30 ms·
Going 'meta' for a moment, this is a tragedy of huge proportions, the question I have been considering is whether or not it is even possible to avoid? Updates
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Going 'meta' for a moment, this is a tragedy of huge proportions, the question I have been considering is whether or not it is even possible to avoid?
Updates from MSF which highlight the level of mistrust and superstition amongst the infected population, where people hide their sick relatives from isolation wards and take them back to their village. We cannot exactly put a giant fence around the place (and not that this would be a reasonable goal anyway).
Do we invade these countries and force our will on them in order to prevent a humanitarian tragedy? What gives us that right? What gives anyone that right? To someone who is not sick, forcing them from their village, for forcing them to stay in their village violates their basic human rights, and yet it is for their own good, but if they don't believe that, what moral authority allows us to overrule that belief?
As you can see I struggle with the challenge of imposing a solution on these people, knowing that without aggressive actions tens of thousands, perhaps hundreds of thousands of them will die. While explaining to someone who doesn't understand the virus, or the danger, who undergoes forced relocation to a quarantine camp and is never sick during the outbreak, that they were in very real danger from this thing they do not believe in.
- zvrba 12y agoRelated; an example of efficient government action: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1972_outbreak_of_smallpox_in_Yugoslavia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1972_outbreak_of_smallpox_in_Yu... Somehow I don't believe that an action like this is possible in a democracy :/
- Asparagirl 12y agoOh yes it is: - 1924-1925 smallpox outbreak and mass vaccinations in Duluth, Minneapolis, and St. Paul: http://www.mnopedia.org/event/smallpox-epidemic-1924-1925 http://www.mnopedia.org/event/smallpox-epidemic-1924-1925 - 1947 smallpox outbreak and mass vaccinations in New York City: http://www.virology.ws/2009/12/22/smallpox-in-new-york-city-1947/ http://www.virology.ws/2009/12/22/smallpox-in-new-york-city-...
- maxerickson 12y agoThis episode of Frontline is informative as to the situation: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/ebola-outbreak/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/ebola-outbreak/
- davesque 12y agoYeah...it's heart breaking. One of the people interviewed in that episode died after it was filmed. And, of course, there will be thousands more like him.
- lotsofmangos 12y ago"what moral authority allows us to overrule that belief?" Statistics on mortality.
- Afforess 12y agoLet's just say not all of us believe in Utilitarian theories of Ethics.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoEthical theory is not much use once you are dead.
- Afforess 12y agoAll of the world religions disagree with you.
- Padding 12y agoThat you have been downvoted is very telling of the crowd that CS people are. We pretend to be all rational professionals on our high horses, decorated with degrees and what not.. And yet, when something manages to hit us on an emotional level we falter. What Afforess said is a statement of fact and relevant to the discusssion. Thus it's a valid counterpoint. You may not like it and you may not agree with it .. you may even discard sprituality as a whole .. but none of it makes the satement any less true.
- vdaniuk 12y agoI would recommend you to stop making such sweeping generalizations about "CS crowd" and educate yourself on deontological vs consequentialist ethics debate. Yes, religions are firmly in the deontological camp and it showed during the millenia of superstition, witchhunts and obstruction of scientific progress. Btw, as far as I see the only one on the high horse in this comment thread is you.
- 12y ago
- polarix 12y agoPerhaps we could quarantine air & sea travel.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lettergram 12y agoEven with air and sea travel the chance of someone being infected outside those areas is minimal (unless they give you a nice bloody hug or you are feeling frisky). Much less an outbreak or something of that nature. Most of the infected cannot even afford to travel.
- swombat 12y agoMost. You only need a handful propagating a suddenly airborne version of the disease to London, New York, Paris, Tokyo, Beijing... Most is not good enough.
- userbinator 12y agoThere's an interesting parallel of this with some of the discussions on (computer) security - if someone's machine is part of a botnet, infected with malware, or possibly running insecure software, does it give us the right to "invade" them and forcibly perform actions which we believe are "for their own good"? The prevailing attitude there seems to be "yes", but the difference is that in those cases the worst that could happen is people lose money, data and maybe their personal information gets leaked; whereas here, with Ebola, people will actually die. Not that I'm advocating either side of the argument, but it's something to think about...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wyager 12y agoI agree that invasion is wrong, but why isn't a large-scale quarantine viable? It's not like you have to lock everyone in; you just allow those who are willing to be subjected to medical treatment passage, and deny passage to anyone else. Seems like it could help those who wish to be helped while not infringing on the right of the superstitious to reject medical treatment.
