3 ms·
This is perhaps less impressive than you would think. Watch some mathematical slight of hand: suppose for the sake of argument that 1% of Facebook has Dark Sec
by patio11 17y ago
This is perhaps less impressive than you would think. Watch some mathematical slight of hand: suppose for the sake of argument that 1% of Facebook has Dark Secret X and you have a DSXdar program which is 99% accurate.
Your program will, out of a sample of 100,000 Facebookers, identify 1,980 people as being DSX. Half of them (99% of 1,000 = 990) have DSX. Half of them (1% of 99,000 = 990) are not actually DSX.
The math is much more favorable for oracle programs which look for traits which are evenly split in the population. This is one reason why "An AI which reads your work and guesses your gender" works so amazingly well as a tech demo. (That program exists, incidentally, and is better than 80% accurate.) However, even supposing there were sufficient cues in a person's writing to tell whether they were e.g. left handed or not in the same fashion, a similar Oracle Of Lefties would be almost useless because you'd get too many misclassified righties in with your identified lefties.
On a related note, this is why a) you are not particularly recommended to get an HIV test if you're not at risk for AIDS and b) the first thing that will happen after an HIV+ result is scheduling another test.
On a totally different note, much of the worries of privacy experts with regards to Gaydar and similar programs don't require the AI to be functional to come to pass. "My sophisticated computer analysis says you're 83% likely to be a child molester." If you're already under suspicion, folks will not ordinarily say "Wait a second, lets see the study showing that this, in fact, actually works." They'll simply take the "expert"'s word at face value.
(See, for example, computer models of global warming. The big black box will spit out any answer you want from it -- want the answer that global warming is no problem at all? Turn off the "Assume that water vapor evaporation causes a vicious warming cycle" and, bam, you can crank your smokestack slider to the max and not have any problems. Yet folks don't routinely consider that prior to saying that "Global warming is a fact -- the UN reported that the scientists proved it.")
- rfreytag 17y agoSeems odd that work done in 2007 is reported in the popular press in 2009 and yet the results are not available because the authors "are hoping to have it published in a journal." Google turned up nothing but more secondary references that don't mention a publication (http://tinyurl.com/nqy5zm http://tinyurl.com/nqy5zm). If I am mistaken and the paper is available online please post the link (thank you).
- nopinsight 17y agoPicking 1,980 people from 100,000 and get 990 out of 1,000 who have DSX is in fact quite impressive--99% recall (in information retrieval) or sensitivity (in medicine). In information retrieval, you rarely get that sort of number out of unstructured data. If you look at the predicted positives for rare conditions (as in your DSX example), you may find that 50% are false positives. It is still considered useful for many purposes. In medicine, for example, it is used as a first-round filter to screen people for another, more expensive/cumbersome test.
- DaniFong 17y agoTo be clear, there's no checkbox associated with water vapor causing a runaway warming cycle. The ipcc radiative forcing metric pegs the contribution at less than 5% of the total positive warming, and cloud alebedo effect, spurred on by the increased humidity, is more strongly negative. The largest anthropogenic contributors are still greenhouse gases, directly.
- tezza 17y agoThe IPCC features 4 feedback scenarios, and 6 original scenarios which are 'equally-likely', and the discussion is always around the worst case of them. 6 models :: http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_sr/?src=/climate/ipcc/emission/150.htm http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_sr/?src=/climate... http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_sr/?src=/climate/ipcc/emission/146.htm http://www.grida.no/publications/other/ipcc_sr/?src=/climate... 4 Economic Response Models :: http://www.lenntech.com/greenhouse-effect/ipcc-scenarios.htm http://www.lenntech.com/greenhouse-effect/ipcc-scenarios.htm http://www.lenntech.com/greenhouse-effect/ipcc-sres-scenarios-consequences.htm http://www.lenntech.com/greenhouse-effect/ipcc-sres-scenario...
- mkyc 17y agoVery much related: http://yudkowsky.net/rational/bayes http://yudkowsky.net/rational/bayes
- jgrahamc 17y agoBayes' Theorem would tell you P(DSX|DSXdar) = P(DSXdar|DSX)P(DSX) / P(DSXdar) Using your figures that's P(DSX|DSXdar) = 0.99 x 0.01 / (0.99 x 0.01 + 0.01 x 0.99) = 0.5