5 ms·
Will Fusion Energy Ever Come Together?
- iaw 12y agoWhy doesn't this article discuss ITER?
- arethuza 12y agoIt does make a brief reference to ITER. Amusingly, there is also a comment on the article asking why it doesn't mention ITER and another comment pointing out that it does....
- iaw 12y agoA brief reference to ITER is not a discussion. It does not talk in detail about the most promising fusion experiment on the horizon.
- aperrien 12y agoI'm kind of disappointed. This article discussed almost none of the dozen small-scale fusion projects out there today. Coverage of them along with the fission companies that were covered would have made for an excellent article. Especially as some of them are running experiments now.
- iaw 12y agoSame here, I expected a lot more when I clicked.
- infogulch 12y agoQuestion: How is the energy released during fusion collected? Just turned into heat for a turbine?
- icegreentea 12y agoMostly, yeah.
- aperrien 12y agoIt depends on the process. Some of the plasma focus devices being experimented with create electricity directly from the ionization process.
- 80ProofPudding 12y agoAny you can recall? I'm curious, and tired of having it pointed out to me that almost anything but solar is just a fancy way of boiling water.
- rpedela 12y agoYes. LLP Fusion is building such a device. There are a couple others, but I don't remember their names off the top of my head. http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/ http://lawrencevilleplasmaphysics.com/
- aperrien 12y agoI'm no expert in this, but from what I've seen, most of the small players are working on variants of aneutronic fusion[1] a method that reduces the quantity and energy of the neutrons that come out of the reaction. There you have Polywell Fusion, Tri-Alpha Energy, and Lawrenceville Plasma Physics (Who are supposed to be running tests on their device this month). There's also Helion Energy[2], which is a YC startup, but their process seems to involve some sort of magnetic reflectivity from the fusion reaction. [1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aneutronic_fusion [2]http://www.helionenergy.com/ http://www.helionenergy.com/
- danbruc 12y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_energy_conversion http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_energy_conversion
- 12y ago
- trhway 12y agoHe turned things upside down. It isn't that fusion power has no risk of proliferation, it is just being developed only in the ways that have no (or extremely low) weaponization potential - limiting development this way significantly slows down overall progress on reaching efficient power production. Add to that the policies (at least in the US) established almost 20 years ago when it was decided that fusion generated energy can't be cheaper than coal (yep, because most of the cost is actual turbines/generators and distribution) and thus no point in pursuing in the foreseeable future.
- duaneb 12y agoIt's such an odd stance--presumably fissile reactions are already dangerous enough that the cat is out of the bag. Everyone who CAN weaponize it can already wreak devestation.
- trhway 12y agofissile weapons are very hard to produce - huge enrichment facilities. Where is inertial confinement fusion device is just a matter of focusing enough power into small enough volume during very small period of time - pure engineering task and once technology is mastered we either have an easy way to colonize Solar system or to destroy ourselves as any ISIL would be able to use it. And judging by the current mindset of our species i doubt that Solar system if the first thing on our collective mind.
- duaneb 12y agoI must admit I don't know enough to really comment on the danger of fissile vs fusible materials; however, I was taught that one of the boons of fusion was that the energy source was stable (radioactive-wise) before entering the reaction.
- Terr_ 12y ago"Inertial confinement fusion device" != "Fusion Weapon" If you want to make a point about relative dangers, you should be comparing apples-to-apples. Simply expressing fission as a phenomenon is even easier than fusion, you can dig up rocks that do it all on their own. Weaponizing a phenomenon, on the other hand, always requires some additional work.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAs someone who follows various fusion efforts I expect the answer to the headline is 'yes' (in opposition to Betteridge's law). The trick of course is 'when'. But like the article, I also find it sad that we've not been able to build more Gen IV projects. You want to fix climate change? Build nuclear plants. Unfortunately not a message that resonates well, although the Chinese seem to be thinking that way. Hard not too with all that coal soot in the air. A more interesting question will be the cost of fusion energy (or even Gen IV fission) versus existing fuels. It's one thing to be "able" to make a net positive fusion generator, and something else again to make it profitable.
- hyperbovine 12y agoBurning fossil fuels would be a lot less profitable if the long-term impacts of doing so were capitalized in.
- hackerboos 12y agoThe same goes for nuclear to be honest. I think we need innovation in the nuclear energy sector - Thorium and Fusion cry out for investment.
- a-priori 12y agoThey're not nearly on the same scale. There are estimates that the US has, in its entire history, produced about 56 thousand metric tonnes of high-level radioactive waste as of 2008 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-level_radioactive_waste_management#cite_note-doe1-81 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-level_radioactive_waste_ma...). On the other hand, the EPA estimates that in 2012 alone, the United States produced 6.5 billion metric tonnes of carbon emitted due to transportation. Obviously, a tonne of carbon and a tonne of radioactive waste aren't really comparable. In fact, I'd argue that the radioactive waste produced by a fission power plant is better for the environment: it remains in the reactor facility, where it can be easily contained and buried in geologically stable rock formations, or reused/reprocessed to extract further energy from it. The carbon produced by burning fossil fuels is dumped into the atmosphere, where it can't be easily collected, disposed of, or reused.
