6 ms·
As the article points out, they don't. By running the business this way they are constantly building / growing new businesses but during a downturn they just bu
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
As the article points out, they don't. By running the business this way they are constantly building / growing new businesses but during a downturn they just build more slowly (rather than lose money). It is a very different way of operating but one which has provided some interesting benefits for them. Nominally a business uses profits to either pay dividends or fund unexpected opportunities (like buying some small company or what not) Amazon doesn't pay dividends and they invest every dollar they make "extra" back into the business to increase the total number of dollars in the pipes. They don't need to turn a profit, they just need to manage their investment profile to their revenue forecasts.
Interestingly enough, after reading that, I realized that Google doesn't stand a chance in hell of beating them at commerce.
- mkaziz 12y agoIf they don't want a profit, what's their motivation for existing?
- amaks 12y agoThey do want the profit, they just keep reinvesting it to capex.
- RaptorJ 12y ago"Amazon" isn't a thing that has wants or feelings. You can not make a profit and still pay your executives a bundle of money.
- zaidf 12y agoIt isn't that they don't want a profit, it's just that as long as they feel they can reinvest the profit relatively safely to make even more profit in the future, they will continue doing so.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoThe other replies to this aside, I think the assumption inherent in your question is myopic. I know for myself, my motivation to get capital (profits) is so I can build things that improve decision making, increase longevity and in the end expand knowledge worldwide. Perhaps Bezos has motivations that are along the same lines and this is how he is achieving them.
- gatehouse 12y agoSince they are a publicly traded company, the ownership can be fluid. As a shareholder you can stay in or cash out whenever you want, if you want to simulate a profit you can sell shares periodically. So the separation between the company's internal finances and the exchange of shares on the stock market is what allows this to happen and still make sense.
- tim333 12y agoProfit in this case is generally a quantity calculated by accounting rules (US GAAP probably) and is a different thing from wealth created. Amazon has produced a lot of wealth for it's shareholders, enough for Bezos to be worth ~$30bn build spacecraft as his hobby. The difference is more obvious with a company like Facebook. Say they spend $1bn building the company from zero to 500m users and at the same time receive $1bn in ad revenue. Their accounting profit is $0 but their wealth is a lot due to the value of the 500m users. There are advantages to keeping the GAAP profit near zero because you pay no corporation tax that way.
- wodenokoto 12y agoBut in the end that wealth is based on people's belief that 500m users can be turned into a profit.
- Twirrim 12y agoYour question could be interpreted in a couple of different ways. Are you implying that profit is the only reason for a company to exist? If so, would you indulge my curiosity, what leads you to think that way?
- auxbuss 12y agoYou might be confusing profit with margin. You need margin, in general, but you don't necessarily need profit.
- sliverstorm 12y agoSo if they will never pay dividends, why is their stock worth anything?
- superuser2 12y agoBecause you can sell it?
- jmccree 12y agoBecause you can sell it for more than you bought it for. Look at Warren Buffet's Berkshire: You would have doubled your money in 4 years if you bought in 2010. They've pretty consistently increased the value of their shares without paying a dividend in 50 years or so.
- apalmer 12y agoAbsolutely understand what you are saying. But isn't that by definition a hot potato Ponzi scheme? I mean there are large monster e-commerce giants in other nations, it is a very real possibility that Amazon will have to battle with some company at scale who is also in the razor sharp margin mindframe. Its not impossible to imagine a world where amazon gets into a war with an Asian e-commerce giant for domination of the worlds e-commerce needs. If this does come to fruition this battle will probably not be resolved until 2020 ish time frame... so its a real possibility that amazon could be in business for 30 years, never return a profit to its investors, and NOT end up ever ruling ecommerce.
- cellis 12y agoBut in the meantime, there is money to be made in holding on to it. Look at AMZN speculation like Bitcoin speculation: there's really no intrinsic value of a Bitcoin or AMZN share, except that others want them and there's a finite supply of them, and also there is some underlying (quickly growing) market that they represent, which means that the shares should also grow in value. Couple that with a nice PR machine ( can't understate the value of people like PMarca writing about how amazing they are ) and you've got a way to reliably grow your portfolio.
- swalsh 12y ago"Interestingly enough, after reading that, I realized that Google doesn't stand a chance in hell of beating them at commerce." I used to work for a strapping start-up. Our competition had a lot more money, and people than us... but it didn't really matter because we were smarter in how we approached building the product. The future of eCommerce is going to be very heavily dependent on AI & robots. Product Suggestions > inventory management > ware house > packing > delivering. AI makes your customers buy more, and robots make delivering it cheaper. As good as Amazon is at creating this infrastructure, google has demonstrated a mastery in AI, and they're purchasing every robot company around. The competition is on, and I wouldn't count them out.
- exelius 12y agoAmazon has actually been better at this kind of stuff than Google. Since their acquisition of Kiva Systems, they have built what is by far the best automated warehousing/logistics platform of any company in the world. The future of EVERYTHING is going to be very reliant on AI and robots. My view is that the last 20 years have been the Internet revolution. The next 20 are all about AI and robotic automation. Both disciplines have existed for a long time, but they've hit a tipping point where price and effectiveness are putting them within reach of total ubiquity.
- jfoutz 12y agoBoth Amazon and Google are very smart. Amazon seems to have a greedy algorithm with regard to new tech. I mean, Amazon seems to keep automating the least efficient thing - http://www.kivasystems.com/ http://www.kivasystems.com/ for example. Google is much more forward looking, looking for big changes, like self driving cars. I can see google taking over more markets like they did with search. "more wood behind fewer arrows" was the saying. Amazon is much more broad, if Amazon has something, they'll rent it to you.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoAgreed. Google is more likely to be the GE of the future: a lot of great technology, hands in many industries. Amazon, in contrast, is like a cross between Wal-Mart and the old AT&T (there is no good previous analogy for what they are doing, but many are doing the same...see Taobao).