7 ms·
Your Own Indoor, Hydroponic Grove
- deanclatworthy 12y agoI think we will be seeing a lot more hydro stuff in the coming years and hopefully it'll shed it's image as being used for growing pot. It's a much more efficient way of growing than soil, often yielding 3x as much. There's quite an active group over on reddit who discuss hydro issues /r/hydro. You can actually build a pretty decent home brew set up with minimal cost with some careful planning.
- ibisum 12y agoI've seen folks using the Space Buckets (http://www.spacebuckets.com/ http://www.spacebuckets.com/) technique to grow tomatoes and other edibles - I think that the pot growing industry definitely innovates and pushes the curve forward for these sorts of techniques, so I hope the derogatory nature of associating with that crowd doesn't prejudice someone against looking into the techniques. I could imagine a lot of good things coming from homegrow/DIY hydro gardening - although I have a huge normal garden which provides a family of 4 with more than enough high-grade food, I'd still like to set things up for the non-growing season every year. There's nothing quite like consuming food one produced oneself.
- jrapdx3 12y agoBy "non-growing season" I'm assuming you mean winter. If you don't live in the Arctic Circle, or have temperatures to match, it's quite possible (I've seen it done anyway) to grow some vegetables under glass even in pretty unfavorable climates. Modern greenhouse materials are amazing. With short days or chronically overcast skies, daylight still gives adequate blue light such that supplementary high-pressure Na (reddish spectrum) lighting can provide good enough conditions at low-moderate cost. It wouldn't duplicate the lovely garden you describe, but might be better than nothing at all.
- exDM69 12y ago> If you don't live in the Arctic Circle, or have temperatures to match, it's quite possible (I've seen it done anyway) to grow some vegetables under glass even in pretty unfavorable climates. I live 60 degrees northern latitude (still 1000 km to arctic circle). It is not possible to grow vegetables in gardens like this (indoors, in warm, with artificial light next to a floor to ceiling window wall). It is barely possible to grow herbs and greens, as long as they have been germinated earlier in the fall. Trying to start a seedling or a cloned cutting no longer works when the length of day goes around six hours or so. Of course, you can put in a huge amount of grow lights but that's no longer practical to do in your kitchen.
- jrapdx3 12y agoI was referring to an outdoor greenhouse, set up on a plot of land where a large garden was mentioned. Oriented in a north-south direction natural light is still plentiful even in winter, and supplementing with artificial light can be effective. You are right though, even a large south-facing window doesn't provide as much illumination as a proper greenhouse, sharply limiting what can be grown. BTW if you get 6 hours of daylight at 60 deg latitude, that's impressive. My location is ~46 deg, but because of surrounding hills, and frequent thick cloud cover, we effectively get barely 6 hours of daylight at the start of winter, maybe less. In the off season, we're relegated to getting what produce we can from the grocery store, taste-free as it may be...
- exDM69 12y ago> BTW if you get 6 hours of daylight at 60 deg latitude 6 hours was a guesstimate figure for when plants stop growing. That's for the actual lit period, not sunrise-sunset times. At the darkest period of the year, the sunrise is after 9am and sunset is somewhere around 3 pm. Looking at the exact figures, it's 5 hours 49 minutes on the shortest day of the year. If you work a regular day job, you'll never see the sun for several months. But effectively, that's pretty much perpetual darkness. During the midday, there's a brief period of "daylight", but most of the time is just twilight because the sun doesn't rise very high. The weather tends to be cloudy for the whole period, last year there was 20 minutes of unoccluded sunlight in December and one or two clear nights. You learn to manage with the darkness in the winter and the light in the summer but coping with the rapid change in spring/fall is the worst. Humans are photosensitive animals, it really fucks up your mind.
- sliverstorm 12y agoI thought homebrew referred to, you know, brew.