- Kompulsa 12y agoMaybe it will. However, I would remain hopeful, but not bank on it too much, as it may not happen for now. Society needs to do what they can to increase energy independence and sustainability with whatever they can use now, as time is limited.
- Kompulsa 12y agoThe various combined sources of energy available today can help to keep society going more sustainably while Nuclear Fusion technology is under development.
- bluedino 12y agoWouldn't it make more sense to pour money into this instead of solar? On one hand, the solar industry provides jobs but the discovery of fusion would be a huge step to energy independence and reducing pollution. If China gets this first, and doesn't share it with the rest of the world, that would solve a lot of their problems.
- afterburner 12y agoOn the other hand, you can pour money into fusion for decades, maybe centuries, and get nothing useable. Solar gets much better the more money you put into it, and that's on top of already being competitive vs other traditional energy sources now. If I had to choose one, I'd choose the one I get actual returns on.
- parsnips 12y agoSo, fission?
- JTon 12y agoGood thing we don't have to pick just one. I like the idea of big hairy audacious goals.
- afterburner 12y agoYes. Parent commenter phrased it as one or the other. The choice of fusion given that restriction is even stranger.
- Houshalter 12y agoWell we haven't really tried. http://i.imgur.com/sjH5r.jpg http://i.imgur.com/sjH5r.jpg
- gtirloni 12y agoIncreasing the power output of solar panels is very costly. The more money you put into it, the smaller increase you get. It's like charging a battery to 100%, you'll spend enormous amount of energy ($$) for nothing at some point.
- jobu 12y agoThis was an interesting quote: “China just put a huge chunk of money and hired hundreds of people to work on molten salt reactors. I think that’s probably going to come first—and it’s going to come from China” China also built a pebble bed reactor at Shidaowan, and has plans to build up to 19 more. (http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-02-21/china-wants-nuclear-reactors-and-lots-of-them http://www.businessweek.com/articles/2013-02-21/china-wants-...) (http://nextbigfuture.com/2014/04/construction-progresses-on-chinas-high.html http://nextbigfuture.com/2014/04/construction-progresses-on-...) It will be interesting to see if the Chinese can make nuclear fission clean and economical over the long term.
- dmfdmf 12y agoI don't know that it will be fusion but I think eventually we will solve the energy problem. If we look at nature the energy scale of natural processes such as solar flares, movement of planets, oceans and atmospheres, etc dwarf human needs. The energy is out there we just haven't figured out how to efficiently access it. When we look at atomic processes the conversion of even tiny amounts of mass to energy also easily dwarf human needs. I know we are constrained by the First and Second laws of Thermodynamics but I think this is powerful evidence that there has to be a way. Both fusion and fission convert mass to energy but are crude ways to do it. Physics is currently stuck and has been for 60-70 years. Physicists cannot integrate the large scale theory (General Relativity) with the small scale theory (Quantum Mechanics). They are incompatible. I can't prove it but I suspect that once this impasse is resolved we will find elegant ways to convert mass to energy and the energy problem will be solved.
- lutorm 12y agoAll forms of energy extraction ultimately convert mass to energy. The coal we burn weighs imperceptibly more than the combustion products. That's really a red herring, though -- you must be able to harness an exothermic reaction to convert what you have into energy, and unifying QM and GR is unlikely to have any implications about reactions at energy densities we can usefully use.
- fleitz 12y agoWe already have a pretty elegant self assembling method of building fusion reactors, we just lack sufficient hydrogen.
- graycat 12y agoIndeed, we already have such a reactor, just about where we would want it!
- lutorm 12y agoEver is a long time... It's an engineering problem, and it seems prudent to keep working at it until it succeeds, given that the available supply of fissile materials is vastly more limited than that of fusible ones. Uranium mining isn't exactly an activity with negligible environmental impact, either.
- fleitz 12y agoOutlook seems sunny :)
- guelo 12y agoI don't understand why more resources aren't devoted to developing geothermal. We are all floating on top of endless layers of energy-dense molten rock.
- graycat 12y agoApparently heated by nuclear fission!
- ufmace 12y agoIn brief, we can extract energy not from heat, but from temperature differences. It's very easy to extract energy from a conventional power plant, because the hot stuff is right next to the cool stuff - the environment here. The molten rock has a huge amount of energy, but we can't extract it unless it's close enough to something cool to build a heat engine between the hot and the cold. Thus, geothermal is only viable at a select number of sites where the lava or other carriers of heat naturally flow near the surface. To make it viable in general, you'll have to figure out a way to send a working fluid down deep enough to pick up enough heat and bring it back up again without losing all of that heat on the way back up, and do it with huge flowrates to extract enough energy, and in such a way that it can run pretty much continuously for years.