12 ms·
I'm one of those drivers who hates sharing roadways with bikers. It's not that I have to share, but between slowing traffic down, pure safety concerns for the b
by bane 12y ago
I'm one of those drivers who hates sharing roadways with bikers. It's not that I have to share, but between slowing traffic down, pure safety concerns for the biker (who I as the automobile driver am responsible for in the case of an accident) and the generally shitty entitled attitude lots of bike riders seem to have (probably earned from dealing with irritated drivers like me) I get my hackles raised every time I see one on the roads. Bikes aren't automobiles no matter how much we debate about it. They shouldn't be sharing the road with cars.
But you know what? I'm absolutely in favor of this kind of road engineering. Regardless of making traffic faster or not, it's just smart design. Between roads, sidewalks and bike lanes, this provides a designated travel area for everybody regardless of the mode they choose to travel with. Bikes shouldn't be sharing the road with cars, they should have their own designated travel areas.
It eliminates all three of my issues in one swoop and provides equitable space for sharing the travel conduits in a city. In fact, it would probably get me out on a bike more often.
- lotsofmangos 12y ago"I get my hackles raised every time I see one on the roads. Bikes aren't automobiles no matter how much we debate about it. They shouldn't be sharing the road with cars." Horses must really piss you off then.
- HCIdivision17 12y agoI don't know if you're joking, but horses aren't much fun to share a road with either. They're slower than the traffic and literally defecate anywhere. It's positively impressive how much urine can be left behind at a stop light.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoRoad users come in many types. At one point cities were full of horse shit and now they are full of smog from vehicle fumes. No matter your preferred choice of ride, other people's choices may interfere with your day, but it is your choice if you let that get you angry. Personally, I think people who become dangerously enraged from having to deal with other forms of transport, should probably not be operating a motorised vehicle on the public roads in the first place.
- HCIdivision17 12y agoTo be sure, driving emotionally is a terribly dangerous thing to do. Personally I thought it was cool to see the horses, but the plant engineer in me fears animals on the road (no matter how big). And the motorcyclist in me fears the giant heap of poo to slip on. My attitude is whatever has the most momentum gets right of way; but again, I think forklifts will do that to a person. I doubt I could ever have the nerve to ride a bicycle in a city.
- bane 12y agoPeople around where I live are smart enough to keep their horses off of the roads and onto horse trails (or in a trailer when they're transporting them). And despite having hundreds of miles of dedicated bike trails I still get stuck behind some guy in full bike kit going 15 mph in the middle an undivided 2 lane 45 with double yellow at least once a week. Being a 15-20 minutes late because he couldn't be bothered to drive his bike to one of the bike trails to play 'Tour De France' is beyond irritating.
- heydenberk 12y agoBeing in a full bike kit doesn't mean someone is playing Tour de France. For people (like me) whose quotidian bike commute is 10+ miles each, it is incredibly uncomfortable to wear street clothes, and it's very inconvenient to ride several 5+ miles out of the way to take an isolated path. Besides which, the impossibly small portion of infrastructure that doesn't allow car traffic often requires cyclists and pedestrians to mix on narrow paths that are poorly maintained.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoHang on, you want the people who are currently cycling, to drive cars containing bicycles to where the dedicated lanes are, park these cars, then cycle on, because you think this will stop you being delayed in traffic as much? Are you this irrational in general, or is it just on this topic?
- bane 12y agoI don't give a bag of squirrels how they get there, so long as they aren't putting themselves and me in danger or inconvenience. I'm not responsible for their decision to bike, how they get to the trails is not my concern. They've decided to take up this hobby not me. I shouldn't be penalized or made liable for their decision. It's not their right to impose upon me their safekeeping because they decided to take an unsafe and alternate form of transportation on road surfaces that are clearly not engineered or planned for bike usage. If they want to lobby for better bike trails and safer areas to bike. I'll be right out there holding the sign at the rally. I'll even give up extra income in the form of tax dollars to make it a reality. Because it's good for everybody. But biking on high speed roads that are unsafe for bikes isn't good for anybody.
