6 ms·
Books that have stayed with us
- dmix 12y agoIs there a name for statistics that are presented as specific to x which are primarily just a reflection of popular choices in general?
- lutusp 12y agoYes, they're called demographic studies, studies of the choices of populations. Such studies can be used to find out what populations are likely to do when confronted by various choices. Then there's polling, meant to test one's population theories using actual data.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- herbig 12y agoI'd be willing to bet that the majority of books people cite on these lists they haven't actually read. The list serves as a status symbol and there's no way to verify it anyway. Also, U.S. citizens will happily list the entire high school summer reading list that they "loved" over ten years ago, which of course they didn't actually read then either. Just my cynical take on it. Still interesting data.
- smeyer 12y agoReally? I didn't get that sort of idea at all. For example, the top book, the Harry Potter series, is something that tons of people have read. I don't think I've ever encountered someone who only pretended to have read the Harry Potter series but hadn't actually. Also, among my personal friends, I haven't seen anyone post a list where I had any suspicions they hadn't actually read everything, although most of the lists I've seen posted are by my more well-read friends. Edit: I forgot the word "everything" in "actually read everything".
- henrik_w 12y agoMaybe not, but the six I have read (out of the top ten) were all really good in my opinion. So it seems (to me at least) that they are still good recommendations. The only one in the top 20 that I have read and not like is The Alchemist - I thought it was terrible.
- viewer5 12y agoCan I ask what you hated about The Alchemist? I heard it as an audiobook on a road trip (read by Jeremy Irons) and loved it, as did the people traveling with me. But I ran into some people who hated it, because they saw it as a mystical self-help allegory, whereas I just took it as a work of fiction.
- henrik_w 12y agoIt just didn't do anything for me. It felt like it tried too hard to give some deep insights, but to me it just fell flat (that's the mystical self-help part). And I didn't care for the story as just fiction either - I can't really explain why. But I know a lot of people of liked it, so I can see why it is on the list, even if I didn't like it.
- graeme 12y agoNone of those are particularly high status books. It's a mix of popular fiction, popular books children read and books assigned in high school English classes.
- herbig 12y agoThat depends on the local definition of high status. To many, the high school English assigned reading list is high culture.
- VLM 12y agoClaims the Silmarillion, probably lying. Claims the Hobbit or LOTR, probably telling truth I am willing to put it out there that people are embarrassed to admit certain books, so I'll be the first to admit that I think most people prefer "Blood Meridian" to "The Road" but don't want to put their full authenticated legal name to the claim. I don't claim blood meridian is some kind of great literature, but as an action book with memorable characters and local flavor... Another book with gallons of local flavor and just "weirdness" and interesting is Lucifers Hammer and that's another "I'm not going to admit in public, but ..." How about "Post Office" another, uh, questionable tome. There is also an age aspect. Some young kid claims to have slogged thru all of Gibbon, he's probably a history student or more likely lying, but I'm an older guy and I really did invest the time reading the whole decline and fall. I think it was worth it, at least the first half or so.
- darasen 12y agoI will gladly admit I thought Lucifer's Hammer was great. One of my favourites from my favourite author.
- pacaro 12y agoGiven how few books most people read, my suspicion is that this captures "10 books that you have read", more than "10 books that have stayed with you"
- IneffablePigeon 12y agoI'd counter that people who've only read 10 books are probably much less likely to participate in this meme.
- pessimizer 12y agoDepressing list. Is there an index for the reading level required for particular books to join this with? The mean on this would have to be somewhere around 8th-10th grade, and if the weights were used the median would be even lower. What percentage of books here would be found outside of the 'Young Adult' section of the bookstore or a high school assigned reading list?
- kelukelugames 12y agoI have a similar thought: how many books are on here because they are a part of high school curriculums? Of course, it's also possible that they are read in high school because they are good works.
- k2enemy 12y agoThere's probably a lot of sample bias. FB users that participated in the meme probably don't represent the universe of readers. I'd guess that the meme participants skewed towards young adults.
- VLM 12y agoAnecdotally, last night on the couch my wife was scrolling thru facebook while I was reading in the kindle app. This is pretty typical "wind down" end of day for us. Therefore I did not hear of this meme until it hit HN and I certainly didn't participate although I spend a lot of time reading, in comparison my wife could have seen it and participated, but she's on FB not reading. Its like asking a bunch of xbox gamers about their favorite PS4 game or vice versa. Well, there might be some overlap in that Venn diagram, but...
- freehunter 12y agoI think there are a couple of factors here. This is a popularity contest, which means it's mass-market by default. If you listed the "favorite artists" or "favorite songs" from Facebook, it would be similarly easily accessible pop music that can be played on the radio when children are in the room. The average person is going to like a lot of easily accessible books and a few outliers in specific genres. So while you might get 95% of people liking Harry Potter, you gets 15% liking the Mistborn series and maybe 12% liking Snow Crash and 4% liking The Martian. There is likely a long tail that Facebook won't show you. So people like pop literature, which means pop literature is going to be written so the mass market can read and enjoy it. I've read quite a few books where I've said "I liked it up until..." or "I like it but this part annoys me". I can't say the same about Harry Potter or The Hunger Games. They're inoffensive and appeal to everyone (or at least the 95%). Social factors also play into it, such as the appearance of The Holy Bible so high in the list. Is the Bible actually so many people's favorite book? No, of course not. That would be like saying my favorite book is Learn Python the Hard Way. It's a textbook, really, something to study and learn from. But it's a way to easily identify with a group. If you want people to know you're serious about your religion, you say the Bible is your favorite book. Another social aspect, The Great Gatsby is known at The Great American Novel and also a popular movie recently. Did this many people read it? No. They watched the movie or they heard it's a great book so they "like" it in order to appear smart and well-read. Nobody likes Hamlet as a book. No one. Because it's not a book. But you were probably forced to read it like one in high school, and it's one of the few books you've ever read, so let put it on the list too. In fact, I would say most of these books are on there because they're the some of the only books the 95% have ever read.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Kurtz79 12y agoIs "Watchmen" considered a book ? Not complaining, just surprised.
