14 ms·
Richmond Italian restaurant waging war on Yelp
- ryanackley 12y agoNot sure why but Yelp always seems inaccurate to me. I also tried to write a review once but it flagged it for some reason and it never appeared. It was a 3 star review too, neither exceptionally positive or negative. I use TripAdvisor to find local places to eat. Usually the top 1 or 2 places are good for a given type of food. Anything under that is a mixed bag.
- beachstartup 12y agowhat's amazing to me is people still read the reviews on yelp. they're completely worthless. it's a bunch of kids and wannabe snobs preening for each other. i went through that phase - that's how i can recognize it. now i just use it to search and get directions. its interface is still superior for a quick lookup on my phone when i'm headed somewhere. as soon as they require a login to use the mobile app, i'll probably stop using it.
- jff 12y agoYou remember that girl in high school who was always talking about how Becky was totally giving her this look earlier, seriously you guys she's such a bitch? Yeah, she's 25 now and likes to write angry Yelp reviews whenever her water glass level falls below 50%.
- debt 12y agoI like the part at the end of the article where they ask is this Italian restaurant any good anyhow(their reviews on Yelp being unhelpful at this point, worthless). I couldn't help but think if only there was a place on the web to find out whether a business is worth the money or not.
- rondon2 12y agoI understand it does suck to have one or two idiot customers that will flip out about something stupid and write a terrible review of your great restaurant. But I think it would be better just to have no reviews at all on Yelp. Is there anyway to ask yelp to remove your business. Can you not tell yelp that the phone number and address they have listed are personal and no longer a business and that yelp should remove them?
- walterbell 12y agoIt would break their court-approved business model, i.e. apply any algorithmic filter that generates revenue for Yelp.
- malka 12y agoie. blackmail
- jedberg 12y agoThey tried to get removed from Yelp and Yelp ignored them. That's what they really want, to be removed. See my comment elsewhere with a link for more details.
- sine_dicendo 12y agoGoogle Cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://www.richmondstandard.com/2014/09/richmond-italian-restaurant-waging-awesome-war-yelp/ https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http:/...
- pesenti 12y agoLink to the yelp page: http://www.yelp.com/biz/botto-italian-bistro-richmond-3 http://www.yelp.com/biz/botto-italian-bistro-richmond-3
- VeejayRampay 12y agoThe main issue here is the idiotic customers writing asinine comments and reviews. I can't count the number of times I've seen things like : "I ordered that pair of running shoes, I really wanted a toaster, one star" or "The packaging was broken when I received my game, 0.5/10". When you accumulate "reviews" like these where people are totally unable to dissociate their internal state of mind and the quality of the product at hand (and basically using the system to vent their personal frustration), the value you get out of it is basically non-existent.
- estebank 12y agoWouldn't the distribution of bogus reviews be fairly consistent across competitors?
- soft_dev_person 12y agoUntil someone starts to take advantage, and fills it with false reviews faster than the system can cope...
- schnable 12y agoThe place has to have enough reviews for the bad ones to be rendered insignificant. If a restaurant has only 10 reviews and three of them are one-star "they only had one gluten free option" or type of reviews, the rating will be skewed over bullshit reviews.
- estebank 12y agoThat is true, but it definitely seems broken that that could be the case. Personally, I always either read all the reviews or disregard them completely when the review count is <10 or 20 on every "start driven" website, precisely because of this. May be these sites shouldn't even be showing the avg when there aren't enough reviews to be meaningful?
- tedunangst 12y agoSmaller restaurants don't always have enough reviews to average away the bad ones, especially when people conscript their friends (like getting everybody in your Google+ circle to leave a one star review for a restaurant that didn't let your wear your Glass).
- jedberg 12y agoThis is a better article: http://insidescoopsf.sfgate.com/blog/2014/09/17/richmond-restaurant-owner-encourages-bad-yelp-reviews/ http://insidescoopsf.sfgate.com/blog/2014/09/17/richmond-res... It has the full emails back and forth between yelp and company, which are the most telling part. Basically the company doesn't want to be on yelp, but yelp won't remove them. Now they are "buying" bad reviews, so yelp has threatened to take action and the restaurant basically says "bring it on" since that is exactly what they want.
- mnw21cam 12y agoIt's interesting that Yelp refer to their terms of service in their letter to the restaurant. Since this is all being done behind the restaurant's back, and they will not have signed up to any terms of service, that is completely irrelevant. Yelp has no legal contract with the restaurant.
- harshreality 12y agoTortious interference with the contract Yelp has with its users (if Yelp's sign-up clickthrough agreement is enforceable).
- Retric 12y agoFYI: Tortuous interference is causing harm by unlawful means. Otherwise things like a union protest would be illegal.
