3 ms·
"When the Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Lab (CSAIL) moved into Stata in 2004, the MIT administration decided, without consulting the personnel of
by joezydeco 12y ago
"When the Computer Science and Artificial Intelligence Lab (CSAIL) moved into Stata in 2004, the MIT administration decided, without consulting the personnel of CSAIL, to make the system log which cards are used to open which doors and when."
Who owns the building? MIT or the personnel of CSAIL? If the building's owner wants a log of who came in and out of the building is that really something Mr Stallman has the power to object to?
- _delirium 12y agoIn universities power is typically a bit distributed. Ultimately a nonprofit corporation owns everything, overseen by a board of trustees. But the board doesn't do that much day-to-day management. Instead there is an administrative and departmental structure. Unlike in a company, it's usually slightly less clearly hierarchical: there is usually a President or Provost, but they usually have less power than a CEO (for example, their ability to hire & fire academic staff is significantly constrained). And there are other structures like departments, faculty senates, etc. which have independent power (varying by university). My guess is that, in this case, nobody at a high level made a decision in the first place, but rather a mid-level organization like MIT security or facilities management instituted the policy. Since they probably are delegated responsibility over building-access systems, they can do that. But the building inhabitants can also try to complain about the way their departments' buildings are being managed. If you were to ask more specifically, "does facilities management or CSAIL own the building?", the answer is sort-of neither, and sort-of both: it's owned by the corporate parent of both of them.
- NotAtWork 12y agoLet's take an extreme: What if MIT were logging who went to the bathroom? There's clearly no fundamental difference in securing a different part of the building. Does Mr Stallman (or perhaps an employee of the building if he's just a third party) not have a basis to criticize MITs tracking of bathroom habits because he (or they) don't own the building? In what way is door access different?
- joezydeco 12y agoI don't think we're talking about bathroom hygenic habits here, so let's skip that derail. Stallman's thesis is "logs have no use". I'm sure the building's owners disagree. Let's think of a possible use-case: "Someone stole a laptop from Room 214 over the weekend" So are the logs useful now?
- ShaneOG 12y agoMost likely, not very. Do you honestly think someone who wants to steal a computer will use their own access card?
- at-fates-hands 12y agoI think you'd be surprised how many people never think about details like that in the commission of a crime. Also, stealing laptops and computer equipment are crimes of opportunity and rarely do people plan out extensively how they can get away with something like that before they do it.
- freiheit 12y agoIf the area/door is busy, they just might. Or they might tailgate through a door. Tailgating through doors is a lot harder when everybody knows that the doors log everything.
- middleclick 12y agoMaybe the person before me took the laptop and I didn't notice? Or maybe the person before that? If a laptop is reported missing, there is no definite proof that the person who entered previous to the one who noticed that the laptop missing took it. Correlation does not equal causation.
- superuser2 12y agoNo, but it narrows down the list from hundreds to a few.
- deleted 12y ago
- ef4 12y agoThat's beside the point. Even Stallman isn't saying that MIT doesn't have the power or authority to do it. He's arguing it's a bad idea to do it.