7 ms·
Scotland rejects independence
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoAn English parliament based in say Manchester could be interesting, I wonder if they'll go for modern representative democracy or try to just expand the power of the current dysfunctional first past the post system? "But Michael Gove, the chief whip, made clear that greater protections would have to be offered to protect the interest of English, Welsh and Northern Irish MPs” Notice he says its the MPs interests that need protecyes!, not who they represent.
- Toenex 12y agoGiven this is a Hacker forum lets go one step further and ask "Does a modern society need a centralised seat of government at all?"
- hackerboos 12y agoExactly - powers should be devolved to councils. Not an English parliament.
- CatsoCatsoCatso 12y agoIf I trusted my council I would back this idea, but they have proved themselves to be about nothing but greed. The general feeling I get from speaking to people is that councils are not well liked at all and have a reputation for being rude, money-focused and arrogant.
- icebraining 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeF_o1Ss1NQ&t=2m21s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeF_o1Ss1NQ&t=2m21s
- zimpenfish 12y agoYeah, if they gave Greenwich Council any more power, I'd be moving out of the borough quick-damn-smart. They're bad enough with the limited powers they have.
- icebraining 12y agoHacker's Reform Bill? :)
- mike_hearn 12y agoWhy be so unambitious? We have the technology these days to make every change in the law a referendum, with a form of automated delegation in place to ensure people can focus only on the areas that matter to them or they have expertise in. The tricky part, technologically, is finding a design that preserves all the qualities you might want in a voting system whilst still having the new features. For example being able to delegate your vote by topic in a treelike structure is attractive, but this is somehow opposed to the notion of a secret ballot.
- jiggy2011 12y agoHow do you decide who has expertise in an area? That seems to be very open to gerrymandering.
- mike_hearn 12y agoPeople themselves do. E.g. I might delegate my vote on financial matters to my accountant, foreign policy to a friend of mine I trust on the matter, rural affairs to the politician nominated by some political party I trust as an expert, and keep votes on issues affecting the tech sector to myself.
- jiggy2011 12y agoHow do you stop people from using their delegated votes in their own self interest? I would think that a proposition for providing tax breaks to programmers would be popular amongst people on HN for example. Is there transparency so that others can see how I voted? If so , how do you prevent people from being bribed or intimidated into voting a certain way? Can votes be re-delegated? Is this process transparent? For example if I collect a large number of "tech" votes , what is to stop me from selling them all to Microsoft?
- mike_hearn 12y agoDelegated voting is just a way to vote on decisions, it doesn't say how those decisions get put in front of the system itself. E.g. they could still be made by politicians or a Swiss-style system in which a number of signatures must be gathered. I'd always imagined that the way you voted is visible only to your delegees. Thus buying votes at scale doesn't work because to verify someone voted the way they said they would, you need another voter to delegate to them. You gain visibility into one vote but it costs you one vote, so there's no benefit to be had by attempting to purchase. Of course you can try and purchase the votes of trusted figures to whom many people have delegated their vote, but this is no different to the existing system where you could try and bribe MPs.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoCould probably replace most of it with a bug/feature tracker on a public block chain.
- dang 12y agoAlthough most stories about politics are off-topic for HN, this one seems like the exception that proves the "most". Let's hold off flagging it unless the thread goes haywire.
- arethuza 12y agoI wrote this earlier but the discussion I posted it to originally is dead: As a Scot who voted "Yes" I must admit I am disappointed with this result - but also not in the least surprised, this is pretty consistent with the polls. However, thinking about it a bit more (even if it is 6am) - I'm actually pretty pleased with both the turnout and that 45% of people voted "Yes" - a few years ago that would have seemed crazy. In some ways this reminds me of the devolution referendum of 1979 - while the result then was also a "No" it raised the topic as a realistic alternative so when there was another devolution referendum a generation later it passed easily so now we do have an independent Scottish Government which has a fair amount of power within Scotland (although no powers over things like foreign affairs and defence). I suspect that, just as in '79, the UK is in for a lot of political upheaval over the next decade and I suspect that now that independence has been introduced as something to be seriously considered that in a generation or so it might also look more sensible than it did at first. My immediate concern is that I hope that everyone can put the differences introduced by the campaign behind them.
- hackerboos 12y agoI read in The Economist that the No vote was bolstered by Scottish pensioners who fear for their retirement funds. It's inevitable that the referendum will occur again (probably under a Tory majority government) and with those said pensioners not around; you'll get the result you wanted.
- linker3000 12y agoPensioners are not a finite resource.
- UVB-76 12y agoPensioners with considerable state pensions are unfortunately a dying breed.
- mike_hearn 12y agoEr, I know life expectancy in Scotland isn't great but you realise the dead pensioners will be replaced by new ones, right?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- trhway 12y agoalmost magic how far some western countries have advanced - in most of the world the "separatist" is pretty much equivalent of "terrorist" and a valid reason to send tanks in while in UK they just let the vote happen (even though it would be a high treason just a couple hundred years ago there too).