- tsaoutourpants 12y agoNot quite, actually. The elements of tortious interference vary by state but are roughly: 1) The existence of a contractual relationship or beneficial business relationship between two parties. 2) Knowledge of that relationship by a third party. 3) Intent of the third party to induce a party to the relationship to breach the relationship. 4) Lack of any privilege on the part of the third party to induce such a breach. 5) The contractual relationship is breached. 6) Damage to the party against whom the breach occurs. Yelp may have a case for tortious interference against the restaurant if they are paying customers to break their Yelp terms. Yelp still sucks.
- Nursie 12y agoThis won't work on people like me who may look at the star rating but have no desire to read user reviews. You'll just be a one-star place and I'll dismiss you out of hand..
- alexjeffrey 12y agobut with all the publicity surrounding their actions, will they become more well known which will in fact counteract their star rating on Yelp? My guess is yes.
- ganeumann 12y agoI think there's also an appeal to certain types of businesses like restaurants when they don't act like corporate profit-maximizers.
- mikeryan 12y agoYou're missing the point. With all one star reviews in a crowded field like restaurants most folks will never see your reviews on Yelp. They don't care if you don't find them they're doing just fine without Yelp's "help".
- nlh 12y agoYour loss then, no? If you dismiss them out of hand, you're losing out on the chance to visit them and eat there (and enjoy a good meal). Clearly a lot of people like them, and they're not suffering for business because of dismissals like yours, and, in fact, they're saying they want to avoid getting people who like Yelp and trust Yelp reviews, so the only one who seems to lose in this scenario is you...?
- Nursie 12y agoSo I should try all the one star places in case they're actually pretty good? Seems to me I'd be better off sticking to highly recommended places, if the false positive rate is small enough. The false negative rate is obviously not great but it's far less of a concern.
- acomjean 12y agoI've used yelp reviews with great success when traveling. The signal noise ratio in urban areas is good enough to weed out the occasional bad review. I look out for the really low rated ones and avoid. People aren't stupid, and read online reviews with a certain amount of skepticism. If they can survive with regulars thats fine for them. I would avoid any place thats fighting any kind of reviews.
- beatpanda 12y agoJust a note about the "Richmond Standard": it exists for the sole purpose of publishing press releases from Chevron, as well as op-eds by Chevron-supported public figures, as a propaganda tool in the ongoing fight for political control of Richmond, California. They trick people into reading the Chevron PR as "news" by hiding it among stories like this one and hoping people don't read the fine print.
- mikeryan 12y agoI agree with you however, it should be noticed there's a large box on the page where Chevron notes its role (emphasis mine). "This news website is brought to you by Chevron Richmond. We aim to provide Richmond residents with important information about what's going on in the community, and to provide a voice for Chevron Richmond on civic issues"
- menriquez 12y agogive it a rest already...all publications have to sell advertising and all become tools of those industries...on the right and on the left.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 12y agoYes, they have to write so many seemingly legitimate articles to hide the PR releases among, that nearly 99.998% of all articles are decoys! How dastardly.
- blakeja 12y agoThis has been going on for what, 100+ years? Is there any newspaper that is not owned by some rich company or individual with their own motivations? I'm still waiting to see how far Bezos plans to go with the Post.
- brudgers 12y agoThe Tampa Bay Times [ formerly the St Petersburg Times ] is published by Times Publishing Company which is wholly owned by the Poynter Institute. The Poynter Institute is dedicated to journalism. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tampa_Bay_Times http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tampa_Bay_Times [2] http://www.tampabay.com/ http://www.tampabay.com/ [3] http://www.poynter.org/ http://www.poynter.org/
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jonifico 12y agoThat's a pretty good (and unorthodox) way to promote yourself and get some free press. Never really trusted Yelp anyway, too many stupid people pretending they're experts.
- orbitur 12y agoIt is untrustworthy when a restaurant has only 4 or 5 reviews, even if they're written by "Yelp Pros". But when hundreds of people have "Checked In" at a place, you can usually rely on the star count to give you a fairly accurate estimation of how good it's going to be. I've also noticed some cities are way more into it than others, making it more reliable. Everyone in Halifax, NS depends on it, but when I visit my home Little Rock, AR, it's worthless, even though Little Rock is technically a larger city.
- illumen 12y agoYours seems like anecdotal evidence. I've had great experiences without reviews or guides, and also with places that aren't supposed to be good. McDonalds is really popular, but I don't eat there.
- don_draper 12y agoIs the restaurant claiming all review systems are broken? Do the owners ever read reviews on Amazon or the general web? I don't think you should throw the baby out with the bathwater.
- kissickas 12y agoNo, in the article it clearly states that the owners are getting "blackmailed" by Yelp and have decided to retaliate, but otherwise think it (I assume a rating website) is actually a good idea. Edit: my apologies for any snark above, I just realized that the article I was referencing was the one posted by jedberg. http://insidescoopsf.sfgate.com/blog/2014/09/17/richmond-restaurant-owner-encourages-bad-yelp-reviews/ http://insidescoopsf.sfgate.com/blog/2014/09/17/richmond-res...
