information, who do not take the appropriate steps to secure it because they would rather win the VC lottery. Putting customers data at risk is ok if they can get their payday. I have personally observed two startups that have done this. One was a startup working in the identity management and protection space logging sensitive information in plain text on their servers and bringing them down to unsecured local dev boxes for debugging. When I asked them about it they said they knew what they were doing was wrong but didn't feel like it was a big deal. From their point of view they didn't think they were a target. Of course they also didn't feel that it was worth the cost. The other was a banking startup that was storing Social Security Numbers and account details that would allow direct access to bank accounts on Heroku PostgreSql databases. Once again when I brought it to their attention, making the product look good for the next round of funding was more important than a customer having their bank account cleared out or having their identity stolen. Incidentally many of the developers for this banking application had come from a large established Accounting company and didn't seen anything wrong with what they were doing. What this really comes down to are ethics. Is it ethical to cut a corner and save money on development if it means that a data breach of our system could lead to possibly significant financial consequences to our customers? I personally try to adhere to the ACM code of ethics http://www.acm.org/about/code-of-ethics http://www.acm.org/about/code-of-ethics . But unlike the field of medicine where even the worst doctor has been vetted by a committee of professionals we have no bodies that evaluate the character of people in our field nor a oath like the Hippocratic oath that is an automatic piece of the training. If more engineers were willing to say no and even quit over poor security practices I'll bet you security would be taken more seriously.
- morgante 12y ago> We have two issues here which are both bad. Sorry, where does anything in this article mention startups?
- norespectei388 12y ago0. Did Govt BUY or contract with the COMPANY? yes or no 1. Can employees SUE FOR BIG MONIES under qui tam law? 2. IS IT EASY TO FIND A LAWYER and GOVT agency and 'partners' who DO MOST OF THE WORK (other whisleblowers are RICH) in helping the GOVT to sue the COMPANY? yes or no 3. got an entire group? ex-employees? do not plan on working for COMPANY AGAIN? 4. Employee in I.T., computers, security, etc DONT GET NO RESPECT? 5. Employees could be WHISTLEBLOWERS and when the GOVT and you and partners WIN, then the 99% ninety nine percent win? Yes, I a worker. Yes, I paid taxes. Yes, COMPANY got all sorts of tax loopholes, Management got golf club memberships and perks and benefits. Yes, see books by David Cay Johnston about tax loopholes and 'structures.'
- ROFISH 12y agoThings like this just means we should really bring out something that doesn't expose the magic 16 digits of "charge me anything" to the world. Tokenization schemes like Apple Pay go a long way to securing the general public in an easy to use way.
- untilHellbanned 12y agoBitcoin and cryptocurrencies should really be capitalizing on the nightmare PR of all these credit card thefts at major retailers. This is way worse than the transaction fee argument.
- mullingitover 12y agoWhoahahaha no, this does not make bitcoin seem more appealing. At least with credit card breaches nobody loses real money permanently.
- ufmace 12y agoAnd how would they go about capitalizing on the bad PR, considering that Bitcoin security is far, far worse than even the sloppiest credit card system? Virtually every business dealing in Bitcoin has been hacked, and this basically always results in the full balance of their bitcoins being stolen and the attacker getting away with it clean. The credit card system has its issues, but even these massive thefts of numbers generally lead to no financial losses for customers and modest losses for banks and retailers, and the attackers often do get tracked and caught. The biggest complaint on here is that the losses are not high enough to convince these companies to pay serious attention to security.
- enraged_camel 12y agoThings like this will continue to happen as long as the government insists on slapping companies on the wrist with small fines, which most of the time is a tiny portion of their annual profits. My solution: hold the executive management directly liable for all security breaches that compromise customer data. Send a few of them to jail and you will suddenly see other companies treat information security with the seriousness it deserves. (Most corporate CEOs make millions of dollars a year on top of an untold number of perks. It's time for them to start earning it.)
- ufmace 12y agoIn this particular case, what is the justification for the Government fining them? Did the customers lose something that they were not adequately compensated for by existing system? Exactly who would we be protecting? To me, this sounds like a matter to be handled between the banks, card processors, and Home Depot.
- asdfologist 12y ago"They say many companies do not even know they have been breached." This is the scariest fact of the whole article. We hear about Sony, Target, Home Depot, etc. on the news, but how many others are out there that we don't know about? Dozens? Hundreds?