- zachrose 12y agoIt's a very important question, but I wonder how accurate and widespread this picture of West Africans is. Practically, I am concerned that there aren't enough treatment/care resources for those that want them.
- djcapelis 12y agoThat is documented fact in Liberia right now, especially in Monrovia. This release from WHO sharply highlights this issue: http://who.int/mediacentre/news/ebola/8-september-2014/en/ http://who.int/mediacentre/news/ebola/8-september-2014/en/
- kijin 12y ago> forcing them to stay in their village violates their basic human rights Better-informed villages, towns, and cities have every right to refuse to admit, or interact with, individuals from superstitious villages. Self-defense is a powerful right, and I'd say it easily trumps a potentially infected person's right to visit a cousin. People are free to die for their beliefs, whether such beliefs are true or not. But they have no right to make other people die with them. If push comes to shove, better-informed villages will expel all infected persons (preferably into quarantine centers, not into the jungle), post armed guards at every entrance, and either isolate themselves or only admit visitors from villages that have enacted a similar policy.
- swombat 12y agoThat sounds reminiscent to what happened during the Black Death. Unfortunately, it doesn't sound like it worked particularly well, considering the Plague still took a sizeable percentage of the human population at the time.
- kijin 12y agoVillages that quarantined themselves during the Plague were left completely to their own devices. Back then, you couldn't even try to communicate with other villages without risking the messenger's life. Today, outsiders can airlift food, clean water, and medical supplies to any isolated village that asks for help. So let's stop wasting resources on people who don't want to be helped, and focus on people who actually are desperate for help.
- wavefunction 12y agoYou do realize _how_ isolated these villages are right? Like the only stranger they see in a month is an itinerant trader? How exactly are they supposed to safely get word out to the "civilized" world? That is assuming that they have already heard that there is a disease going around and what the proper precautions are...
- dredmorbius 12y ago
- joesmo 12y agoI think you bring up some good points and I don't mean to discount the moral dilemma here, but in reality such moral considerations are hardly ever considered. I don't think the article is suggesting invasion, but if that was the best solution, I don't see a problem with it if it prevents an epidemic or worse, a world wide pandemic(especially if it mutates into airborne transmission). After all, the US has invaded many other countries for absolutely no reason. It'd be hard to justify not invading at this point given our history if this was indeed thought to be the optimal solution. We've invaded at least three countries illegally and started major wars but we ate considering the ethical implications of stopping a pandemic? I suppose such moral questions become quite easy once moral decisions have been discounted in favor of immoral ones repeatedly in the past.
- techdragon 12y agoAnd given the level of equipment and training the military have with regard to doing their job while wearing full Nuclear/Biological/Chemical protection. I would honestly prefer that if the situation escalates and we see confirmation of airborne transmission, the situation be dealt with by prompt deployment of fully NBC trained military medical units and sufficient security forces to ensure that whatever those doctors say is law within the quarantine. I do my best not to be a knee jerk reaction person, but an airborne ebola strain, is beyond question a deadly deadly threat. Ebola has an incubation period, there is a period of time where you are infectious, before its obvious, and if airborne your very presence places anyone in the room with you now has 50/50 odds of living. This isn't SARS, this isn't Spanish Flu. This is quite possibly the closest we can get to a disease threat strait out of a zombie movie. I don't feel we should violate the human rights of everyone in that region, but this is one of those things where its squarely a "The needs of the many, outweigh the needs of the few or the one." scenario. So if the army doctor says "that guy has ebola, stop him from running away", I kinda feel (presuming an airborne ebola) that the situation may (depending on how far away he's getting, indoor or outdoor, etc) warrant lethal force.
