6 ms·
Don’t Take Your Vitamins
- trumbitta2 12y agoTake your vitamins if a doctor tells you to after proper exams... it's that simple.
- nkozyra 12y agoI don't think it's that simple for a myriad reasons: First, a lot of vitamins are poorly understood in terms of practical effect. We know that a vitamin C deficiency leads to scurvy and that a vitamin D deficiency leads to rickets, etc., but beyond some of the most basic and conclusive cases, it's unlikely you'll be prescribed vitamins and minerals for most trips to the doctor via bloodwork, discussion and other analysis. Second, you'll still want/need pharmaceutical grade vitamins, minerals and supplements. Fish oil has some fairly reliable benefits, but quality can vary immensely. But in many cases, you'll have to do the research, ask the doctor and get their opinion rather than waiting for them to suggest something.
- trumbitta2 12y agoThat's if you want to take vitamins and ask the doctor for an opinion. My point is a doctor should be the one telling you that you actually need vitamins in the first place. But I'm not american, and I sense a high probability of cultural clash here :) [Edit] Example: in Italy if you are somewhat healthy you tend to take the vitamins you need from the food you eat, and if you're not then your doctor will prescribe (is it the right word?) proper exams and then tell you if you need vitamins and which ones.
- matznerd 12y agoMost doctors in the US are not experts on supplementation and they are also not paid by anyone to push them.
- selectodude 12y agoMy doctor in the US has me on a vitamin D supplement and her opinion was unsolicited as to that. I take them every day, everything's good. I wonder if that's not a normal thing here.
- nkozyra 12y agoYes, I'd say there's probably a cultural difference here. Vitamins are not high on the list of things doctors think about when they see a patient here in the U.S. I think there are valid reasons for this - vitamin deficiencies are super rare and there isn't a ton of evidence that much higher levels of any vitamin does anything. Herbs, amino acids, compounds, minerals ... there's a snarky comment below about doctors here not getting paid to push those and sadly that's largely true. Doctors will literally hand out promotional drugs to patients. It's a kind of bizarre situation. Worse yet, unless formulated into a "drug," a manufacturer cannot claim that a substance can cure or prevent a disease. There are two (and a half) sides of this coin. On the one hand, it means that you cannot sell a bottle of Vitamin C that says "will cure and prevent scurvy." On the other hand, the supplementation market is largely unregulated. That's good because people have access to many substances that have a lot of science behind their benefits without waiting on the FDA. And here comes the half - it means that companies can sell things that are dangerous and/or of dubious content. A largely untenable situation for a consumer, but money drives everything.
- jmcphers 12y agoI have read this in several independent books about nutrition: there's a strong correlation between vitamin intake and health, but it disappears if you do a random trial. Moral of the story: be the kind of person who takes vitamins, and then don't worry about actually taking them.
- matznerd 12y agoVitamins are "vital" substances that the body cannot make itself and need to be added from the outside through diet or supplementation. So if your "being the kind of person who takes vitamins" means that you eat an extremely balanced diet that covers all your macros, then you are good, but most people do not eat enough of the right foods. In addition, there are tons of substances that your body can synthesize itself, but would love more of it. Creatine for example can be made in the liver and kidney from L-arginine, glycine, and L-methioninein, but it takes work for your body to do it. It is much more efficient (something like 20X) to just take a creatine supplement and bring it to levels that will allow your body to maximize it's production of the energy molecule ATP (by resupplying a phosphate molecule).
- astrange 12y ago> Vitamins are "vital" substances that the body cannot make itself and need to be added from the outside through diet or supplementation. So if your "being the kind of person who takes vitamins" means that you eat an extremely balanced diet that covers all your macros, then you are good, but most people do not eat enough of the right foods. But we know your first claim is not true, because the body can make Vitamin D by itself. Just because it was called "vitamin" isn't enough to mean anything. And the second claim is just what the article is disproving!
- vixin 12y ago'the body can make Vitamin D by itself'. Sorry for underlining the obvious but no, it can't. It needs sunlight and the prevalence of rickets (as a result of vit D deficiency) in women who by custom, habitually cover themselves and live in somewhat sun-free England is a demonstration of this. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/1936208.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/england/1936208.stm
- manachar 12y agoHere's a relevant visualization that tries to determine how the evidence stacks up. I can't speak to their evaluation of the studies, but it's an interesting addition to the dialog: http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/play/snake-oil-supplements/ http://www.informationisbeautiful.net/play/snake-oil-supplem...
