8 ms·
Schizophrenia not a single disease but multiple genetically distinct disorders
- DiabloD3 12y agoI find this research to be very interesting. It should make it much easier to pin down the cause of the individual features of Schizophrenia, many of which are believed to be caused or triggered by the modern Human diet (refined sugars, grains, other (sometimes highly) processed foods et al.) by a growing number in the scientific community.
- sedachv 12y ago> many of which are believed to be caused or triggered by the modern Human diet (refined sugars, grains, other (sometimes highly) processed foods et al.) by a growing number in the scientific community. Links to studies published in peer-reviewed journals or GTFO. "Modern diet" is the medieval humorism of the last decade.
- llamataboot 12y agoLots of links here. http://evolutionarypsychiatry.blogspot.com/2013/11/gluten-and-schizophrenia-again-with.html http://evolutionarypsychiatry.blogspot.com/2013/11/gluten-an... There is also rising evidence that gut flora correlate with various mental health issues. http://www.apa.org/monitor/2012/09/gut-feeling.aspx http://www.apa.org/monitor/2012/09/gut-feeling.aspx http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/gut-bacteria-may-exacerbate-depress/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/gut-bacteria-may-e...
- daeken 12y agoFrom your first link, the only study that attempted to show a causal link between gluten and schizophrenia had no control group, no placebo, and n=2. This isn't a study, it's a guess. There may well be something to this whole thing, but the science just isn't there right now, at all. Right now what we need are studies, not solutions. The evidence is non-existent.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tunesmith 12y agoThat's really good news - if the same were discovered for bipolar and depression (which are often diagnosed along the lines of "well, you have these symptoms, so you probably have it") then it could help prevent a lot of misdiagnoses and increase quality of life.
- javert 12y agoI would say that there is no doubt that depression can be caused by a person's own beliefs about him/herself and the world. So it seems unlikely that such an explanation could account for all forms of depression.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoThat presupposes that a treatment exists for the "correct" diagnosis. In bipolar disorder there is a wide range of symptoms and prognosis. However, the subgroup don't inform treatment decisions to the point that the first choice of treatment usually works. Any subdivision must lead to better treatment options and guidance to be meaningful.
- haberman 12y agoThis is promising. If you read the DSM (the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, published by the American Psychiatric Association), it reads a lot like a fuzzy pattern-matching algorithm: (A) Characteristic symptoms: Two (or more) of the following, each present for a significant portion of time during a 1-month period (or less if successfully treated): (1) delusions (2) hallucinations (3) disorganized speech (eg. frequent derailment or incoherence) (4) grossly disorganized or catatonic behavior (5) negative symptoms, ie., affecting flatting, alogia, or avolition. Note: Only one Criterion A symptom is required if delusions are bizzare or hallucinations consist of a voice keeping a running commentary on the person's behavior or thoughts, or two or more voices conversing with each other. What is a "delusion?" What is "bizarre?" There is a lot of subjective judgment here, and just generally speaking this feels more like alchemy than science. I don't mean to criticize this approach too much though, because without a more detailed understanding of the underlying mechanisms and causes, this approach is the best possible way of at least clustering mental problems into groups. That at least allows people to share data about what treatments have worked for people in each cluster. But if we can get a better understanding of the true underlying causes, and isolate the causes with better granularity, it should put us in a much better position to (I hope) provide much better and more specific treatment.
- serve_yay 12y agoYeah, and the way these things are diagnosed is telling. (Basically, similar symptoms will tend to be classified as "borderline" or "schizophrenic" depending on the individual's demographics.)
- Kalium 12y agoIt's worth remembering that the DSM is not intended for use by the average person. It can and will use technical terms - like "delusion" - that users of the manual are expected to understand as technical terms.
- haberman 12y agoFair enough. It still seems safe to say that diagnoses based on criteria like "meets at least two of these five symptoms" are less than an exact science.
- mcone 12y agoThis is potentially good news. My sister has schizophrenia, and not a day passes when I don't worry about my 3 year-old son being diagnosed with this terrible disease. I'm not a scientist or an engineer, so maybe somebody who has read the published article can help me out here. I wonder what the percentages mean. How do they determine whether or not someone has a 73% chance of being diagnosed with the disease? And what does that mean exactly? On the other hand, this research raises even more questions. For instance, I wonder what steps you could take to help a child with, say, a 60% chance of being diagnosed with schizophrenia? Are the genes like switches, in the sense that certain environmental variables can flip them on and off? If so, I guess there is a lot that could be done to help someone who has a good chance of being diagnosed.
