5 ms·
An Astrobiologist Asks a Sci-fi Novelist How to Survive the Anthropocene
- swartkrans 12y agoKim Stanley Robinson's books are all pretty fantastic. I recommend the Red Mars trilogy as well as 2312. His vision of the future is exciting and optimistic, his deep knowledge of science and technology topics is enlightening, and his writing ability and character creation are fun and imaginative. It's great stuff for any hard science fiction fans.
- maaku 12y agoGreat books. Zero understanding of the singularity or transhumanist ideas though.
- swartkrans 12y agoOh I think he gets those ideas, but as can be gathered from his characters, he doesn't think people will go for it. And the spacers in 2312 are pretty transhumanist I'd say.
- maaku 12y agoI have not read 2312 yet, although it is on my list. As for most of his other works, he explores ideas of immortality and such, but only in the context of humans. He explores what happens in a society where humans live forever, without all our weaknesses, idiosyncrasies, and quirks. He also presumes such biologically limited humans will remain the dominant species and their tribal power structures the mechanism effecting change. That makes for good storytelling when your audience is regular old humans. But not very accurate predictions.
- aetherson 12y agoI yield to no one in my appreciation for the Mars trilogy, but 2312 is a lazy, stupid book. Its world is incoherent -- the premise is that in 300 years of advance, in a solar system where Mars and Venus have both been terraformed in a timescale in under 250 years or so, where humanity has near-magical technology, the problems on earth are EXACTLY the same problems that an academic liberal like KSR thinks are the problems today (basically: global warming + the developing world is poor). Somehow, we can turn Venus into a pastoral world but we can't scrub a few trillion tons of CO2 out of the atmosphere? Really? His thinking on every issue makes those plastic wading pools look deep. His treatment of economics in particular makes me think that he once heard someone describe economics, but only in a language he only partially understands. His proposed solutions range from the simplistic (really smart computers make the planned economies that he longs for right now more plausible -- novel) to the utterly insane (the way that we solve environmental catastrophe and poverty on earth is literally to air-drop animals into northern Canada). As a political novel, 2312 is deathly dull. Go to any college campus or most of the internet, and you can hear every concern KSR raises described in much greater nuance and detail, and reasonable attempts at much more convincing solutions thought up. As a science-fiction novel, 2312 reiterates the Mars trilogy without adding anything. But its true, breathtaking failure is in stitching together its (bad) political novel with its (rehearsed) science fiction novels, the terrible amalgamation making both components worse due to just how poorly the two sides fit. The science fiction part makes mockery of the political part -- these political problems simply do not make sense in that world. The political part drags the book off trap in the science fiction. It's really quite impressive how bad it is. There is a way to address poverty and environmental catastrophe in a technologically advanced future of terraforming. 2312's approach of just ham-handedly putting today's unaltered problems into a setting that is otherwise quite alien is not that way.
- sanoli 12y ago> the problems on earth are EXACTLY the same problems that an academic liberal like KSR thinks are the problems today (basically: global warming + the developing world is poor). Well, if you were to tell someone in 1714 that we had gone to the Moon, had robots on Mars, had eradicated smallpox and cured a bunch of other deadly stuff, had the internet on everyone's pockets, nuclear energy, etc, they probably wouldn't believe that at the same time we'd still have people living like they do in some parts of Africa.
- harshreality 12y ago> [KSR on the Fermi Paradox] My feeling is, the universe is too big, and life too planet-specific for intelligent life forms to communicate with each other, except for by accident and very rarely. What does the possible variation in life forms have to do with the nature of communications mediums or techniques? Encoding might be different but the mediums used will depend on level of technological advancement and not the specifics of how the life forms communicate face to face. (That's speciesist. I meant lifeform-to-lifeform.) I love that KSR mentions Banks' Culture novels. While I'd agree that biosphere sustainability is critical, I don't think it's the only critical problem, or even the most short-term problem, we may have. I may be paranoid, but I'm very worried that there is a Great Filter[1], and that it is some sort of abuse/misuse/weaponization of biotech at, or just beyond, our current level of technology. Just past that would be concern about unfriendly AI. There are also some existential threats to modern advanced civilization due to low-probability but unmanageable-if-they-occur problems. Other than an asteroid we can't detect in time, there are also supervolcano eruptions that decimate world food supplies (volcanic winter).[2] [1] http://hanson.gmu.edu/greatfilter.html http://hanson.gmu.edu/greatfilter.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Filter [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supervolcano http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supervolcano
- Ygg2 12y ago> What does the possible variation in life forms have to do with the nature of communications mediums or techniques? Lots of stuff apparently. What if a species communicates using pheromones and checks for specific smells similar to their own as in this strip http://xkcd.com/638/ http://xkcd.com/638/ What if there are creatures that live millennia and take days to form cohesive words. What if the creatures are able to use physics that is unknown to us or that we can't detect?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Balgair 12y agoIt's more basic than just talking. Feynman has a great lecture on just making sure you have 'left' and 'right' correct. http://www2.lbl.gov/abc/wallchart/teachersguide/pdf/Chap05.pdf http://www2.lbl.gov/abc/wallchart/teachersguide/pdf/Chap05.p...