- freehunter 12y agoIs Hamlet considered a book? It's stretching the definition the same way calling The Star Spangled Banner a song. A poem set to music doesn't automatically become a song.
- Kurtz79 12y agoPoint taken. I am actually glad to see a graphic novel being granted "book" status.
- tokenadult 12y agoSeveral of the previous comments here mention the methodological issue of how much these data really represent the population of interest. A FAQ comment posted to Hacker News before[1] points out that voluntary response data in general are often very unreliable for generalizing to nonresponders. We can't be sure that the people who bother to respond to online quiz questions or poll questions (including here on Hacker News) have much resemblance to the people who do not bother to respond. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2772603 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2772603
- e12e 12y agoInteresting to see Watchmen on there as the only(?) graphic novel?
- brian_cloutier 12y agoGiven how many comments there are mentioning how lowbrow this list is (which I don't necessarily disagree with), maybe you could offer some suggestions of books which have stayed with you? Personally, Godel Escher Bach was pretty formative on my path to becoming a programmer; and The New Jim Crow is a monument to overkill, there are so many statistics that it's impossible to read the entire thing and not come to believe her thesis.
- devindotcom 12y agoIt's really more middlebrow than lowbrow. Lowbrow would be fantasy romance, potboiler political thrillers, and other such pulp. This is more like a greatest hits of the 20th century collection, plus a few accessible classics.
- VLM 12y agoFire in the Lake, which boils down to Ho Chi Minh was the "best" world leader of the 20th century? Best as in most capable and effective and intelligent not necessarily best as in matches my ideal of leadership?
- oldbuzzard 12y agoIf I was going to pick one Frances Fitzgerald book it would be "Cities on a Hill"[1] not "Fire in the Lake". One explains why our foreign policy fails and the other explains who we believe ourselves to be and how that shapes who we are. McPhee's "Encounter with the Archdruid"[2] and Reisner's "Cadillac Desert"[3] have similar elements... [1] http://www.amazon.com/Cities-Hill-Brilliant-Exploration-Communities/dp/0671645617/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=undefined&sr=8-1&keywords=cities+on+the+hill+fitzgerald http://www.amazon.com/Cities-Hill-Brilliant-Exploration-Comm... [2] http://www.amazon.com/s?ie=UTF8&field-keywords=encounter%20with%20the%20archdruid&index=blended&link_code=qs&sourceid=Mozilla-search&tag=mozilla-20 http://www.amazon.com/s?ie=UTF8&field-keywords=encounter%20w... [3] http://www.amazon.com/s?ie=UTF8&field-keywords=encounter%20with%20the%20archdruid&index=blended&link_code=qs&sourceid=Mozilla-search&tag=mozilla-20 http://www.amazon.com/s?ie=UTF8&field-keywords=encounter%20w...
- devindotcom 12y agoI suppose it's not that strange that this data was aggregated intelligently from status updates. I do wonder, though, the number of lists and data collections like this that are assembled and we are not told about. Not that I resent it, exactly, I know the terms I joined the network on — but it is a little unnerving to think just how many ways such a huge trove of data could be mined - weekly popularity lists for books, movies, etc. Makes me wonder why Facebook bothers advertising when they have the most powerful and targetable polling tool in history available to be gated off for a price. Maybe they're already doing this and I just don't know.
- sharkweek 12y agoWith all that data and most users being logged into Facebook on their browser at all times, I cannot for the life of me figure out why they haven't released an Adsense competitor - I'm assuming there are some deep philosophical reasons about not wanting to encourage any business decision that focuses entirely outside of the Facebook ecosystem, but hot damn, I would drop Adsense on my sites in a heartbeat for a FB version as I'm 100% convinced their service would easily defeat the competition in an ad relevancy test. I can't imagine it's privacy related, because that's proven to mostly be only a minor hurdle to overcome every time everyone freaks out at every FB change.
- Retric 12y agoIntention is incredibly important when doing advertising. Consider the difference between "Looking for a new car this weekend" vs. "just bought a new car the weekend".
- polarix 12y ago> deep philosophical reasons about not wanting to encourage any business decision that focuses entirely outside of the Facebook ecosystem What you're proposing would be a radical expansion of the facebook ecosystem, not a departure.
- patja 12y agoThe most interesting bits in this summary are the network connections such as "people who liked this liked that". Is there anywhere this is published in detail or with the ability to manipulate the visualization/report? Just posting a zoomed out pretty picture of "look at the nifty analysis we can do" without sharing the ability to do so is as disheartening as seeing Harry Potter, the Hunger Games, and The Stand in the top titles.
- oldbuzzard 12y agoIt is interesting that there is no non-fiction in the top 100. Godel Escher Bach Plagues and People by McNeil Something by Jared Diamond Braudel's Capitalism series The Worldly Philosophers by Heilbronner etc etc Maybe nonfiction is more dispersed but it is still interesting to have none in the top 100.
- kamaal 12y agoI don't find the absence of GEB in the top 100 amazing at all. Firstly not all readers have a science inclination. Even most of the programmers I know of, haven't heard of GEB. And plus GEB is a long slog even for people like us. Because to really understand it fully, you have to work through it and re read a few chapters over and over again. As much as a gem of a book it is, its not for every one.
- icebraining 12y agoWell, there's The Art of War and the Autobiography of Malcolm X.
- bemmu 12y agoWould be interesting to see an animation of the meme spreading over time.