- arethuza 12y agoThe UK is unusual though - it is a "Union" with Scotland maintaining a lot of separate institutions that predate the union in 1707: notably the legal and education systems which are often completely different from those in the rUK. For the last while we've even had our own government here in Edinburgh. So we were already a sort of a "country within a country" anyway.
- hessenwolf 12y agoIs rUK pronounced ruck or are-you-kay?
- CatsoCatsoCatso 12y agoI've always read it as ruck, or just read Rump-UK in my head.
- user24 12y agoI think it was a typo. I've never heard of the term before. edit: Oh, it seems it's a Scottish term for Rest-of-UK. TIL.
- slamontales 12y agoYou must not be familiar with the recent history of Northern Ireland - widespread gerrymandering, suppression of civil rights, massacres of civilians by unaccountable armed forces of the state, illegal torture/detention camps for political detainees etc. A lot has changed but all of that is the very recent living memory of the UK.
- 12y ago
- allegory 12y agoI'm glad, for one obscure reason. The few people I know in Scotland became terribly hostile over the last week. I mean really anti-English. I'm talking non-patriotic professional people I've known for 20 years. It made me wonder what purpose further dividing of the world serves other than to introduce nationalism and protect primitive identities promoted by the politicians and media. We're all humans. Do we need another line between groups of us?
- arethuza 12y ago"Do we need another line between groups of us?" Actually, one of the reasons I voted "Yes" is because I'm in favour of the EU - I'd far rather have been part of an independent Scotland that wanted to be part of the EU (even if there might have been a bit of a fuss about getting back in) rather than a part of the UK that seems destined to leave.
- allegory 12y agoAgree with you there, but I'm taking a different approach. If the UK leaves the EU, I'll move into the EU. I doubt the UK will leave the EU though as most of it is manipulation and posturing.
- malka 12y agoUS still needs their lapdog in the EU.
- UVB-76 12y agoThe UK will not leave the EU any time soon.
- mike_hearn 12y agoI suspect "bit of fuss" would have been an understatement. Thankfully it's an issue that will be explored some other day, in some other part of the world. I don't think you should see UK exit from the EU as a dead cert. That debate has hardly even begun. Of course right now it's being driven by the Euroskeptics because a referendum date hasn't even been set and they're the ones agitating for it. But as this referendum shows, sentiment can change a lot in the runup to a vote. There are lots of people who do not want to see the UK leave the EU, although I guess most of them would be in favour of a rebalancing of powers. Those people will presumably/hopefully learn lessons from the iScotland campaign and base the "no to leaving" campaign on positivity rather than simply listing all the problems the UK would face on its own. If the no campaign can seize the positive moral ground AND it has lots of economic arguments on its side, it should force the yes side into simply being negative about the EU and well, Salmond has shown everyone the power of positivity (even over reason).
- gabemart 12y ago> For the no campaign there was relief: a spate of > authoritative polls in the final days of the campaign had > said the vote was on a knife edge, bringing Yes Scotland > within touching distance of victory after a dramatic surge > in support. Did anyone actually believe the odds were close? I've been following the odds at the major betting exchanges for the last few weeks. I am not aware of any large exchange or bookmaker offering decimal odds lower than 3.00 at any point during that period. For the last few days it's typically been between 3.50 and 4.50. If anyone actually believed that the outcome of the referendum was "on a knife edge", they should have placed some very large bets on a "Yes" outcome.
- tinyman 12y agoI agree, though as in a real market, the betting odds are quite sentiment driven. Maybe more so. Many more people were betting "yes" than "no" (see oddschecker). This tended to skew the market towards a higher "yes" probability. At least one high-street bookie said the same thing. They said that they had their books setup effectively gave them a bet on "no". This means the betting markets were optimistic on "yes". "Yes" was never that likely.
- sytelus 12y agoWhat are these "major betting exchanges"? People often refer them but I've no clue where they go to find them. Google/Bing is turning up funny links as well.
- gabemart 12y agoBetfair is probably the best known in the UK.
- learnstats2 12y agoI will say the same as the other commenter, but the opposite: It was suggested that very large bets were placed on No, skewing the odds, perhaps because City of London workers had significant sentiment for No.
- blackRust 12y agoWhat is amazing about the Yes campaign is the odds they were up against: all but one newspaper were against independence, the one for is a weekly paper. We have seen a strong and undeniable media bias. Even though the majority is for No, ~1.6m voted for radical change. This was not a "nationalist" movement. It was a movement of ideas (the breadth of the campaign has been astounding). A majority of the ~2m that voted No did not vote for the status quo: they just thought the risks too great.
- UVB-76 12y ago> We have seen a strong and undeniable media bias On the contrary, the media insisted for weeks the referendum was "too close to call", citing endless polls that generally favored the 'no' vote, but were close to 50-50. Obviously people vote more conservatively when it matters. Meanwhile, the bookmakers, who actually had skin in the game, knew a 'yes' vote was unlikely, and reflected that in their odds.
- treerock 12y agoNot sure how that is to the contrary? Press may report that it's too close to call to motivated No voters to get out and vote. (I don't know either way, not being paying much attention to the press, though BBC Scotland has seemed quite balanced)
- jcbrand 12y agoSaying the referendum is "too close to call" is not the same as being even-handed (i.e. not having a bias). They were biased because they consistently took a negative stance towards the potential ramifications (not chance of outcome) of independence.
