13 ms·
Uber Drivers “Strike” and Switch to Lyft Over Fares and Conditions
- jonifico 12y agoSo they were fine and dandy until a better competition came around. When Lyft has its rival, same thing will happen.
- deadfall 12y agoWhat about Sidecar? Isn't that Lyft's rival? I think SideCar and Lyft are about the same service since they don't offer black town cars/luxury SUVs.
- viscanti 12y agohttp://fortune.com/2014/09/11/uber-vs-lyft-the-credit-cards-dont-lie/ http://fortune.com/2014/09/11/uber-vs-lyft-the-credit-cards-... It doesn't look like a lot of competition honestly. That probably paints Lyft in the best possible light too because it just takes into account US only trips (100% of Lyft's business and only a fraction of Uber's). But even then, that's only competition for the uberx market. These drivers are black car drivers, where uber has no competition at all.
- SEJeff 12y agoThis is how capitalism works, survival of the fittest. If someone comes along that allows the drivers to make more money, prudent drivers will likely switch to that service. It is a no brainer.
- philip1209 12y agoIt's amusing because fewer drivers online will trigger multiplier, thus increasing their pay.
- aetherson 12y agoYeah, but that pisses off passengers and drives them to try Uber competitors.
- tdicola 12y agoAnd the irony is this is exactly what Uber is doing to the traditional taxi industry.
- SEJeff 12y agoBut the best part of this is that as a consumer of taxi services and digital ones like Uber (I've not used Lyft but love Uber), we get cheaper and ultimately better service by them competing. I say bring on the competition!
- mkal_tsr 12y ago> This is how capitalism works, survival of the fittest* * Unless you have enough money to change regulations in your favor, skirt regulations, and so on, in which case it's survival of the financially-backed.
- aeturnum 12y agoAccess to capital and the political world are part of "fitness" in this environment. Generally, the companies that are seen as most likely to survive have easier access to funding than companies that are seen as riskier. The same can be said of companies that are likely to succeed v.s. simply survive.
- mkal_tsr 12y agoDon't forget that even if you have a stellar implementation and great service, you may not be able to secure financing for marketing/lawyers/etc. or other "gate-keepers" that would enable financing ... thus there's the "who you know / who you can influence" aspect. I guess that's kind of my issue when I see people talk about how great a free-market is, when the reality is that our "free"-market has numerous levels and types of gatekeepers which prevent those "genetically"-strong startups/companies from disrupting. Hmm, my explanation on that was absurdly bad, I apologize, but hopefully you kinda get what I'm saying, hehe.
- jackpirate 12y agoIf you're willing to redefine fitness like that, then any economic system is by definition "survival of the fittest."
- innguest 12y agoStatists, take notice of how improvements in work conditions come from competition and not from regulation. They're better off now than through the monopoly of taxi medallions.
- dragonwriter 12y agoAnd anti-statists should take notice of how many improvements in working condition did require regulation, and how the Uber/Lyft market has special features (particularly, the fact that the primary service being provided to the end customer is provided entirely by one worker using their own capital and that the fact that what Uber/Lyft provide is essentially a matchmaking service where there is very low friction for a driver to switch services and for the other service to absorb new drivers -- which is not true in many other industries regardless of how competitive they may be on the consumer end. Even in a competitive market for autos, the capital dependence of the industry -- and potentially geographical separation between plants -- means that if the workers in Alan's factory are upset with their working conditions, they very likely can't just walk over to Bob's factory en-masse and sign up to work there. The ability to do that with certain services that are 1:1 and where the middleman is just providing matchmaking gives the individual service providers more power to set working conditions with the middleman in a market where there are competing middlemen then would be the case in many industries.