- GFischer 12y agoWell, today the entire traffic in a (supposedly) main thoroughfare in Montevideo in which I was driving was slowed to a crawl due to a horse-drawn carriage. Not to mention they're a huge source of accidents (including mortal ones), when the horse freaks out. Yes, they're a huge problem. http://www.bluechannel24.com/?p=23885 http://www.bluechannel24.com/?p=23885 http://www.pulsamerica.co.uk/2012/07/02/uruguay-crusade-to-forbid-carts-pulled-by-horses/ http://www.pulsamerica.co.uk/2012/07/02/uruguay-crusade-to-f...
- shiftpgdn 12y agoA cyclist is just a brief inconvenience. It's the same as a school bus or slow driver in a lane requiring you to go around. Every bike on the road is one less car causing traffic. It's crazy to want infrastructure for JUST cyclists when the road is a perfectly good way to travel.
- derekp7 12y agoI'm OK with the occasional cyclist. It is when there is a group of 30 from a club riding in a pack, going 15 MPH, on a 45 MPH highway with not a lot of passing areas that get irritating. The other thing that I don't like is having to pass the same cyclist several times in traffic. They pass you on the right when traffic is stoped, but don't move over so you can pass them on the left when traffic starts to move again.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoIm sure its annoying, but its that way for a reason. You are belted into a multi-thousand-pound steel-reinforced vehicle. They are riding on some pipes with a Styrofoam block strapped to their head. I most states its legal for cycles (motor and non) to pass cars and pull to the head of the line at a light. Not sure why; but that's the way it is. Stopped cars + agile cyclist = no problem. When traffic is moving after the light, the car sure as heck better leave some room for the cycle, because any error there means an ambulance.
- goblin89 12y ago> I most states its legal for cycles (motor and non) to pass cars and pull to the head of the line at a light. Not sure why; but that's the way it is. Try staying for a minute or two behind a vehicle that has its engine running and burning fuel. In a line at a light inhaling exhaust is enough to make you dizzy—at least that's what happened to me when I tried it once. Always pulling right to the light afterwards.
- watwut 12y agoThe car passing and pulling to the head of the line makes more sense for motorcycles. They have faster starts then cars and are relatively more vulnerable. If they go first they do not slow starting cars down while lowering the chance of collision.
- osconfused 12y agoSharing is caring. Learn to love, not hate.
- msandford 12y ago> Bikes aren't automobiles no matter how much we debate about it. They shouldn't be sharing the road with cars. While I understand the sentiment you need to understand that cyclists are put in a pretty awkward legal situation themselves. They exist in a no-mans-land between pedestrians and vehicles. Sidewalks are often too narrow, too close to blind corners, etc for safety. They're often VERY bumpy. At 2mph a sidewalk is fine, but at 15mph it tries to shake your bicycle apart. Pedestrians don't expect cyclists on the sidewalk and that can make for horrific collisions. In the street cyclists get no respect. Cars cut cyclists off making right turns regularly. "Dooring" is a very real phenomena that can put people in the hospital. Cyclists regularly get killed by cars and the drivers suffer no real consequences. Here's a NYT article on precisely this subject: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/10/opinion/sunday/is-it-ok-to-kill-cyclists.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/10/opinion/sunday/is-it-ok-to... > pure safety concerns for the biker (who I as the automobile driver am responsible for in the case of an accident) As you can see from the NYT article that's often not true at all. The police tend to look at cyclists the way you do, and many times don't find fault with drivers even if cyclists are KILLED much less injured or have their bikes destroyed. > generally shitty entitled attitude lots of bike riders seem to have (probably earned from dealing with irritated drivers like me) A lot of the shitty attitude has to do with a constant fear of death. Further cyclists are definitely treated as second class citizens on the road, despite being required to obey all traffic laws however ill-suited they are for pedal powered vehicles. But if the law applies evenly to cars and bikes then cyclists have every right their three feet of roadway and possibly the WHOLE lane (depending on how wide the shoulder is and the lanes are) without fearing for their lives. But often that's not the case. It makes "sharing the road" a very adversarial experience and worse is that cyclists can't see who's about to run them over, honk at them, swerve far closer than legal, throw something, etc because the cars are usually going faster than the cyclist. The idea that bike riders have shitty attitudes and drivers do not is a non-starter. The problem -- as you've stated -- is best solved by making dedicated room for cyclists rather than expecting everyone to just magically get along in situation which rewards neither for doing so.