- javert 12y agoThis is anecdotal, but having known schizophrenics, make sure your son stays away from drugs (e.g. marajuana and the like). I had a close friend who attributed his very bad schizophrenic symptoms to an increase in drug use (specifically marajuana). Correlation does not imply causation, but in this case, it's probably not worth the risk.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoNarcotics will serve as catalysts for the symptoms. If they're present, they'll manifest themselves organically, regardless.
- javert 12y agoBy "serve as catalysts" do you mean "make more severe," "make more frequent," "make appear earlier in life," or perhaps all of the above, or perhaps something different?
- bbrian 12y agoI think he means "make appear earlier in life". > Several studies have suggested that regular, long-term cannabis use is one of a number of environmental factors that, in combination with certain genetic predisposing factors, may significantly increase a young individual’s chance of experiencing psychosis and developing schizophrenia. However, numbers of people being diagnosed with schizophrenia remained stable over time during which the number of cannabis users increased and average strength rose significantly. http://www.drugscience.org.uk/blog/2013/10/24/think-cannabis-harmless-no-does-anyone-what-about-propagating-drug-hysteria-harmless/ http://www.drugscience.org.uk/blog/2013/10/24/think-cannabis...
- kornork 12y agoThe article doesn't mention it, but I'm curious if Watson involved in this (or similar efforts) at all.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoI sure hope not. Associating genetic variations with symptoms or physiological findings is a relatively clear-cut statistical problem. The major challenge in whole genome association studies (or their extension to whole genome sequencing data) is to get enough data to draw meaningful conclusions. There is a cognitive dissonance in biology/medicine: On the one hand they complain about too much data to process, but at publication time, the power is too low...
- pinkyand 12y agoThe problem with a lot of the data in electronic medical records is that they are not structured but in natural language. This is exactly where Watson can help.
- bayesianhorse 12y agoI don't think so. It is too expensive to enroll more than a couple of thousand of participants for a GWA study, though they are often pooled for a broader analysis. Anyway, genotyping will probably cost at least $100 (depending on the technology a lot more), which puts manual entry of patient data into perspective. An unpaid intern can be cheaper than fancy artificial intelligence!
- gwern 12y agoNo; the phenotype data was extracted from structured interviews: "Ninety-three clinical features of schizophrenia from interviews based on the Diagnostic Interview for Genetic Studies (30), as well as the Best Estimate Diagnosis Code Sheet submitted GAIN/non-GAIN to dbGaP, were initially considered with the MGS sample (see references 31, 32; see also Appendix I in the online data supplement). The Diagnostic Interview for Genetic Studies was utilized for the Portuguese Island samples. Corresponding features were extracted in CATIE from the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale, the Quality of Life Questionnaire, and the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV (23). These phenotypic sets and their relations with one another characterize the phenotypic architecture of schizophrenia (Figure 1B)." They did consider but reject using medical records (which is where a Watson might come into play): "Despite the detailed phenotypic information we had available about subjects, there are still limitations to data obtained even from reliable structured interviews like the Diagnostic Interview for Genetic Studies. Interview data are based on self-reports that are interpreted and coded by interviewers. Subjects may not be willing or able to report their symptoms accurately. We had obtained information from treatment records and family history reports, but we chose not to use such additional information, except for the resulting best-estimate final DSM ratings of diagnosis, because its extent and quality varied in unmeasured ways between cases. The greatest limitation in the phenotypic assessments in available GWAS databases has been the overreliance on subjective symptoms with an absence of objective measurements, such as cognitive tests, brain electrophysiology, and neuroimaging (37). Subjective symptoms are fuzzy indicators of the underlying pathophysiology. Objective measures could complement the assessment of symptoms and could be applied to both cases and controls, thereby providing a more comprehensive and valid characterization of the phenotype of all subjects. The biggest challenge in GWAS is access to studies with rich phenotypic data about both subjective and objective measures obtained systematically from all subjects."