- innguest 12y agoWhat's happening right now to Uber and Lyft is a metaphor for how the free market works. You've touched on a few interesting points yourself: "provided entirely by one worker" : this is like admitting that the problem comes from injecting hierarchy into the system, which in a free market can only happen voluntarily if both parties benefit from it, but in a statist society is imposed or restricted by the economy planners through regulation. "essentially a matchmaking service where there is very low [switching] friction" : every market is a matchmaking service between the seller and the buyer, and the way to sustain low friction is to have as little regulation as possible (you will see the Uber/Lyft_fuelled prosperity (e.g. happy workers) disappear if the government steps in, and it will decrease wages to the point that it will be equal to the taxi market which is heavily regulated) "which is not true in many other industries" : how can we know? "many other industries" are mostly regulated, and heavily so.You're saying deregulation doesn't work in other industries because they're already regulated. The problem of workers and factories, as far as I know, is solved by unions. However, historically governments have regulated unions as well. Cf. Bangladeshi garment workers, their poor working conditions and their torturing of labor organizers.
- ForHackernews 12y agoWhat would it take for somebody to just build a free, open-source matchmaking service for drivers and riders? It doesn't seem like what Lyft or Uber offer is very technically demanding (perhaps doing it at scale is), and presumably you could attract a lot more drivers by offering them the chance to keep ~99% of the fare. The existence of Lyft demonstrates that Uber's first-mover advantage isn't insurmountable, so who's to say the third-mover shouldn't be a free utility that provides matchmaking at cost?
- spydertennis 12y agoInteresting consequence of the lower cost of technical resources. I'm guessing the higher cost would be in marketing the service to get initial critical mass.
- eli 12y agoI think Sidecar lets each driver set their own rate. It would take a whole lot more than 1% of the fare to keep the system running though.
- grogenaut 12y agoWhy would you say that?
- badusername 12y agoCredit card processing itself cost 2.7%, on average.
- grogenaut 12y agoSo charge 1% over fees
- eli 12y agoJust managing disputes between rider and driver would cost more than that. Since you're the one running the credit cards, you're going to be on the hook for all chargebacks and fraud. And are you going to vet drivers at all? Check that they have a license and insurance?
- drivingmenuts 12y agoI thought the whole point of Uber and Lyft was that didn't have to be full-time occupations.
- seanmccann 12y agoMany folks do it full-time because it pays more than the their other job. There are also incentives if they driver full-time hours.
- eipipuz 12y agoThat's what I thought, but now it's rare when I see a driver that isn't a full-timer. I'm sure the system works better with stability so the incentives push towards full-timers.
- pkfrank 12y agoI almost hope that Lyft is orchestrating all of this behind the scenes. It would be such an Uber-move.
- smacktoward 12y agoUpdate -- Uber reverses policy: http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2014/09/12/uber_drivers_strike_they_protested_cheap_uberx_fares_uber_backed_down.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2014/09/12/uber_drivers_...
- ivraatiems 12y agoI'm genuinely surprised. I imagine this is just a policy of minimum appeasement, but it's very interesting how rapid the change was. Edit: Also, the strike is going forward - not all of their demands were met. Maybe this is just so Uber can say "hey, we tried to do what they asked?"
- viscanti 12y agoOr maybe the strike is closer to what happened last year in SF, where a bunch of drivers who were banned from the uber system because of low quality scores protested for other reasons. Something doesn't add up with the strike anyway (the threat to leave Uber because some trips might be on uberx, but to go to lyft where all their trips would be at that level and they'd make less doesn't make sense). The fact that the strike is still going forward makes it pretty clear it's not about having to make more money per hour by doing uberx trips.
- modfodder 12y agoOr maybe now that a large group of drivers have an impact on Uber, they want to continue to build muscle. If it was something other than accepting UberX fares, Uber wouldn't have caved (they're too smart for that). No this points in at the very least a small shift in negotiating power between Uber and its drivers. The fact that Uber caved makes it pretty clear Uber knows it was in the wrong and they are starting to fear a unified group of drivers.
- Shivetya 12y agoIts bound to happen as long as there is a viable competitor within the market. Until then Uber really doesn't have a choice, they cannot lock in drivers.
- jefflinwood 12y agoThe really interesting story here is that if drivers are so willing to switch networks for better opportunities, there isn't a compelling reason for Uber to have the valuation that they do. The value of Uber isn't really in the tech or the app - it's in the networks of riders and drivers in each city. If each of those can be aggregated into some other kind of service, where Uber, Lyft, etc. are just providers of payment processing, and possibly some operations expertise, that middleman network will capture all of the value.