- mindslight 12y ago> The police tend to look at cyclists the way you do, and many times don't find fault with drivers even if cyclists are KILLED much less injured or have their bikes destroyed. I mostly drive these days, but I'm no friend of cars in general or police for that matter. However it's important to keep in mind that injustices occur both ways, and forming blanket statements is a great way to end up just talking past one another. Many drivers do stupid things (eg right turns, doors), many bikers do stupid things (eg ride on wrong side of road, sidewalks). That doesn't indict either group. If 'bane is worried about being wrongfully found at fault for an accident with an irresponsible biker, I would say the best approach would be to get a dash cam (or five).
- mindslight 12y agoHave you ever tried walking between a residential area and a commercial one in a suburban area? Most places don't keep up or even fully create the second system of sidewalks - what makes you think they would actually do so for a third system? By far, most roads we travel on have no expectation of minimum speed, passability, etc. The exceptions that do are called controlled access highways and indeed bikes, pedestrians, horses, tractors (etc) are not allowed.
- bane 12y agoBecause by and large the road system is already there (and being used for cyclists). Extended the shoulder out a bit and putting a stick figure on a bike every quarter mile to show it's a place where bikes are supposed to go is at a minimum what I'm calling for.
- songshu 12y agoI bike, drive and walk in Manhattan frequently and find that I am delayed in each case by all of the modes fairly often, and cars certainly get in the way the most, especially to pedestrians. Whichever delay it is, it's just traffic. Sometimes I'll be upset about it, sometimes not. The attitude of some drivers that certain traffic is better than others is bizarrely entitled.
- soperj 12y agoI'm one of those bikers who hates sharing roadways with cars. It's not that I have to share, but between taking up so much of the road, pure safety concerns for bikers(since automobile drivers win every single colition) and generally shitty entitled attitude lots of car drivers seem to have (most likely because there are more of them so they think they own the road) I get my hackles raised every time I see one on the roads. Automobiles aren't bikes no matter how much we debate about it. They shouldn't be sharing the roads with bikes. I see more people driving break the law every day while driving then I've ever seen bikers do in my entire life. People are jerks regardless of what they use to commute with.
- fidlefodl 12y ago> I see more people driving break the law every day while driving then I've ever seen bikers do in my entire life. People are jerks regardless of what they use to commute with. I don't think he (or many) would claim otherwise. The issue isn't the people who ride bikes, but rather the mode they choose to travel with and the impact it has on your drive. Bikers cause all sorts of added danger to both themselves, and you as a driver. If you have a moment of human error in car-v-car, you're very likely to have both parties walk away from the incident. You call your insurance(s), your rates go up a bit, and your life moves on. Accidents are very, very common. Repeat this same scenario in car-v-biker, and the odds quickly swing towards it being a life endangering accident. It's just a step away from hitting a pedestrian. I don't dislike bikers because they slow me down or anything like that. I dislike them because of the likely increase in severity for almost all car-v-biker accidents. edit: Interesting, seems i am getting downvotes for my opinion. Care to explain your thoughts? I can't imagine you (downvoters) feel that car-v-biker is an equal risk compared to car-v-car, do you?
- everyone 12y agoVarious car related taxes and levies dont even begin to finanace the cost of road building and maintainance. Most of that comes from VAT and income tax.
- 12y ago
- Pxtl 12y agoMy list of pet peeves As a cyclist: motorists As a motorist: cyclists And MSBuild. But yeah, studies have found that when it comes to cyclists, there are three categories: Die-hard fearless ninjas that would bike through an active firefight, bike-haters that would never bike in a million years, and casual cyclists who would bike if they felt it were safe. Protected bike lanes are they key to getting #3 on the road.