- webnrrd2k 12y agoIt's been interesting to see genetics slowly get expanded to help understand more conditions... Just like cancer isn't caused by one thing, many of the common "psych" diseases aren't caused by one thing. The more obvious candidates for a strong genetic component are disorders like depression, alcoholism, and ADHD; but I'm sure this will be broadened into other mental health areas like diet, obesity and stress management. There is still a strong environmental component, so I'm not trying to say that genetics is everything, but it's still important.
- azernik 12y agoWhat's even more interesting is the insight this gives into biology. When we find a protein-encoding gene that, when mutated, causes a certain disease, it gives a pretty good clue as to that protein's function in the body.
- tokenadult 12y agoWhat a coincidence. This was posted just as I was at the weekly "journal club" on human behavior genetics at the University of Minnesota with two researchers who used to be associated with Washington University in St. Louis (the source of the press release kindly submitted here). Genetic research on schizophrenia has been going on for a long time, and one of the WUSTL researchers I know locally[1] has been conducting that research since the year I was born. Experienced researchers on schizophrenia have always suspected that the finding announced in the press release headline is the correct description of reality, but it has taken a long time to do enough careful genetic research to be sure of multiple genotypes that all lead to the same clinical set of phenotypes that can be described as schizophrenia in current diagnostic categorization. As other comments suggest, research along this line may eventually lead to more effective interventions for treating or even preventing schizophrenia. We already know (links below) that schizophrenia does have a very strong component of genetic risk, yet every once in a while identical (monozygotic) twins brought up in the same household are discordant for schizophrenia, so plainly some "environmental" risks matter too. It will be good to continue the research program on this devastating illness. AFTER EDIT: Irving Gottesman is looking forward to reading the journal article by his former colleagues at WUSTL. Of course a preliminary finding like this will have to be replicated in other data sets to become part of established scientific knowledge. Then the hard work of matching treatments to patient genome patterns will begin. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4661802 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4661802 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7663622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7663622 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8069518 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8069518
- jrapdx3 12y agoI'll have to read the article to really understand what the authors have found out, but judging from the summary the advance is dividing the huge number of genes linked to schizophrenia into 8 groups of genes that associate or interact more closely than with other related genes. In many ways, this isn't surprising. It's been evident that many genes have been linked to psychiatric disorders, but no "smoking guns" are evident, usually a gene accounts for <2% of the variance, and dozens or hundreds of genes have some influence. So it's logical that it takes a cluster of many genes contributing something to have enough effect to be clinically apparent. How genes interact is an enormously complicated matter, and perhaps an even bigger question is the role of gene-environment interaction. One thing to track is with the multitude of genes shown to be clustering, an important element is how "tight" the clustering is. I anticipate we'll find out as it's investigated further that overlap among clusters is significant, that is, "blends" or mixed/intermediate types are probably common. Certainly in the real world there are seldom pure cases of any condition, the boundaries tend to be fuzzy. Not that the article implies at all that the new work gives "answers", but with any luck, it will lead to new insights, shed light on the astonishingly complex processes, and clues to making progress. Just expect the path will have many more twist and turns on the way there.
- pender 12y agoSounds like malarky to me. Sounds like a group to understand something outside their reach; finding subjective data points to further categorize the problems allowing themselves to believe they now have more of a handle on than they did before. I don't believe they know anything that adds more value.