- wwwwwwwwww 12y agohow about "Don't take health advice from econ grad students on the internet, take it from your doctor"
- cperciva 12y agoTo be clear: Serious vitamin deficiencies can cause serious problems (scurvy in the case of vitamin C, rickets in the case of vitamin D, beriberi for vitamin B).1 But if you live in the developed world and eat a normal diet — even a pretty unhealthy one — you will be nowhere near this kind of deficiency. I live in Canada and eat a normal diet. My blood 25-hydroxyvitamin D level was 22 nM. I had symptoms of hypovitaminosis D which went away after taking 150 kIU over the course of a month, at which point my blood level of 25-hydroxyvitamin D had increased to 76 nM. Sure, this is pure anecdote, but it proves that it is possible to be deficient.
- matznerd 12y agoCanada is so north that at this time of the year it is already not having UVB ray penetration, which is required for the body to make Vitamin D.
- imanaccount247 12y agoI'm in Canada and the UV index (which is based on UVB levels) is still hitting 4 or 5 on clear days. That is above the level where you are recommended to wear clothing, hats, sunscreen, etc to avoid burning. How do you figure that is not enough to produce vitamin D?
- strathmeyer 12y agoDid you take pure vitamin D or something naturally high in it such as fish oil?
- exhilaration 12y agoYou don't want fish oil for supplemental vitamin D, you want cod liver. It's usually on the shelf next to the fish oil.
- cperciva 12y agoConsidering that vitamin D is typically measured in nanograms, it would be pretty difficult to take pure vitamin D! But to answer the question I think you're asking: I take pills. Now that I'm on a "maintenance dose" of 1000 IU/day I could theoretically get it from dietary sources if I worked hard; but when I was placed on 5000 IU/day there was no possible way to get enough that way.
- matznerd 12y agoDon't take your vitamin advice from an economist, is what the headline should read... This article is seriously dangerous in planting the false ideas that vitamin D and other supplementation are not worthwhile. The main reason to take Vitamin D has nothing to do with heart disease or cancer, that is why there are not significant beneficial results from the studies testing for that. It is a true straw man argument. Vitamin D is super important for your body and especially for bone development, the brain, and your immune system. It is less a vitamin and more of a hormone, as every single cell in your body has a receptor for it. It is very, very important to supplement it during the winter if you live anywhere above the line from Los Angeles, CA to Colombia, SC [1], as the sun never rises above 50% azimuth and so no UVB rays penetrate the atmosphere and no vitamin D synthesis can take place in the skin. These studies also use what appears from my brief checking, to be way too low of doses. I generally recommend at least 5,000 IU/day and a lot of those studies are between 400 to 600 IU/day. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_effects_of_sun_exposure#Synthesis_of_vitamin_D3 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_effects_of_sun_exposure#...
- Blackthorn 12y agoDoes food not come from the grocery store enriched with Vitamin D for this purpose?
- kazinator 12y agoYes, some of it does; but the doses are ridiculously small.
- matznerd 12y agoMilk is fortified with Vitamin D, but only about 100 IU per serving, so you would need to have around 50 glasses a day to get it. Do you know anyone who drinks that much milk?
- mitchty 12y agoI drink a gallon of milk about every 3 days. Even at that rate its a bit too much.
- scythe 12y agoSo, worth noting is that we might as well attack the question from a theoretical angle as well as an empirical one, when we are choosing to disregard so many studies due to confounders and the like. It turns out that a surprising number of people in developed countries nonetheless suffer vitamin deficiencies: Vitamin D deficiency at 41% of population: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21310306 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21310306 Other deficiencies: http://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2012/p0402_vitamins_nutrients.html http://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2012/p0402_vitamins_nutrie... It is commonly stated that vitamin supplements do not do anything for people who do not have vitamin deficiencies. But even in rich Western countries, a significant proportion of people do have vitamin deficiencies! So the supplements are not always misguided. Worth noting that potassium is never included in vitamin supplements due to technical limitations (high concentrations of potassium are cytotoxic). Eat your vegetables! Also worth noting is I'm drunk so this post contains errors...