- justin66 12y ago> And given the level of equipment and training the military have with regard to doing their job while wearing full Nuclear/Biological/Chemical protection. I would honestly prefer that if the situation escalates and we see confirmation of airborne transmission, the situation be dealt with by prompt deployment of fully NBC trained military medical units and sufficient security forces to ensure that whatever those doctors say is law within the quarantine. I don't think the people speculating here understand how bloody military quarantine imposed by a foreign power could be - however well intentioned - compared to the mere 2,200 people who have died of the disease so far. Send in a U.S. Marine division of 20,000 people (or maybe make it a "coalition" and send in a few hundred European troops as well to, ahem, share the burden) and tell them that they need to direct some people from one place to another, keep some people penned up, keep all these people fed, keep them from doing anything unfriendly to the nice doctors in the space suits, and everyone who resists - resistance here includes rioting or just not being able to follow instructions because, you know, the troops don't speak the language - needs to be taken into custody with that legendary marine gentleness while being treated as a potentially lethal disease carrier. Keep the troops mindful that if they err on the side of laxity they could get a disease that might cause them to die bleeding from their bodily orifices. Multiple massacres should be the expected outcome of such an operation. The projected cost of the disease needs to pretty horrible before it becomes worth contemplating such a high-risk, low-reward action and we'd want to exhaust all other means of supplying these countries' civil authorities with what they need before we took such a step. We haven't done that yet.
- joe_the_user 12y agoNow, both countries' government are already engaging in the rather extreme preventative measures that's your talking about. But both also lack basic, basic supplies. It's hard to know whether this event can controlled. It seems obvious it would be more likely to be controlled if more resources are flowing in. And while I'm pretty cynical as rule, it seems cynicism and despair at this point could actually hurt people.
- narrator 12y agoThe American perspective is to solve every problem with the military or money. We believe that violence and more money are the only effective solutions to every single problem the world faces. Original thinking just doesn't happen. A creative solution would be to temporarily halt all regulations on anti-ebola drug development and let them experiment on any willing person in Liberia who wishes to receive treatment. The example of Banting and Best in the 20s is a great example of the enormous progress that can be accomplished if there is no regulation on medicine. These guys came up with the idea for extracting insulin from animals and injecting it into humans. They tested it out on willing patients, the first being a 14 year old, released the invention for use by the public and won the Nobel prize in the span of 3 years (1921-1923). That speed of drug development and testing is impossible today. A good analogy of the present situation would be this. Someone is drowning in the river. You can use the military to prevent him from knocking any nearby bathers into the river as he floats down stream but don't you dare throw him something handy like a branch or a quickly improvised flotation device because that might help him float and it may not work and there would be lawsuits or regulatory violations! You can pay someone to swim after him and try and save him, but the stream is really rushing fast and they might drown too, but that's seemingly a-ok.
- waps 12y agoAnd who pays for the, potentially unbounded fallout from that decision ? Let's say this happens : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thalidomide (First read about the advantages of the drug, then move to the crises. in particular the birth defects crisis) And please don't just say that people knowingly took the risk, read the article first to see how that played out. People won't accept the consequences of decisions made under duress (and this decision would be "death or we experiment on you". Decision to be made in an isolation camp, guarded by soldiers with guns), for obvious reasons, and this has been an accepted legal principle since a millenium before Jesus was born. You're suggesting just canceling it ? Really ? What you're suggesting is a really, really, really, really bad idea.
- ng12 12y agoI would argue there are at least a few orders of magnitude between someone with morning sickness and someone who will almost definitely die of Ebola or T1 Diabetes. It's a calculated risk, sure, but I don't think the Thalidomide example is particularly relevant.
- gear54rus 12y agoThey didn't hesitate to send troops for some bullshit reason, why hesitate now when it's actually beneficial (assuming it is executed correctly which may or may not be the case)? Right, because it is not beneficial right now (it's not like there is oil in there) and we can always take action later when it gets closer and more serious.
- saryant 12y agoThere's lots of oil in that part of the world. Nigeria is a major producer and there are lots of promising fields off Liberia and Sierra Leone. https://lukoil-overseas.com/press-centre/7059.php https://lukoil-overseas.com/press-centre/7059.php http://www.chevron.com/countries/liberia/ http://www.chevron.com/countries/liberia/ http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-17115042 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-17115042
- dredmorbius 12y agoUnderstanding systems effects (see Donella Meadows Thinking in Systems) is hugely important for understanding complex interactions. The factors feeding into the Ebola crisis, and emerging from it, are sobering both in their interactions and how they tend to lead toward a fairly inevitable conclusion. As for whether or not this is possible to avoid: human population and impacts on the world are unsustainable. Something is going to happen to bring numbers down. Voluntary population control, disease, starvation, war, social disruption, or other catastrophe, are pretty much the only real operators. In that sense, yes, I'd argue that the general concept is pretty unavoidable. I'm not saying Ebola (or this particular outbreak, or even necessarily disease) is "the one" and that the End Times have come. But it's a bit like an old-school video game. The challenges will keep coming harder and faster until we fail one.