- smacktoward 12y agoI'm not sure a middleman service is even really necessary. There's plenty of drivers right now driving for multiple services. The more services there are, the more competition there is for drivers' time, which means drivers have more leverage. One could read Uber's insistence on canning drivers who turn down too many rides as an attempt to reduce this leverage, since the only way drivers can exercise it is to turn down Uber rides in order to drive for somebody else. Requiring them to accept a certain volume of Uber rides effectively ties them to Uber.
- jkestner 12y ago> There's plenty of drivers right now driving for multiple services. The more services there are, the more competition there is for drivers' time, which means drivers have more leverage. We're gonna need an Uber for Ubers. But of course a middleman is necessary - who's going to match customers and available drivers? But if drivers have the leverage, it could resemble more of an agent relationship. Why haven't Uber/Lyft demanded exclusivity with drivers?
- smacktoward 12y agoThe services match customers and drivers; they just don't do so authoritatively. Instead, you have a sort of pseudo-auction going on for chunks of drivers' time. Each match from a service is essentially a bid. If there's only one bid, the driver takes it; if there's multiple bids, she chooses the one that best fits her circumstances and turns down the others. > Why haven't Uber/Lyft demanded exclusivity with drivers? That was my point above, it sounds like that is what Uber, at least, is trying to do. They want their drivers to be Uber drivers first and foremost, so they punish drivers who turn down too many Uber-proposed rides. Of course, if that's the relationship they want to have with their drivers, it sort of calls into question how "independent" those independent-contractor drivers really are. If Uber wants drivers to only drive for Uber, they could always just hire them as full-time employees. That would cost them money, though, so instead they prefer to keep their drivers as contractors and just force them to behave like employees instead.
- seanmccann 12y agoIt's great to see how easy it is for drivers to switch networks if they are unhappy, but drivers have to understand that prices are going down and they'll likely earn less money over time on all networks. When articles are posted about Uber drivers earning $90k/yr, I'm sure many folks quit their $40k office job and hit the road. The thing is, driving taxi is pretty low skilled so the growing supply of drivers will really push down their income. There's an efficiency problem when an Uber driver "can earn" more than 75% of Americans, and existing drivers have been reaping the benefits of those inefficiencies.
- potatolicious 12y agoEven if $90K a year is sustainable, driving a taxi is a very high-expense business. You'll drive your car into the ground far quicker than you did before, insurance is going to be insanely expensive (an UberX driver I talked to once told me his insurance is $7K a year), and gasoline isn't free (and getting less and less free every day). The take-home from $90K driving taxis is very different than the take-home from $90K sitting at a desk.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Pxtl 12y agoI'm going to go ahead and assume there's an app that aggregates Uber/Lyft/whatever and just gets you the closest driver regardless of network. Uber's service goes from being a premium product to a replaceable commodity in a blink.
- aetherson 12y agoWell, Uber, Lyft, and whoever will fight such an aggregator for obvious reasons, and attempt to prevent them from accessing their APIs.
- josephjrobison 12y agoNot sure about an app, but there's a cool site that does it - http://www.whatsthefare.com/ http://www.whatsthefare.com/
- jbigelow76 12y agoThe drivers, who are mostly comprised of SUV and black car drivers, have planned a protest outside of the Long Island City Uber Office I wonder how much good the office protest will do versus just emailing Uber saying "Adios Uber! I'm headed to Lyft because of..." The on site picketing made sense for blue collar industrial and government workers because the switching cost of quitting your job and (hoping) to get hired at another plant would have been very high. For hire drivers working for Uber and Lyft essentially have close to zero switching costs. A demonstration of that would seem more effective than picketing.
- peatmoss 12y agoThe media attention that drivers get through this action help signal to consumers that they are moving to a competitor. This might make me (a rider) more likely to fire up the Lyft app instead of Uber next time I need a ride.
- jbigelow76 12y agoTrue, media attention is important but I wonder if the protest will make it onto more mainstream channels and not just the tech news/blogosphere. Local papers in Dallas have been doing quite a bit of coverage as Uber and Lyft taken on the politically connected taxi industry here. I don't know if intra-service fighting would get as much attention. Maybe some HNers in the Long Island area will chime in.