- galago 12y agoI knew about the vitamin studies previously, and I also, from experience discussing it with friends, know how upset people become. Its really something people want to believe in.
- zo1 12y agoI can understand the appeal. Vitamins are a sort of "quick fix". All you have to do is pop a pill every day and magically you get benefits x, y and z. There is quite a bit of helplessness involved in life, and vitamins allow people to believe that they have an easy way to control their body. Sure it may be the case. Vitamins probably do help lubricate and enhance all sorts of things, which is intuitive. But that "intuitive" property is exactly the sort of thing we need to watch out for. If a solution/answer seems intuitive, then that pretty much means it has a back-door around our usual bullshit detectors.
- lorddoig 12y agoAn alternative point of view is that it's seriously unlikely to do you any harm and might even do you some good - not to mention that if you are the kind of person who takes vits, it's likely that changing your behaviour off the back of some article will cause some level of psychological stress ("I've got what? I knew I shouldn't have listened to that woman!"). So ignore, and move on.
- mitchty 12y agoThats like saying that doing rain dances can't hurt and might bring rain. If you can't link the two its really not worth doing. Sure vitamins might not do harm (this is questionable), but that doesn't mean they are doing anything productive. Also its just wasteful money wise. Why spend N dollars a year on something that has about as much evidence to back it up as a placebo pill?
- Retric 12y agoAs the article says large random controlled studies demonstrate taking vitamins lower your risk of death. In what way is that like a rain dance? PS: Well assuming your an elderly woman taking vitamin D.
- lincolnq 12y agoI guess it depends on your credibility thresholds. I take vitamin D because some studies say it's good for you, none say it's bad, and some people on the internet report subjective cognitive & mood enhancement. It costs me around $5/year. Sure, it might be doing nothing. But even a subtle cognitive or mood enhancement would easily be worth two orders of magnitude more than that, so I only have to think there's a 1% chance of a tiny effect before it becomes worth it.
- jjoonathan 12y agoI think P(rain dances bring rain) is several orders of magnitude smaller than P(diet goes to shit, experience some weird deficiency). Is $20/yr really so much to pay for peace of mind that you aren't slowly degrading your bones or something?
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- brownbat 12y agoA few commenters are dismissive of Oster as an economist commenting on health issues. Let's set aside the fact that "health across populations" has basically been Oster's research focus throughout her career. There's a bigger issue here than the mistaken belief that she's not an expert on this subject. If the drive for credentialism means that we don't allow smart statisticians to review existing literature, then we've failed at whatever we're trying to achieve. I think I understand the drive for expert-only opinions. We've probably all been disappointed by misinformed scientific discussions, probably on some policy issue. Excluding opinions from random people on the street yields more productive discussions. After random people on the street, we might also exclude people in positions of irrelevant authority, like religious or political leaders. We might continue to exclude voices right up until we're just left with those who have actually conducted some research directly on topic. There comes a point, though, where by narrowing the field of voices you listen to, you're actually lowering the signal/noise ratio rather than upping it. In fact, if you can only talk to one person about scientific consensus, absolutely do not ask a scientist in that field. One researcher out of a field full of contentious debates is a terrible sample! If you can only talk to one person, start with a smart statistician who engages in lit reviews or meta-analysis. That way you have one conversation, but sample a much greater percentage of the field, and you get to hear it from someone who has some distance from the interpersonal debates going on in that narrow corner of academia. If you can only talk to one person about a topic, talk to someone like Emily Oster.
- lorddoig 12y agoRegardless of most of that - she doesn't need to be an expert on vitamins or biomed as this article is an analysis of the statistics that have come from the actual experts work, which she's very qualified to do.