- tim333 12y agoOn a slightly different tack I found the 2010 Discover Magazine article about the role played by the HERV-W retrovirus in Schizophrenia interesting. Not quite sure how that line of research is panning out these days. http://discovermagazine.com/2010/jun/03-the-insanity-virus http://discovermagazine.com/2010/jun/03-the-insanity-virus
- andrewl 12y agoI'm glad to see advances being made. Schizophrenia is extremely hard to research. And it's devastating to the patient. In the early nineties I worked at the University of Pennsylvania measuring brain MRIs as part of a schizophrenia study. They knew there was a strong genetic component, but they also knew that not everybody with a strong genetic weighting would develop the disorder. They had plenty of records of identical twins where one suffered from schizophrenia and the other did not. The model then was the Diathesis-Stress model [1]. The diathesis, or predisposition, is in the genes. They thought the stress could be one of a number of things: maternal infection while the baby was still developing, birth complications such as brief interruptions in oxygen flow, infections after the baby is born, and perhaps extreme psychological trauma, like combat. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diathesis-stress_model http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diathesis-stress_model
- vacri 12y agoThe idea that schizophrenia is a collection of different diseases is not new at all. When I did my neuropsych degree in the early 90s, the lecturers commented that schizophrenia was likely to be at least four different things (this article suggests eight). Their commentary was that schizophrenia was a sort of dumping ground where people got put if they didn't fit into a different diagnosis, and I remember the run-down of frequency of symptoms - the most common symptom exhibited by schizophrenics, auditory hallucinations, was only seen in 69% of patients. The idea of the four broad groups at the time (from very rusty memory here) stemmed from plus/minus showing cognitive/perceptual disturbances (like auditory hallucinations) and plus/minus showing social withdrawal symptoms, along with a couple of other things I can't recall. It's not to cast aspersions on the article - mental health research is always good - just to say that this idea has been bouncing around for quite a while.
- gwern 12y agoFulltext: https://pdf.yt/d/rErZm8HUluBbj8xu https://pdf.yt/d/rErZm8HUluBbj8xu / https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/5317066/2014-arnedo.pdf https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/5317066/2014-arnedo.pdf / https://www.sendspace.com/file/ht7shm https://www.sendspace.com/file/ht7shm (excerpts: https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/iJBeuxupqfX https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/iJBeuxup... )
- _98fj 12y agoSchizophrenia is more a catch-all term for "things are going severely wrong in a brain" than a disease.
- fideloper 12y agoMy personal, uneducated guess about mental illness in general is that it's a systemic issue, having to do with a person's overall health (genetic + lifestyle/environment). Systemic issues are likely hard to research, and so we take this scienctific (method) approach of studying small bits in isolation. This is similar to food science - there are too many factors to clearly study how we get nutrients from our food, and so science has studied bits in isolation (vitamin c, vs "orange juice with pulp and eggs"). My hope is that we'll find ways to study the overall health/status of an individual and see how that all adds up to behavior we deem "unhealthy", rather than being "trapped" poking at minute details (or perhaps well finally get enough detail to see the bigger picture). Anyway I have zero expertise in this, but this is my guess on the situation.
- Eleopteryx 12y agoMost mental "disorders" seem to be just co-occurring negative symptoms aggregated by experts in a matter that is not arbitrary but also far from objective. The reason why e.g. anxiety and depression are typically comorbid might be because the practical distinctions between them are artificial and only exist to slap labels on nebulously defined mental ailments. I believe that over time doctors will cease with the labels such as "inattentive ADHD", and merely treat debilitating inattentiveness based on the individual. The fact that ADHD can be hyperactive or inattentive, has always seemed bizarre to me. One person can't sit still, but my problem is I can sit still to a fault. But we have the same underlying disorder that's treated with the same medications. The number of types of clinical depression, for example, is absurd. It's not merely depression, it's bipolar disorder. It's not merely bipolar disorder, it's bipolar disorder type II. Seriously? Decades from now we're going to regard this approach as highly primitive and bordering on pseudo-scientific. Because every brain is different, trying to strictly classify these disorders would force people outside of a category, but the other side of that is that we have schizophrenia which seems incredibly broad "junk-drawer" sort of classification, to the point where it's easy to imagine someone who is highly eccentric being misdiagnosed. I have no credentials obviously so this is all baseless conjecture.
- DanBC 12y agoDepression is not a single illness; it's likely to be several different illnesses that fall under a single umbrella diagnosis. Please don't make the mistake of thinking bi-polar is in anyway similar to depression. They are very different illnesses with different treatments. And, again, as we learn more about bi-polar we may find that it's a bunch of different illnesses that get given the umbrella diagnosis of bi-polar. Your example of ADHD being treated with the same meds is just a function of our lack of knowledge of ADHD. So we might not always use the same meds for treatment. In the future we'll have genetic testing to determine what meds will be useful or which meds are unlikely to work.
- baddox 12y agoYou're treating the term "illness" as if they are actual objects, rather than just labels we give sets of symptoms and causes to make them convenient to discuss, research, and treat.