- javert 12y agoRobinson is indirectly proposing that humans alive now massively sacrifice their well-being, with a severely crippeled economy and totalitarian government. In exchange for some non-existent, hypothetical future that nobody alive today (i.e. those who would actually suffer under his proposal) would ever experience. This is absolutely monstorous. This is Pol Pot-level evil.
- harshreality 12y agoSure, let's instead roll the dice that whatever's in our best interest now, and in the near future, won't be too bad for future generations, despite that we can see that we're altering the biosphere in significant ways without a good understanding of the long-term effects and with no plan to reverse the changes we're making and have made, much less a plan and the technology to deal with unforeseen consequences. Is that not monstrous? What if our decisions, due to the culture and lifestyles of developed nations, free markets, and short-to-mid-term democratic attention spans, lead to an ecological catastrophe that can't be technologically ameliorated 100 years from now? What if it could have been mitigated at present with modest intellectual effort and modest cuts to standards of living? I recognize many problems with the sort of governance that would be required to mitigate long-term ecological and technological problems (ecological collapse, grey goo, unfriendly AI), but calling it "Pol Pot Level" evil to trade some quality of life in the present for reduced risk of having the biosphere take a wrong turn a generation or two from now, seems polemical. If reduced quality of life increases mortality rates, that's unfortunate, but concern about people today should not trump concern about people in the future, to the extent we can foresee risks due to stressing the biosphere in ways we have no empirical analogs for. I think the popular idea that technology can and will overcome problems we cause in our biosphere, is unsupported (and unsupportable, even if it's true) by evidence. We either take it on faith or we don't; I choose not to.
- marcus_holmes 12y agoIf people in the past had reacted to their 100% certainty that Malthusian predictions of imminent global starvation were about to be reached, then a lot of us would not be alive today. If they had reacted by limiting technological progress (as you suggest) then we would almost certainly not be talking together over the Internet, and may have burned every single tree on the planet striving to maintain our civilisation without technological progress. Luckily they did not, and our technological progress included a "green revolution" that managed to produce massively more food on the same land. Technology can and does solve problems like this. Global government is a nightmare I wouldn't wish on my worst enemy. I live in a country with three layers of government (local, state and federal) and adding a fourth would just multiply the waste, corruption and nepotism.
- markbnj 12y agoI have no particular expertise, but I'll just toss this out there: I suspect that the popular modern view that the Earth and our biosphere are "tightly balanced and interwoven" is just wrong. I doubt that any system requiring such careful balancing and sporting such immutable inter-dependencies could have ever come into being through random evolutionary changes. I think rather that the biosphere is incredibly resilient, independent, and that nothing we or anything else does to it short of moving it further from or closer to the sun, stripping its atmosphere, or burning off its water will change its essential nature as a warm, watery rock supporting an incredible diversity of life.
- harshreality 12y agoThere's no rule that says the biosphere has to be resilient in every dimension we might push on it. If the biosphere has been stressed in a particular way and life (animal and mammalian life, specifically) rebounded, that does not mean the biosphere is resilient to any other kind of stressor, and it's only mostly assured that it's resilient to that particular one because of empirical evidence. We don't have models accurate enough to confirm your suspicions about the hardiness of the biosphere. There may be an attractor to current life-supporting conditions even under a broad range of stressors, but if human progress is adding an additional stressor (that we may not even recognize), we could be screwed.
- markbnj 12y agoAgreed, it doesn't mean those things. But I think that when we say we'll be "screwed" it doesn't necessarily mean the earth will be fundamentally different after the screwing is completed. The dinosaurs got screwed, and so did the Neanderthals, and in the end all that did was make room for us, the latest species about whom the Earth cares not at all.
- hcarvalhoalves 12y agoThat humans will impact the planet is a certainty. Like all species, it's constantly "screwing" the environment. The missing link is that, in turn, the environment "screws back". This exogenous will force humans into adaptation - only failing that comes the extinction scenario. So it's not like we have a choice. Unless the entire species subscribes to nihilism (which I doubt it's at our core, or we wouldn't be here today), we have to adapt.