4 ms·
He didn't make a statement that Apple or the NSA can't read your messages. He said that Apple can't read your messages. However since you are so concerned about
by simonh 12y ago
He didn't make a statement that Apple or the NSA can't read your messages. He said that Apple can't read your messages. However since you are so concerned about half truths, if you're going to criticise someone's statements, it would be nice if you'd address what they actually are saying.
It's entirely possible that the NSA has hacked Apple, or that an Apple employee has been subverted by the NSA and inserted a back door into the encryption system. Tim Cook wouldn't know about that and can't give assurances of that kind, and isn't trying to. All he can do is state what Apple as a company intends and can do acting according to it's policies.
So yes it's entirely possible Apple or the NSA has back door keys to iMessage. Tim Cook is now publicly on record saying that Apple don't. That's not a 'half truth at best'. It's either true or it's a lie. I'm not telling you to believe him or not, but historically these things have a way of coming to light eventually, one way or another.
- danieldk 12y agoThe half-truth is here: If the government laid a subpoena to get iMessages, we can’t provide it. It’s encrypted and we don’t have a key. It's encrypted and they don't have the key, but since the user does not have any control over the public keys being added, they could add a trusted public key and get it anyway. So they can actually provide messages if they really wanted to. I don't believe they really want to. But the thing we should've learnt from last year's revelations is (1) that companies can be forced to do so anyway via secret courts; and (2) the NSA is willing to make a 'technical solution' otherwise. So, Tim Cook is not being completely honest here. Apart from what hardware can do, the only way to trust such an application is if you had the source code, the source code of the operating system and the source code to firmware blobs, and some way to prove that everything was compiled from public source code without modifications. Since that is not going to happen, iMessage should be considered as secure as unencrypted e-mail when it comes to governments. Of course, it does provide more protection than e-mail against less equipped actors.
- simonh 12y agoThey can't create trusted public keys after the fact, they'd have to already have them. So there's no half truth. Either they currently create and store such public keys or they don't. Tim Cooke is saying they don't. That statement can't be half true. It's either true or false.
- waps 12y agoTrue. But they can replace any program on any iPhone with an NSA/Justice system version, and give the replacement access to any keys stored on the iPhone. There can never be any security on a closed system where a central party has all the control. That means apple's system is a lost cause for user security.
- threeseed 12y agoApple can silently slipstream applications onto a users iPhone ? That would means dozens of employees would be involved in a conspiracy with the US government. And over all the years none of them has leaked anything ? Sounds far fetched. Also better not use a phone. Because Android and Windows Phone would have the same problem.
- JetSpiegel 12y agoThey can issue an "update" for the system that adds that functionality, they have the trusted keys to sign apps.
- maljx 12y agoApple can remotely delete apps on iPhones. They've used it to delete apps that were removed from the app store. Apple can force your phone to download the latest U2 album. Upgrading your apps silently is probably not outside their control if they wanted to.
- threeseed 12y agoiPhones by default are set to automatically download purchased content from the iTunes Store. It's a feature so purchases made on one device automatically appear on others. All Apple did was "buy" the U2 for everyone. Nothing magical about it. To bring that up in the context of iMessage security shows either ignorance or stupidity. And remote deleting is quite a bit different to silently upgrading apps for the purpose of spying.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- SixSigma 12y agoAnd the source code to the compiler they use. And the source code to those compilers, ad infinitum. And the masks for every IC inside the products, and the schematics of all the circuitry. And then someone to verify that they are all the correct ones.
- spott 12y agoAnd someone to verify that the verifier is correct, and someone to verify her... Ad absurdom...
- X-Istence 12y agoEven if a new public key is added to the keybag, the NSA wouldn't get old messages, only messages from that point forward. Still troublesome, and I wish there was some way to see what keys are being used and cross verify them with the remote user, so that if a new key is added you would be notified. But there is no way for Apple to retrieve old messages and send them to the NSA.
- waps 12y agoEuhm, no, it would have access to any message you can see from the phone, old or new. Plus I don't think there's a per-message key at all. So they could have logged the messages, then install a patched iMessage on your phone to send them the key. That is assuming Apple's claim is true at all, and they need this in the first place.
- pilif 12y ago>He said that Apple can't read your messages. which is also a half-truth. They can't read messages encrypted with another phones public key, but they can certainly read messages encrypted with their public key which they might or might not send to your phone in addition to the actual recipient's public key. Neither me nor he is saying that Apple does in-fact read your messages (they probably don't), but saying that they can't read your messages is not correct. They certainly can by sending your phone an additional public key.
- chmars 12y agoWhat's about iCloud backups?
- Tyrannosaurs 12y agoNot really. He's pretty clear: "If the government laid a subpoena to get iMessages, we can’t provide it. It’s encrypted and we don’t have a key." There's no wiggle room there. He's not saying we don't have the users key, he's saying categorically they can't provide iMessage information. I don't understand why you think that can be read as they can't get the information through mechanism X but that they can through mechanism Y. That's not to say the NSA can't read them - possibly with Apple's help, possibly without - but he's really not in a position to talk about what the NSA can and can't do. From a corporate PR perspective, he really doesn't have to say anything about this. He doesn't do many interviews, he could have declined this, or declined to talk about certain topics as part of the conditions around doing the interview. If Apple can indeed read your messages then the easiest thing for him would be to shut up and say nothing so it would seem odd to go public with a lie when he has that option.
- Spooky23 12y agoWhat is missing is that they can add another key for intercept. They really need to be able to do so to comply with the law. It's well established that the police can intercept communications with a warrant. Many HN posters have an issue with that too, but that is just a hard truth with decades if legal precedence. The issue, IMO, is the warrantless collection part. IMO, iMessages probably protects you against the latter, although 3-letter agencies may record the messages and use other means to decrypt them later.
- madaxe_again 12y ago"Let's not worry about it, it's probably all ok, you can't say anything unless you have 100% cast-iron proof"? That's an excellent recipe for sleepwalking into this mess.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- monokrome 12y ago- "It's either true or it's a lie" Or is it both at the same time?!
- avn2109 12y ago>> "It's entirely possible that the NSA has hacked Apple, or that an Apple employee has been subverted by the NSA and inserted a back door into the encryption system." "Entirely possible" is the understatement of the year. I think you mean "absolutely guaranteed." This is the raison d'etre of signals intelligence agencies. The alphabet agencies would be utterly failing at what they see as their job if they didn't have many, many plants inside Apple/Google/AT&T/large communication organizations. And Tim Cook isn't stupid; he knows this. His claims might be technically true in a strictly literal sense, in that he doesn't have the key, but the claims are certainly misleading to the nontechnical public. He knows full well that iMessage is uber-compromised, probably in several different ways (legal wiretaps, technical intrusions, HumInt, etc).