- viggity 12y agoI know this is anecdotal but here it goes anyway. I've had bariatric surgery and as such my physician orders a full blood panel once a year. I had a significant deficiency in vitamin D, B12 and Iron. After taking supplements for 3 months they all returned close to recommended levels. One difference may be the specific bio availability of the supplements I take. The Vitamin D is D3 (it is an oil filled gelcap) which increases your body's ability to absorb it. The powdered Vitamin D is supposedly worthless. I take 50,000 IU twice a week, most pills you buy from the store are 250 to 1000 IU, although you can find 5,000 IU. The B12 is a sublingual tablet which increases bioavailability, but unsure how much better it is supposed to be compared to what you'd normally find in a multi vitamin. Lastly, the Iron supplement - Feosol with Bifera has two kinds of iron (HIP and PIC) which minimizes side effects and increases bio availability. I started taking bifera before the other two and the increase in my energy levels after a week or two was really quite remarkable. As other people have stated, this is something you should probably talk with your doctor about, but try to be as informed as possible when you do.
- TillE 12y ago> B12 and Iron Vegan? B12 supplementation is mandatory if you eat little or no meat, and iron is usually an issue too. Either you have to eat iron-rich plants with vitamin C in the same meal, or you take supplements.
- dchest 12y agoSee also "Vitamins and Supplements: An Evidence-Based Approach" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2mDrAQi1SwU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2mDrAQi1SwU
- jrapdx3 12y agoMentioning vitamin D is a great way to start an argument, especially what is an optimum level for humans as measured in a blood sample. The controversy certainly comes up frequently at the medical conferences I attend. The "evidence base" remains unsettled, and there's a wide range of interpretations of the ideal range for vitamin D levels or intake. The conservative recommended level is 20 ng/ml, but there is substantial opinion that the minimal level of 20 ng/ml is way too low, and that 40 to 60 ng/ml is consistent with historic human environmental conditions. Here's my take on the subject. Depending on where you live, it may be important or not. I agree with the comments here: the further north you reside, the greater the risk of inadequate body level of vitamin D and attendant health consequences. At my location just north of the 45th parallel, I order D levels frequently and about half of patients show D level <30. (Reference range: 30-100 ng/ml.) Low levels have been associated with many conditions, but I'd point out cognitive dysfunction and depressed mood as less widely known effects. Vitamin D is an enzyme co-factor at rate-limiting steps in pathways of CNS neurotransmitters synthesis. Negative effects on brain functioning are a logical consequence of D deficiency. Human populations indigenous to arctic regions have only a few months a year of enough UVB exposure for synthesis of D in the skin. Yet they have survived at far north locations for a millennium. How is that possible? Consider their diet, very high in fish and seafood, e.g., 100g of salmon contains around 350 IU of D, so easily intake >=2000 IU/day. We recommend D supplementation of 2000 IU/day and calcium 1g/day for most people who live north of 40th parallel, especially people living in rainy coastal climates. Vitamin D toxicity can develop with super-high doses of D. I've seen it a few times, but only with very high amounts (>10kIU/day) over months of excessive intake. At any reasonable amount, say 5kIU/day, toxicity is very unlikely. In any case it's easy to check blood level if a reason to suspect it and advise accordingly.
- imanaccount247 12y agoSupplement means "I am not getting enough, so I supplement my intake with this". Of course it is not helpful to take a supplement when you don't need supplementation. The problem is, plenty of people do need supplementation, and vitamin supplements work perfectly well for their intended purpose.
- JeremyNT 12y agoExamine, a source I generally trust, recommends vitamin D supplementation [0] while also noting that its benefits have been overstated [1]. They do agree that vitamin E, however, should not generally be supplemented [2] I find the "Don't Take Your Vitamins" title to be especially linkbaity and misleading. The reality is closer to: "you probably don't gain anything by taking some vitamins." Examine notes that vitamin D is both safe and cost effective, so there is very little downside to taking it even if the magnitude and certainty of benefit is still somewhat unclear. [0] http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+D/ http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+D/ [1] http://examine.com/blog/the-truth-about-vitamin-d/ http://examine.com/blog/the-truth-about-vitamin-d/ [2] http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+E/ http://examine.com/supplements/Vitamin+E/
- osmala 12y agoIs this the guy who's did the paper which is refuted by researcher Rhonda Patric Phd in medicine. Quite simply if you are on of the 96% of americans who don't take vitamins who have deficiency of said vitamins in your blood it does help to take them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0u8UdZeOhc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0u8UdZeOhc