3 ms·
The local governments invariable claim it's not about the money; it's about safety or some such. I want an amendment that puts all the money from fines, seizur
by CapitalistCartr 12y ago
The local governments invariable claim it's not about the money; it's about safety or some such. I want an amendment that puts all the money from fines, seizures, etc. to the national debt. That's the closest thing to a black hole for money I can think of. Watch them scream then. Not about the money, my ass.
- ganeumann 12y agoFrom the article: 'The attention prompted Congress to reform federal seizure laws in 2000, allowing owners to be reimbursed for their legal fees after successful lawsuits. But a key reform was cut. It would have removed what some lawmakers called the “perverse incentive” to target cash — the sharing of money between the feds and locals. It died after police and Justice waged a “voracious lobbying” campaign, according to former representative Barney Frank (D-Mass.). “We didn’t have the votes,” said Frank, who is still an ardent critic of asset forfeiture. “There is this terrible unfairness. It is about as fundamental a denial of their constitutional rights as I can think of.”'
- delinka 12y agoWhile a noble thought, I doubt the ultimate implementation would be amenable to a free society. I fear this would encourage the federal government to step up efforts to seize money. Sure, local authorities would forward the money, only to receive kickbacks from the feds. How that would actually impact the national debt is anyone's guess.
- JamesBarney 12y agoI think you're underestimating the difficulty with which someone in the government can just transfer funds. And two overestimating the incentives for anyone in the federal government to reduce the debt. I would be more interested to hear exactly who has an incentive to reduce the debt in the federal government and the power to transfer money to local police departments.
- chongli 12y agoNo, we should pass a law barring law enforcement from seizing property in any case until a judgment has been reached in a court of law.
- scott_karana 12y agoHow would you distinguish seizure of property with the false justification of probable cause, from legitimate seizure of evidence with legitimate probable cause? I assume you are not advocating that police cannot collect evidence until after a crime is proven in court.