- TillE 12y ago> in the Long Island area Long Island City is right across the river from Manhattan. It's technically on the Island, but for most people Long Island = Suffolk and Nassau, not Brooklyn and Queens.
- whitej125 12y agoWait, strike? First off...IANAUD. If you become an Uber Driver are you under any sort of contract? Are you now an employee (W-2) of Uber or free agent contractor (1099). If drivers think they can get better fares elsewhere... go nuts and do it. Yay economics! I feel like I am missing something here.
- viscanti 12y agoThis. Although I don't understand the argument from the driver's side. They're upset about sometimes getting trips from uberx (and apparently making more doing so), so they're going to a place that pays less per trip and per hour? Something doesn't add up there. If there was a factual claim here, I have to believe that they'd be sharing their numbers. It would be trivial for them to show a decrease in earnings (they can easily calculate gas and wear-and-tear) in the before-and-after earnings. The fact that that isn't happening makes me believe this is similar to the protests last year in SF. From the reports back then, it ended up being mostly drivers who had been banned from the uber platform who were trying to be reinstated (although that's not what they claimed).
- bitJericho 12y agoMay I ask what you make per hour?
- vertex-four 12y ago> They're upset about sometimes getting trips from uberx (and apparently making more doing so), so they're going to a place that pays less per trip and per hour? They're trying to convince Uber to stop doing what they don't want (according to them, they do not make more by accepting UberX fares, no matter what the company says) by denying them labour. In the meantime, they're doing work elsewhere, although are hoping not to permanently work there; they're hoping that Uber will cave in. Denial of labour ("striking") is a tried-and-tested approach to persuading companies to do what the labourers want. They can't operate without labour, so labourers organise to deny them that until they get better working conditions/better pay/etc. Assuming enough labourers agree to deny labour, this will work unless (a) what the labourers want, the company literally cannot provide without going bust, or (b) there are enough people looking for jobs and willing to put up with the bad terms that the company can hire them to replace the striking labourers. This is a relatively simple idea, and has been a thing since the Industrial Revolution; I'm not really sure what you're not getting.
- ed 12y agoI can think of two possible sources of driver lock-in: insurance (on the clock but between rides) and car financing. Anyone heard of uber or lyft working on this?
- philiphodgen 12y agoThere is another reason: employment status and the resulting side-effects. If you lock in a driver, you start to look like an employer with employees. This creates enormous payroll tax responsibility, workers comp insurance and other headaches for Uber/Lyft. I would bet that Uber/Lyft have burned a metric crapton of lawyer and accountant brains in an effort to be on the "safe" side of the independent contractor vs employee fight. They're not going to screw that up.
- loceng 12y agoThis is how free market capitalism is supposed to work - where mobility (switching services) is low to non-existent and so then users can migrate en mass to the ecosystem that is governed better or more in their favour.
- pptr1 12y agoWhy not have a social network for professional drivers. Let that network destroy any type of information withholding that companies like uber do. Leverage the power of scale. Unions 2.0
- stefan_kendall3 12y agoSounds like the market is demanding UberX, and Uber is responding. I'll keep using UberX in cars that don't need $80/day in gas.
- spiritplumber 12y agoExcellent, this shifts the balance of power a little. Looks like the whole "everyone is a free agent" thing has some benefit for the little guys too.
- sprkyco 12y agoThat's awesome I cancelled my account last month due to the issue of "we are lowering prices for summer" me thinking naively that this meant eventually prices would go up after a month or two. However after receiving not only notification that the prices would not go up further (Houston drivers at a minimum) but also I would now be required to pay 10 dollars a week to maintain service. Prior to Uber I was thinking the sharing ecnonomy was an embodiment of a change in corporate attitudes. F me right?
- omnivore 12y agoMy ugly questions on this are: What about liability for when an Uber or Lyft driver kills someone in an accident driving unsafely? Or just murders someone because they're having a bad day? Or get carjacked? I mean, I guess it's just one spree away from people doing dangerous things?