- LaikaF 12y agoAs a cyclist: motorists, pedestrians, motorcycle riders(You are motorized you don't go in the bike lane) As a motorist: cyclists, motorcycle riders (If your mode of transport requires my windows to shake for safety stop using it) As a computer user: Stupid ui decisions
- nether 12y ago> Die-hard fearless ninjas that would bike through an active firefight, bike-haters that would never bike in a million years, and casual cyclists who would bike if they felt it were safe. And casual cyclists who are fearless/clueless. I'm talking the about the flip-flop wearing soccer moms pedaling their beach cruisers without helmet or lights down the PCH at night. Truly nuts.
- jrockway 12y agoThey should get lights. You should slow down according to the conditions. The speed limit is the absolute maximum which you must never exceed. It isn't an SLA.
- apendleton 12y agoSo you think your particular mode of transport should have exclusive use of a public right of way that everyone owns and everyone's tax dollars pay to build and maintain, but it's cyclists that have the shitty entitled attitude?
- tzs 12y agoWait...you don't think particular modes of transport should have exclusive access to particular public rights of way that everyone owns and everyone's tax dollars pay to build and maintain? So does that mean you think motorcycles should have access to the sidewalks, and pedestrians should be able to walk in the street?
- apendleton 12y agoLack of exclusivity might mean sharing the same lanes for multiple modes (what you're suggesting), or it might mean giving up some real estate to build dedicated infrastructure for other modes of transport (e.g. bike lanes, etc.). Which is appropriate will depend on context. But I don't think drivers have a right to object to both having to share lanes with cyclists and to giving up car lanes to build bike lanes. Cyclists are taxpayers, too, and should be entitled to something, but to hear some drivers talk about it, any infrastructural decision that doesn't lead to cars moving as quickly as possible ought to be verboten. That's what I find objectionable. But to more bluntly answer your question: actually, yes, at least sometimes. Though I would instead phrase it as erasing the distinction between sidewalks and streets: http://nacto.org/usdg/commercial-shared-street/ http://nacto.org/usdg/commercial-shared-street/ This kind of streetscape is common in Europe and Asia, but much less so in the States.
- bane 12y agoNo, I think cyclists should also have a dedicate right of way and transport infrastructure. At least as comprehensive as the automobile road network. Even if it costs me more in the form of higher tax dollars and yes, even if if I lose a travel lane because of it. Why is that controversial or problematic? I don't understand the shitty entitled attitude of bikers honestly. I'm not only advocating for something that's safer, more pleasant and more convenient for them, but I'm willing to put my wallet to work and inconvenience myself to support it. All I'm getting is flak over it and the responses to it are doing little to dissuade me of my already negative opinion of cyclists as a population.
- revelation 12y agoYour comments in this thread strongly suggest you are unsuitable for driving cars on public roads. The law rightfully places significant burdens on those operating multi-ton vehicles in the close proximity of pedestrians and cyclists. It also recognizes bicycles as proper vehicles, giving them the right to ride on roads, at the speed and position the situation calls for. I sincerely hope you won't ever hit anyone. This kind of attitude will do you no favors.
- bane 12y agoI've been driving for 23 years in about as many countries with not a single traffic accident (though I'll admit to a couple speeding tickets). I've driven in weather, climates and conditions as varied as polar winter conditions to mountains and desert. I have something over a million road miles under my belt which puts me at near 20,000 hours of on the road driving experience in mixes of cities to extreme rural environments. I feel comfortable saying I'm a driving expert and that I'm a very safe driver. I've never felt safe sharing pavement with a cyclist. Ever. Not for my own personal safety, or because of some dubious legal requirement, but for the safety of the cyclist. If you think that makes me sound like some kind of wild west psychopathic car driver hellbent on a Death Race high score spree I suggest you rethink that. The law also puts requirements on bike riders when using public roads. It's not an unburdened responsibility. However, bicyclists would like to make it a responsibility of car drivers only (as the comments in this thread pretty clearly indicate), and have an unlimited right to use infrastructure that wasn't designed or built with them in mind. However, enforcement of those laws on bicyclists is virtually nonexistent. The reason I feel unsafe around cyclists is that not only am I operating a complex, multi-thousand pound machine that can take me to triple digit speeds in under a minute, but because cyclists don't seem to be aware that I'm doing involved in that operation. They'll routinely swerve out into traffic, cut across busy intersections and otherwise behave like all the world revolves around them. Not all cyclists are like this. But I'm hard pressed to find many that observe even some fraction of the laws they're supposed to follow.