- UVB-76 12y agoThe media thrive on fear, uncertainty, and doubt. The possibility of Scotland voting for independence had that in spades; nobody really knew what it would entail. Thus the media persisted in presenting it as a realistic, likely prospect, even when it was quite apparent (as per bookmakers odds) that a 'yes' vote was very unlikely.
- doc_holliday 12y agoPolitically it is very interesting and a result that in a lot of ways can bring about real change too (however, I do have obvious scepticism). The tide is now with change as for the Union to continue change must happen. A lot of the high yes vote was not because people 100% believed Scotland should be independent but more they wanted change to the system (and I do believe a Scottish Parliment offered a better system), it did come with a lot of risk and a possible lose / lose for the people of the UK as a whole. It opens up the question of representation for people of the regions of England, Northern Ireland and Wales. I think a lot of momentum has been gathered for something a kin to federal government in the UK and is something I would very much welcome. In essence that is in a lot of ways what that Nationalists wanted... to keep the currency union and have essentially the same terms of attachment to the EU. I voted no on the day after a long time believing in a yes, the tide of politcal change swayed me that we may ultimately be better in a UK that had the momentum with change to our representation. The no campaign however ran an abysmal campaign and it pained me to end up siding with them, and that was in more in spite of what they had to say. Being part of the UK benefits Scotland's internal trade immensely and to think terms would have remained the same with the rUK who would have become a foreign nation at that point was naive. I think a Union with the UK has much the same arguments as staying in the EU with respect to trade, contracts and funding. It is just English nationalism and Scottish nationalism have picked differing sides.
- jiggy2011 12y agoI don't know how a federal system could work when England is about 80% of the population. The USA already has issues with California and Texas being so significant in terms of population, but England would dwarf both of them in terms of proportion. The only way it could work would be to abolish England entirely and break it up into regions.
- doc_holliday 12y agoI think English regions should be split up too, and their is great desire for that. England is made up of many quite distinct regions, the problem is much of the power is concentrated in London and subsequently a lot of investment and money is poured into London and immediate surroundings. The fact that England has such a disparity in investment between it's first city (London) and second city (Birmingham) is a problem. It also isn't helping concentration of populations and jobs which remained close to London. The issues Scotland has are felt throughout the UK, and Scotland therefore has a lot in common as far as wanting powers as do regions of England out with the immediate surroundings of London. This in essence is why this result could be better for the regions of England.
- jokoon 12y agoit's true that it would have changed a lot of things.
- argumentum 12y agoThis referendum has convinced me that we should enfranchise 16 & 17 year olds for US elections. My main hangup before was that these people might be pressured by their parents into voting a certain way. It turns out not only do they have political minds of their own, their energy and intelligence was clearly a boost to the spirit of democracy so evident in this election. As adults, we often romanticize our childhoods, because well .. they are by and large romantic. The experience of discovering the world and yourself is the centerpiece of youth, and it's important that we have that perspective reflected in our democracies.
- tobylane 12y ago>It turns out not only do they have political minds of their own, their energy and intelligence was clearly a boost to the spirit of democracy so evident in this election. Does it? I would always assume that, but I'd shy away from claiming it without proof.
- throwaway283719 12y agoI think it's interesting to talk about the failure of polls to predict the magnitude of the result. Here are the results of the final polls from six major polling organizations, taken 1-3 days before the vote Organization Yes No Number* --------------------------------------- Opinium 0.479 0.521 1087 ICM 0.477 0.523 1010 Panelbase 0.474 0.526 954 Survation 0.473 0.527 910 YouGov 0.474 0.526 3043 Ipsos Mori 0.474 0.526 951 --------------------------------------- TOTAL 0.475 0.525 7955 * excluding undecided voters On one hand they were accurate in that they forecast a "no" result with high probability - the proportion of "no" voters is more than four standard errors away from 50%; the standard error being s.e. = sqrt(0.475 * 0.525 / 7955) = 0.006 On the other hand, the final proportion of "no" voters was 55.3%, which is more than four standard errors away from the forecast value of 52.5%. So the polls were significantly underestimating the proportion of "no" voters out there. A similar effect was seen in the Quebec independence referendum, where the polls actually predicted a slight advantage for "yes" but the final result was a decisive victory for "no".
- mike_hearn 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shy_Tory_Factor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shy_Tory_Factor
- nknighthb 12y agoA related question I'd be curious about is the likely voter issue. In the US, left-wingers are less likely to actually go vote than right-wingers. Pollsters try to correct for this with a "likely voter" model (which varies by pollster, but tries to discover how likely a respondent actually is to vote). If you poll everyone eligible to vote, you get left-wing results. If you poll registered voters, it pulls a bit right. If you poll voters that match a reasonable "likely voter" model, you'll get results that are even further right and tend to be closer to the reality of votes actually cast. Does this dichotomy exist in the UK and/or Scotland specifically, and if so, do pollsters there try to correct for it?