5 ms·
Nimrod has amazing performance, extremely clear syntax, and advanced metaprogramming features. That combination is unmatched in programming languages. It is a
by ilaksh 12y ago
Nimrod has amazing performance, extremely clear syntax, and advanced metaprogramming features. That combination is unmatched in programming languages. It is a significant advance.
Yet, the Wikipedia editors continuously delete the Nimrod programming language article, claiming Nimrod is "not notable".
Wikipedia editors will say that there aren't enough third party articles or something, but that isn't true. And then they will say, yes, this is notable compared to quite a lot of other garbage or trivia that has articles on Wikipedia, but just because "other crap exists" isn't an excuse to allow this article.
I think that notability has to be a relative concept, and Nimrod is notable. At this point its just small-dick Wikipedia editors asserting their control. Either that or some editors are invested in other programming languages and are trying to stop this one from becoming mainstream.
This proves to me that Wikipedia is utter crap. But unfortunately, we are stuck with Wikipedia and it has quite a lot of influence. I wish someone who had pull on Wikipedia or knew how to make it work would fix this problem. I have tried. It seems like maybe it actually just made the editors band together more to try to continue to keep it off, just as sort of a reaction. Like its a group that works together to oppose anyone who isn't already an insider.
- ternaryoperator 12y ago>This proves to me that Wikipedia is utter crap. The most it proves only that Wikipedia does not include some items that it should include. It says nothing about the quality of the articles that are included.
- _delirium 12y agoI don't think there'd be an objection to creating a cited article. I took a brief look at the deleted version, and it didn't have any sources considered sufficient. It cited two things: 1) a random blog post by someone who tried Nimrod and liked it; and 2) an introductory Dr. Dobbs article written by the Nimrod author himself. Now #2 is useful as a supplemental source, but typically can't be the only source for a Wikipedia article. Had I run across it, I personally would've just tagged it "needs third-party references" rather than deleting, but which way things on the borderline go has a lot of variance. A better place to start would probably be to find a description of Nimrod in some standard source—textbook, survey article, etc., and start from there, then flesh out with supplemental sources written by the Nimrod author himself for details. If Nimrod hasn't yet gotten solid third-party coverage despite deserving it, the root of the problem might lie elsewhere than Wikipedia—on scientific/technical/etc. topics, Wikipedia just summarizes the current state of the literature, leaving improving the literature as a job better done elsewhere.
- ilaksh 12y agoIt has been deleted many times. There are plenty of references including the one to the Dr. Dobb's article, which is what comes up at the top of a Google search. The fact that you looked into this and your actions (none) are siding with the other Wikipedia editors proves my point. You personally would have tagged it "needs third-party references"? Put your money where your mouth is, undelete it, and add that tag. Or prove my point. You actually do nothing, which is the same as standing behind the other Wikipedia editors. Like a little small-dick Mafia. I have nothing but despise for Wikipedia editors.
- _delirium 12y agoAh, I see I overestimated your interest in good-faith discussion vs. just flinging insults.
- dom96 12y agoHave you taken a look at this draft? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Nimrod_%28programming_language%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draft:Nimrod_%28programming_la.... I find it unfair that "other crap" does indeed exist. There is plenty of programming languages which are more obscure with far less references and they have not been removed. Even looking at the D programming language article I am left wondering which reference makes it notable? They all seem to be written by Walter, or by Andrei or linking to some random D projects.
- rurban 12y agoI have no energy to deal with people like Czarkoff on Wikipedia, who clearly have no idea what they are talking about. They should clearly think over their guideline keepers, if declining a perfectly notable programming language like Nimrod for Wikipedia makes more sense then keeping it. From a fellow language designer: Nimrod is very notable, combining previously unthought language features like efficient compilation and macros (only Elixir can compete here) and a real-time GC, with a python-like syntax with types. But not only that. It is also practical.
- rogerdpack 12y agoYou can probably get it to "stay" as long as you provide 3 references from websites to it, basically. GL!
- throwX 12y agoThe editors don't get it: Not only does crap exist, but it is actively protected from deletion by editors. For example this nice little notable content farm: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Softpedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Softpedia