- endzone 12y agothere is zero chance you're a good driver. you seem pretty deluded
- stusmall 12y ago>Bikes aren't automobiles no matter how much we debate about it The road isn't just for cars. Its more dangerous for us to ride on the sidewalk and put pedestrians in danger. The road isn't for just bikes or cars, its for us to share. Its just how it is. For every entitled bicyclist you see on the road, we've seen plenty of awful drivers. I live in one of the most bike friendly cities in the country and still get yelled at by passing trucks or have people swerve at me because they think its funny. There are horrible people out there on all different types of modes of transit. Even if you are irritated be kind to us. There are a lot of us out there who obey traffic laws and use signal when we ride. In the words of the great philosophers, "Be excellent to each other."
- dllthomas 12y agoThe parent comment seems to be endorsing provision of dedicated space to bikers. The fact that "biker on road" is safer for everyone than "biker on sidewalk" isn't any sort of an argument against that.
- heydenberk 12y ago>> (who I as the automobile driver am responsible for in the case of an accident) This is factually untrue, as much as I'd like to be so.
- bane 12y agoWhile it may be legally untrue, it's not ethically or emotionally untrue. If you were to take out a cyclist and be legally not at fault, don't you think you'd carry around some sense of responsibility?
- turar 12y agoAs a motorist who sees cyclists daily, I have yet to see a cyclist obey a stop sign. I see blatant disregard for stop signs every single day. Same thing for red lights -- I see cyclists routinely disregard red lights, unless crossing a busy road, where disregarding a red light will certainly get them killed.
- dllthomas 12y agoWhere are you located? In Oakland, I certainly see some bicyclists break the rules, but I probably see more abiding by them. (And I see cars and pedestrians break rules, as well...)
- turar 12y agoEdmonton, Alberta. I live in a central/downtown location, where most streets are quiet 2-lanes. And like I said, I have never seen a cyclist actually stop at a stop sign. Most don't even slow down -- just a quick check to make sure they're not going to get killed, and blow right past.
- seanflyon 12y agoIn many cities it is perfectly legal for bicycles to treat stop signs as yield signs. I have no idea if this is the case in Edmonton, Alberta.
- elblanco 12y agoCorrect, where I grew up, we were taught in school to get out of intersections as quickly as possible, or dismount and walk across the crosswalk if it was available.
- endzone 12y agoit's one of the benefits of cycling. you could do the same if you weren't stuck in a big metal box. deal with it
- sxcurry 12y agoI totally agree - bikes should not be sharing the road with angry entitled nasty car drivers. Solution - get rid of the cars. Seriously. Make all traffic lanes in city cores bikes only, and make public transit free for everyone. Have dedicated hours at night when delivery vehicles can use the roads. BTW, I drive and bike and would be willing to give up a lot of the convenience of using my vehicle if these measures could be implemented.
- everyone 12y agoIn civilised countries (eg. Germany, Netherlands) cars are not allowed in the city centre. because of congestion, pollution, danger of death.
- gph 12y agoAh yes, civilization is based solely on mode of transportation. You should become an anthropologist with such great insight.
- bane 12y ago> Make all traffic lanes in city cores bikes only, and make public transit free for everyone. I was against you until this part. And now I'm totally with you. In the states it's tough though, the public transport system is woefully inadequate to support this idea.