- dragonwriter 12y agoThe restaurant might not be, but I will claim something close to that: all aggregated-score-oriented (e.g., number/star) review systems that aren't centrally based on some reasonable measure of the the individual user's trust/affinity with each individual reviewer presented are fundamentally broken, just because reviews are subjective and without accounting for taste similarity, other people's subjective ratings are useless (individual text reviews have a similar problem, but at least well written ones will report information from which one might infer the basis of the opinion and get some utility from a review by someone with different tastes.)
- squigs25 12y agoA large population of diners in this country do this when trying to find new eating establishments: 1. Searches google for a restaurant name 2. Checks the number of stars Yelp gives it in the Google result or 1. Searches "dinner" on yelp 2. Clicks on the highest rated Yelp pages For a popular restaurant with a fan following the Botto pizza strategy might work. Generally speaking, ignoring your customer's needs and wants is a fast path to complacency. And hopefully you're all aware that: COMPLACENCY WILL BE THE ARCHITECTURE OF YOUR DOWNFALL. Internalize that statement. While Botto's is cool today, adaptation is the key to long term success. Inevitably after serving each of their loyal customers many times over, the customers will have a bad meal here or there. With an attitude of "The customer is not always right", disagreements will leave customers disenchanted one by one, and slowly these loyal customers will become less loyal. Or another good Italian pizza place will open up. Or the italian food wants of the neighborhood will change. Or Yelp's powerhold on connecting diners to restaurants will grow stronger.
- ganeumann 12y agoOption 1: pay attention to what popular and busy restaurant owner is doing to promote his business. Option 2: take advice from random HN commenter. How to choose, how to choose...
- squigs25 12y agoOption 1: Listen to the words of 1 successful business Option 2: Listen to the words of many successful businesses Yeah, I guess you're right that thinking is too hard and we should simply listen to a population with a sample size of 1.
- dreamweapon 12y agoWhat's silly about this whole thing is that the solution for Yelp is so obvious: Just acknowledge what everyone knows already -- that the current system for managing and aggregating ratings has been a total flop -- i.e. that 99.99% of their users use Yelp for address search, NOT recommendations -- and let business opt out of having their ratings listed (at no charge, of course) -- until they come up with something that actually does work.
- oskarth 12y agoWouldn't it be a better business model to charge businesses to opt-out? Doing this would provide them with more runway to come up with a sustainable business model to leverage and monetize their crowdsourced reviews in a creative manner. Seems like it would be more in line with their values, too. EDIT: /s
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoSounds like a shakedown. Is that what you mean by 'inline with their values'?
- dreamweapon 12y agoWouldn't it be a better business model to charge businesses to opt-out? Most people would consider that blackmail. But the folks over at Yelp would probably like that kind of thinking. Ever consider applying for a job with their marketing team?
- frandroid 12y agoWhat if many people decided to pay the fee? Then they would lose their usefulness, and then their users.
- GFischer 12y agoThat's great to know, I'm building a website focused on address search (only in my country for now), and I looked upon Yelp as inspiration :)
- jerf 12y agoLINKS. IT'S 2014. DEAR ALL THAT'S HOLY IN JOURNALISM, WHERE ARE THE DAMNED LINKS? Pardon the all caps. Shame on you, Richmond Standard. This is just absurd for 2014. pesenti has the link to the yelp page, which I won't replicate, but here's the Botto Bistro FAQ page, which they went to the effort to take a screen shot of and cut into pieces and upload into their content system (which had to be at least five minutes total) but couldn't be bothered to link to (at about five seconds): http://www.bottobistro.com/FAQ.html http://www.bottobistro.com/FAQ.html
- blisterpeanuts 12y agoSome of these Yelp reviews are priceless! I like the self-referential ones (or is it self-anticipatory?) where people write predictive reviews based on their expected dislike of the restaurant in advance of actually visiting it. Also priceless is the one referenced in the article where the restaurant manager steals away the reviewer's girlfriend, so he goes and sulks there once a week in a dark corner booth. Yelp's fundamental flaw is the fact that you can't tell real from fabricated reviews. You have to read with a skeptical eye and any overly gushing praise or overly nasty criticism of a particular business is suspect. I tend to trust the three and four star reviews over the 1's, 2's, and 5's. Amazon at least has the advantage of identifying people who actually bought the product, and there is the option to comment on a review. It's not perfect but can be useful. Yelp's reviewers seem a bit under-vetted by comparison.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThey are what they are. I think the mistake is imagining people care about the Yelp rating. Do folks look at the number, or read the reviews? Most of us can spot a rankled-reviewer-rant and ignore it. Sensitive restaurant owners are getting upset over very little.