- robbyking 12y agoThe only reason to phrase your question the way you did is to increase the FUD surrounding car services like Uber and Lyft. The same question could be asked of any person in any profession. Regardless, the answer to your question is the first result when you search Google for "Uber liability coverage": > Uber holds a commercial insurance policy with $1 million of coverage per incident. Drivers’ liability to third parties is covered from the moment a driver accepts a trip to its conclusion. This policy is expressly primary to any personal auto coverage (However it will not take precedence over any commercial auto insurance for the vehicle). We have provided a $1 million liability policy since commencing ridesharing in early 2013. http://blog.uber.com/ridesharinginsurance http://blog.uber.com/ridesharinginsurance
- ColinCera 12y agoIt's a legitimate question because Uber and Lyft are a "new thing" and they're international brand names, something that's not true of regular cab services. If a cab driver in New York City rapes and kills a passenger, it wouldn't make people distrust all cabs in NYC, much less cabs in other cities; there's no brand name to be damaged by news coverage, and as a news story it probably wouldn't even be covered by media outside of the NYC area. But if an Uber driver rapes and kills a passenger, it will be covered by media everywhere, because Uber is a newsworthy company and because Uber has a global presence, and the Uber brand will be damaged worldwide, not just locally. Because Uber is a "new thing" there will be lots of people/media asking questions about the safety of Uber (in many cases stupid questions, but still).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ChrisAntaki 12y agoLyft drivers are creeped out by Uber. "Operation: Shave the Stache" [1] is one of the most manipulative business practices I've heard of. Lyft chooses to invest its money on improving the experience inside the car, and hiring socially intelligent people, who they then treat like human beings. Uber could learn a lot from them. [1] http://www.theverge.com/2014/8/26/6067663/this-is-ubers-playbook-for-sabotaging-lyft http://www.theverge.com/2014/8/26/6067663/this-is-ubers-play...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- abalone 12y agoThis is a much more specific issue than most of the comments here are making it. People are talking about capitalism, competition, etc... The problem is simply that a couple weeks ago Uber started sending UberX fares to Uber black car drivers. Which was a dumb move, because they are unprofitable and undercut the value of the premium car service. They've now reversed that dumb move.
- anateus 12y agoExactly. This was a protest over a very specific issue, and Uber ended up listening. The article surprisingly doesn't really spin this into generalized pontificating and really talks about this specific grievance at length. HN commenters however are responding as if this was a general piece on Uber's failings as a whole... Strange.
- gaikokujin 12y agoThe bottom line is: If you're easily replaceable, you will feel the squeeze sooner or later. Been in those kind of jobs myself and the only way out is to upskill until your value as a worker is high enough that ruthless managers that couldn't care less about the impact of their decisions on individuals won't get away with it.
- igl 12y agoFollowed this Uber thing for a little, Read a few articles from the neo liberal tech press, specially interesting when Uber was banned in germany. Initial Reaction to this: haha
- tjbt 12y agoThe current incarnation of ride shating is fatally flawed. I imagine a superior model in which there is no direct reward for picking somebody up, rather a network of normal people, who can submit and receive requests to pick up. The only compensation would be that in a splitting of gas, which could potentially be done automatically. The main difficulty in getting a network like this to succeed is the fact that there is no incentive for new drivers to join. Until then, they are just a taxi company with lax employment protocol.
- 11Blade 12y agoClearly the cracks are starting to show. If the drivers create the value/provide the service and Uber is facilitating that by taking a share, it has to make sense for the value-creator/service provider to continue the relationship. If Uber erodes that margin, the drivers will leave. Eventually Uber has to change to benefit their service providers and act a little more ethically. The drivers know of their underhanded ways with dealing with Lyft and eventually the public will. I am an immigrant, I drove a black car in NYC(many years ago), my cousin drives one now. He is none too happy with the UberX situation right now. Uber should consider the plight of the drivers and not their 100X VC overlords. Nobody ever got rich driving a cab, why victimize the drivers? "Because we can?" "We are making the market more efficient" "Frictionless" It is just at the expense of the drivers. That's your friction point. Hard working people just want a fair shot, not to be exploited. Instead of a billion-dollar pay day, why not just a little human decency.
- zobzu 12y agoHeh they get banned if they accept/deny or plain deny more than 50% of the requests it says in the article.. that seems legit to me as a customer ;) dont really want drivers (of uber or any similar company) to accept/refuse my rides.