- cdnsteve 12y agoAgree with this completely. What I still don't understand is everyone is ok with someone going 15 mph or less, only wearing a helmet, with no license or understanding of traffic. Cyclists should pass a road license just like motorbikes to be on the roads IMO. Bike lanes, fine, no license. Get on the road with cars, you better understand the risks. Especially when you go 6 cyclists wide and absolutely refuse to move over or go single profile. That's just ignorance. However, governments are blocking electric cars entirely that pass safety ratings and require valid drivers licenses from entering the market. Go figure that one out. Instead of putting more people on bikes why aren't electric cars allowed on the roads in cities? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZENN http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZENN
- DanBC 12y agoOne reason cyclists stay in the middle of the lane is to prevent selfish dangerous drivers from overtaking dangerously. I haven't seen people cycling 6 abreast - I agree that's probably unacceptable and definitely infuriating.
- 7952 12y agoMost of the world is far less car centric than the US. People go outside on foot or bikes instead of traveling everywhere in cars. Cycle paths are a way to make room for cars in busy cities that would be much more pleasant without them. It should be possible for anyone to go outside without fearing for their lives or waiting for ages to cross the road. That is just good design.
- tbrownaw 12y agoBetween roads, sidewalks and bike lanes, this provides a designated travel area for everybody regardless of the mode they choose to travel with. I still have a pair of inline skates somewhere, that I used for transportation around campus when I was at university. That's about half-way between foot speed and bike speed.
- iak8god 12y ago> Bikes aren't automobiles no matter how much we debate about it. They shouldn't be sharing the road with cars. I think you're confusing roads with highways. A highway is a place that cars goes and bikes can't go. A bike path is a place that bikes go and cars can't go. Roads are for cars and bikes and for people to live on and near and cross on foot regularly. Imagine a cyclist saying "Cars don't operate at human-scale speeds no matter how much we debate about it. They shouldn't be sharing the road with bikes and people." See how car-centric the debate is, that such a statement will be immediately dismissed. > Bikes shouldn't be sharing the road with cars, they should have their own designated travel areas. Everyone agrees that bikes should have their own designated areas, and cyclists especially would like nothing more than to see designated bike lanes and paths everywhere. Where those are absent, which is nearly everywhere even in urban centers in the US, traffic laws and infrastructure should be designed to accommodate all different types of road users, and preferably without killing as many of them as are currently killed each year.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bane 12y ago> See how car-centric the debate is, that such a statement will be immediately dismissed. It's car centric because roads are car centric. From design to paving, the vast vast majority of roads are designed purely for the automobile. I don't like it, I don't agree with it. But it is what it is. I'm definitely not talking about highways. I'm talking about the average kind of road that you see for millions upon millions of miles all over the U.S. This http://enews.ntta.org/images/2014-01/Open%20Road.jpg http://enews.ntta.org/images/2014-01/Open%20Road.jpg is not a road meant for bikes or pedestrians. But it's a typical road that you'll find almost anywhere. This one at least has some designated space for people on bikes http://velotraffic.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/bike-lane.jpg http://velotraffic.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/bike-lane.... but it's definitely not pedestrian friendly. However it clearly has a "cars go here" and "bikes go here" aspect to the marking design. I would personally love to see every road everywhere at least have that. But I'd love it if the average road segregated bikes and cars even further. http://media.cmgdigital.com/shared/lt/lt_cache/thumbnail/960/img/photos/2013/01/13/fd/f3/jwj-Bike-Lane-091.jpg http://media.cmgdigital.com/shared/lt/lt_cache/thumbnail/960... I'm picking these non-urban pictures on purpose, because cyclists seem to think they only exist in cities and that any problems people have about cyclists comes from angry car drivers in cities or I'm some asshole with issues with highways or something. But there are more than 4 million miles of roads (8.61 million lane miles) and almost 3 million of those are in non-urban environments. I'm personally interested in the 75% of all roads that aren't in cities because that's mostly what I and about half the U.S. population drives on. Of all these roads, less than 300,000 can be called highways. Which includes roads that look like this https://www.google.com/maps/@38.8810165,-77.3978133,3a,75y,138.29h,74.81t/data=!3m4!1e1!3m2!1sOLY679YTfCrfgQOZM9q4iA!2e0 https://www.google.com/maps/@38.8810165,-77.3978133,3a,75y,1... for which I think there should also be good cycling infrastructure.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]