- dkrich 12y agoI was in Boston a few weeks ago visiting a famous bar by Fenway called the "Cask n Flagon." This place is a gigantic sports bar and one of probably only five or six bars that sits around the stadium. I got to talking with the bartender and he told me a story about a customer who became irate that the bar was closing early and that they were scared that she would go on Yelp and write a bad review. I laughed because I thought he was joking, thinking that nobody would ever base the decision to visit this place on a Yelp review. However he told me that the reviews matter a lot. I still doubt that he is correct about that, but it does show you the perception and fear restaurants large and small have about Yelp.
- Tyrannosaurs 12y agoI don't know about Yelp, but I've met people working in hotels who live in genuine fear of bad Trip Advisor reviews. And I can understand that - if I'm going somewhere I don't know and have little time for research you just go somewhere like Trip Advisor and skim read. A couple of very negative reviews might make a real difference for smaller places which only have a couple of dozen reviews in total.
- golemotron 12y agoI wonder what Yelp's recourse is for buying reviews? If it's de-listing, well, that's exactly what the restaurant wants. It would be interesting to see whether Yelp decides to exercise the power to change someone's one-star review into a four-star review based on its content.
- natnat 12y agoFor some businesses, Yelp puts a big consumer alert on their business page when they catch the businesses soliciting reviews on craigslist or whatever: http://officialblog.yelp.com/2012/10/consumer-alerts-because-you-might-like-to-know.html http://officialblog.yelp.com/2012/10/consumer-alerts-because...
- WoodenChair 12y agoUnderdog story, or arrogant owners who don't want to listen to feedback? The Yelp review process is certainly flawed, but I find their FAQ troubling. "Q. Have you heard that the customer is always right? A. Yes and we find it hilarious. A business owner who believes that deserves to deal with the monsters he has created. We don't belong to that club, but if you do...bravo!" http://www.bottobistro.com/FAQ.html http://www.bottobistro.com/FAQ.html Update: A couple people have asked for my clarification on why this is "troubling." I worked in the service industry before. I also have travelled extensively outside the U.S. in other Western countries. I have found that what differentiates the American service industry from other countries is that we do have this ingrained notion that "The Customer is Always Right." If I'm handing over my hard earned money to a business, I do expect the business to bend over backward for me. If it doesn't there are plenty of other business that are willing to. That's one of the great things about a free market - we can choose where to shop in a non-monopoly market based on how well a business treats us. Businesses that don't get that deserve to lose customers (and do). In short: You're not the only suitor for my business and I don't need to feel bad about having high expectations.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoMy mum works in a shop devoted to the marine industry. There the mantra is, the customer is almost certainly wrong and probably needs saving from themselves before they buy something that will kill them. They spend a lot of time telling people not to buy something and telling them to buy something else. Customers are not useful when dead, no matter how happy they were when they left.
- GVIrish 12y ago> Customers are not useful when dead, no matter how happy they were when they left. One of my hobbies is motorcycle racing/track days and I'm always flabbergasted about how lax organizers are about safety. I'm going to share this quote with them next time I head out.
- lotsofmangos 12y ago
- protonfish 12y agoI honestly don't bother with online restaurant reviews anymore. No matter how good of a place it is, you can always have an off night or a challenging customer. These generate negative reviews in an indistinguishable manner from any other restaurant. The only positive reviews I see look suspiciously like what employees would write so those aren't helpful either. 1-5 star ratings are meaningless. But movie reviews (a la Rotten Tomatoes) work somehow. Possibly because they aren't just flaming rants about how there was a hair in their popcorn. Maybe if the reviewing community were asked "what restaurants do you frequent and why?" and you could follow active citizen reviewers in your area it might generate more constructive feedback.
- ape4 12y agoOn the other hand, I dealt with a company that was really deceptive and then looked at the online reviews (not on Yelp). They were all glowing. But when I looked more closely they all followed the same template and seemed to be posted at 9:xx am every morning - like its somebody's job.
- brightsize 12y agoSomewhat off-topic, but the Real Actors Read Yelp series on Youtube is priceless. http://goo.gl/mlsTWQ http://goo.gl/mlsTWQ
- vishalzone2002 12y agoI always find this flaw in yelp which I think might become a bigger problem for them. They allow pretty much anybody to write any kind of review for any business. There is no validation that the yelp user have had interacted with the business unless the business owners takes a notice and claims that its otherwise. I was at a a small business hackathon and not even a single SMB owner was happy with yelp. Even the ones who had good reviews do not think that it contributed a lot to their business. Has this thing ever crossed your mind?
- ivancamilov 12y agowait a minute, you can't force Yelp to remove your restaurant?! and I thought we had retarded Internet laws in my country... here in Colombia, no business can have your information without your consent. If they do, you can force them to remove any records they have on you –it's a principle called Habeas Data.