- xnull2guest 12y agoThe problem with this is that the grove will not be able to grow enough to sustain (or come close to sustaining) even a single person. By the very, very most optimistic calculations (best recorded growth in tropical greenhouses) you need at a minimum 300 sq ft of space. But more realistically a 1000 sq ft or more are required to sustain a person. Then there's actually a ton of labor that goes into growing, picking and correcting the plants. Just ask someone who has worked in a garden, tried aquaponics or grown something hydroponically (weed or otherwise). Automation can still only do so much, especially when it isn't at scale. This relegates their grove to growing single types of plants very well. Growing fruits requires more light than vegetables, but either way you're looking at at least 40 watts per sq ft of space, usually much more (especially since the light needs to penetrate down through the leaves). For even a small setup of 8 sq ft you're looking at something that pulls 4 kwh of electricity a day at minimum (around a half a dollar). Taking between 3 and 6 months to grow some fruits you're look at a minimum of $75 a yield but probably closer to $400-$500 or even more after you calculate the costs of HVAC (big), water pumping and heating/cooling costs and chemicals (which are on the order of a dollar-per-day expensive). And then a lot of the equipment needs to be replaced and is very expensive, especially if you are running lights. Most of those have a shelf life of around a half year, unless you do LEDs which are extremely expensive investments. Of course this needs to be compared to the yield but generally economies of scale, even organic ones, can produce goods much cheaper. And hydro isn't organic... The reason hydroponics is associated with weed is because you need to grow something that costs more than your inputs.
- prawn 12y agoWon't we eventually have rooftop solar and domestic batteries that mean that power costs (heating and air cycling, for example) are no longer as much of an issue? I don't care about organic. I'd be happy to see contained growing that means I'm not losing large amounts of my plants to slugs/snails and caterpillars as I am now. Also the extreme heat in Australian summers troubles my garden too.
- lmm 12y agoBatteries really suck; it's only when you compare the energy density to actual fuels that you realize quite how bad they are. And the energy efficiency of collecting sunlight, turning it into electricity and then back again is likely to remain poor; you're looking at what, 20% at best from solar panels? (and that's after a lot of work has gone into optimizing them). And at absolute best with optimized LEDs you're looking at 30% on the lighting side, for a combined efficiency of 6%. You might remember that a few years ago there was a big environmentalist fuss about light pipes - weird as they are, they can do much much better than solar-powered lighting if they're practical for the building in question.
- theRhino 12y agosee prev hacker news item - http://miter.mit.edu/the-unexotic-underclass/ http://miter.mit.edu/the-unexotic-underclass/ lets solve some real problems?
- thenomad 12y ago"How to feed yourself" is kind of the king of all real problems. Currently this is being marketed at people with money, but research into indoor / vertical farming is definitely attacking a real problem.
- theRhino 12y agostraw man..
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI had an idea for a Wicker Man parody where people who worship fallacies burnt people alive in a giant straw man. Do you think there might be funding available?
- prawn 12y agoThat's funny because reading Unexotic Underclass, I immediately wondered if people could eventually dedicate areas of their property to growing food or insects automatically. Energy may become cheap enough, and time is the same for all of us.
- chillingeffect 12y agoYes indeed. In the discussion following that thread, I pointed out people don't need money as much as they need land on which to grow, fish, hunt, etc. This is a decent example of this, although the style that it's being implemented is more for bourgeous effect than helping everyday families.
- exDM69 12y agoWe have a similar but smaller flood'n'drain type hydroponic garden at our office (it's a brand called Zengrow, but that particular model is discontinued). It's rather nice but not really a viable source of food. Similar indoor garden products are very popular here in northern Europe because the price of salad and veggies is outrageous during the winter months. And also it's a nice aesthetic element when there's very little light or green in the winter. This garden looks nice but it's way too big and probably too expensive. It will never be able to pay back its price in the food it produces. So if the guys of this startup are listening, you should go smaller, at least initially. Apart from that, this kind of gardens are very nice and low maintenance. But it's just a nice supplement, not something that feeds your family.
- aikah 12y agoHydroponics, a great way to grow weed!
- mark_l_watson 12y agoTo be economically feasible, I think that light tubes, which capture sunlight and route the light indoors, would be necessary. I grow food in two ways. I use "earth boxes" (very water efficient) to grow veggies on our deck - where the wild pigs and other wild animals can't eat the plants. I have about a 25x30 square foot area in a community garden. In return for doing a lot of volunteer work keeping a 1 mile irrigation ditch free and running (that supplies water to both the garden and a park) I get free water and use of the land, for non-commercial use. In other words, I can just grow food for my family and friends. Really hard physical work, but fun!
- lotsofmangos 12y agoConsidering the water, fuel and labour required in normal food production and delivery, growing under LEDs at home could easily be economically feasible. Especially since you don't have to beat the cost of production, but only match the store price. Also, I don't think these people would be expanding their operations if growing under artificial lights was uneconomic. - http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/07/140717-japan-largest-indoor-plant-factory-food/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2014/07/140717-japan...
- 5partan 12y agoWhy not make this aeroponic? Even more yield in faster time, also the fishtank suggests that this is an aquaponic system, very nice :)