3 ms·
I disagree. Investors almost never value cash $1 to $1. It's always about the earnings, then it's about the sales, then it's about the assets (unless the asset
by adventured 12y ago
I disagree. Investors almost never value cash $1 to $1.
It's always about the earnings, then it's about the sales, then it's about the assets (unless the assets are staggering in size in relationship to the operating business, and in that case the market cap will get a severe discount vs the assets, which is why you end up with weak businesses trading at discounts to assets).
If investors almost always valued assets at a $1 to $1, you'd almost never under any circumstances see a company trading for less than either cash or net tangibles. When in fact this is historically frequent, and for the majority of the history of the US stock market it was quite common.
You can see the cash and asset discount demonstrated across companies including Berkshire Hathaway, Apple, Microsoft, Yahoo, Cisco, banks small and large, and classically in cable companies like Comcast or Time Warner.
It's fairly easy to prove this is the case. When companies with low multiples and tons of cash, drop that cash off their balance sheet, the operating business does not receive a hyper small multiple, and the market cap does not collapse in line with the cash dump. If Apple dumped $100 billion to investors with a one time dividend tomorrow morning, their stock would not plunge by 15%. There is case after case after case of historical examples to reference.
If investors valued balance sheets so strongly, Comcast would be nearly worthless. It's the operating business that is valued first and forecast. Investors know cash does not yield a great return (especially right now), and for most businesses it does not provide great growth opportunities period, it is thus investors heavily discount cash.
- ggupta 12y agoYou're conflating cash with assets. None of the companies you mentioned are trading at a discount to their cash balance. Institutional investors don't value tech companies based on tangible book - they use P/E or EV / EBITDA multiples (or FCF multiples for software companies). The only companies that trade on net asset value (NAV) are financial companies such as banks. For those companies, the balance sheet structure is the opposite of traditional companies - assets such as cash represent liabilities (they're funds individuals have deposited in their account). As a result, the NAV framework is inappropriate to apply to tech companies. Two specific points on the above examples: (1) Cable companies are valued using a different investment framework. They are highly capital intensive businesses, where cash today does not reflect cyclical future capital expenditures. Furthermore, these businesses have a tremendous amount of leverage, and thus you have to look at net cash balances, not gross cash. (2) Your Apple example is absolutely correct. This actually happened when Microsoft announced a special one-time dividend in 2004. This goes back to my 3rd point above - when companies hoard a significant cash balance without any plans for capital returns, investors start to discount the cash. This was Icahn's thesis when he went activist on Apple. However, I would caution against extrapolating this to companies that don't have significant cash balances. I know it sounds tempting to say that cash doesn't generate great returns and is thus logically undervalued. There are two reasons why that's not the case. (1) Investors usually use EV / EBITDA multiples to arrive at an enterprise value. EBITDA is prior to the recognition of interest expense / income - the earnings generation of cash does not matter here at all. After arriving at the EV, they then add cash and subtract debt (at a 1:1 value) to arrive at the equity value, and then divide by shares outstanding to arrive at the target price. (2) Investors that use P/E multiples need to normalize for variations in cash balances by using ex-cash P/E multiples. For most companies, cash is a small percentage of the market cap such that P/E multiples are a close enough approximation to ex-cash P/E multiples. For companies with large cash balances, that's not the case, and the valuation method needs to be adjusted appropriately. If your argument is that some investors fail to do this, you're absolutely right. However, they are doing so based on an error of judgement - not because they really believe cash shouldn't be valued on a 1:1 basis.